Lot 0004

An 1889 Old Judge N172 Hugh Duffy Chicago Baseball Card (SGC 1)

Similar Sale History

View More Items in Trading Cards

Sold

An 1889 Old Judge N172 Charlie Sprague Cleveland Baseball Card (SGC 1) POP 1 in SGC: An 1889 Old Judge N172 Charlie Sprague Cleveland Baseball Card (SGC 1) POP 1 in SGC NOTE: If a bid is placed within one minute of the closing time of a lot, five additional minutes will be added to

An 1889 Old Judge N172 Charlie Sprague Cleveland Baseball Card (SGC 1) POP 1 in SGCSee Sold Price

Sold

OLD JUDGE 10,000 KELLEY CHOCAGO BASEBALL CARD: RARE VINTAGE 19TH CENT N172 OLD JUDGE CIGERETTE BASEBALL CARD - GOODWIN & CO N.Y - 10,000 KELLY (MIKE KING KELLEY) IN CHICAGO JERSEY W/ BAT AT THE READY LEFT HANDED - SLIGHTLY ROUNDED CORNERS - RESIDU

2022OLD JUDGE 10,000 KELLEY CHOCAGO BASEBALL CARDSee Sold Price

Sold

Old Judge N-172 baseball tobacco card: 1887-90 Goodwin Co. New York, Old Judge tobacco card, Dailey, pitcher, Philadelphia, pitching ball in right hand shoulder high (opinion of condition VG) note: back shows signs of being glued in album

2020Old Judge N-172 baseball tobacco cardSee Sold Price

Sold

Old Judge Cigarettes Baseball Cards N172: Group of 14 Estate-fresh Original Old Judge Cigarette baseball cards produced by Goodwin & Co. New York 1887-1890. This was the first major set of Baseball cards produced in the United States. All car

2015Old Judge Cigarettes Baseball Cards N172See Sold Price

Sold

OLD JUDGE ED SWEARD BASEBALL CARD: VINTAGE 19TH CENT N172 OLD JUDGE CIGERETTE BASEBALL CARD - GOODWIN & CO N.Y - SEWARD PITCHER ATHLETICS - ROUNDED CORNERS, 1 IN PENCIL ON BACK, IMPERFECTIONS - UNGRADED

2022OLD JUDGE ED SWEARD BASEBALL CARDSee Sold Price

Sold

OLD JUDGE WILLAIM SOWDERS BASEBALL CARD: VINTAGE 19TH CENT N172 OLD JUDGE CIGERETTE BASEBALL CARD - GOODWIN & CO N.Y - SOWDERS PITCHER BOSTON - 3 PIN PRICKS, IMPERFECTIONS - UNGRADED

2022OLD JUDGE WILLAIM SOWDERS BASEBALL CARDSee Sold Price

Sold

1886-87 Old Judge N172 #282 Jack Lynch MLB Card: 1886-87 Old Judge N172 #282-5 Jack Lynch MLB Baseball Trading Card. By far the oldest card we have ever seen come through the shop. After conducting research we weren't able to find much information o

20231886-87 Old Judge N172 #282 Jack Lynch MLB CardSee Sold Price

Sold

Old Judge Tom Daly Chicago White Sox 1887-1990: Baseball Card. Has Star Shaped Punch Hole and General Wear with corners rounded. See photos

2021Old Judge Tom Daly Chicago White Sox 1887-1990See Sold Price

Sold

Hall of Fame Hugh Duffy Baseball Tobacco Card: 1909-11 T206 White Border Polar Bear Hugh Duffy Baseball Tobacco Card (VG+)

2021Hall of Fame Hugh Duffy Baseball Tobacco CardSee Sold Price

Sold

2023upper deck 1991, Studio 1994, and signature rookies old judge 1995 baseball cardsSee Sold Price

Sold

1909-11 T206 Hugh Duffy White Border tobacco baseball card: 1909-11 T206 Hugh Duffy (HOF) White Border Polar Bear tobacco baseball card â€‹â€‹â€‹â€‹â€‹â€‹â€‹**Please Note: In-house shipping is NOT available for the Sports Mem

20231909-11 T206 Hugh Duffy White Border tobacco baseball cardSee Sold Price

Sold

Hugh Duffy RC T206 vintage baseball card: Hugh Duffy RC T206 vintage baseball card

2017Hugh Duffy RC T206 vintage baseball cardSee Sold Price

Sold

Old Judge Pat Deasley Sliding NYs 1887-1890 Card: Baseball Card. Has Crease and Wear. See Photos

