DAVENPORT, WA – Professional women’s baseball was a dream that became reality. As with most things that allowed women to expand their horizons in the 20th century, World War II opened the door. Most of the sport’s best male players of the 1940s traded their bats for bayonets and their tour buses for troop transports, leaving behind a baseball-starved nation.
Phillip K. Wrigley, son of the chewing gum magnate who purchased an ownership stake in the Chicago Cubs team in 1916, cofounded the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League in 1943, and held the tryouts at Wrigley Field. The league managed to outlast the war, but dwindling attendance and gate receipts led to its demise in 1954. Nonetheless, its twelve years of existence paved the way for professional women’s sports of all sorts. The story of American professional women’s baseball was dramatized in the beloved 1992 film A League of Their Own, as well as two small-screen versions bearing the same title, one on CBS in 1993 and another on Amazon Prime in 2022.
Several artifacts from the time when the Rockford Peaches, Racine Belles, and Peoria Redwings ruled baseball diamonds were presented at Grant Zahajko in its August 21 Sports Cards & Memorabilia & Collectibles auction. The lots had modest three-figure estimates and many bested those numbers, proving this underexplored realm of sports memorabilia remains in reach of collectors.
The Rockford Peaches team was the most dominant of the ten, winning four league championships. The sticker-covered suitcase toted by Rockford Peach pitcher Mary ‘Prattie’ Pratt, who died in 2020 at the age of 101, is on display at the Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown, New York. While the Rockford Peaches baseball cap offered at Zahajko was not linked to Pratt or any specific player, it was authentic and described as being in ‘excellent condition’. Estimated at $100-$200, it earned $441 with buyer’s premium.
Six yearbooks for the Racine Belles, having all their pages and spanning the years 1944 to 1949, were presented. All sold, and four beat their estimates. Interestingly, only the earliest of the six yearbooks had a photographic cover, showing an unidentified woman in uniform with a bat on her shoulder and a noble look on her face. It was one of the two that sold within estimate.
The four that exceeded their numbers featured idealized illustrations of women players, and the one that did the best of all, a 1947 yearbook, showed a catcher peeling her mask off to reveal a smiling, perfectly made-up face and a curly coiffure. The quick aesthetic shift from photographs to illustrations might reflect the league owners’ concerns that the players appear unimpeachably feminine.
Perhaps the glamorous 1947 cover image helped spark bidding, but it was also one of three yearbooks in the lineup that boasted more than ten autographs from women players. It drew the highest estimate of the six, at $300-$400, and it realized $819 with buyer’s premium.
Another winner was a postcard with a black-and-white image of the Peoria Redwings, issued in 1946, the year of the team’s debut. No one pictured is identified in the lot notes, but the women players are flanked by their chaperone on the left and their manager on the right. Estimated at $100-$200, it sold for $284 with buyer’s premium.
Vintage Rockford Peaches baseball cap, $441 with buyer’s premium at Grant Zahajko.
1947 Racine Belles yearbook with 18 signatures from players, $819 with buyer’s premium at Grant Zahajko.
1946 postcard with a black-and-white team photo of the Peoria Redwings, $284 with buyer’s premium at Grant Zahajko.