Schultz Auctioneers, NY - Read over 518 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Schultz Auctioneers (518)

badge TOP RATED
4.7 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

50-100 of 518 Reviews

Pam
Orono, MN

Dec 22, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 4-star review. Feel free to reach out if there is anything we can do to enhance your experience with us.
Persian Sarouk Rug

Nora
Mt Lebanon, PA

Dec 22, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the positive feedback, we are always here to help get your items back home with you.
Crystal Beach Metal Typer Souvenir Coin Machine

Theresa
Orchard Park, NY

Dec 22, 2024
Very organized and efficient
This purchase went well. I did buy an "oil painting" from them last year that turned out to be a print... that pissed me off, but it was only $50. I pick up, so don't have issues with shipping but it seems like they would do a good job on that. Usually their descriptions are pretty good, just had that one bad experience with the "painting"... I should have addressed it with them but didn't realize the issue until I got home.
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for your positive feedback. We are sorry to hear about the one item from a previous auction. Please, always feel free to reach out in the future if there are any issues that we can help with.
Swallowtail of California Art Glass Lamp

Anne Marie
Coboconk, CA

Dec 22, 2024
Excellent packaging and shipping.
Very responsive and helpful.
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Our pleasure, we are glad we could help. Thank you for the kind words.
Antique French Bisque Head Doll

Terry
Staunton, IL

Dec 22, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
Meissen Figurine Boy and Girl with Goat

Patricia
Bethesda, MD

Dec 22, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
L.C. Tiffany signed and numbered Favrile Bowl

John
Cape Coral, FL

Dec 22, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
Weller Art Pottery Pitcher, Mugs and Owens Utopian Tankard

Tom
Wilmington, NC

Dec 22, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
Art Pottery including Forester Majolica Dragon handle Jardiniere

Robert
West Palm Beach, FL

Dec 21, 2024
A pleasure
Very professional and responsive.. excellent in every way!
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you so much for your review. We sincerely appreciate your business.

Gary
Wyoming, NY

Dec 20, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
Gorham Sterling dresser set

Richard
Avon Lake, OH

Dec 17, 2024
Great Experience!
Great overall experience and communication. Due to travel restraints on my part, I could not pick-up my items for almost 2 weeks. The auction house was gracious enough to hold them for me until I had the opportunity to arrive. I highly recommend this seller!
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Your support means a lot to us! We will always try to accommodate our valued customers in any way possible.

Valerie
Cocoa, FL

Dec 13, 2024
GREAT AUCTION HOUSE TO WORK WITH
VERY NICE EMAILS, QUICK RESPONSE, FAST SHIP, ITEM EXACTLY AS DESCRIBED
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you so much for the kind and positive words.

James
Vestavia Hills, AL

Nov 12, 2024
Great to work with!
Item as described; priced appropriately; packed right and shipped on time.
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review! We strive to provide the best of services as possible.
Leslie Organ Speaker model 120

Douglas
Winnetka, IL

Sep 07, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!

Billy
Friendswood, TX

Sep 07, 2024
Rare Find
This was a GREAT lot! The Miller Beer signs are hard to find and extremely expensive when you do. For the price that we paid for this lot, I was expecting issues with the motion signs, however, they worked perfectly. Just needed some cleaning and minor maintenance. After the auction, the process to pay and receive the items went smoothly, with zero issues. And the cost for the shipping was fair. GREAT auction house!!
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
We are so grateful for you and appreciate your 5-star refiew. thank you so much

Johnny
Gloversville, NY

Sep 06, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
Large group of U.S. Lincoln cents 1930's-1970's

Michael
Ogdensburg, NJ

Aug 29, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
Huge Lot of Loose U.S. & Foreign Stamps, Cancels, 1st Days & More

Charles
Livingston, TX

Aug 25, 2024
Great house
Service after the sale was excellent, everything was as described and we look forward to continuing to do business with this excellent auction house.
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
We thank you for your kind words and look forward to also working with you in the future.
Large oil on canvas of Nymphs dancing in the forest

