M.J. Stasak Jr. Auction and Appraisal Service, NJ - Read over 2,283 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for M.J. Stasak Jr. Auction and Appraisal Service (2,283)

badge TOP RATED
4.8 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 2,283 Reviews

RODNEY
Yucaipa, CA

Jun 02, 2026
BEST AUCTION HOUSE, THANK YOU MIKE
THANK YOU LOW SHIPPING COST
Report
Military Pins, Patches, Good Conduct Medal , WWI Medal

Debra
Mount Arlington, NJ

Jun 01, 2026
Always a great experience!
Same great experience over the years.
Report
Mixed Lot of Books

Wanda
Kanata, CA

May 30, 2026
Missing Information
If products have an odour I think that should be disclosed. Otherwise a great experience throughout the entire process.
Report
Cloth Dolls & Clothes

Clifford
Mattituck, NY

May 27, 2026
Robinson Aluminum Street Sign

Wieslawa
Brodheadsville, PA

May 23, 2026
Very nice people to deal with.
Very nice people to deal with.
Report
2 Hortensja Cut to Clear Goblets

Mobile Exchange Gt Inc
Doral, FL

May 18, 2026
Hilton Womens Wristwatch

Lisa
Oxford, NJ

May 10, 2026
D.L Norris Jessica Cardone Oil on Board

Laurie
Potomac, MD

May 10, 2026
Lenox Bowl

Lorri
Marlboro, NJ

May 08, 2026
The best auctions, wonderful owners, love my items!
You will not be disappointed... always quality treasures!
Report
Old Sturbridge Village Redware Jar

Jessica
Baltimore, MD

May 05, 2026
Great Items, Friendly Staff
I recently won a handful of items with M. J. Stasak Jr, and all items were exactly as described and pictured. However most importantly, I was scheduled to pick up my items and had an emergency and all the staff I spoke with (3 different people) were not only very responsive, but so empathetic, understanding, and accommodating. Thank you so much for a wonderful experience!
Report
Hipopotamo Hand Colored Lithograph

Anne
Phillipsburg, NJ

Apr 28, 2026
MJ Stasak are so Great to Work with!
I love working with Laurel and Mike at M Stasak! Everything about their operation is top-notch-from accurate descriptions to great quality items, willingness to work with purchasers with pick up issues, to niceness and just a fun, friendly experience.
Report
John Reilly Oil on Board Painting

William

Apr 26, 2026
Best Quality Service levels to be copied by other auctioneers
i could write poetry about them. I see them as the best service in every way. Ultimate customer service. Often times online companies are to blame for problems and then you need to go there Stasak will tell you that and although wish they could help but cannot. So, realize that fact. They are really the best. Ok? Sign up!
Report
Oval Decorator Wall Mirror

Jim
Phoenix, AZ

Apr 26, 2026
M. J. Stasak is not responsive to shipping question. By default, they keep the item.
M. J. Stasak is not responsive to shipping question. By default, they keep the item.
Report
M.J. Stasak Jr. Auction and Appraisal Service logo
M.J. Stasak Jr. Auction and Appraisal ServiceApr 27, 2026
Hello, I responded to your shipping question and you did not like the answer. When you purchase a large radio with a shipping weight of 55 pounds, shipping is not going to be cheap. We can not control the postage charges. We do not want to keep any item! You could have had your own shipper pick up the item.
Hallicrafters SX -71 Ham Radio Receiver

claude
Verdun, CA

Apr 24, 2026
shipping to canada $uck $
Paid shipping then was asked to pay shipping again a week later so i did thinking the first payment hadn't passed, checking with visa confirmed 2 payments had been sent, contacted Michael Stasak twice for a refund with no answer
Report
M.J. Stasak Jr. Auction and Appraisal Service logo
M.J. Stasak Jr. Auction and Appraisal ServiceApr 27, 2026
There is not a chance you got charged twice for shipping. There is no way that could happen. I never received any messages or calls from you.
Schuco Replica Examico 4001 Wind Up Car

Lorri
Marlboro, NJ

Apr 17, 2026
Excellent purchase from auction... thank you@
Best auctions ever!
Report
Austin Prod.  The Kiss Sculpture

Lorri
Marlboro, NJ

Apr 11, 2026
Stasak's Auctions are the best! Unusual items and I always look forward to bidding!
You cannot find a better auction house. Always are satisfied with my winnings.
Report
Bessey GSCC4PK Bar Clamps

Giuseppe
Venice, FL

Apr 06, 2026
Corgi Classics Mack Truck Thornycraft Van

Jim
Arcadia, OH

Apr 05, 2026
Marx Trains , Lamp Posts , Crossing Signs, & Misc

DANA
Indian Trail, NC

Apr 05, 2026
Wing Dingus Master Modelcraft Airplane Model

Lorna
Seatac, WA

Apr 05, 2026
Ginny Wardrobe & Irwin Doll

David
Tucson, AZ

Apr 05, 2026
Great
Had a great experience, well done
Report
HO Motoring Pretzel Bender Raceway Slot Car Track

Ronald
Inverness, IL

Apr 05, 2026
Perfect
Perfect transaction, quick shipping. Thanks!
Report
Gi Joe Figures , Parts , He-Man & Misc

