Reviews
Bidder Reviews for Old Steel Historical Firearms LLC (163)
TOP RATED4.6 out of 5.0 Stars
5 Star
88%(143)
4 Star
7%(11)
3 Star
2%(3)
2 Star
2%(3)
1 Star
2%(3)
Accurate Descriptions
Quick Responses
Easy Payments
Seamless Shipping
50-100 of 163 Reviews
PaulLancaster, MA
Apr 25, 2026
GregSanderson, FL
Apr 23, 2026
Great company and saved a sale due to better shipping costs
Great outfit. Prompt payment processing and excellent shipping prices very competitive. I would highly recommend them. Product was delivered on time, as expected and with no surprises. Thanks for the sale. Hope to do business again in the future.
AB1 MANAGMENT LLC Cooper City, FL
Apr 20, 2026
PaulSumter, SC
Apr 20, 2026
BrianDelaplane, VA
Apr 12, 2026
Great experience!
First time auction buyer and I am very satisfied with the experience. Item was described accurately, was packed very well and shipped quicker than I was assuming. The communication was quick, friendly and helpful. Thanks!
MitchelSpringfield, OR
Apr 12, 2026
Excellent auction house
Accurate description. Quick shipping. Easy, all the way around. Nothing else need be said.
RobertAfton, MN
Apr 12, 2026
Very honest and helpful when I called with a shipping question.
Shipping has become a problem to figure out. Old Steel looks out for their customers.
AB1 MANAGMENT LLC Cooper City, FL
Apr 5, 2026
PaulLancaster, MA
Apr 3, 2026
Murray Mannsville, OK
Mar 30, 2026
Item was well packaged and taken care of. Good folks to work with. Would definitely use again.
Item was well packaged and taken care of. Good folks to work with. Would definitely use again.
BruceWest Haven, CT
Mar 16, 2026
AlbertHelena, AL
Mar 15, 2026
JackLufkin, TX
Mar 15, 2026
I am completely satisfied with the guns and more importantly, the service from Old Steel firearms.
I am impressed by the service from Old Steel firearms. Most any company can compete on price, yet it's the service after the sale that makes the most difference. Old Steel firearms was prompt in shipping the guns and were the exact same as the catalog showed. Highest recommendation for future business. Thanks Jack
davidNebraska City, NE
Mar 15, 2026
They placed a lot sticker on a leather item which then removed finish from the leather.
I can't honestly imagine anyone with any experience with vintage leather would put a sticker on the leather item. Could have been placed on any other part of the item and it wouldn't have affected the finish. Actually, adhesive stickers have no place being stuck to an auction item in the first place, especially for something as inconsequential as a lot #. That is what hang tags are for. When contacted, received no reply back. That was really disappointing.
VincentWimauma, FL
Mar 13, 2026
BrianFort Wayne, IN
Mar 4, 2026
RICHARDChalfont, PA
Feb 23, 2026
AnthonyOzone Park, NY
Jan 18, 2026
JingmingPleasanton, CA
Jan 18, 2026
JohnnyNorwood, CO
Jan 18, 2026
CharlesElizabethport, NJ
Jan 11, 2026
Great prices and fast shipping
Thank you so much for the fast shipping and great communication. I truly appreciate it and hope to do business with again
Jonathan Canandaigua, NY
Jan 8, 2026
JeffreyDevils Lake, ND
Dec 31, 2025
Excellent experience!
Top shelf interaction with staff member and shipping department. A great online auction experience!
ERIKNorth Wilkesboro, NC
Dec 22, 2025
everything was great. looking forward to the next auction.
everything was great. looking forward to the next auction.
JohnBell Buckle, TN
Dec 11, 2025
Dec 7, 2025
FredOrange Park, FL
Dec 7, 2025
JamesPapillion, NE
Nov 28, 2025
AndyCorona, CA
Nov 5, 2025
honest good people and items for sale
they are very professional and I would buy from them again.
StevenSumter, SC
Oct 26, 2025
Excellent experience bidding with Old Steel Historical Firearms
The written and photographic descriptions were accurate and clear. I received excellent service on in-house shipping. Very pleased with Old Steel and have already bid on items in a future auction.
GregNaples, FL
Oct 26, 2025
TimothyLees Summit, MO
Oct 26, 2025
DaveDallas, TX
Oct 26, 2025
JeremyWaterloo, OH
Oct 26, 2025
Great company!
Old Steel Historic Firearms LLC was great to deal with. Received amazing items at a great price! Contacted them concerning shipping as the Liveauctioneers shipping was very high and they were a great help! I highly recommend doing business with them. I hope to do so again in the future! Thanks for everything!!
AB1 MANAGMENT LLC Cooper City, FL
Oct 16, 2025
Harold EDumfries, VA
Oct 8, 2025
Jonathan Canandaigua, NY
Oct 3, 2025
DonGrenada, MS
Sep 29, 2025
RickPlymouth, MI
Sep 29, 2025
john f.Milwaukee, WI
Sep 28, 2025
AnthonyOzone Park, NY
Sep 16, 2025
Honest, straight shooters. Chelsey was great
I would rather bid more with Chelsey. Great service. honest and fair
TOP