Kimberly
Silver Creek, NY

Jul 05, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
Group of U.S. $2 bills and foreign currency

Cary
Tavares, FL

Jul 05, 2024
First auction purchase with Schultz wad positive.
Item is as described. Good communication. In-house shipping was smooth and fast. Excellent packing. Good experience.
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
You are greatly appreciated. Thank you for the kind words
Signed Charles Relyea Oil on canvas "Come Along"

Iriene
Eagle, WI

Jul 04, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
1849 Niagara NY coverlet

EDWARD
New Richmond, WI

Jul 04, 2024
Sarah did a Wonderful Job!
All 3 clocks were individually boxed, lots of packing materials, and in great shape! 2 other clocks arrive 2 days later, both in the same boss, with only bubble wrap, both smashed! Sarah did a great job, and would definitely do business with Schultz Auctioneers again! Super job Sarag!
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you so much for the kind words. We always try to put thought and care into our packing to give items the best chance possible to arrive home safe and sound.
Ornate Vienna wall clock

Wayne
Johnson City, TN

Jul 04, 2024
Fair. Responsive. Good communication. Looks out for buyers ’ interests.
These are good people to deal with. No problems.
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Your support means a lot to us. We look forward to working with you in future auctions.
Group of books on Religion, Christianity, Darwin and more

Carl
Craryville, NY

Jul 04, 2024
VERY flexible with their shipping
I changed my mind a few times between having my item shipped or having a friend pick it up and they were SO friendly and helpful I was astonished. Sarah in Shipping is a real star!
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the kind words, we always want to be flexible with our customers to ensure they can get their items in the best way possible.
Oil on board in wonderful gold frame

Ken
Duncanville, TX

Jul 02, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
Silkscreen artwork signed EA Duino 27

Dennis
Lomita, CA

May 31, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!

Mike
Bridge City, TX

May 16, 2024
👍
👍 👍
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
2 Clocks, Blue Coal & Rex Automatic Storage Water Heaters

Rita
Holland, NY

May 11, 2024
Auction dealings.
Schultz Auction is the beat auction house I have dealt with in a long time. Their descriptions of items they auction off are very accurate about the condition of the items I would like to bid on. I am hoping to see more of their auctions so I can find something to bid on.
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for such kind words. We run auctions roughly every 2-3 months. We look forward to working with you again.

Darko
Longwood, FL

May 11, 2024
Complicated for no reason.
Ive been buying here for many years, dozens of simple transactions. Im very used to the normal additional fees. I'm not sure why this house makes it so complicated? Perhaps to nickel and dime for extra fees? They demand payment prior to providing a shipping cost after adding the hammer fees, plus some internet fee which I have never seen. You pay the bill, then have to wait for a separate shipping bill. Most houses provide this immediately.... but this one basically has your money, then sends you bill for overpriced shipping. My $175 item ended up costing $280... 60 % more: (Exorbitant!!!! KEEP IT SIMPLE AND HONEST!!
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for your feedback, we will take your words into consideration as we grow as a company. We do encourage all potential buyers needing to utilize our shipping department to reach out prior to auction day to request a shipping estimate on any items that they may be interested in. Hopefully that can help bridge the gap between us and bring us back to a happy auctioneer/bidder relationship.

Thomas
Clarkston, MI

May 11, 2024

Tim
Edinboro, PA

May 11, 2024
Prompt communication and coordinated pickup, item as described, recommended Live Auctioneer House
Prompt communication and coordinated pickup, item as described, recommended Live Auctioneer House, smooth transaction
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for your kind review. We, here at Schultz Auctioneers, look forward to working with you again.
Vintage Sparton Model 566 "Bluebird"

Elissa
Naperville, IL

May 10, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
Allwin De Luxe penny amusement machine

David
Lakewood, NJ

May 10, 2024
Great people
Happy to do business here!
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you, we strive to make everyone as happy as possible within our abilities. We hope to have you back as a customer in the future.
H.B. Hortons Ithaca Calendar Clock

