Hartzell's Auction Gallery, Inc., PA - Read over 1,544 Reviews from Customers
LiveAuctioneers Logo
Reviews

Bidder Reviews for Hartzell's Auction Gallery, Inc. (1,544)

badge TOP RATED
4.7 out of 5.0 Stars
5 Star
90%(1392)
4 Star
5%(73)
3 Star
2%(28)
2 Star
1%(10)
1 Star
3%(41)
trophy

Accurate Descriptions

trophy

Quick Responses

trophy

Easy Payments

trophy

Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 1,544 Reviews

LaurieEast Stroudsburg, PA

Oct 4, 2026
Very friendly and professional!
Hartzell Auction Gallery makes everything easy, from the postings to the pickup process. Everyone is very friendly and helpful and professional and knowledgeable. Always a great experience.
Report
LOT OF (6) PEWTER ICE CREAM MOLDS, CHOCOLATE

AliceOrange, CT

Oct 4, 2026
LOT OF VICTORIAN TRADE CARDS / BLOTTERS

JoeSouth River, NJ

Sep 13, 2026
Great description and item quality
Everything was top shelf, but I thought the shipping was a high.
Report
G.A. KOHL, LAMBERTVILLE, N.J. BOTTLE

AllenBethlehem, PA

Sep 13, 2026
DERAIL CAST IRON SIGNAL SIGN

RichardBirmingham, AL

Sep 13, 2026
One of the Best!
One of the best auction houses. Always a pleasure to do business!
Report
(2) TIN LUNCH PAILS

JamesLa Cygne, KS

Sep 13, 2026
Added Costs too High
Selling fee much higher than other auction houses from other parts of country. Also handling, packageing, and shipping fees are extremely high compared to other sellers.
Report
(2) MILLVILLE FRUIT JARS

NicholasTroy, PA

Sep 9, 2026
(2) CAST IRON TOY STOVES

KennethPlymouth, MI

Aug 31, 2026
ITME DESCRIPTION AND CONDITION
HONEST AUCTION HOUSE, WELL PACKED ITEMS, AS DESCRIBED, GOOD VALUE
Report
CAST IRON SEAL BANK

KennethPlymouth, MI

Aug 31, 2026
SERVICE
HONEST AUCTION HOUSE, WELL PACKED ITEMS, AS DESCRIBED, GOOD VALUE
Report
(3) TIN LITHO BANKS

LaurieEast Stroudsburg, PA

Aug 28, 2026
Very friendly and helpful!
Everyone at Hartzell's Auction is very friendly and helpful. They are all very professional and knowledgeable. Great to work with!
Report
LARGE AQUA WATER BOTTLE

KimBrooklyn, NY

Aug 23, 2026
MID CENTURY MODERN PAUL MCCOBB MAPLE CHEST

Helen RMillbrook, NY

Aug 23, 2026
Incredibly fast...
Of all the auction houses I've dealt with these past years, Hartzell's is hands down the most efficient, has very reasonably priced in-house shipping, and quickest to get your won lots to you-really excellent
Report
(2) ENGLISH SPORTING PRINTS

RobertWilloughby, OH

Aug 18, 2026
(3) VINTAGE PAINTED CAST IRON CARS

JackBelvidere, NJ

Aug 16, 2026
"NAUGHTY NELLIE" BOOT JACK

ScottBristow, VA

Aug 16, 2026
(2) PAINTED CAST IRON MOTORCYCLES

JamesRutland, MA

Aug 16, 2026
Easy process
Nice transaction from a nice Auction House!!
Report
BLUE DECORATED STONEWARE PITCHER

NicholasTroy, PA

Aug 16, 2026
Greatttt
Received this the other day and their in house packing and shipping has always been great and for the most part reasonable. I’ve been dealing with them for quite a few years now and they’ve been great.
Report
19TH C. OIL ON CANVAS, ORNATE FRAME

ZbigniewBelchatow, PL

Aug 9, 2026
Iron collection
Ca ł y proces od wygranej licytacji do wysy ł ki i szybko ś ć dostawy. Wszystko szybko i sprawnie. Dostawa do drzwi w przeci ą gu 11 dni.
Report
(2) MINIATURE DETACHABLE HANDLE ADVERTISING IRONS

JerryValley Stream, NY

Aug 9, 2026
ADVERTISING SMOOTHING IRON

LuisBoston, MA

Aug 8, 2026
LOT OF NATIVE AMERICAN PHOTOGRAPHS

NicholasTroy, PA

Aug 7, 2026
Love it
Great items as shown and promised. Great packing, pleasure to deal with
Report
(2) VINTAGE, SMALL SIZE WAFFLE IRONS

JustinDoylestown, PA

Aug 3, 2026
Friendly and professional
Rich was friendly and professional. He even helped me load for a few minutes in July heat & humidity. I would not hesitate to go through Hartzell's in the future.
Report
RELIANT 14" BAND SAW