2021Old Judge Pat Deasley Sliding NYs 1887-1890 CardSee Sold Price

Sold

1961 Topps #35 Ron Santo MLB Rookie Card (SGC 3.5): 1961 Topps #35 Ron Santo MLB Baseball Trading Card (Rookie Card) (SGC 3.5). One of the true Chicago Cubs legends, Ron Santo needs no introduction in this city. A 9-time all-star, 5-time Gold Glove Win

20231961 Topps #35 Ron Santo MLB Rookie Card (SGC 3.5)See Sold Price

Sold

1957 Topps Chicago Cubs Team Card #183 SGC 5.5: 1957 Topps Chicago Cubs Team Card #183 SGC 5.5

20231957 Topps Chicago Cubs Team Card #183 SGC 5.5See Sold Price

Sold

A Group of Five SGC Graded 1978 Topps Eddie Murray Rookie Baseball Cards No. 36,: A Group of Five SGC Graded 1978 Topps Eddie Murray Rookie Baseball Cards No. 36, comprising the following grades: 7 (NM); 5.5 (EX+); 5 (EX); 4.5 (VG-EX+); 4 (VG-EX). This lot is located in Chicago.

2023A Group of Five SGC Graded 1978 Topps Eddie Murray Rookie Baseball Cards No. 36,See Sold Price

Related Trading Cards

Group of 3 Chicago Cubs Baseball Trading Cards: Includes Ryne Sandberg, Charley Grimm and William Nicholson

3 days LeftGroup of 3 Chicago Cubs Baseball Trading Cards

$15

Approx. 900+ pcs Vintage Collectible Trading Card Assortment. DonRuss Baseball Cards. See pics.

$20

Michael *Jordan*1986-87* Fleer *Rookie* Card (RC) #57- PSA: Condition: Graded - PSA Authentic Altered: Professionally gradedType: Sports Trading Card, Sport: BasketballSet: 1986-87 Fleer, Manufacturer: Fleer,Player/Athlete: Michael Jordan, Features: Rookie,Sea

4 days LeftMichael *Jordan*1986-87* Fleer *Rookie* Card (RC) #57- PSA

$1,600

Box full of Fleer and Score traded factory sealed baseball card sets: Box full of Fleer and Score factory sealed updated and rookie traded card sets est. value $250.00-$300.00

7 days LeftBox full of Fleer and Score traded factory sealed baseball card sets

$200

Circa 1890 Baseball Trade Card: Circa 1890 Baseball Trade Card

6 days LeftCirca 1890 Baseball Trade Card

2022 Bowman Baseball Trading Card Collection Lot: 2022 Bowman Baseball Trading Card Collection Lot

6 days Left2022 Bowman Baseball Trading Card Collection Lot

6 days LeftCirca 1890 Baseball Trade Card

Vintage Baseball Trading Card Collection: Vintage Baseball Trading Card Collection

5 days LeftVintage Baseball Trading Card Collection

$10

5 days LeftVintage Baseball Trading Card Collection

$10

5 days LeftVintage Baseball Trading Card Collection

$10

5 days LeftVintage Baseball Trading Card Collection

$10

5 days LeftVintage Baseball Trading Card Collection

$10

5 days LeftVintage Baseball Trading Card Collection

$10

5 days LeftVintage Baseball Trading Card Collection

$10

5 days LeftVintage Baseball Trading Card Collection

$10

5 days LeftVintage Baseball Trading Card Collection

$10

More Items in Trading Cards

Pokemon lot: Items will be uploaded and change as I can get to them.

Sep 25, 2024Pokemon lot

$42

1999 Pokemon Cards Binder: 1999 Pokemon Trading Cards Binder, includes two Top Deck Stragedy and card guide on the binder, one holo 1999 Pokemon card, many Pokemon Cubone, Kadabra, Magmat, Machop, Kabutops, Abra, Psyduck, Arbok

Jun 23, 20241999 Pokemon Cards Binder

$110

1990s Magic The Gathering Cards Binder: Vintage MTG Binder trading Cards. Years, 1993-2000, 1997 , 1993-2001, 1993-2003 And More. Over 200 cards in binder

Jun 23, 20241990s Magic The Gathering Cards Binder

$40

1999 2000 English And Japanese Pokemon Cards Binder: 1999 2000 Pokemon Trading EnglishCards Binder And also vintage Japanese Pokemon cards in the binder. many Pokemon Zubat, Kadabra, Dark Kadabra, Machop, Abra, Starnine, psyduck, Dark Dragonair, ekans,

