Sold20212005 Peyton Manning Fleer Ultra Indianapolis Colts2005 Peyton Manning Fleer Ultra Indianapolis ColtsSee Sold Price
Sold2022Peyton Manning 2000 Fleer Ultra Millennium Monsters #5 Indianapolis ColtsPeyton Manning 2000 Fleer Ultra Millennium Monsters #5 Indianapolis ColtsSee Sold Price
Sold20212005 Donruss Zenith Peyton Manning #45 Indianapolis2005 Donruss Zenith Peyton Manning #45 Indianapolis ColtsSee Sold Price
Sold2022Peyton Manning 2006 Fleer Fantastic 40 Insert Indianapolis Colts #F40-PMPeyton Manning 2006 Fleer Fantastic 40 Insert Indianapolis Colts #F40-PMSee Sold Price
Sold2021PEYTON MANNING BOWMAN 2005 INDIANAPOLIS COLTS FOOTBALLPEYTON MANNING BOWMAN 2005 INDIANAPOLIS COLTS FOOTBALL CARDSee Sold Price
Sold2022Peyton Manning 2005 Topps 50th Anniversary Golden Moments Indianapolis Colts 327Peyton Manning 2005 Topps 50th Anniversary Golden Moments Indianapolis Colts 327See Sold Price
Sold2022Peyton Manning 2005 Topps 50th Anniversary League Leaders Indianapolis Colts 318Peyton Manning 2005 Topps 50th Anniversary League Leaders Indianapolis Colts 318See Sold Price
Sold2022Mixed Lots of 10 Top Loaded Sport CardsPeyton Manning 2005 Topps 50th Anniversary League Leaders Indianapolis Colts 318Peyton Manning 2014 Topps Chrome Green Refractor 42 BroncosConnor Scott Bowmans Best Auto Prospect Refractor Rookie #B18See Sold Price
Sold2022Peyton Manning 2005 Donruss Zenith "TEAM Zenith" #TZ-5Peyton Manning 2005 Donruss Zenith "TEAM Zenith" #TZ-5 Indianapolis ColtsSee Sold Price
Sold2022Peyton Manning 2005 Topps 50th Anniversary Football Card #203 Indianapolis ColtsPeyton Manning 2005 Topps 50th Anniversary Football Card #203 Indianapolis ColtsSee Sold Price
Sold2019BALTIMORE COLTS AND INDIANAPOLIS COLTS LEGENDS2000 TOPPS JOHN UNITAS AND 2003 FLEER PLATINUM PEYTON MANNINGSee Sold Price
Sold2021PEYTON MANNING INDIANAPOLIS COLTS FOOTBALL CARD LOTTitle: PEYTON MANNING INDIANAPOLIS COLTS FOOTBALL CARD LOT Description: LOT OF 2 PEYTON MANNING INDIANAPOLIS COLTS FOOTBALL CARDS FEATURING 2004 FLEER SWEET SIGS & 2000 FLAIR SHOWCASE HOLOFOIL. BOTH ASee Sold Price
Sold2020LOT OF 12 PEYTON MANNING COLTS CARDS200 FLEER METAL, 2005 DONRUSS CLASSICS, 1998 COLLECTORS EDGE GOLDSee Sold Price
Sold2023Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed White Panel FootballPeyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Autographed White Panel FootballSee Sold Price
Sold2021Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Signed DisplayPeyton Manning led the Colts to a 29–17 victory over the Chicago Bears in Super Bowl XLI and was voted Super Bowl MVP. Manning, who had been criticized for failing to win big games, exorcised hiSee Sold Price
Sold2020Autographed Peyton Manning Indianapolis ColtsAutographed Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Picture Measures 13" x 10 1/2"See Sold Price
Sold2021LOT OF 9 PEYTON MANNING INDIANAPOLIS COLTS CARDS2004 NATL TRADING CARD DAY, 2006 SCORE 'THE NATIONAL', 2020 MOSAIC MVPSSee Sold Price
Sold2019EARLY PEYTON MANNING INDIANAPOLIS COLTS LOTEARLY PEYTON MANNING INDIANAPOLIS COLTS LOTSee Sold Price
Sold2021PEYTON MANNING INDIANAPOLIS COLTS FOOTBALL CARD LOTTitle: PEYTON MANNING INDIANAPOLIS COLTS FOOTBALL CARD LOT Description: LOT OF 2 PEYTON MANNING INDIANAPOLIS COLTS FOOTBALL CARDS FEATURING 2004 PLAYOFF CONTENDERS & 2006 PLAYOFF PRESTIGE. BOTH ARE NMSee Sold Price
Sold2022Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts 2019 Panini Prizm Legendary Talents InsertPeyton Manning Indianapolis Colts 2019 Panini Prizm Legendary Talents InsertSee Sold Price
Sold2021Peyton Manning Signed 1998 Bowman #1 RC (BGSRookie Card has been hand-signed by Peyton Manning (Indianapolis Colts, HOF). Please see scans for details regarding the condition of the card. The item / autograph(s) has been authenticated and encapSee Sold Price
Sold2021Peyton Manning Signed 1998 Bowman #1 RC (BGSRookie Card has been hand-signed by Peyton Manning (Indianapolis Colts). Please see scans for details regarding the condition of the card. The item / autograph(s) has been authenticated and encapsulatSee Sold Price
Sold2021Peyton Manning Signed 1998 Bowman #1 RC (BGSRookie Card has been hand-signed by Peyton Manning (Indianapolis Colts). Please see scans for details regarding the condition of the card.See Sold Price
4 days LeftMynt AuctionsPeyton Manning Signed Indianapolis Colts Camo Speed Mini Helmet - Fanatics$10
6 days LeftMynt AuctionsPeyton Manning Autographed Indianapolis Colts Eclipse Speed Mini Helmet-Fanatics$120
2 days LeftMynt AuctionsPeyton Manning Autographed Indianapolis Colts Speed Mini Helmet-Fanatics *Black$10(1 bid)
5 days LeftMynt AuctionsPeyton Manning Autographed Indianapolis Colts Flash Speed Mini Helmet-Fanatics$10
764 Lots AwayMynt AuctionsPeyton Manning Signed NFL Debut Original Ticket Sep 6 1998 PSA DNA Pop 3!$8,800
17 hrs LeftMynt AuctionsSuper Bowl XLI 41 Full Ticket Silver 2007 Bears v Colts Peyton Manning MVP PSA 8$10
2 days LeftMynt AuctionsSuper Bowl XLI 41 Full Ticket Silver Bears v Colts Peyton Manning MVP PSA 8$10
7 days LeftMynt AuctionsSuper Bowl XLI 41 Full Ticket Silver Bears v Colts Peyton Manning MVP PSA 8$70
4 days LeftMynt AuctionsPeyton Manning HOF Autographed Mitchell & Ness Football Jersey Colts Fanatics$10(1 bid)
6 days LeftRichard L. Edwards Auctioneering2005 McFarlane SportsPicks Series 2 Peyton Manning 12 Inch White Uniform Variation Figure$1
6 days LeftRichard L. Edwards Auctioneering2005 McFarlane SportsPicks Series 15 Peyton Manning Boxed Set$1