Milestone’s selection of Winchesters, Colts, draws enthusiastic bidders

selection of Winchesters

Near-mint unissued Whitney Model 1861 U.S. Navy rifle, barrel dated 1863, .69 caliber, large eagle-and-flag motif on lock. Bayonet made by Collins & Co. (Hartford, Conn.). Sold within estimate for $6,000. Milestone Auctions image

WILLOUGHBY, Ohio – Milestone Auctions continues to increase its bidder base and market share, as evidenced most recently by their successful and well-attended Nov. 2 Premier Firearms sale. There was strong international interest in the 830 lots of high-quality modern-era handguns and long arms, as well as big-caliber and antique guns and rifles, many from the Civil War era.

“There wasn’t any one particular ‘top gun’ in this auction – there were highlights in all of the various categories,” said Milestone Auctions co-owner Chris Sammet. “For this event, we focused on accessibility and offered as wide a variety of clean, desirable firearms as possible. There were some great Colt models and the largest selection of Winchesters ever cataloged in a single Milestone sale. It seemed to us that very few collectors, if any, left the auction disappointed.”

Leading the list of prices realized was a near-mint unissued Whitney Model 1861 U.S. Navy rifle (above). The .69-caliber gun featuring a large eagle-and-flag motif on its lock and “1863” on its barrel came with a bayonet made by Collins & Co., of Hartford, Connecticut. It reached its presale estimate range, settling at $6,000.

A high-condition Smith & Wesson 2nd Model Schofield .45-caliber revolver (below), U.S.-issued during the Indian Wars era, was one of fewer than 6,000 of its type produced in 1876 and 1877. “The survival rate of original Schofield revolvers remains very low, given a large majority were purchased from the government by Wells Fargo, which had the barrels shortened and stamped with the company’s logo,” said Sammet. The auction’s scarce original-state gun sold for an above-estimate $5,760.

selection of Winchesters

High-condition Smith & Wesson 2nd Model Schofield .45-caliber revolver, US-issued Indian Wars era, 1877. Sold for $5,760. Milestone Auctions image

The highest-priced Colt in the sale was a high-condition Model 1878 six-shot double-action revolver designed to use a .44-.40 cartridge. Although the double-action revolver had been popular in England since before the Civil War, it was a novel idea in America, and gun makers feared the public would not like the change. “But they were wrong,” Sammet said. “Both the small-frame Model 1877 and large-frame Model 1878 went on to become very popular out west and in the East, as well.” The example in Milestone’s auction, which was made in 1893, sold at the midpoint of its estimate range for $4,560.

selection of Winchesters

High-condition Colt Model 1878 .44-.40 cartridge double-action revolver, made in 1893. Sold within estimate at $4,560. Milestone Auctions image

Several novelty firearms caught the attention of bidders, including a circa-1850s E.M. Reilly (London) .32-caliber air-powered cane gun designed to shoot lead balls. Presented in its original felt-lined, partitioned oak case with the dealer’s trade label affixed inside the lid, it surpassed expectations at $3,120.

selection of Winchesters

Circa-1850s E.M. Reilly (London) .32-caliber air-powered cane gun in original oak partitioned case with dealer’s trade label inside lid. Shoots lead balls. Sold above estimate for $3,120. Milestone Auctions image

Another intriguing item was an 1850s wood sewing case with a pincushion top that opened to reveal what was in actuality a false bottom. Hidden away in the cavity below was a 4-inch-long, .22-caliber Derringer. Accompanied by a partial cardboard box of Clinton .22 short ammunition, the Derringer sewing case sold for $1,920, nearly four times the high estimate.

selection of Winchesters

Novel 1850s wood sewing case with pincushion top that opens to reveal beneath its false bottom a 4-inch-long, .22-caliber Derringer. Sold for $1,920, nearly four times the high estimate. Milestone Auctions image

Yet another unusual firearm was a U.S.-made Model FP-45 Liberator .45-caliber single-shot pistol. Produced solely in 1942, it was cheap and easy to mass-produce because it had only 23 mostly stamped and turned steel parts. “The Liberator pistol, which could accommodate five extra rounds of ammunition in its pistol grip, was intended for use behind enemy lines by resistance fighters wanting to quickly overtake an enemy and seize his gun. It was not intended for long-term use,” Sammet explained. Estimated at $800-$1,200, the gun offered by Milestone sold for $2,040.

selection of Winchesters

U.S.-made Model FP-45 Liberator .45-caliber single-shot pistol, produced solely in 1942, intended for use behind enemy lines by resistance fighters. Sold for $2,040 against an estimate of $800-$1,200. Milestone Auctions image.

Winchester collectors were charmed by a huge (37½- by 55-inch) cardboard three-panel ad produced in 1924, following the competitive shooting season of 1923. Richly colorful, it depicts shooters in military garb, trap shooters armed with Winchester’s Model 12 slide-action shotgun, deer hunters with a Model 1894 rifle in a canoe, and a display of dozens of Winchester ammunition boxes. Bright and clean, the sign sold within estimate for $2,340.

selection of Winchesters

Huge Winchester cardboard triptych ad, 1924, framed, 37½ x 55 inches (sight), bright and clean. Sold within estimate for $2,340. Milestone Auctions image

Milestone Auctions is now accepting consignments for their 2020 firearms auctions. All inquiries will be kept confidential. Contact Milestone’s firearms expert Dave Bushing by calling 440-527-8060 or email All prices quoted are inclusive of buyer’s premium as specified on Milestone Auctions’ website.