Scott
Bristow, VA

Apr 05, 2026
What to know
Invoicing, payment, shipping/tracking was very easy and convenient. My old issue would be with the items packing, an old unsturdy box shouldn’t be used to ship fragile items. Other then that no issues with the auctioneer.
Report
Hubley Cast Iron Crash Car Cycle

Gerry
Ocala, FL

Mar 29, 2026
SHIPPING
SHIPPING IS A RIP OFF
Report
M.J. Stasak Jr. Auction and Appraisal Service logo
M.J. Stasak Jr. Auction and Appraisal ServiceMar 30, 2026
Hello, We charged you actual postage, plus the $15 handling charge. Your package dimensions were 22x16x9 weighing 5 pounds going to Florida and postage was $31.04, plus the handling charge. If you read the shipping terms, you would have known there was a handling charge.
1973 Mack Bulldog Stake Truck Model

Wayne
Brooklyn, NY

Mar 23, 2026
Five star review
Quickly shipped for a reasonable price and well packed. The item was as described in text and shown in photos. And, it runs as it ought!
Report
Hot Air Model Engine

Marilyn
Chalfont, PA

Mar 15, 2026
Models , Sink , & Misc

RODNEY
Yucaipa, CA

Mar 11, 2026
BEST AUCTION EVER, THANK YOU MIKE
MIKE IS THE BEST, FAST SHIPPING
Report
ATI Radeon 9800 Pro 128Mb Mac Edition

Lisa
Claremont, NH

Mar 08, 2026
Art Bin Box & Misc

William
Lincolnton, NC

Mar 08, 2026
Winchester Pocket Knife

Andy
Upper Black Eddy, PA

Mar 08, 2026
Electric Chainsaw , Torque Wrench Pipe Adapter & Misc

RODNEY
Yucaipa, CA

Mar 05, 2026
THANK YOU MIKE, GREAT AUCTION
FAST SHIPPING, SO WELL PACKED IN SHIPPING
Report
Verlinden Miniatures & I/R Productions Figural Models

Dave
Pipersville, PA

Feb 22, 2026
They are very professional and organized
They are great! Highly recommended
Report
Wood Tote in Black Paint & Esquire Footman

Mark
Keyport, NJ

Feb 15, 2026
They always have great stuff and accurately describe everything.
Always very professional in every aspect!
Report
Porcelain Door Knobs , Locks , Square Head Nails , Misc Hardware

Lorri
Marlboro, NJ

Feb 13, 2026
Always the best auctions!
Thank you for having the most unusual items up for bidding. I love your antiques.
Report
Krakow Straw Art

RODNEY
Yucaipa, CA

Feb 09, 2026
BEST AUCTION HOUSE EVER
BOUGHT FROM MIKE FOR YEARS, HE'S THE BEST, FAST SHIPPING, SO WELL PACKED
Report
Annelies Van Dommelen Watercolor

Pete
Danielsville, PA

Feb 09, 2026
Auction
Great transaction Great people to deal with!!
Report
1981 Nowell's Mold Ceramic Christmas Tree

William
Lincolnton, NC

Feb 08, 2026
3 Mary Gregory Glass Cruets

Dean
Logansport, LA

Feb 08, 2026
Griswold Aluminum Tea Kettles

Lee
Buffalo, MN

Feb 08, 2026
good packing.
good packing
Report
Nautical Ships Lantern

bolos@littleoldme.com
Whitehouse Station, NJ

Feb 08, 2026
Always a great transaction!
I've been purchasing from them for years and this is the best auction house I have dealt with. Friendly responsive owners and good deals every time.
Report
Craftsman 2 Piece Tool Chest

Chris
Sterling, VA

Jan 27, 2026
Everything was a seamless experience and would bid again
Everything was a seamless experience and would bid again
Report
1879-80 Jere. Rohrer Liquors Enveleopes to US Engineers Corps

Alan
Peoa, UT

Jan 23, 2026
Easy to Work With.
Thank you for your flexibility and responsiveness.
Report
Movie & Metropolitan Museum Posters

Nicholas
Troy, PA

Jan 22, 2026
Anna Hamilton Seated Nude Glass Plate Negative

Jon
Easton, PA

Jan 22, 2026
1927 Cunard Line R.M.S. Coronia Passenger List w/ Chart

Scott
Bangor, PA

Jan 22, 2026
Stazak auction house
Honest people and post their items accurately
Report
1969 David Schiller Sparta Graphics Rock Poster

Alexander
Laguna Woods, CA

Jan 22, 2026
Very responsive to questions,
This was a simple and professional transaction. Communication was excellent.
Report
First Regiment of NJ Artillery Discharge Papers Civil War

Tarek
Verona, NJ

Jan 19, 2026
Outstanding Service
Great, honest people. Unique items. You really don't find this regularly in the auction world-which is riddled in scammers and misrepresentations. 5 Stars.
Report
1816 - 1828 Letters incl Townsend Oyster Bay New York

Jim
Washington, NJ

Jan 18, 2026
Great Auction Company
Mike is a Great guy to deal with. Very responsive and accommodating. A pleasure to deal with
Report
6 Speed Auto Bike Classic

Lisa
Claremont, NH

Jan 18, 2026
Prelude International Sterling Silver Candle Holders

Tary
Ottsville, PA

Jan 18, 2026
Le Creuset Enameled 24 Casserole