Baker's Antiques and Auctions, NY - Read over 440 Reviews from Customers
LiveAuctioneers Logo

Bidder Reviews for Baker's Antiques and Auctions (440)

3.5 out of 5.0 Stars

150-200 of 440 Reviews

All Ratings
Highest Rated

Sean
Richmond, VA

Oct 08, 2020
Sent wrong item, THIS IS A SCAM!
Sent wrong item, THIS IS A SCAM!
Report

Nathan
Marion, NC

Oct 02, 2020
Be CAREFUL when bidding with these guys!
Won an item in an auction on July 4th. It is now OCTOBER!!! I made payment up front, never got any updates. I tried contacting via phone and live auctioneer messages, no response. Today (October 3rd) they took an additional 50 bucks from my checking account without my permission. I attempted contact, could not get anyone to answer the phone. 10 minutes later, someone calls back, says that 50 bucks is a shipping charge. I asked this person if they knew what was being shipped, they had no clue. I questioned a $50 shipping charge on an unknown item and was told that my item is heavy. How would they know? He had no clue what was sent to me. Furthermore, they could not tell me if the item was sent fedex, UPS or US mail, only that "We ship items out by the hundreds, we have been backed up". One thing is for certain, I will NEVER deal with this auction house again. A complaint was lodged with live auctioneers, yet it has not really gone anywhere. As someone who makes a living buying, selling, and shipping items, I can say that this is by far the WORST experience I have ever had. I finish by saying, make sure what you bid on is worth the headache of trying to get it sent to you.
Report
Moving and Storage Company mystery box lot

Alan
Hillsborough, NH

Sep 24, 2020
Selection of automemorabilia
Reasonable bidders
Report

Artem
Frisco, TX

Sep 22, 2020

Francine
Pittsburgh, PA

Sep 14, 2020
Muhammed Ali boxing champion Wheaties cereal box

Sep 12, 2020
I never received the item that I won in the auction and Baker’s never returned my messages.
I won an auction and called to make the payment. My credit card was charged by Baker’s but I never received the item. To make matters worse, they never responded to my emails or phone calls.
Report

Sep 09, 2020
Have not received items
I have four outstanding items from Baker's Antiques and Auctions, one being almost five weeks. I got this item within a week, but I have not received the others, nor have I received a response from Baker's with tracking numbers.
Report

Harrison
Las Vegas, NV

Sep 09, 2020
Very Poor Communication and Service These Days
In the past Baker has always been slow but great folks and goods always arrived timely. This most recent purchase, called for payment immediately following auction closing, paid with CC. today is Sept. 9, 2020 no merchandise, NO RESPONSE to many, many messages etc. They are good folks so not sure what is going on there past few months. Proceed at your own discretion.
Report

Matt
Oakland, CA

Sep 06, 2020
Took 2 months to deliver, charged me twice
I had to call this place twice just to get them to mail the package I'd won more than a month previous, and after I finally did get it-disappointed in the item, because it was described poorly int he listing-they charged me again. Same amount I'd paid two months earlier. I guess they're so unused to delivering items to customers, they figure they should get a bonus for actually doing it. There are a lot better auction houses out there-shop elsewhere.
Report
Large box full of vintage baseball cards

Stefan
Park Ridge, IL

Sep 01, 2020
delivery
Did a great job in shipping. Nice item.
Report

George
Cleveland Heights, OH

Sep 01, 2020
Great, smooth, honest transaction.
Had special requests and they accommodated me. Very pleased with dealings and lots.
Report

George
Cleveland Heights, OH

Sep 01, 2020
Great, smooth, honest transaction.
Had special requests and they accommodated me. Very pleased with dealings and lots.
Report
Box full of vintage children's books

George
Cleveland Heights, OH

Sep 01, 2020
Great, smooth, honest transaction.
Report
Hockey cards factory sealed box includes rookies

Mark
Lawrence, KS

Sep 01, 2020
Needs to Learn How to Pack Comics
I won two lots from these folks, and I received the comics in shrinkwrap. I would strongly recommend communicating with them before they ship your items that they be shipped bagged and not shrinkwrapped. Luckily my lots weren't damaged, but there could be significant issues with others.
Report

David
Abita Springs, LA

Aug 31, 2020

Michael
Wading River, NY

Aug 28, 2020
Very Good Experience
From start to finish the whole process was handled professionally & in a timely manner. Overall A +. Thank you.
Report
1989 Donruss baseball cards 36 pack box