Ray
Grantham, NH

May 09, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
Group of book plate prints from The Complete Works of Shakespeare etc

Steven
Berkeley, CA

May 08, 2024
Good experience bidding
Reasonable prices, good auction process, and efficient shipping. Item arrived safely and was as described in listing.
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
We appreciate your business and kind words, thank you.
Yoshiko Yamamoto Magnolia print, 8/300

Linda
Sequim, WA

May 03, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
C.W. Illig signed oil on board painting

Dylan
Warren, PA

May 01, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
Assorted lot of costume jewelry, some signed Regency, glass, crystal and more

Jaime
New York, NY

Mar 10, 2024
Everything perfect
Reliable auction house.
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
This makes us happy to hear, thank you for the kind words.
Nuart Art Deco Whirling Figures Lamp

charles
Bronx, NY

Mar 02, 2024
this place is honest
received exactly what i saw...
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
We are pleased that you were happy with our services. Thank you.
American Flyer Trains, Cars & More

Dennis
Lomita, CA

Mar 02, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
5 Binders of Over 500 Postcards incl. Tuck Holiday, Real Photo & More

John
Waterloo, CA

Mar 01, 2024
Prompt communication. Great experience.
Answered my questions promptly. Provided additional pictures as requested. Very easy and pleasant pick up process. Helped load my item. I could not ask for a better buying experience.
Report
Victorian walnut cylinder roll desk

Marcia
Daytona Beach, FL

Feb 25, 2024
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
Thank you for the 5-star review!
Herend Mixed Serveware

Bryan
Lakewood, OH

Feb 24, 2024
Thank you!!!!
Thank you!!!!
Report
Schultz Auctioneers logo
Schultz AuctioneersJun 11, 2025
You're welcome and thank you for your patronage.
14k gold Waltham pocket watch

Havala
Felt, ID

Feb 23, 2024
Excellent Shipping
I won some VERY fragile items (over 65 pieces) and am impressed with how good the packing job was to ensure the items did not break. Every piece arrived intact! I also appreciated the shipping notifications to ensure when to expect my goods. Thank you!
Report
Mixed Lot of Spode, Bavaria, Mintons, etc.

Kenneth
Buffalo, NY

Feb 23, 2024
Kelly Schultz Auctions are great!
Kelly Schultz Auctions always has interesting and quality items. The team is very easy to work with and extremely responsive.
Report
Leaded Glass Panel

Michael
West Chester, PA

Feb 23, 2024
Religious Statue Lot incl. Plaster Capodimonte & more

Theresa
Orchard Park, NY

Feb 23, 2024
Good service, good photos
I pick up, so I can't say anything about shipping, but have been pleased with the items, descriptions, and photographs of everything I have bid on and won so far. Very easy to deal with and no surprises/disappointments as yet.
Report
Contemporary Cameo Vases

Gary
Penn Valley, PA

Feb 22, 2024
very efficient
Good communication. Fast in house shipping. Very nice to deal with,
Report
Art Glass Shades

Louis
Boise, ID

Feb 22, 2024
quick response time
Quickly rectified a shipping issue. Much appreciated as item made it before Valentine day...
Report
14k Ring with Amber Colored Stone

Heidi
Waymart, PA

Feb 19, 2024
A beautiful, well described Minton Majolica Dish!!
I purchased one of the Majolica pieces that was listed and couldn't be more pleased with the whole transaction... The item was as described and showed enough pictures from all angles.. This was the first time using LiveAuctioneers shipping method, was nervous since the price was so reasonable and could not have been happier.. Great communication as well with the shipping comapny they used, received email messages when the item was picked up which was certainly quick and received my purchase eight days after winning my bid which is a BIG PLUS!! Packaging was absolutely perfect in every way.. Thank you to Schultz Auctioneers in using LiveAuctioneers for a shipping method choice.. So many online auctions shipping fees have been ridiculous high it seems and giving this option makes me gladly return and bid again with your Auction House... regards...
Report
Minton Majolica Game Dish