TimStroudsburg, PA

Aug 2, 2026
Merchandise advertised accurately, payment easy, questions answered quickly
Merchandise advertised accurately, payment easy, questions answered quickly, highly professional!
Report
2020 FIAT 124 SPIDER ABARTH

JamesRingoes, NJ

Aug 2, 2026
DEWALT 20V 1/2" TORQUE IMPACT

MarkMaplewood, NJ

Aug 2, 2026
Great experience
Everyone from Hartzell's was friendly and accommodating. l went to the preview and all my questions were answered. When picking up the lots I won, everyone went above and beyond the call of duty to help.
Report
CABINET TOP AND MORE

RichardBartonsville, PA

Aug 2, 2026
LARGE LOT OF ITEMS

NicholasTroy, PA

Aug 2, 2026
ANTIQUE TURKMAN SADDLE BAG

RobertDixon, IL

Jul 30, 2026
WALT DISNEY AND POPEYE TINS

Denise Prescott Valley, AZ

Jul 28, 2026
ARMOND MARSEILLE BISQUE HEAD DOLL KID BODY

DrewMaitland, FL

Jul 28, 2026
SUPER FAST
Got my invoice, shipping and items all extremely fast and well packed. Thank you!!!
Report
(2) HAT IRONS

RobinHudson's Hope, CA

Jul 26, 2026
Prompt and Courteous.
Great to work with. My item was packed safely and shipped expeditiously.
Report
SPARK IRON HEATER POTBELLY STOVE

EricNew York, NY

Jul 26, 2026
Quite happy
Smooth, unexceptional transaction, and I got a useful item. Quite happy.
Report
"YAWMAN & ERBE" OAK FILE DRAWER

AngelaProsperity, SC

Jul 26, 2026
PORCELAIN LITHOPHANE MUG

LindaWesthampton, NY

Jul 16, 2026
Excellent Experience
Very helpful and friendly. I would definitely recommend Hartzell's!
Report
LOT OF ANTIQUE GLASS NEGATIVES

MartinMurfreesboro, TN

Jul 15, 2026
LARGE TRAMP ART FRAME

JohnCatskill, NY

Jul 15, 2026
Wonderful Experience, from Start to Finish
I cannot recommend Hartzell's highly enough. The items I purchased were bargains; the professionalism exhibited after purchase was first-rate.
Report
CURRIER & IVES FIRED DEPARTMENT CERTIFICATE

JoeSouth River, NJ

Jul 12, 2026
Hartzell's Proves Time After Time That They Are A Quality Auction House
Everything from registering for the auction, bidding, checkout & shipment was top shelf. Be aware that Hartzell's DOES NOT gouge you for shipping. Their shipping rates are in line with the going rates and their packing is excellent. Quality all the way!
Report
S. SMITH'S KNICKERBOCKER BOTTLE

Kevin Bethlehem, PA

Jul 12, 2026
S. EVERHART, EASTON PA BOTTLE

DianaTroy, PA

Jul 12, 2026
great auction house
Wonderful items. I hope to see more on the future
Report
WOODEN HANGING SHELF

JosephAtlanta, GA

Jul 12, 2026
(4) DOVER, NJ EMBOSSED BOTTLES

PeterPeace Dale, RI

Jul 12, 2026
HOPKINS & LEWIS TALL CASE CLOCK

LucienneNazareth, PA

Jul 12, 2026
VINTAGE LEATHER WINGBACK CHAIR

YuriyBrooklyn, NY

Jul 12, 2026
(3) ACOUSTIC RESEARCH SPEAKERS

TigheBangor, PA

Jul 12, 2026
SCRANTON, PA ADVERTISING SCRIPT JUG

FrankYork, CA

Jul 12, 2026
TANDBERG CASSETTE DECK

AbelardoSacramento, CA

Jul 11, 2026
Unhappy with item. Auction house unresponsive
Unhappy with item. Auction house unresponsive
Report
800 SILVER SYRUP PITCHER

GaryQuakertown, PA

Jul 1, 2026
A great place to do business with. Very knowledgable.
Thanks
Report
Topps 1998 Set with Variety of Packs.

JimRoanoke, AL

Jun 30, 2026
Very good expreience from start to finish!
Requested a shipping quote, received one quickly. Won three items, paid and received a shipping invoice quickly, paid it and received the items safe and sound in a week. Considering how many lots that were in the auction I am pleasently surprised and happy about the whole process. Great Job! Looking forward to other finds in your future auctions.
Report
MCINTOSH STEREO PREAMP

Joe Staten Island, NY

Jun 28, 2026
(20) Marvel comics (Midnight Sons) comic books "Ghost Rider"

toddWaterville, OH

Jun 21, 2026
(39) Dark Horse and Legend comic books.