Cottone Auctions, NY - Read over 346 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Cottone Auctions (346)

badge TOP RATED
4.7 out of 5.0 Stars
5 Star
92%(317)
4 Star
5%(16)
3 Star
1%(3)
2 Star
1%(2)
1 Star
2%(8)
trophy

Accurate Descriptions

trophy

Quick Responses

trophy

Easy Payments

trophy

Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 346 Reviews

RonaldRockwood, CA

Communication
Will purchase again
Report
Pair of Roycroft Goodie Boxes

Jerry ABig Horn, WY

Outstanding service. Expert packing and shipping. I was very impressed with Cottone.
Excellent service, expert packing and shipping of item purchased. I was definitely buy through Cottone Auctions again.
Report
Jaune Quick-to-See Smith (Native American, 1940-2025) "Down the Rabbit Hole"

GregNokomis, FL

Great items, Great Price, Fast Shipping... AAA + + +
Great items, Great Price, Fast Shipping... AAA + + + I had an AAA + + + experience buying from Cottone Auctions. Everything was professional and I felt like a valued customer. (rare in today's world) I will buy from again.
Report
Four Quezal Pulled Feather Art Glass Shades

andrewKingston, NY

Great auctions, very beautifule items. Super professional. I am very happy. Thanks
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + +
Report
After Joan Miro, Cartones, Eight Works

JulieBath, NY

Quality item's auctioned.
Very helpful staff at pickup.
Report
Steuben Amber Sherbets, Nine Plates, Candlestick, & Flower Frog

PhilipBurr Ridge, IL

Native American Hopi Pots by Nampeyo (1859-1942)

CherylMoseley, VA

Fantastic experience
I'm absolutely thrilled with my new Steuben pieces. Cottone Auctions was great from start to finish!
Report
Steuben Tableware

DanielPrinceton, NJ

Early 19th Century American Sampler

WilliamDothan, AL

1967 Fender Coronado XII Electric Guitar

GeoffAbington, PA

Friendly and Professional Auctioneers
A fine experience all around with Cottone Auctions. The folks there are very friendly and helpful, and they are true professionals. I look forward to bidding with them again.
Report
1908 Gibson Style U Harp Guitar

LaddChanhassen, MN

So easy to ship.
Shipped and packaged quickly
Report
Attributed to Alexis Jean Fournier (American, 1865-1948) Native American Landscape

(8) Kennedy Half Dollar Graded Proofs

AudraNantucket, MA

Zhen-Huan Lu (Chinese American, b. 1950) "Fourth of July, 2000"

AmyEarlysville, VA

Near Pair of Brass & Lithophane Hanging Library Lamps

JohnEdwardsville, IL

18th Century Dutch Delft Polychromed Inkwell

ChristopherBrooklyn, NY

Great Experience
I love dealing with the people at Cottone Auctions. Always courteous, knowledgeable, and helpful. The items are just as described. The payment and shipping are easy and fast. Looking forward to my purchase.
Report
Rare Aaron Dodd Crane Patent Year Shelf Clock

JosephCandor, NC

Kroeber Vienna Style No. 19 Wall Clock

Clifton Westport, CT

Everything was perfect
Shipping arrangement are easy and reasonable
Report
Chinese Green-Glazed Hu Form Vase

Anne MarieCoboconk, CA

Better than described!
Very happy with my purchases that turned out to be far better in person. I would absolutely recommend.
Report
Two Early Dolls

James Monroe, CT

Paul Lorenz Ritter (German, 1832-1921) Engraving

CarmenFlorham Park, NJ

a
a
Report
Tiffany Studios Counter-Balance Table Lamp

AllenAlameda, CA

A terrific auction house!
A great auction house!
Report
Tiffany Studios Paperweight Vase

ScottOgdensburg, NY

Pair of Handel Sconces with an Extra Shade

G C SolutionsLouisville, CO

Native American Pima Bowl / Basket Tray

LeonardCincinnati, OH

Miniature Inuit Eskimo Doll Jacket

paulWhittier, CA

Well run operation
Every part of the process ran well. The in-house shipping was outstanding; a delicate clock movement was expertly packaged with no damage in transit.
Report
Bulle Electric Crystal Regulator

JimMount Bethel, PA

fine auction all as described
Super-fast shipping. The best packing I have ever seen. Everything came in excellent condition. I highly recommend Cottone Auction House.
Report
Group of Chinese Export Canton table Articles

JonGleneden Beach, OR

Great experience with Cottone.
Would highly recommend.
Report
Dale Chihuly (American, b. 1941) Shell Form

JosephWanaque, NJ

very cooperative
no
Report
Men's 22K Gold & 7.3 ct. Rubellite Tourmaline Ring

Alfred's-gravenhage, NL

Rare Vacheron Constantin 18K Gold Quarter Repeating Chronograph Open Face Pocket Watch

AllenAlameda, CA

A terrific auction house!
I have bought many great treasures from Cottone Auctions over the years and cannot recommend them highly enough!
Report
Tiffany Studios Eight-Light Candelabrum

MatthewNew York, NY

Rookwood Pottery Scenic Vellum Vase

GreggChagrin Falls, OH

Cowam Pottery Plate

KathleenNew York, NY

Thomas Faed (Scottish, 1826-1900) Woman Fanning Fire

RobLombard, IL

Shipping overpriced
They wanted 50.00 to mail something that weighs less then 12 oz. Will never use their auction house again
Report
Cottone Auctions logo

Cottone Auctions

Jul 11, 2024
They were 3 fragile glass bulbs. The UPS charge alone was $35.
Three Antique Edison Light Bulbs

PavelStaten Island, NY

Louis Duchene 18K Rose Gold, Enamel and Pearl Pendant Watch

DerkTomball, TX

Review auction list before live date
Great experience very helpful with list of shipper list
Report
E. Howard No. 59 Vienna Regulator (Re-issue)

James Mussallem Treasures LLCJacksonville, FL

Japanese Meiji Period Bronze Elephant and Tiger Group

PatrickBrick, NJ

Great overall experience
Professional, helpful, friendly! Reasonable shipping! How I wish all auction houses were run.
Report
Four 19th Century Small Round Pantry Boxes

MaxCachan, FR

Rapid an clear answer
I am satisfy with my first purchase and the Cottone's behaviour.
Report
Plains Leather Boy's Shirt

GingerColumbia, SC

Daguerreotype, Ambrotype, & Tintypes

MichaelNew York, NY

Shipping Process
They did a great job properly and safely packed and protected the item for shipping. It arrived perfect!
Report
Vintage Fada Model 845 "Cloud" Bakelite Radio

SusanKennett Square, PA

Roseville Art Pottery Panel Vase

ChristianMünchen, DE

Patrick Caulfield (British, 1936-2005) "Jar, 1974"

DominicColeraine, AU

Excellent Auction House.
Excellent Auction House. Followed up with packing the items how I asked & I am very pleased. AAA + + +
Report
Italian Grand Tour Plaster Intaglios

James Mussallem Treasures LLCJacksonville, FL

J. & R. Lamb Eagle Lectern

HughEau Claire, WI

Charles Cumberworth (French, 1811-1852) Nubian Water Bearer

AndrewPlacitas, NM

Agnieszka Winograd 18K Gold & Diamond Bracelet

AllenAlameda, CA

Trustworthy!
Always a great experience at Cottone's!
Report
Two Tiffany Studios Blown Out Cats Paw Candlesticks

IrisHamburg, DE

Steiff Teddy Bear, circa 1904-1906