Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers, OH - Read over 178 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers (178)

badge TOP RATED
4.6 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 178 Reviews

Dennis
Tampa, FL

Mar 03, 2026
HONEST!!!!
HONEST!!!
Report
IN THE MANNER OF SAMUEL BENTZ (MOUNT PLEASANT, LANCASTER COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA, 1792-1850) WATERCOLOR

Jerry A
Big Horn, WY

Feb 21, 2026
BUNNY CONNELL (AMERICAN, 20TH CENTURY) CAST BRONZE SCULPTURE OF BEAR EATING SALMON.

Maritza
North Olmsted, OH

Feb 19, 2026
Responsive & helpful
Entire team was very helpful and quick to respond. Thank you for being so accommodating also!
Report
GLOBE-WERNICKE (CINCINNATI, OHIO) FOUR-STACK BARRISTER'S BOOKCASE.

Joyce
Laguna Niguel, CA

Feb 16, 2026
Everything is usually great, till it isn't
Frustrated. I received my pottery pieces just fine, but when I ran one under a little water to clean it before displaying it, pieces chipped off, showing a repair was done, but hidden. I have no idea who knew over there, and it might have just been a surprise to us both, but this was kind of an expensive vase and now, it's showing damage that was pretty well hidden till I discovered that cleaning it took off fresh paint. My issue is the stalling with the communication. I have sent photos, and tried to reach someone, anyone who can help and I just keep getting told that they are reviewing it and someone will get back to me... and no one does. No follow thru, and it feels like they are waiting for me to go away. Very disappointing.
Report
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersFeb 16, 2026
As explained by email earlier today, this is an unfortunate review for us to receive from you given how hard we have worked on the transaction. First, you paid your invoice almost 6 weeks after the auction, but we did not "ding" your bidder account with negative feedback. Instead, we shipped your items right away via FedEx. You received the package on December 10, and only notified us on February 3 that one of the items had what you claim to be a "repair that washed off under running tap water". This item was reviewed by an outside third party as a part of our condition reports prior to auction, and neither he, nor our catalog staff or photographer, have any notes about a repair. The photos show nothing that would indicate there was any problem with the piece. Art pottery is routinely examined under blacklight for condition reports-and the third-party expert who conducted the condition report recorded that it was in "excellent condition." Now, a new bidder who has bid with us for the first time notifies us TWO MONTHS after receiving a piece to claim that a chip in the rim was because of a "repair that washed off under running tap water"? The delay in replying to you was simply our team scratching our heads and investigating to see if there was any way we missed something, but I cannot find any evidence of that. Instead, I believe you chipped the vase in handling it, and are now fabricating a reason to make us take it back-including threats of negative reviews. We maintain excellent relationships with our fellow auction houses, and I am hopeful that our negative experience will save them from similar experiences with an irresponsible and unreasonable bidder who seems prone to use blackmail to force auction houses to take back her mistakes.

larry
Cheyenne, WY

Feb 02, 2026
Na
Na
Report
AMERICAN MOLD BLOWN GLASS BOTTLE.

Karri
Pittsburg, KS

Feb 02, 2026
GROUP OF MINIATURES, INCL. JANE GRABER (GOSHEN, INDIANA) AND JEFF FREEMAN POTTERY (EAGLE SPRINGS, NO

Rob
Sheridan, WY

Jan 30, 2026
E. HOWARD AND COMPANY (BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS) MAHOGANY WALL CLOCK.

Rae
Sedgwick, KS

Jan 29, 2026
Awesome Auction House
As an out of state buyer it was a pleasure to work with Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers. Their invoicing, payment, and shipping processes were all top-notch! When I called with a minor question the office staff was amazing with their willingness to help and kindness in answering my question. I look forward to purchasing from this auction house in the future. It was a wonderfully easy buying experience!
Report
ANNA PEEL NEWTON (AMERICAN) NEEDLEWORK SAMPLER, DATED 1805.

Kathleen
Bridgewater, MA

Jan 29, 2026
TWO PETER PELTZ (AMERICAN, 1915-2001) FOLK ART CARVED AND PAINTED WOOD BIRDS.

CODY ANN
Endicott, NY

Jan 26, 2026
Packed to Perfection
Auction House Staff was incredibly helpful and polite when I called with questions ss this was my first time bidding with them & I am a State away, so pickup was not possible. Due to value and fragility of items I was concerned with inadequate packaging and the potential of it breaking. They assured extra packaging and insurance. It was flawless and i am so happy & Thankful!
Report
AMERICAN COBALT-DECORATED STONEWARE PITCHER WITH THREE FEATHERS.