Louise
Friendsville, MD

Aug 27, 2020
Good!
Item exactly as shown and fast and reasonably priced shipping. Happy.
Report
Delftware signed blue decorated cow creamer

William
Carrboro, NC

Aug 27, 2020
Lack of Communication
I have not recieved any responses from this aiction house after calling (leaving a message), messaging them via LiveAuctioneers, as well as a direct email. Their phone always goes to messaging and they leave thier customets in the dark.
Report

Melissa
Auburn, KS

Aug 18, 2020
Quick to take your money but no contact when you dont receive your items.
Won July 24th, payment and S & H processed in my bank, from their call to me (should have been a red flag), never received an invoice, items still shown unpaid on LiveAuctioneers website, and a month later still do not have my items. I have emailed them twice with no response. I do not recommend you do business with this auction house if you aren't willing to deal with the hassel.
Report
Hard Boiled Haggerty wrestling sports card

SCOTT
Evergreen, CO

Aug 17, 2020

George
Sandy Hook, CT

Aug 09, 2020

Elizabeth
Helendale, CA

Aug 02, 2020
Rip OFF/FRAUD
This Auction House has not sent me my items from May 27th or July. I have asked them about it and they ignore me.... When I called to make my payment for item I purchased, in second auction (at this point I assumed the previous item had not shipped due to corona,... I was wrong) and I inquired about where my first items I purchased were, the man taking my payment info all of a sudden couldn't wait to get off the phone. He made all kinds excuses as to why I hadn't received my items yet. These people are thieves.
Report

Rob
Lake Hopatcong, NJ

Jul 29, 2020
Payment and Shipping
It was so hard to get payment to them after an auction with multiple crossed voice mails, emails and phone calls. The auction was May 20, 2020 and the item was promptly paid for. It took until July 29, 2020 with several contacts from Live Auctioneers to settle this and not just receive my item, but get a response for an update on the status of shipping. I understand it may take longer beyond the auction date to ship, but after several unanswered emails and messages, it took Live Auctioneers intervention to get it resolved.
Report

Ross
Lethbridge, CA

Jul 28, 2020
Be very weary of this auction house!
This company uses multiple names which should be a red flag. They don't use the billing system with in the auction site. They don't send invoices for you to pay but rather just run your credit card that they have on file, and will keep running until you tell them to stop and then they charge you 30 dollars each time they do. I bought one item under 50.00 and by the time they had finished i owed over 200 and if i didn't pay they were going to black list me from the site. I have dealt with at least 20 other auction houses on this site that use the billing system and even send out invoices that allow you to pay at your leisure instead of just running your card when they see fit to do so. I don't recommend this auction house at all i would look to other more reputable auction houses. If anybody wants proof or has any questions feel free to email me at ********** and i can clearly explain and back up my claims.
Report
Baker's Antiques and Auctions logo
Baker's Antiques and AuctionsAug 17, 2020
Ross-You have on multiple occasions attempted to pay with lost, stolen, questionable or declined credit cards, that's the reason you have been disputed and blocked from bidding. Forget all that other nonsense. Please do not bid if you don't have the funds to pay for your purchases.

Lori
Dallas, GA

Jul 25, 2020
Still have not received
Although quick to process payment, they are not available for questions or emails. As of this date, the items have not shipped. I contacted Live Auctioneers for help and they finally were able to speak to them. They claim they don't have the staff to ship; however, they do have the staff to continue to have auctions. Maybe a reallocation of resources would be in order for this auction hours.
Report
Moving and Storage Company mystery box lot

Joseph
Bridgeport, PA

Jul 24, 2020

Gerry
Escondido, CA

Jun 25, 2020

David
Northbrook, IL

Jun 19, 2020
International Bank of Chicago bank check

Kathy
Newark, DE

Jun 15, 2020
A Month and NO Merchandise
Bakers has no ability to manage or track shipment. I am very disappointed that I have to keep following up. Lots of promises but no delivery.
Report

Russell
Buckhannon, WV

Jun 15, 2020
Large group of vintage Lincoln pennies

Patricia
Vineland, NJ

Jun 14, 2020
The owner was so nice!
Would you believe, I was called post auction to arrange payment? Packing to ship was done promptly, and my kitty arrived home immediately. I will visit again!
Report
Hand painted porcelain windup musical cat