Jun 23, 20241999 2000 English And Japanese Pokemon Cards Binder

$60

100 Original Adult Magazine Risque Trading Cards: SERIES 1 in Mint Condition

Jun 28, 2024100 Original Adult Magazine Risque Trading Cards

1999 Nintendo Limited Edition Pokemon Togepi 23k Gold Plated Cards: 1999 Nintendo Limited Edition Pokemon Togepi 23k Gold Plated Cards

Jun 23, 20241999 Nintendo Limited Edition Pokemon Togepi 23k Gold Plated Cards

$25

CGC Pristine 10 Yozora Mel Hololive Super Rare Signature w/ Sketch: CGC Pristine 10 Yozora Mel Hololive Super Rare Gold Sig Weiss Schwarz anime trading Card. We are a veteran owned company. Please look at the pictures carefully to determine what you believe the condit

Jun 15, 2024CGC Pristine 10 Yozora Mel Hololive Super Rare Signature w/ Sketch

$21

British School (19th Century), Portrait Miniature of a Young Gentleman: British School (19th Century), Portrait Miniature of a Young Gentlemancirca 1820s, watercolor on , unsigned, the handsome gent with curly coup au vent strawberry blond hair and gentle expression, atti

Jun 14, 2024British School (19th Century), Portrait Miniature of a Young Gentleman

$100

Nice lot of Garbage Pail Kids Cards: Garbage Pail Kids Trading Cards. We are a veteran owned company. Please look at the pictures carefully to determine what you believe the condition of collecitible is. We are currently accepting consig

Jun 15, 2024Nice lot of Garbage Pail Kids Cards

$10

1994 Marvel Trading Cards Binder: Vintage 1994 Marvel Trading Cards Binder. Spider-Man , Wolverine, Gambit limited edition card, Thor And many more . About 140 cards

Jun 23, 20241994 Marvel Trading Cards Binder

$45

Large lot of Misc Trading Cards, Hustler, Muppets: Large lot of Misc Trading Cards. Includes Risque Hustler Cards, Muppet Cards, Power Ranger Cards and more. We are a veteran owned company. Please look at the pictures carefully to determine what you b

Jun 15, 2024Large lot of Misc Trading Cards, Hustler, Muppets

1999 Pokemon pikachu, charmander, Pikachu, Squirtle And Charmeleon: 1999 Pokemon pikachu, charmander, Pikachu, Squirtle And Charmeleon

Jun 23, 20241999 Pokemon pikachu, charmander, Pikachu, Squirtle And Charmeleon

$55

1999 Charizard Pikachu Mewtwo Pokemon Limited Edition Collection: 1999 Nintendo Charizard, Pikachu , Mewtwo , Togepi And More Limited Edition Pokemon Balls , Trading Cards And Their boxes with exception of Mewtwo

Jun 23, 20241999 Charizard Pikachu Mewtwo Pokemon Limited Edition Collection

$100

Approx. 1200+ Vintage Collectible Trading Cards Assortment. Baseball, Garbage Pail Kids. See pics.

$27

Huge Garbage Pail Kids Card Binder: Huge binder filled with Garbage Pail Kids Trading Cards. Includes Holo Patty Putty and 3d holo cards. Pack in binder is empty. We are a veteran owned company. Please look at the pictures carefully to

Jun 15, 2024Huge Garbage Pail Kids Card Binder

$11

1975 Topps Wacky Pack Cards, Blank Backs: Large lot of 1975 Topps Wacky Packages Trading Cards. Most cards are blank back. We are a veteran owned company. Please look at the pictures carefully to determine what you believe the condition of co

Jun 15, 20241975 Topps Wacky Pack Cards, Blank Backs

Recommended Toys & Hobbies

Giant Estate Lot of Vintage Lesney Matchbox Cars & Trucks England 75 pieces: Giant Estate Lot of Vintage Lesney Matchbox Cars & Trucks England. This is a wonderful lot of assorted Lesney Matchbox cars, the count is 75 pieces came with a vintage Matchbox Superfast Collector Car

Jul 07, 2024Giant Estate Lot of Vintage Lesney Matchbox Cars & Trucks England 75 pieces

$300

Bally Playboy Pinball Machine: Powers on, won't coin up a ball. All bulbs LED. *This is a remote auction in McHenry, Maryland. Pickup or Third-party shipping is required on all items. A list of suggested shippers can be found in th

2 days LeftBally Playboy Pinball Machine

$850

DING DONG PINBALL MACHINE: MADE BY WILLIAMS. SERIAL #6563. PLEASE READ CAREFULLY - Terms for Purchasing and Shipping of Auction Items. Please read carefully before bidding. All payments for purchases will be made through LiveAu

