Reviews
Bidder Reviews for Eddie's Auction (253)
TOP RATED4.5 out of 5.0 Stars
Accurate Descriptions
Quick Responses
Easy Payments
Seamless Shipping
1-50 of 253 Reviews
JianCollege Point, NY
Jun 14, 2026
DukeStaten Island, NY
Jun 14, 2026
MichaelNew York, NY
Mar 4, 2026
Sharing Knowledge
Not only scouting out interesting items, the team at Eddie's Auction is also ready to share their experiences.
SPound Ridge, NY
Jan 25, 2026
Perfect dealings, Flexible pick-ups!
This coat is amazing-better than the description. The photos were well done. Loved that I could pick up from their office any time during their business. hours. Friendly answers to my questions.
GregPisgah Forest, NC
Jan 25, 2026
Eddie's Auction
Jan 26, 2026
After the auction, We helped him find suitable shipping and packaging options, and then shipped the item. We provided him with excellent service, and we don't understand why he is still not satisfied.
DerekSan Francisco, CA
Dec 27, 2025
CharleneFarmington, CT
Dec 21, 2025
I am very happy with my purchase. Michael could not have been friendlier during the pickup.
Beautiful planters and vase! Thank you!
KEVINNewark, DE
Nov 2, 2025
EliasWest Hollywood, CA
Sep 7, 2025
CristinaHayward, CA
Sep 7, 2025
Room for Improvement
Even though payment was made via ACH and receipt was obtained from LiveAuctioneer almost immediately, Eddie's Auction refused to release the items to the shipper almost 10 days past the payment. Their excuse was that they have not received their share of the payment from LiveAuctioneer. After I called and argued with the owner and opened ticket with LiveAuctioneer, only then, they released. Also, one of the lots I purchased look like it has brand new items instead of 19th Centurey as they claimed.
YingBrooklyn, NY
Jun 25, 2025
shengOld Hickory, TN
Mar 13, 2025
very happy with my purchase highly recommended everything is very good.
very happy with my purchase highly recommended everything is very good.
MichaelNew York, NY
Feb 2, 2025
Always Fresh Estate Collectibles
Eddie's is an old-time estate consignment auctioneer-I never miss a sale.
WillyJersey City, NJ
Jan 30, 2025
julieSarasota, FL
Jan 23, 2025
jamesUpperholland, PA
Nov 17, 2024
KristenDenver, CO
Oct 13, 2024
JaredNew York, NY
Sep 8, 2024
Wonderful Experience
I've purchased from Eddie's a few times over the years and have alway been very happy.
siak chiewSarasota, FL
Jul 11, 2024
Eddie responded promptly to my request for official invoice.
Eddie responded promptly to my post-auction request for an official invoice. everything else went smoothly without any unexpected surprises which is great.
CraigKearney, MO
Jul 1, 2024
Shipping was difficult.
The shipping was much harder than I would have liked. I was given a couple options for shipping but I had to do all the leg work and the shipper I used (a UPS Store) was not too responsive. I will never buy anything again unless the seller handles the shipping.
BarryNew York, NY
Jun 30, 2024
MichaelNew York, NY
Apr 21, 2024
Interesting & easy to understand
Interesting descriptions, easy to understand condition reports
JudithVictoria Harbour, CA
Mar 23, 2024
Outrageous shipping cost!
Another auction house that farms out shipping to third party shipping companies. Shipping three necklaces to Ontario from NY cost $117.74 plus buyers premium and online platform fee. Getting ridiculous, not worth it anymore.
CynthiaVenice, FL
Dec 28, 2023
JulieNew York, NY
Dec 4, 2023
ThomasColumbiana, AL
Nov 19, 2023
EduardsSouth San Francisco, CA
Sep 26, 2023
KennethDuncanville, TX
Sep 18, 2023
NipingChappaqua, NY
Sep 16, 2023
NipingChappaqua, NY
Sep 16, 2023
NipingChappaqua, NY
Sep 3, 2023
JimYonkers, NY
Jul 30, 2023
TOP