Milestone Auctions, OH - Read over 1,889 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Milestone Auctions (1,889)

badge TOP RATED
4.7 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 1,889 Reviews

Richard
South Orange, NJ

May 03, 2026

Jerry
Nantucket, MA

May 01, 2026
Very pleased
My item was fragile, but well packaged and on damaged on delivery Items ship fast and easy to deal with.
Report

GREGORY
Falls Church, VA

Apr 29, 2026
Respectable, reputable, honest auction house
Bid and aquired the executioner sword. The auction house listed it correctly and appropriately. Very nice piece, well packaged, quickly shipped. I like these guys-I will do business with them again. Just to clarify, several voiced disbelief as to the authenticity of the item-research proved them wrong. Great deal on a great piece. Thank you.
Report

Kenneth
Plymouth, MI

Apr 28, 2026
EXCELLENT AUCTION HOUSE
EXCELLENT AUCTION HOUSE
Report

Andrew
Scottsdale, AZ

Apr 27, 2026

Dennis
Fletcher, NC

Apr 27, 2026
Great company friendly described photographed well.
great service
Report

Darin
Aptos, CA

Apr 25, 2026
Pros
Awesome Experience
Report

James
Sarasota, FL

Apr 25, 2026
no
no
Report

edward
Huntingdon Valley, PA

Apr 18, 2026

PETER
Vienna, VA

Apr 13, 2026
Items as described, shipping slow
Checkout was smooth and my items were received as described. It did take some time for my items to arrive, but they did get here.
Report

Mitchel
Springfield, OR

Apr 12, 2026
Excellent auction house
Accurate description easy shipping.
Report

John
San Antonio, TX

Apr 11, 2026

Joe
Bennett, CO

Apr 11, 2026

darin
Winston Salem, NC

Apr 05, 2026

Yang
Taipei, TW

Apr 04, 2026
Excellent and professional service
Perfect packaged and good arrangement, fast shipment, well service
Report

Victoria
Winston Salem, NC

Apr 04, 2026

Jerome
Louisville, KY

Apr 04, 2026
Easy to deal with and very helpful folks
Great Experience with Milestone Auctions. I had never participated in an online auction before, so I was a little apprehensive about the experience. I should not have worried at all. Milestone was super easy to deal with and very helpful with all my questions. The collectable I bought, a hard to find space toy, was just as pictured in the auction materials. Milestone quickly and securely packaged it and even called me to tell me exactly when it shipped and the tracking number. I got to spoke to the owner, who was friendly and knowledgeable, too. All-in-all, for a first experience, Milestone was perfect. I would buy again from them again in a heartbeat. Jerry
Report

bruce
Alamo, CA

Apr 04, 2026

Vern
Keswick, CA

Apr 04, 2026

Matt
Lone Tree, CO

Mar 29, 2026

Israel
Erie, PA

Mar 24, 2026
Great service
Lowest shipping fees
Report

Robert
Jonesboro, AR

Mar 22, 2026

JOHN
Syracuse, NY

Mar 20, 2026
Item that was sent to me was not what was described.
The H & R sportsman that I received was described with a 98 % finish. At best it was a 70 %. Described with a flawless action. The revolver was inoperable. The barrel would not move to the next position. When you break the gun open the barrel falls off. The gun is completely useless without a complete overhaul. No holster came with it as description said. There should be some accountability on the auction house to make sure the description fits the item.
Report

Heinrich
Belmont, MA

Mar 17, 2026

Bill
Williamsburg, VA

Mar 14, 2026

Fred
Belleview, FL

Mar 14, 2026

Brian
Columbus, IN

Mar 14, 2026

Scott
Wellsburg, WV

Mar 14, 2026

John
Keedysville, MD

Mar 14, 2026
Accurate representation of the rifle
Accurate description of the rifle. Satisfied with the communication with the company. Had the rifle in about fifteen days.
Report

Tom
Darien, IL

Mar 14, 2026
Accurate description; very fast shipping
Very happy with my purchase from Milestone. Bidding was easy, one call to provide payment info and arrived within the week. 👍 🏻
Report

J
Hampstead, MD

Mar 09, 2026
WILLIAMS #6250 NW-2 SWITCHER LOCOMOTIVE w/ BOX

Lester
Franklin, PA

Mar 08, 2026
Good prices, great packaging, excellent consumer response.
Good prices, great packaging, excellent consumer response.
Report

Brian
Fort Wayne, IN

Mar 05, 2026

John
West Vancouver, CA

Mar 01, 2026
JAPAN BATTERY OP #38 RACE CAR

Randy
Madison, WI

Feb 28, 2026
USALITE LONE RANGER SIGNAL SIREN

brian
Schenectady, NY

Feb 28, 2026
JAPAN BATTERY OP OCEANLINER UNITED STATES w/ BOX

Ken
Williston Park, NY

Feb 28, 2026
2- TOOTSIETOY LASALLE SEDANS

Preston
Milwaukee, WI

Feb 27, 2026
shipped without mag
No mag
Report

Richard
New York, NY

Feb 24, 2026
1956 TONKA PRESSED STEEL FIRE PUMPER

Richard
New York, NY

Feb 24, 2026
1968 TONKA POLICE JEEP w/ BOX

Herbert
Sunapee, NH

Feb 18, 2026
Excellent experience from this auction house.
Very satisfied with Milestone Auctions. Seamless from payment processing to shipping.
Report
SHEPARD JONAH AND THE WHALE MECHANICAL BANK

Hisham
Sarasota, FL

Feb 15, 2026
Milestone Auction is the Best
I find it very easy to find the rarest and best quality of tin toys in the Milestone Auctions. Completing the payment and shipping process is always smooth.
Report
AHI BATTERY OP SHERIFF CAR w/ BOX

David
San Diego, CA

Feb 13, 2026
Always Great To Deal With
Always Great To Deal With
Report

Gary
Atlanta, GA

Feb 10, 2026
Shipping charges are more reasonable and predictable than most
This is a great auction house. I am almost always very pleased with the items, and their shipping is always very reasonable. Online bidding is difficult in that the final costs can far exceed the actual bids, but with Milestone they are predictable and manageable!
Report
7- 1970s TONKA TOYS w/ BOXES

Mark
Tannersville, VA

Feb 09, 2026
J&E STEVENS CAST IRON OWL MECHANICAL BANK

George
Spring Branch, TX

Feb 08, 2026

Prokopios
Las Vegas, NV

Feb 07, 2026

Gary
Macclenny, FL

Feb 07, 2026
Awesome Auction Site
Answered all my questions and did an outstanding job
Report

Dan
Franklin, TN

Feb 07, 2026
👍 🏼
👍 🏼
Report

John
Greenwich, CT

Feb 07, 2026