5 days LeftDING DONG PINBALL MACHINE

$110

Williams Line Drive Baseball Pinball Machine, Animated Backglass: Working. All bulbs LED. Backglass has been professionally re-created and sealed. *This is a remote auction in McHenry, Maryland. Pickup or Third-party shipping is required on all items. A list of sugg

2 days LeftWilliams Line Drive Baseball Pinball Machine, Animated Backglass

$1,000

Sega G-Loc Air Battle Sit Down Arcade: Working but no motion. *This is a remote auction in McHenry, Maryland. Pickup or Third-party shipping is required on all items. A list of suggested shippers can be found in the terms of this auction a

2 days LeftSega G-Loc Air Battle Sit Down Arcade

$600

Data East Hook Pinball Machine: Working. All bulbs LED. *This is a remote auction in McHenry, Maryland. Pickup or Third-party shipping is required on all items. A list of suggested shippers can be found in the terms of this auction

2 days LeftData East Hook Pinball Machine

$1,700

Sep 25, 2024Pokemon lot

$42

Gottlieb Volcano Pinball Machine: Powers on, won't coin up a ball. All bulbs LED. *This is a remote auction in McHenry, Maryland. Pickup or Third-party shipping is required on all items. A list of suggested shippers can be found in th

2 days LeftGottlieb Volcano Pinball Machine

$800

Williams Pitch & Bat Baseball Pinball Machine, Animated Backglass: Working. All bulbs LED. Backglass has been professionally re-created and sealed. *This is a remote auction in McHenry, Maryland. Pickup or Third-party shipping is required on all items. A list of sugg

2 days LeftWilliams Pitch & Bat Baseball Pinball Machine, Animated Backglass

$850

Jun 23, 20241999 Pokemon Cards Binder

$110

United Laguna Shuffle Alley Bowling Arcade: Powers on, needs work. Pins not lifting. *This is a remote auction in McHenry, Maryland. Pickup or Third-party shipping is required on all items. A list of suggested shippers can be found in the terms

2 days LeftUnited Laguna Shuffle Alley Bowling Arcade

$50

Lionel Postwar O Gauge 2148WS 773 Passenger Set from 1950 Boxed: Lionel Postwar O Gauge 2148WS 773 Passenger Set from 1950 Boxed, including 773 Loco and 2426W Tender in C7 plus or better overall condition, and each with its original box; also includes 2625 Irvingto

3 days LeftLionel Postwar O Gauge 2148WS 773 Passenger Set from 1950 Boxed

$1,250

Gottlieb Mars God of War Pinball Machine: Working. All bulbs LED. *This is a remote auction in McHenry, Maryland. Pickup or Third-party shipping is required on all items. A list of suggested shippers can be found in the terms of this auction

2 days LeftGottlieb Mars God of War Pinball Machine

$650

Jun 23, 20241990s Magic The Gathering Cards Binder

$40

Data East Maverick Pinball Machine: Working. All bulbs LED. *This is a remote auction in McHenry, Maryland. Pickup or Third-party shipping is required on all items. A list of suggested shippers can be found in the terms of this auction

2 days LeftData East Maverick Pinball Machine

$2,750

United Team-Mate Bowling Alley Ball Bowler, 14 FT with 3 Balls: Not working. Powers up, needs ball lift motor fixed. *This is a remote auction in McHenry, Maryland. Pickup or Third-party shipping is required on all items. A list of suggested shippers can be found

2 days LeftUnited Team-Mate Bowling Alley Ball Bowler, 14 FT with 3 Balls

$250

An 1889 Old Judge N172 Hugh Duffy Chicago Baseball Card (SGC 1)

Sold

Item Details

Description

An 1889 Old Judge N172 Hugh Duffy Chicago Baseball Card (SGC 1)

NOTE: If a bid is placed within one minute of the closing time of a lot, five additional minutes will be added to the designated closing time for that lot. This process will repeat until no new bids are placed in the final minute of a lot. Please note that the extension of one lot’s closing time does not affect other lots’ closing times. A detailed explanation of the Timed auction format can be found here.

This lot is located in Chicago.

Buyer's Premium

An 1889 Old Judge N172 Hugh Duffy Chicago Baseball Card (SGC 1)

Name: An 1889 Old Judge N172 Hugh Duffy Chicago Baseball Card (SGC 1)
SKU: 154955669
Price: 700 USD
Availability: InStock

Estimate $300 - $500

See Sold Price

Starting Price $150

Sell a Similar Item

5 bidders are watching this item.

Shipping & Pickup Options

Item located in Chicago, IL, us

See Policy for Shipping

Payment

Freeman's | Hindman

TOP RATED

Chicago, IL, United States

1,547 Reviews

47,026 Followers