WILLOUGHBY, Ohio – Some of the highest-quality firearms and most important historical relics ever to pass through Milestone Auctions’ doors will be presented in a January 19 sale comprising more than 800 lots. Many of the items chosen for the suburban Cleveland company’s first event of 2019 are fresh to the market from private collections. Bid absentee or live via the Internet through LiveAuctioneers.
Featured: Extraordinary Civil War archives containing Pa. soldier’s diaries, tintype, Gettysburg correspondence + POW collection of officers’ CDVs, bone carvings
The auction was intentionally designed as a one-day affair. “We’re a boutique auction house and take a different approach as to how we market consignments. I think it’s especially evident with our firearms sales,” said Milestone co-owner Chris Sammet. “While a marathon sale of three or four consecutive days may work quite well for some auction houses, we prefer not to conduct massive multiple-day firearms sales. We strive to keep the number of lots manageable so items don’t get lost in the shuffle. We feel that we owe it to our consignors to make sure their pieces have a chance to shine.”
The January 19 auction will open with modern-era firearms and conclude with antique weapons whose timeline starts with a 1680-1720 British .80 caliber dog-lock musket. Important militaria will be interspersed throughout, adding variety to the day’s lineup.
The Civil War section of the sale is led by two exceptional collections. Lot 376 (shown below) consists of a Civil War POW grouping from Lt. Josephus F Schuyler of the 123rd Ohio Voluntary Infantry. Schuyler was captured in 1863 and sent to Richmond’s notorious Libby Prison.
During his imprisonment at Libby, Schuyler amassed an autograph book of fellow officers’ signatures and photographic cartes de visite. Together with the ephemera, he retained many articles that he carved from bone while incarcerated, from cutlery to rings to crochet hooks. Each is a work of art. This extensive set of Civil War mementos was sourced directly from one of Schuyler’s descendants and is estimated at $15,000-$20,000.
A second featured Civil War archive is so extensive that it has been apportioned into 11 consecutive lots, starting with Lot 377 (shown below). All of the items represented pertain to the Civil War service of James Bolestridge of the 23rd Regiment Pennsylvania Volunteers and, later, Birney’s Zouave regiment.
Within this extraordinary collection of historical keepsakes, which was retained by many successive generations of Bolestridge’s family, are a ferrotype of the soldier in uniform at age 17, his enlistment papers, saber bayonet, medals, CDVs, diaries, and a riveting collection of 50 wartime letters. In one of them, Bolestridge describes the Battle of Gettysburg, writing: “I have escaped unharmed during the last fight,” going on to note regimental casualties and the nature of wounds, some mortal. Bolestridge added: “We gave the Rebels a terrible punishing on the 3rd of July and if it had not been so stormy on the 4th we would have peppered them again…” Chris Sammet expects the 11 lots to realize at least $25,000 cumulatively.
Included among the earlier firearm highlights is a witness to America’s westward expansion, a Winchester 1873 (patent) .44 caliber saddle ring carbine rifle. It was shipped from the Winchester warehouse in 1889 and has the rare distinction of having been a traveling salesman’s sample. “This is confirmed by the notation within its matching Winchester letter (included in auction lot) that says ‘Consigned,’” Sammet explained. In excellent condition, its auction goal is $15,000-$20,000.
Another very rare Winchester is an experimental or prototype .32-.40 caliber lever-action rifle discovered in a Vallejo, California gun shop that went out of business in 1942. “In 1990, this unique rifle was taken to the 15th annual Winchester Arms Collectors show in Cody, Wyoming, and to the Winchester Museum. No information pertaining to it could be found. In 1991 an article about the gun, titled ‘An Unknown Winchester Rifle,’ appeared in ‘The Winchester Repeater.’” Sammet said. “This important rifle comes from the collection of John Kopec, a renowned Winchester and Colt collector. It’s already attracting many inquiries.” Estimate: $10,000-$15,000
Within the 20th-century firearms category, a desirable 1936 Krieghoff Suhl semi-automatic Luger pistol ranks very highly. Dated and bearing Krieghoff proof marks, the near-mint example from the World War II era is expected to make $6,000-$8,000.
A rare 1939 German SA presentation dagger with a Damascus blade by E.F. Horster is engraved on the obverse in high-relief gold: “Alles fur Deutschland” (All for Germany). The rare Nazi piece came out of the collection of WWII veteran Master Sgt. Dominick J. DeMaggio, who was an interrogator and interpreter of Italian POWs. With fitted box, the historical dagger is estimated at $15,000-$20,000.
One of the highest-estimated lots in the sale is a WWII Luftwaffe gold “Double Badge” with 150 brilliant-cut diamonds. Regarded as one of the most sumptuous awards of the Third Reich, such brooches were created to a very high standard, under instruction of high-ranking Nazi leader Hermann Goring, who awarded them to favored Luftwaffe members and important Third Reich figures of allied states. Accompanied by a Detlev Niemann COA, the example to be auctioned is estimated at $70,000-$80,000.
Made in 1990, a featured Colt .45 single-action army revolver is a cutaway special edition that comes with a printed Colt historian letter, original box and papers. The letter notes that the term “cutaway” refers to the left stock, which has been designed to allow for viewing of the internal mechanism. Only 100 units of this special model were produced, and the one being auctioned is one of only seven made in its particular configuration. In crisp, mint condition, it carries a $5,000-$7,000 estimate.
For the antique gun collector who is a “completist,” a Smith & Wesson Model 320 revolving rifle originally shipped on May 29, 1894 would fit the bill nicely. Not only is it one of the most sought after of all Smith & Wesson guns, it also comes housed in a custom French-fit wood case with a box of scarce Smith & Wesson .320 cartridges, and a detailed S&W factory letter. Its auction expectation is $8,000-$12,000.
Milestone’s Saturday, January 19, 2019 Historic Military and Firearms Auction will begin at 10 a.m. Eastern Time, with absentee and Internet live bidding available through LiveAuctioneers. For additional information on any item in the auction, call 440-527-8060 or email firstname.lastname@example.org.