Old Barn Auction, LLC, OH - Read over 326 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Old Barn Auction, LLC (326)

badge TOP RATED
4.6 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 326 Reviews

Murray
Mannsville, OK

Jan 26, 2026
Thank you very nice to work with.
Easy folks to work with.
Report

Samuel
Bossier City, LA

Jan 05, 2026
Look Forward to More Old Barn Auctions!
All items as described, simple payment process and fast shipping to my FFL. Very satisfied with the business and will be watching for more of their auctions!
Report

Steve
Columbus Grove, OH

Jan 01, 2026
great service
spot on! great items, good deals
Report

David
Fortson, GA

Dec 29, 2025
Watch out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Item descriptions are VERY incomplete. You MUST ask questions and WAIT for the answers which are SLOW incoming back or else you'll be "Snake Bit"
Report
Old Barn Auction, LLC logo
Old Barn Auction, LLCDec 29, 2025
As an auction house we take items from consignors who give us the descriptions for their items, we do not appraise or authenticate their items, we are just the seller. We do have a gun expert here the week of the sale that will answer questions, I personally answer questions, send additional pics, and try to give my honest opinion to keep our clients safe.

Michael
Glen Rock, NJ

Dec 27, 2025
Description of the item.
Overall no complaint about post auction processing, fast shipping and good customer service. The only complaint-descriptions of firearms could be better and more detailed. The way images of firearms are taken rather obscure imperfections and avoid typical problematic areas, like front and back strap. Also, images should have been much brighter.
Report

Phillip
Kingston, NY

Dec 27, 2025
top notch auction
accurate description, pleasant staff, fast shipping
Report

CLINT
Baytown, TX

Dec 27, 2025

Joseph
Quakertown, PA

Dec 27, 2025

Scott
Wisconsin Dells, WI

Dec 27, 2025

Foussat
Valbonne, FR

Dec 27, 2025
Consistently professional and reliable.
Without a doubt, the auction house where I have my best purchasing experiences. Consistently professional and reliable.
Report

Ricky
Dublin, TX

Dec 26, 2025
Item as described
Got what I paid for quickly and well packaged. Thanks!
Report

Andre
Baton Rouge, LA

Dec 23, 2025
Excellent packaging! Thanks!
Excellent packaging! Thanks!
Report

AB1 MANAGMENT LLC
Cooper City, FL

Dec 22, 2025

Andre
Baton Rouge, LA

Dec 18, 2025
Prompt shipping, VERY well packed!!!
Prompt shipping, VERY well packed!!! Excellent communication!
Report

Mike
Canby, OR

Nov 13, 2025
thank you
thank you
Report

John
Logan, IA

Nov 13, 2025
Repeat buyer
I've purchased twice from Old Barn Auctions and both times my questions were answered. Both times the guns were extremely well packaged. It's like my neighbor said "Quality is remembered after price is forgotten".
Report

Vit
Arvada, CO

Nov 09, 2025
Smooth easy transaction. No issues.
This was a perfect transaction. I contacted the seller and they were fantastic. The packaging was far better than I could've hoped for. It arrived looking as good or better than the pictures. I am 100 + % satisfied. And I feel I got a great deal!!!
Report

Steve
Columbus Grove, OH

Nov 09, 2025
well organized
items described accurately great items
Report

Steven
Boynton Beach, FL

Nov 08, 2025

Orrin
Boise, ID

Nov 08, 2025
Friendly, Professional Service
Items were as described. Easy to contact, friendly responses. Shipping was a little more than I expected, yet without a doubt packaging was the safest out of the multitude of auction houses I've delt with. Overall very happy with Old Barn Auction.
Report

George
Goodview, VA

Nov 08, 2025

Johnny
Norwood, CO

Nov 08, 2025
Accurate description, prompt shipping, excellent service.
Accurate description, prompt shipping, excellent service.
Report

Travis
Mount Hermon, LA

Nov 06, 2025

Ryan
Columbus, OH

Nov 03, 2025
Great Seller
Easy transaction. Kind staff. Would not hesitate to buy from them again.
Report

Dennis
Kutztown, PA

Oct 30, 2025
Top of The Line Auction House
But Another Great Selection of Quality Artifacts from Old Barn Auction House packaged and Shipped by a Team of Professionals! Thank You Old Barn! ๐Ÿ‘ ๐Ÿ‡บ ๐Ÿ‡ธ
Report

Dennis
Kutztown, PA

Apr 05, 2023
Great Experience!
Lots of Great Items and Hidden Gems! Thanks ๐Ÿ‘ ๐Ÿ‡บ ๐Ÿ‡ธ
Report
Florida Newnan Point