Lorraine
Palm Coast, FL

Jan 08, 2026
One of the easiest action houses to work with.
They are quick to respond to questions. Their in house shipping is phenomenal. They pack your items with great care. Would not hesitate to purchase from them again.
Report

Patty
Fredericktown, OH

Dec 31, 2025
My Go To Auction House
I've bid from Amelia Jeffers because I always know the quality of antiques are exactly as described. Always looking forward to their next auction.
Report
LARGE N. & J. HOWE & CO. (FITZWILLIAM, NEW HAMPSHIRE) PAINTED, STAVED, AND FINGER-LAPPED "CR.

Ronald
Oakton, VA

Dec 20, 2025
Easy purchase
Amelia Jeffers auction was great … a model for other auction houses. The invoice came quickly and the shipping was seamless. I love in-house shipping! My only hesitation to bid with them again is the buyers premium was high.
Report
COL. SAMUEL COLT MODEL 1860 ARMY PISTOL.

Scott
Ash Flat, AR

Dec 20, 2025
U.S. CIVIL WAR IMPORTED FRENCH LEATHER SHAKO WITH APPLIED INSIGNIA.

Cate
Bozeman, MT

Dec 20, 2025
THREE HEREND PORCELAIN SERVING DISHES IN THE ROTHSCHILD BIRD, QUEEN VICTORIA, AND GARDEN MARKET

Brianna
Elizabethton, TN

Dec 18, 2025
They ship
Great packing crocks arrived great thanks I was very happy with everything!!!
Report
LARGE AMERICAN GREEN-PAINTED, STAVED, AND FINGER-LAPPED FIRKIN.

Connie
Atlantic Highlands, NJ

Dec 07, 2025
AFTER FRANCIS ALEXANDER (AMERICAN, 1800-1880) "PORTRAIT OF JANE ANN HUTCHINS AND HER DAUGHTER" OIL

Glenn
Hellertown, PA

Nov 15, 2025

Michael
Rockfall, CT

Nov 15, 2025

Rodney
Bellevue, WA

Nov 14, 2025

Rob
Preston, MD

Nov 13, 2025
1st Class auction house!!!
Great and friendly staff, accurate descriptions fast shipping
Report

Mary Ellen
Bridgeton, NJ

Nov 13, 2025
All good!
All good. Smooth transaction.
Report

Tim
Edinboro, PA

Nov 09, 2025
I'm picky, this Auction House was a wonderful experience ALL around
I'm picky, this Auction House was a wonderful experience ALL around. I'm a 50-yr collector and of diverse pieces and I'm using auctions 3-6 times per month, I'm unfortunetly used to auction houses feable attempts to communictae, to add added items and info. to descriptions, and last but not the least, most auctions still force you todeal with everythign from contacting a pack & shipper in a unknown city, deal with thme picking up and quoting an increased price as many times they have you over the barrel and the auction house have washed their hands as the items gone so, they're done Some auctions are beginning to use Live Auctioneers quoting and handling for pack & ships, that's in it's infancy but making progress and leading bidders to those aucitons because of this new option. Whether or not they use Live Auctioneers reference, quotation, or not, some auctions handle things start to finish and they know how important communication and updates are to the Buyers. This was my 1st interaction with Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers, but they communicated throughout and made the shipping and tracking process an excellent experience. I highly recommend them as this experience was greatly appreciated. Thank you
Report

Patty
Fredericktown, OH

Oct 04, 2025
Great Wins As Always
A trusted auction house always brings in unique finds. Process always easy. My 1 item was larger then auction house coukd ship so they gave a large number of shippers to choice from. Will continue to follow and bid.
Report
TWO SCANDINAVIAN PAINT-DECORATED BENTWOOD BRIDE'S BOXES WITH TINES.

Nicholas
Troy, PA

Oct 04, 2025
AMERICAN CASED SIXTH-PLATE TINTYPE OF CIVIL WAR SOLDIER.

fj
Oneonta, AL

Oct 04, 2025
SHIRVAN AREA RUG.

Deborah
Cincinnati, OH

Oct 04, 2025
MARTIN RETTIG (OHIO, 1869-1956) "MARIGOLDS" OIL ON CANVAS BOARD.

