Bidder Reviews for Keystone Auction LLC (1,040)
4.6 out of 5.0 Stars
1-50 of 1,040 Reviews
DarrellJohnstown, PA
Jun 28, 2026
DarwinShermans Dale, PA
Jun 28, 2026
JeffreyPikesville, MD
Jun 20, 2026
Incomplete description
I have been very pleased with several past interactions with this auction house. However, my recent purchase was marred by inaccurate descriptions. To be fair, one problem was addressed when I picked up the item and an offer to pay for a replacement pane of glass was made. I plan on continuing to view these auctions, but verify information before bidding.
RobertDixon, IL
Jun 13, 2026

JonathanDalmatia, PA
May 29, 2026

Nathaniel Portland, OR
May 29, 2026

EmmaBrooklyn, NY
May 29, 2026
Communicative and flexible
The product I received was exactly as listed and I'm very satisfied. I had some trouble organizing my shipping (ended up going with uShip for York-> Brooklyn and highly recommend) but Keystone was there to answer any and all questions, and helped me figure out how to best proceed. Would buy from them again!

VictoriaBaltimore, MD
May 29, 2026

RandyNew York, NY
May 19, 2026
This company needs better customer service.
This company needs better customer service. The piece arrived broken at the ankle and after writing, I was completely ignored. I was able to do the repair, but it cost me dearly in supplies. A return note regarding my experience would have been appreciated.

StephenKingston, NY
May 18, 2026
Professionally handled
Bought this item for my wife. Item was shipped in a timely manner and was well packed.

MarieCelina, TX
May 17, 2026
Great auctioneer sells interesting pieces to add to your collections
Great auctioneer sells items as described. Items were sent quickly to the shipping department which is appreciated.

IrenePalmyra, VA
May 17, 2026
Great auction house!
Very impressed with the depth and quality of auction items. Many items are curator worthy. It was worth the 100 mile drive to pick up my items.

Mobile Exchange Gt IncDoral, FL
May 14, 2026

WayneOstrander, OH
May 12, 2026
Great Auction house, my items were exactly as they were described, very well packaged. I
Wow, what a great Auction House Keystone is! Very professional in the handling of the pieces I won the bid on for their auctions again.

LauriePotomac, MD
May 05, 2026
Great auction house
Keystone Auction is always fantastic to buy from. They are well organized, friendly, and helpful.

TimothyLewes, DE
May 04, 2026
Very Professional
Very professional and fast shipping. Would purchase from Keystone Auction in the future.

DavidMacomb, MI
May 03, 2026
Marx Train Set
The Locomotive had damage that was not disclosed in the photos are in the description, making its value considerably less than I paid. Also the S & H For one single boxed train set was $70. Most auction houses are 1/2 that amount.

Mobile Exchange Gt IncDoral, FL
Apr 19, 2026

Murray Mannsville, OK
Apr 13, 2026
Item was well packaged and taken care of. Good folks to work with. Would definitely use again.
Item was well packaged and taken care of. Good folks to work with. Would definitely use again

RichardChicago, IL
Apr 08, 2026

TammyHoschton, GA
Mar 29, 2026
TimPortola, CA
Mar 29, 2026
Murray Mannsville, OK
Mar 20, 2026
Thank you.
First and foremost, No judgement on shipping PRICE. Here are my details. I made a statement saying I was in no hurry and looking for reasonable shipping. This was my choice. USPS Ground Box was 10 "X12" X3 "and weight was 2 lbs. My Items were several jewelry pieces that cost me $154 after auction and taxes. Shipping cost was $47.24. I did not leave a bad review because I don't know the details on how shipping was done. These folks did help me out to take care of it so that's not a problem. I try to let folks like me out of town know what cost are and had no bad experience with this auction. I am just passing my story.
CliffHarrisburg, PA
Mar 15, 2026

SaeedMinneapolis, MN
Mar 15, 2026
They are very responsive and helpful.
Had a very good experience, they are fast and responsive.

AlexPortland, OR
Mar 15, 2026

LawrenceEl Paso, TX
Mar 11, 2026

MichelleChattanooga, TN
Mar 03, 2026

JasonBrogue, PA
Mar 02, 2026

CharleneFarmington, CT
Mar 02, 2026
Great auction items
Always happy to buy from Keystone. Quality auction items and fantastic service.

MaureenAnnapolis, MD
Mar 01, 2026

FrankCambridge, MD
Mar 01, 2026

LuChino, CA
Feb 24, 2026

LisaMadison, CT
Feb 22, 2026

YesomPalisades Park, NJ
Feb 21, 2026

DrorTel Aviv, IL
Feb 05, 2026

BenSacramento, CA
Feb 01, 2026

CynthiaLaredo, TX
Jan 25, 2026
Prices are great! 👍 🏼 👍 🏼
Love my jewelry 🥰 everything excellent condition 👍 🏼 👍 🏼 I just keep coming back 😬 🥰 🥰

DerekSan Francisco, CA
Jan 22, 2026

TerryFairhope, AL
Jan 18, 2026
Travis Frostburg, MD
Jan 14, 2026

American Pawn CompanyNorth Fort Myers, FL
Jan 14, 2026

CharleneFarmington, CT
Jan 01, 2026
Quality items, pick up was easy.
Nice Chinese vases. Very good condition. Very happy with purchase.

AnneCoatesville, PA
Jan 01, 2026
Keystone is a Pleasure
A great Auction House that responds quickly to questions and is very helpful whether picking up or shipping merchandise.

NeilYork, PA
Dec 27, 2025
The people at the auction house are wonderful!
I am always overwhelmed by the kindness, care, and consideration that I receive from the people who run Keystone Auction. They are entirely willing to accommodate my needs with items they are selling. I would recommend Keystone Auctions to anyone who is looking to purchase items from an online auction.

NicholasOverland Park, KS
Dec 20, 2025
ok experience
gold necklace had a knot in it-wasn't disclosed. shipping was kinda slow and communication was just ok. otherwise, items generally as described and I got what i paid for.

DanaGranada Hills, CA
Dec 19, 2025
The table arrived with one leg broken off, of which I was not informed until it was delivered.
Be careful what you order thru them!

TOP