Greg
Hilliard, OH

Jan 23, 2023

Sharman
Mckinney, TX

Sep 12, 2020
Know before you buy
I purchased an Indian belt. I wanted more info about it so I asked them. They had no information other than it had come from another auctioneer. It seems they could have contacted this person to learn more or should have known about it prior to the sale.
Report
Beaded Belt Potawatomi

Jerry
Venice, FL

Aug 31, 2020
7 ¼” Large Blade

Ed
Jemez Pueblo, NM

Aug 24, 2020
Great pieces at great prices
Can hardly wait for your next one, thanks, Ed
Report
Folk Art Wooden & Plaster Carved Woman

Kevin
Colchester, GB

Aug 02, 2020
Dwight D. Eisenhower signed

David
Laramie, WY

Jul 16, 2020
A-OK on All Accounts
Buying items at Old Barn staff for more than a year now, I've always been pleased with their help and smoothness in processing a sale-whether I've been bidding on-site or bidding on-line. I especially like that they do their own packing and shipping-packages have always been in good shape with items very well wrapped.
Report
28” x 6” Cheyenne Pipe Bag

Matthew
Cupertino, CA

Jul 16, 2020
Damaged Items
Purchase and payment went fine. Shipping was inexpensive. Unfortunately two of the items arrived badly damaged, the heads of the figures broken in many pieces. In my opinion the items were poorly packaged, with no structural support (e. g., double boxing, dividers) to keep things from being smashed. After contacting Old Barn my money was promptly refunded. Overall a disappointing experience.
Report
3 Pre Columbian Pottery Figures

Michael
Chicago, IL

Jul 16, 2020
Incomplete Delivery of Lot
I won three lots. One of the lots received was incomplete, meaning I did not receive all that I paid for and was promised. I reached out to the Auction House and they said they would look for the missing item. Quite a bit of time went by so I reached out to them again to inquire about an update. They said that is was lost or misplaced. Itโ€™s very clear they did not care. They did not take any initiative to reach out to me after being aware of the problem. They never apologized. They never offered a solution. They just said itโ€™s lost, goodbye. I am very displeased. It was a very unpleasant exchange with me feeling taken advantage of. I expect compensation for only receiving half of what I paid for.
Report
5” Quartz Wing Banner

KIMBERLY
Laguna Niguel, CA

Jul 13, 2020
I would like a letter of authenticity with such an item. But, not offered
Very well organized and good communication.
Report
Carved Walrus Rib Bone possibly snow knife

Reese
Chesapeake, VA

Jul 13, 2020
Inuit Sealskin Miniature Canoe

David
Prospect, KY

Jul 12, 2020
Northwest Coast Scalping Knife

Christopher
Rome, NY

Jul 12, 2020
A Class Act
Old Barn Auction is a Class Act. From start to finish everything went smoothly. Definitely look forward to doing business with them again soon.
Report
3 Fox Hides & Turtle Rattle

Hugh
Indian Wells, CA

Jul 11, 2020
Frame of 15 Eccentric Flint Arrowheads

John
Placitas, NM

Jul 11, 2020
Helpful and quick
The entire process was easy and seamless. Would gladly recommend.
Report
Group of 2 Hardstone Axes

William
Melbourne, FL

Jul 11, 2020
(2) Cont. War Clubs

John
Bloomington, IL

Jul 11, 2020
Bi Point Stone War Club

Kristen
Reading, PA

Jul 11, 2020
African Leather Window Cover & Water Bag

Robert
Rock, MI

Jun 17, 2020

Russell
Buckhannon, WV

Jun 15, 2020

Mark
Ventura, CA

Jun 07, 2020

David
Beulah, MI

Jun 06, 2020
Expedites the process very promptly.
Seamless process. No guessing about the payment or shipping. Items arrived within a few days. Best experience among all auctioneers I have worked with.
Report

Stephen
Anderson, IN

Jun 06, 2020
Are clocks are working or dead? And did not mention conditions of clocks such crack plastic
Good but no mentions on conditions or clocks are working or not and poor wraps on clocks as were hour and minute hands were smash and bend in shipment next time I would not bid clocks without mention or working or not as none as unknown to me
Report

Jack
Sammamish, WA

Jun 06, 2020
Good communication
I was very pleased with their timely communications and responsiveness.
Report

JOHN
Medford, MA

Jun 06, 2020
EXCELLENT IT IS
100 % PERFECT
Report