Sam
NYC, NY

Oct 02, 2025
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersOct 03, 2025
Thanks so much! I am so glad you had a great experience, and we look forward to working with you again!
PENNSYLVANIA WATERCOLOR AND INK BOOKPLATE FRAKTUR, DATED 1833.

todd
Waterville, OH

Aug 31, 2025
Updated review
I originally gave them a lower review due to poorly packing the comic books I won from them. I changed it because this is the first and only auction house I've had this problem with who actually asked how to prevent it in the future rather then blame someone else or deny it. I will 100 % give them a second chance for that alone. I respect anyone who admits their mistakes and tries to make it right.
Report
GROUPING OF MOSTLY 1980S DC COMICS.

Cesar
Laredo, TX

Aug 26, 2025
ASIAN TAOIST SAGE FIGURAL CARVING.

Stewart
Milton, MA

Aug 26, 2025
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersOct 03, 2025
Thank you so much for taking the time to review your experience with us! I hope we have the chance to work with you again!
TWO VOLUMES: "MASSINGER AND FORD" with "BEN JOHNSON".

John
Edwardsville, IL

Aug 19, 2025
Quality Antiques and great customer service.
Quality Antiques and great customer service. Excellent things to buy, competent staff description.
Report
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 19, 2025
Thank you for your business! And for taking the time to leave such a kind review!
NATIVE AMERICAN SPLINT-WOVEN AND POTATO STAMP-DECORATED BASKET.

Joey
Cottonwood Heights, UT

Aug 16, 2025
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 18, 2025
Thanks so much for taking the time to review your experience. It is so meaningful to our small company! We look forward to the next auction!:)
SIGNED FRENCH POLYNESIAN CARVED WOOD TIKI FIGURE.

Roger
Placitas, NM

Aug 16, 2025
Great auction house
This is a great auction house with a professional staff.
Report
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 18, 2025
Thanks so much for taking the time to review your experience. It is so meaningful to our small company! We think we have pretty great bidders, too! We look forward to the next auction!:)
TWO PORTRAITS: SAN ANTONIO AND SAINT MARTIN DE PORRES.

Ryan
Spring, TX

Aug 15, 2025
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 18, 2025
Thanks so much for taking the time to review your experience. It is so meaningful to our small company! We look forward to the next auction!:)
A TIBETAN BRONZE VAJRA AND TEMPLE BELL.

Michael
Cleveland, OH

Aug 15, 2025
Standish by Hester Bateman
I love the standish (inwell tray) by Hester Bateman's studio. My experience in acquiring and paying for the item was smooth.
Report
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 18, 2025
I LOVE Hester Bateman-her craftsmanship and story. Thanks so much for taking the time to provide feedback to our team. It is always great to hear when we have gotten it right! And congratulations on your find!
GEORGE III STERLING SILVER INK STAND BY HESTER BATEMAN.

Robin
Chillicothe, OH

Aug 15, 2025
Never disappointed
All items I've won have been fabulous and as described. Amelia and her team are always great to work with.
Report
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 18, 2025
Thank you for bidding with us these last several years! We so appreciate your business-and I am very grateful you would take the time to review us! And especially grateful we are giving the kind of service we always strive to provide!:)
AMERICAN SLIP-DECORATED REDWARE PLATE.

Robin
Chillicothe, OH

Aug 15, 2025
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 18, 2025
Thank you for bidding with us these last several years! We so appreciate your business-and I am very grateful you would take the time to review us!
TWO SLIP DECORATED REDWARE PLATES.

Robin
Chillicothe, OH

Aug 15, 2025
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 18, 2025
Thank you for bidding with us these last several years! We so appreciate your business-and I am very grateful you would take the time to review us!
"ROSTER OF OHIO SOLDIERS" VOLUME II AND X.

Tim
Saint Helena, CA

Aug 15, 2025
quality service
prompt and excellent packing!
Report
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 18, 2025
Thanks so much for taking the time to review your experience. I will let our shipping team know how pleased you were! Your feedback is so meaningful to our small company! We look forward to the next auction!:)
SIX ENGLISH PEWTER STEINS.

Joseph
Quakertown, PA

Aug 15, 2025
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 18, 2025
Thanks so much for taking the time to review your experience. It is so meaningful to our small company! We look forward to the next auction!:)
ATTRIBUTED TO JACOB MEDINGER (MONTGOMERY COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA, 1856-1932), DOUBLE-HANDLED REDWARE

Michael
Saint Clairsville, OH

Aug 13, 2025
Great Federal table!
Many thanks to both Amelia Jeffers and to Mike at UPS store # 3910 in New Albany OH for safely bringng this refined example of vernacular Federal period furniture to my door. I am grateful to both businesses for their thorough and efficient services. I highly recommend both places to anyone looking for a hassle free experience.
Report
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 13, 2025
Thanks so much for the feedback! Mike and his team are a great partner for us! Grateful for your bidding and that you took the time to leave this review!
FEDERAL EBONIZED POPLAR ONE-DRAWER STAND.

