Bidder Reviews for A Nice Gift For You (112)
4 out of 5.0 Stars
1-50 of 112 Reviews
GaryChicago, IL
Sep 29, 2025

ChrisNaperville, IL
Aug 13, 2025

DavidChicago, IL
Jan 11, 2025

AnneSan Diego, CA
Jan 01, 2025
Why buy anything but created diamonds.
These earrings are absolutely beautiful and rival any natural diamonds that I have.

AlexEdina, MN
Sep 20, 2024
Unless you like overcharges-avoid
Charged me $25 to ship. It took a week to reach me and there were no additional packaging materials included. So what the heck am I paying 25 bucks for, when you don't pack nicely and don't use expedited shipping?? They also did not include the COA that was in the photo (obviously was a stock image). I DO NOT RECOMMEND.

SuzanneMantua, NJ
Aug 19, 2024

NancySeattle, WA
Aug 11, 2024

Rhoda Brownstown Twp, MI
Aug 06, 2024
Where is my Item? Auction 6/5 Now 8/6 No reply from last email
What does it take to finish this sale? I feel like I am getting the runaround from this auction house. They say it will be shipped, two weeks late still waiting. Call and they say they are checking with shipping. Still no item, no answers. Would not recommend this auctin house.

DillonWaco, TX
Jul 15, 2024

DillonWaco, TX
Jul 15, 2024

RhodonnaOxnard, CA
Jun 19, 2024

MissyDallas, TX
Jun 15, 2024

LisaFairport, NY
Jun 12, 2024

JOHNPequannock, NJ
Jun 10, 2024

ThorPerry, GA
May 13, 2024
Responsive!
Auction was simple. Immediately contacted and arranged shipping. Item was exactly as described and wrapped/shipped securely.

ThorPerry, GA
May 13, 2024
Accurate and Responsive
Collectible coin was accurately described and shipment/communication after winning responsive and fast!

Jaroslav Teplice, CZ
May 04, 2024
Not happy, as stones are MOISSANITE!! bad bad experience and will not shop in this shop again …
Stones that should have being LAB MADE DIAMONDS ARE MOISSANITE … in my case anyway

KathGainesville, TX
May 01, 2024

TroyMagnolia, TX
Jan 03, 2024

FrancesBallwin, MO
Jun 09, 2023

TimPerrysburg, OH
Feb 15, 2023

StevenQuinton, VA
Feb 13, 2023
Something seems fishy
Nearly every item this auction house sells receives a final bid at about 50 % of the low appraisal value. I find this very suspicious.

AlisonKitchener, CA
Dec 06, 2022
The ruby ring I received is better that the photo!
I purchased a 5 carat natural ruby ring set in rose gold and I received exactly what was pictured except better! The ring and stone are fabulous. The shipping was super fabulous and DHL kept in touch all the way from pick up in the USA to drop off at my door in Canada. Totally recommend both the product and auctioneer and platform of course!!

A Nice Gift For YouFeb 15, 2023
Thank you for your feedback! We appreciate it and hope to fulfill more of your bids in the future. Happy Bidding!

ErinPapillion, NE
Jun 09, 2022
BarbieWallbrook, CA
Dec 21, 2021
Lost Package
It took several months to be informed that the package had been lost. Very disappointed!
JamesKaneohe, HI
Dec 17, 2021
RobertGreensboro, NC
Nov 02, 2021
MichaelWindsor, CT
Oct 15, 2021
MichaelWindsor, CT
Oct 15, 2021
CharlesMiddletown, NJ
Oct 10, 2021
Terrible
They expect payment within 3 days. After I paid I didn’t receive any response on status. I had to call and threaten to cancel order with my credit card company before they would even give me status of order. Terrible customer service. Will never again enter a auction run by this company.
JimNorth Haven, CT
Oct 08, 2021
TimOshawa, CA
Oct 02, 2021
ScottReading, MA
Sep 23, 2021
Earring Damaged
Paid the day after I won the earrings and it took them 28 days to send them. I finally got them and there is a chip in one of the garnets. I’m very disappointed and still waiting to hear back from their customer service. How can you send out damaged product? ….. pretty sketchy if you ask me!
GlennOcoee, FL
Sep 15, 2021
TammyGlen Allen, VA
Aug 27, 2021
Be careful
Read descriptions very carefully and be prepared to need to request tracking numbers for shipping. I ordered 2 separate auction dates and both times my items only shipped after I reached out several times. Paid items were not shipped for a month or more. One of my items, I was expecting a necklace and pendant so I was surprised when I only received a pendant. This was my fault because I didn't read carefully enough, but I encourage you to make sure you read the entire description. I will not bid on anything else from this Auction.
WilliamEastman, GA
Aug 15, 2021
Perfect pendant and great service
My first online auction win. The auction house contacted me and walked me through everything. Extremely nice folks! Shipping was fast also.
GerryDavenport, FL
Aug 04, 2021
GerryDavenport, FL
Jul 18, 2021
RichardOlympia, WA
Jul 07, 2021
RobertDallas, TX
Jul 04, 2021
maxineSolon, OH
Jun 27, 2021
Not what it looked like in the picture
The earrings are so occluded that they don’t look like emeralds, maybe moss agates. Also the necklace is disappointing for the same reason. I won’t buy again from this vendor!
Cynthia Kenosha, WI
Jun 18, 2021
Jewelry OK
The pictures on-line were good and rings are beautiful in person but the quality or workmanship of the rings 14k & 10k is sloppy, I haven’t worn them yet and they are all scratched: (maybe from being polished or handled???? You can barely see or read the10k stamp on one ring, pretty but a bit disappointing: (
LauraNew River, AZ
Jun 07, 2021
40 days to receive
Pretty ring but too uncomfortable to wear. Took 40 days to receive item. Seller was nice but overall disappointed.
SheilaGreensboro, NC
May 14, 2021
RayAurora, CO
May 12, 2021
Waited forever for a modified "new" ring
This was the first item I won. The Auction was on March 19th and wasn't sent until May 5th after many messages and even a phone call. Ring was described as an eternity band but only had the three stones showing in the image. However it used to have 8 stones all the way around as you can clearly see where the other 5 strones were removed and the setting was filled with solder. The condition was supposed to be "New" but it was very badly modified from its original state.
MarkNashville, TN
May 07, 2021
Bad, Bad, Bad
The seller's online payment site didn't work. They filed a dispute on me even though they cashed a check for the purchase They haven't responded to LA customer service. They still haven't sent the item I won. I won't do business with this seller again.
DanSaint Louis, MO
May 03, 2021
TOP


