Reviews
Bidder Reviews for Piece of the Past, Inc. (473)
TOP RATED4.7 out of 5.0 Stars
Accurate Descriptions
Quick Responses
Easy Payments
Seamless Shipping
1-50 of 473 Reviews
JenniferWoodbridge, VA
Aug 16, 2026
JoshShelbyville, TN
Aug 2, 2026
The Best there is!
I have one auctions from Piece of the Past a minimum of two dozen times. One thing I’ve noticed is their consistency. They pack every thing I’ve purchased as if it were going in a Museum. I was impressed the first time I got something thinking they may do this for new customers but every single time they take above and beyond care with your items. You will NOT be disappointed with the care they take and the quality of the things they sell. Always as advertised with no discrepancies. Highly recommend!
FrankCanandaigua, NY
Aug 2, 2026
JonathanWarwick, RI
Jul 19, 2026
michaelBrooklyn, NY
Jul 5, 2026
TomDarien, IL
Jul 5, 2026
Quality items
Always grab some unique stuff from POP. Props, movie stills, lobby cards etc. Quality merch from quality people.
JasonMarietta, GA
Jul 5, 2026
JamesAuburn, NY
Jun 8, 2026
WilliamBristol, RI
Jun 8, 2026
Great Sellers
Great sellers of autographs and props. The items are always as described and you cant trust that they are authentic. Dedicated to the industry, Kevin has written quite a few books on autographs.
DannyGoldsboro, NC
Jun 7, 2026
RANDYLocust Grove, GA
Jun 7, 2026
RichardGreeley, CO
Jun 2, 2026
AdamMargate, GB
May 27, 2026
Best packaging job I've seen
Although I had to contact to obtain tracking information, which I eventually received. They were fast in responding to messages. The payment system was fast, the package came internationally so took a few weeks but the packaging was brilliant! Overall Very Happy!
JesseMarina Del Rey, CA
May 26, 2026
Accuracy of description
item was accurately described; with certificate of authenticity. Will bid in future auctions
MatthewLiberty, MO
May 10, 2026
You have to sign for delivery
I love their auctions. But I have to leave work & go to the post office to sign for every delivery. I'd love to option out of the required signature in shipping.
RobertGresham, OR
May 10, 2026
Communications
As a first time buyer, I was not experienced with the process. I messaged them and gotta response with a bit of rudeness. I asked for a tracking number and no response. Got my item but was disappointed with the way they communicated.
GeraldCambria, CA
Apr 30, 2026
Best Autograph Dealer Around by Far!
Most knowledgeable autograph dealer around. Kevin Martin is an honest and very personable individual/owner for Piece Of The Past. He and his store offerings are the reason I've enjoyed collecting autographs over the past 25 + years. Great deals, great prices, great person!
JonathanWarwick, RI
Apr 30, 2026
MatthewDevens, MA
Apr 30, 2026
MatthewLiberty, MO
Apr 29, 2026
robertSacramento, CA
Apr 12, 2026
MatthewDevens, MA
Apr 12, 2026
ScottBurke, VA
Mar 29, 2026
TomDarien, IL
Mar 29, 2026
Quality merch, delivery time slow
Love Piece of the Past for items they offer. Great props & autographs, lots of unique items. But nearly two weeks for items to arrive. I don’t know if that’s LiveAuctioneers delay and certainly not excessive. But I buy thru WhatNot & delivery times are much faster. Still very happy & would heartily recommend.
GeraldCambria, CA
Mar 29, 2026
Very experienced and honest company
They are top of the list company in their field of celebrity autographs and related collectibles. Experienced, honest, and genuine items.
RANDYLocust Grove, GA
Mar 29, 2026
RichardGreeley, CO
Mar 27, 2026
PeteLas Vegas, NV
Mar 16, 2026
Excellent purchase
The signed photos came just as shown on the site. They arrived quick and packaged very well. Great items to add to my collection.
TheoLondon, GB
Mar 16, 2026
TomDarien, IL
Mar 15, 2026
Unique inventory
Recently discovered Piece of the Past and I’ve been really happy with my purchases. Quality autographed photos and some really unique props. I’m confident in the authenticity & provenance of items offered.
JohnWichita, KS
Feb 15, 2026
MikeCutler Bay, FL
Feb 15, 2026
garyWhitehall, MI
Feb 8, 2026
Review was for Piece of the Past not Live Auctioneers
Piece of the Past was great. Live Auctioneers attempts to jump in on the payments and shipping are a genuinely bad idea and experience.
TomDarien, IL
Feb 1, 2026
Unique items
I was impressed with the variety of unique movie memorabilia items available for bid. Very cool and I feel like I snagged some gems.
HeatherPeachtree City, GA
Jan 22, 2026
DuaneOrlando, FL
Jan 5, 2026
JamesEdmond, OK
Dec 26, 2025
RobertHuntington, NY
Dec 22, 2025
JonEastleigh, GB
Dec 14, 2025
All items are as described and fully guaranteed
They are trustworthy, Honest and reliable. Their items are top quality and fully authenticated. I go nowhere else now as I am always sure of good service throughout. In short!, Piece Of The Past are brilliant!
MarkGuilford, CT
Nov 30, 2025
RalphApple Valley, CA
Nov 30, 2025
DavidMissouri City, TX
Nov 22, 2025
Authenticity, Authenticity and Authenticity
Having been both an in-person collector and purchaser from various auction houses around the world for over 40 years, I have no hesitation in saying that Kevin and Piece of the Past are second to none one in terms of authenticity and selection/variety. For me, those are the two most important elements of collecting autographs. Thanks again Kevin for an outstanding auction!
TheoLondon, GB
Nov 16, 2025
MattSimpsonville, SC
Nov 16, 2025
MarshallBohemia, NY
Nov 16, 2025
Great again!
This is one of the very FEW auction houses that I trust and bid with regularly. Great autographed items. Always a good and easy experience with payment and their reasonably priced in house shipping.
JasonMarietta, GA
Nov 16, 2025
Rapidly becoming my favorite auction house
Always friendly and knowledgeable, they run no BS auctions, straight bidding without all of the annoying messages between bids. The prices are reasonable and their in-house shipping is superior. I comb through their auctions each month for new treasures. Bid with authority!
TOP