Peter
Providence, RI

Jul 28, 2025
Great the best
Have dealt with them before and always great response and service
Report
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 13, 2025
Thanks so much for taking the time to review your experience. It is so meaningful to our small company! We look forward to the next auction!:)
G.H. GREENE (BRIDGEWATER, MASSACHUSETTS) PAINTED AND CAST IRON TORY DOORSTOP.

GEORGE K ARNOLD FINE ART & ANTIQUES
Ormond Beach, FL

Jul 21, 2025
An Auction you can trust
5-STARS
Report
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 13, 2025
Thanks so much for taking the time to review your experience. It is so meaningful to our small company! We look forward to the next auction!:)
PERSIAN WOOL TREE OF LIFE MAT.

David
Zanesville, OH

Jun 08, 2025
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 13, 2025
Thanks so much for taking the time to review your experience. It is so meaningful to our small company! We look forward to the next auction!:)
"THE VILLAGE BRIDGE" BY LESLIE COPE (1913-2002).

Dawn
Minneapolis, MN

Jun 06, 2025
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 13, 2025
Thanks so much for taking the time to review your experience. It is so meaningful to our small company! We look forward to the next auction!:)
WOOD TOTE WITH SEWING NOTIONS.

Kevin
Ocean Grove, NJ

Jun 06, 2025
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 13, 2025
Thanks so much for taking the time to review your experience. It is so meaningful to our small company! We look forward to the next auction!:)
UNUSUAL PAINTED AND CARVED NEW JERSEY BLANKET BOX.

Amy
Greenville, OH

May 22, 2025
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 13, 2025
Thanks so much for taking the time to review your experience. It is so meaningful to our small company! We look forward to the next auction!:)
TWO PATRIOTIC HOOKED THROW RUGS.

Mike
Bridge City, TX

May 17, 2025
👍
👍
Report
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 13, 2025
Thanks so much for taking the time to review your experience. It is so meaningful to our small company! We look forward to the next auction!:)
LIGHTED WINCHESTER ADVERTISING SIGN.

PEDRO I
Palm City, FL

May 17, 2025
AMELIA JEFFERS AUCTION TEAM IS SUPERIOR IN EVERY SENSE
THE SERVICE PROVIDED BY THE AMELIA JEFFERS AUCTION TEAM WAS SUPERIOR IN EVERY SENSE. THEIR PROFICIENCY AND DEDICATION WERE EVIDENT FROM THE FIRST INTERACTION ON THE PHONE TO THE FINAL SHIPPING ARRANGEMENT. A REMARKABLE BLEND OF PROFESSIONALISM, KNOWLEDGE, AND CLASSY PERSONAL TOUCH MARKED THEIR APPROACH. EVERYONE ON THE TEAM EXHIBITED AN EXCEPTIONAL LEVEL OF PROFESSIONALISM THROUGHOUT THE PROCESS. THEIR DEMEANOR WAS HONEST, VERIDIC, COURTEOUS, AND RESPECTFUL, ENSURING THAT CLIENTS FELT VALUED AND HEARD. THEY ADVERTISED AND MANAGED THE EVENT WITH AUTHENTICITY, PRECISION, MAINTAINING AN ORGANIZED AND EFFICIENT ENVIRONMENT THAT FACILITATED SMOOTH PROCEEDINGS. THE WRAPPING AND PACKING OF THE ITEMS WERE SUPERIOR, AND THE ITEMS ARRIVED IN PERFECT CONDITION. THEIR PACKING AND SHIPPING COSTS WERE SURPRISINGLY NOMINAL, ESPECIALLY CONSIDERING THE DELIVERY DISTANCE AND ITEM VOLUME. I AM EXTREMELY IMPRESSED BY AND GRATEFUL TO AMELIA JEFFERS AUCTION, AND I PLAN TO CONTINUE TO BUY FROM THIS OUTSTANDING ONLINE SELLER.
Report
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & Appraisers logo
Amelia Jeffers, Auctioneers & AppraisersAug 13, 2025
Oh my goodness! Thank you for this generous praise! My team and I are so motivated to create the kind of feeling and experience you have described. It is incredibly gratifying to hear when we have exceeded expectations! Hoping to have you "back" for another auction soon!
ROBINSON RANSBOTTOM COBALT DECORATED EARTHENWARE LIDDED WATER COOLER.