Jun 10, 2020
do not buy a box of unknow items even if labeled
i got a box that was suppose to be disney and barbie and i got a box with easter chocolate, pez bars and alot of junk items. none were disney or barbie. i had to waste the whole box in the trash. edible goods should not be sold at an auction. Sorry I won't buy items like this again.
Report
Moving and Storage Company mystery box lot

Gary
Lynnfield, MA

Jun 08, 2020
item not received and concerns ignored
my bid won on the may 10th auction. it was paid in full on the 12 of may and I never received the item, I have email them twice and have had no response just been ignored. I would not recommend doing business with them.
Report

Kathy
Newark, DE

Jun 06, 2020
Slow, slow shipping
They aren’t set up for on line auctions. Although responsive to my inquiries, it’s clear they are overwhelmed. The auctions continue before previous merchandise is shipped. I like Bakers and their responsiveness but if you win, be prepared to wait.
Report
Warning Genius at work retro style advertising sign

Louise
Friendsville, MD

May 28, 2020
Reasonable inhouse shipping & quick delivery.
Eclectic offerings, low starting bids, reasonable inhouse shipping, & quick delivery. Same experience in 2 separate auctions. I now follow this auction house & recommend.
Report
Bundle of vintage baseball cards

charlene
Carthage, IL

May 25, 2020
None
None
Report
Vintage Star Trek kite

Theodore
Miller Place, NY

May 24, 2020

Mark
San Francisco, CA

May 21, 2020
Very Fair and Reliable Vendor!
A very fun experience with a smart dealer!
Report
Art pottery vase signed  Bob Verschure

Margaret
Santa Cruz, CA

May 15, 2020
Item not received
I won an auction item on 4/24 and paid quickly with my credit card. It is now 5/15 and the item has never been received.
Report
Great early figural cat pin

Barry
Waterford, MI

May 15, 2020

Randall
Margaree Centre, CA

May 14, 2020
This man AL Baker is one the down to earth men I have ever talked with in this business
Al, I will be slowly cutting back a bit. I would be interested in cards mainly. Can't wait to see what you have up your sleeve
Report

Karla
Worcester, MA

May 14, 2020

Daniel
Houston, TX

May 11, 2020
Antique Bicycle Search Light retro style sign

Eric
Livingston, NJ

May 08, 2020
1924 Lady Liberty Peace silver dollar in good condition

Shawn
Billings, MT

May 08, 2020
They closed down permanently, I think
I believe they closed down permanently. They took my payment and never received the item. They never responded back. So I called my bank to file a dispute charge. Live and learn.
Report
Huge collection of US American state quarters

Chris
Alex City, AL

May 07, 2020
Vintage Precious Moments figurines

Angela
Montgomery, NY

May 07, 2020
Group of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles toys

Randall
Margaree Centre, CA

May 07, 2020
all around great
never had a problem
Report
Gary Carter vintage Topps all star baseball card

Scott
Mendham, NJ

May 03, 2020
Poorly Organized Can Not Recommend
Very Disappointed in lack of respect given to paying clients.......... I've purchased from over 100 auctions houses over the years, even a number of them during the current Corona Challenges. Clear and Honest Communication Matters. This auction house is quick to call you, next business day asking for payment. They didn't read their emails, the one I sent the day of the auction, which I detailed all payment and shipping information. Additionally, dispute telling me item would ship out in a day or two.......... it didn't ship out for a 10 days. When I paid I requested a tracking number be emailed to me, which I don't receive. I waited and finally had to call them 2 wks later for a tracking number. Only to be told then that they ship out in multiples of 100???? Ha? They could not give me tracking information and called me back 6 hours later. Item was not shipped to the address I requested. Item I was told was in "good condition", Item is bronze and came in dented and split. Based on how it was "over wrapped" I have no reason to believe it was damaged in shipping. I realize this auction house mainly sells baseball cards, but I bought a !, 200.00 item.......... now looking at their very bad client reviews onliveauction.com I have to ask the question to LIVE AUCTION, WHY ARE YOU ALLOWING THIS AUCTION HOUSE TO BE ON YOUR ON YOUR WEB SITE? BUT HONESTLY............ When you call this auction they have no answering machine........ even during normal non corona times. They don't answer emails?? VERY DISAPPOINTED, WILL NOT BE BIDDING ON ANOTHER ITEM FROM THIS AUCTION HOUSE IN THE FUTURE, NO MATTER HOW RARE THE ITEM MAY BE.
Report

PTY872656 Mariano
Miami, FL

May 03, 2020
View:
50
TOP