The Lodge Auction House Inc., NY - Read over 204 Reviews from Customers
LiveAuctioneers Logo

Bidder Reviews for The Lodge Auction House Inc. (204)

badge TOP RATED
4.5 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 204 Reviews

All Ratings
Highest Rated

michael
Niagara Falls, NY

Apr 24, 2024
Honest and Trustworthy.
They're GREAT! My favorite auction house. And they're only 28 miles away!
Report
Rare Edison Phonograph w/ Horn

GERRY
Whiting, NJ

Apr 24, 2024
Carved Wooden Beaver Standing 20 1/2 inches tall

Barry
Cypress, TX

Feb 14, 2024
Very Good Experience
Smooth transaction. I appreciate their service and pricing.
Report
Buddy L Texaco Tanker 24 inches long

Eric
New York, NY

Jan 11, 2024
Nice batch of items
I was happy with the items I won at auction, and the auction house handled things with no muss or fuss.
Report
Railroad Grade Crossing Bond Framed

Dean
Windsor, CA

Dec 27, 2023
Got what I bought
As described quick shipping
Report
Reading Railroad Lamp w/ 4 Lenses

Douglas
Advance, IN

Dec 27, 2023
Vintage Metal Railroad Signs

T.J.
Port Huron, MI

Dec 26, 2023
4 Adlake Long time burners for railroad

Ted
Chaumont, NY

Dec 26, 2023
shipping
item was well protected by packaging and arrived sooner than I anticipated.
Report
Delaware & Hudson Railroad Lantern w/ Red Globe

William
Raleigh, NC

Dec 23, 2023
Love Lodge Auctions!
Another terrific auction with prompt, reasonable in house shipping. You folks are the best!
Report
Seaboard Air & Railroad Cloths

Gianfranco
Cagliari, IT

Dec 15, 2023
Not very accurate
Exorbitant shipping charges. Address without house number, Incomplete customs invoice. Worst experience with an American Auction House
Report
MAFFEI Drawing View a Bomb Shipping in Harbor

Ionut
Chicago, IL

Nov 28, 2023
Clash of Empires Continental Line 16038

Steve
Buffalo, NY

Nov 07, 2023
Pocket Knife & Grooming Tool

Kenneth
San Antonio, TX

Oct 24, 2023
American Pocket Knife in org box

Donald
Reno, NV

Oct 17, 2023
Proceed with caution!
Product description was poor. I believe I was over charged for shipping. Packaging was inadequate and signs were damaged in shipment, and was very slow to ship. I was charged sales tax, that I believe is in error. Smaller items not worth fighting over, but not a good experience. Don Reno Nevada. Don Reno NV
Report
Colt Revolvers Tin Sign

michael
Niagara Falls, NY

Oct 17, 2023
GREAT EXPERIENCE EVERY TIME
I like this auction house and the staff very much. And they're local!
Report
Las Vegas Owl Metal & Glass Ornament

Anna
Daytona Beach, FL

Oct 17, 2023
Great items!
Better than expected, fast!
Report
Framed Duran Duran Wall Art

HILARY
Clarkston, GA

Oct 17, 2023
Assorted Comedy Albums (9)

Steve
Buffalo, NY

Oct 17, 2023
Pair of Belgium Wooden Shoes, Dated Belgium 1944

Kevin
Galveston, TX

Oct 17, 2023
Always check the measurements...
The items were exactly as viewed except I didn't check the measurements. They are of fine quality and the experience with the seller was flawless. I can still use the items just not in the same place I had planned. Recommended seller.
Report
Plaster Wall Accents (pair)

Bob
Jacksonville, FL

Oct 17, 2023
Great item
Lodge auction house is fun
Report
Buffalo Bills Helmet Pencil Holder

Carmen G.
Guaynabo, PR

Oct 03, 2023
MAFFEI Sketch of Sugar Barges in Puerto Rico

John G
Hagatna, GU

Aug 31, 2023
I am happy
I am happy
Report
Vintage Zenith AM/FM Alarm Clock Radio - Works! measures 11 inches wide, 7 inches deep and 5 1/4

Spencer
Merion Station, PA

Aug 22, 2023
Responded reasonably quickly to shipping questions Items were as described
Purchased two older mandolin cases these were as described including dust and dirt which is to be expected but functional and as pictured. The process was easy and when contacted for shipping they responded reasonably quickly and made shipping easy.
Report
Hard Cases for Mandolins (2) Each measures appr. 26" x 12"Â

Christie
Lead Hill, AR

Aug 16, 2023
Signed Satin Fenton Glass Pieces (2) Artist name on bottom egg measures approximately 3 inches tall

Feifei
West Henrietta, NY

Aug 15, 2023
Yamaha Eterna EC–10 Acoustic Guitar with soft case and two guitar books; 6 string guitar

bryan
Kent, OH

Jul 13, 2023
A + + + tranaction
very professional
Report
Vintage Nutcracker Doorstop

Bob
Jacksonville, FL

Jun 30, 2023
Great item
Always a nice auction
Report
Vintage Volunteer Fire Department Potholder- Iron

Michael
Como, TX

Jun 30, 2023
Wonderful
Excellent experience
Report
Vintage Squash Blossom-Style Necklace in Silver

Ann
Glen Rock, NJ

Jun 28, 2023
Outstanding service
We were so pleased with the ease, speed, packaging and cost of shipping our heavy wood box. Lodge is one of our new favorites.
Report
MEUX'S Original London Stout Shipping Crate

michael
Niagara Falls, NY

Jun 14, 2023
honest
good
Report
Vintage Poland & Switzerland made Bird Toys, porcupine, fox, and possum

Gavin
Rockaway Park, NY

Jun 01, 2023
Answers the phone! In-house shipping.
I cannot emphasize enough how important it is that auction houses you bid from have their own shipping. My experience was awesome here. They don’t write deep descriptions, but they take good photos for you to judge on your own if you are not at the physical auction. No fluff. Shipped in-house and paid the real shipping cost. I don’t even think they charged me for the materials although I would have happily done so as opposed to using a shipping store.
Report
CSX Number 610 Engine

Jason
Thornton, CO

May 30, 2023
Airlines Playing Cards .

fred
Theresa, NY

May 30, 2023
SECURE SHIPPING
AS ADVERTISED
Report
Railroad & Steam Ship Coffee Mugs (10) RR, steamships and flying tiger plane

William
Raleigh, NC

May 23, 2023
Great job again, fast efficient, watching for future auctions
Lodge continually exceeds my expectations, their in house shipping is affordable and works to get my purchases out promptly. Much appreciated for auctions one cannot attend in person. Thanks again!
Report
Lantern Mounting Brackets for Railroad Cart (4) .

Aniello Ciro
Afragola, IT

May 20, 2023
tutto bene; spese di spedizione eccessive.
tutto bene; spese di spedizione eccessive
Report
Showcase Calvary Figurines (2)

T.J.
Port Huron, MI

May 13, 2023
Repeat Customer continues to be satisfied
Have dealt with this auctioneer several times, have been very pleased with the ease and smoothness off the process, would definitely do so again.
Report
3 Pennsylvania Railroad lease signs .

Mark
Glenmore Park, AU

May 10, 2023
1974 Gold Plated Table Zippo Lighter

Eric
Westfield, NJ

May 09, 2023
Great auction
Recently won a lot at the lodge auction house and cannot be any happier. The items were even better than I thought, and they did a super job with shipping.
Report
Vintage Wooden Chess Set

Steven
Nellysford, VA

May 09, 2023
Excellent experience!
All auction sites should be this prompt to ship and easy to work with!
Report
Designer Unused Smoking Pipe  Aluminum

Nick
Falls Village, CT

Apr 25, 2023
Great auction house
I won two items from the Lodge and wasn’t able to contact them about shipping fast enough. They figured out I won two items (in a big auction) they packaged them together and shipped it to me with one shipping charge. I was really lucky and surprised that I received my win less than a week from when I won!!
Report
1996 Polish Chrome Zippo Lighter Buffalo Nickel

michael
Niagara Falls, NY

Apr 25, 2023
Best house i deal with, and they're only down the road from me.
Very good and honest
Report
1992 Camel Joe on Motor Cycle - Midnight Chrome

Gregory
Edison, NJ

Apr 04, 2023
They are very professional
very professional
Report
Lionel O Scale JLC Joshua Cowen Series Pennsylvania GG1 4866 Silver Single Stripe 6-18374

michael
Niagara Falls, NY

Apr 04, 2023
HONEST AND TRUSTWORTHY
THANK YOU
Report
Retro Sears Hawaiian Shirt Mens xl

michael
Niagara Falls, NY

Apr 04, 2023
The Best
THANK YOU
Report
Blizzard of '77 mug

michael
Niagara Falls, NY

Apr 04, 2023
Honest and Trustworthy
This is my favoritr auction house and they are close by in Buffalo.
Report
Man Cave Tin Sign

William J.
Conroe, TX

Mar 30, 2023
Dealing w/eBay is easier & considerably less expensive where administrative expenses are concerned.
I'll stick with eBay in the future. Much easier and less expensive.
Report
Missouri–Kansas–Texas Railway Key .

Al
Newington, CT

Mar 28, 2023
Good transaction
Lodge Auction House completed another good transaction for me. Shipping cost was fair, received items as promised.
Report
NY NH & H RR Padlock New York New Haven & Hartford Railroad

Paul
Portland, ME

Mar 28, 2023
Eastern Steamship Lines Inc. Plate Measures 8 inches diameter

Andrew
Revere, MA

Mar 28, 2023
Accurate description and quick shipping!
I was very pleased with the items I bid on, the photos and descriptions were accurate. Shipping was very quick and reasonably priced.
Report
Railroad Lanterns (2) .

Steve
Milford, OH

Mar 28, 2023
Beware mutiple Auctions on consecutive days from same Seller with misleading s/h/p and invoice costs
This Seller listed a single Auction that took place over three consecutive days. I bid upon and won 2 items-one on the first day of the auction and one on the second day of the auction. Both items I won were small Brass keys that could easily fit together in a small manilla envelope. Neither the Seller nor the LiveAuctioneers had said on the Auction webpage these 2 auction days were considered two distinct and unrelated auctions from the same Seller with separate invoices with separate s/h/p charges that could not be combined for s/h/p savings. Consequently, I was charged an unnecessary $10 s/h/p for each Brass Key ($20 total s/h/p). LiveAuctioneers declined to contact the Seller and have the s/h/p combined for the Brass Keys and reduce my s/h/p cost by 50 % because the LA Auction advertisement was misleading. LiveAuctioneers told me to contact the Seller who setup these s/h/p terms and conditions and ask if the Seller would modify the s/h/p cost. The Seller apparently made online changes to the invoice to waive the s/h/p charge for one key after I called them by telephone. However the Seller's updated s/h/p waiver was not recognized by the LA website. I again had to call LiveAuctioneers to modify the invoice to reflect the s/h/p waiver granted by the Seller. IMHO, these s/h/p concerns would have been avoided if I had been sent a single Auction invoice for the two items purchased from the same Seller in the same auction with combined s/h/p.
Report
PRR Railroad key .
View:
50
TOP