Reviews
Bidder Reviews for Cordier Auctions (1,698)
4.4 out of 5.0 Stars
5 Star
76%(1293)
4 Star
9%(151)
3 Star
5%(78)
2 Star
3%(54)
1 Star
7%(122)
Accurate Descriptions
1-50 of 1,698 Reviews
WilliamStrasburg, CO
Sep 18, 2026
Coin purchase non searched
Purchased 100's of coins in 2 separate auctions. Items were of more value than cost. Coins were as is NOT searched. Do not buy from them, leave all the coins for me. LOL
MichaelLexington, VA
Sep 10, 2026
SaunyaNew Cumberland, PA
Sep 10, 2026
LilyBaltimore, MD
Sep 10, 2026
KaliDallas, TX
Sep 1, 2026
Great
Great experience. Easy to pay and to ship. I used the UPS Store for shipping and they picked up and shipped quickly.
JosephYuma, AZ
Aug 27, 2026
Unprofessional
the reason I didn't receive my item was that Cordier Auctions did not supply my FFL dealer to their shipping department I am very displeased with them!!!
KenLake Forest, IL
Aug 26, 2026
JonDanville, IL
Aug 26, 2026
Efficient
Had a little difficulty paying with CC but they were very helpful and problem got solved. Easy to contact a real person by phone.
RickJackson, MI
Aug 14, 2026
Shipping
The ease in finding an alternative, qualified shipper from the overly expensive Live Auctioneers options, was smooth, effortless, and quite honestly perfect.
PhilipAustin, TX
Aug 14, 2026
DonnaThree Springs, PA
Aug 13, 2026
ChristineWinnsboro, SC
Aug 13, 2026
stelaFort Myers, FL
Jul 16, 2026
CliffordMattituck, NY
Jul 7, 2026
GlennCave Creek, AZ
Jul 3, 2026
SO NOT BUY FROM THIS AUCTION HOUSE!
The auction house and its affiliated shippers will charge you astronomical prices to ship. When I requested a return I was denied even though the items were never shipped. Such a scam business!
AndrewHanover, PA
Jul 2, 2026
BobWilmington, DE
Jul 2, 2026
SCOTTReading, PA
Jul 2, 2026
CarolPittsburgh, PA
Jun 19, 2026
Great Service!
I contacted them shortly after winning my bid. I live on the other side of the state so I had to coordinate my appointment time with my work schedule and they were very accommodating. And when I got lost and missed my appointment time they were very gracious. This is one very satisfied customer.
ScottKokomo, IN
Jun 11, 2026
DavidSpring Valley, NY
Jun 3, 2026
I received a different diamond what was described
I am shocked how Dishonest Cordier are. They Publicized a GIA Fvvs1 and the stone is a I1
JosetteAllentown, PA
Jun 1, 2026
Another great auction house
Cordiers offers a lot of items to choose from. Bidding was easy and at some points tough and go as they get a lot of bidders. As I’m learning, you need to ask wuestions before you bid on the lots. like asking the length of necklaces, size of rings, etc. some of the lots I won had necklaces that would be like chokers. Unless you’re buying for lots just for melt weight, you could be surprised. Ask questions or you could buy a lot that is not for you. Sometimes the descriptions are light on information, so ask before you bid. But again, a really good auction to bid with.
ThomasGrand Island, NY
May 21, 2026
DeborahCamp Hill, PA
May 21, 2026
ElizabethDania Beach, FL
May 14, 2026
As always, a picture-perfect result!!
It's always fun to bid on lots put up for auction by Cordier!!!
ScottLawndale, CA
May 14, 2026
DanielBonanza, AR
May 7, 2026
Wire payment only but all went very smooth
I bought several bullion items. The only options for payment is wire payment or ACH direct payment. I had to jump through some hoops with my bank to send a larger payment to an unknown recipient. In the end, it all went well, they shipped it very quickly and appears to be exactly has listed.
American Pawn CompanyNorth Fort Myers, FL
Apr 2, 2026
EmilyCamp Hill, PA
Mar 30, 2026
ErikNew York, NY
Mar 27, 2026
Ashley Karana Downs, AU
Mar 17, 2026
Service and Shipping
The items were delayed by US postal. There were no issues with importation of all items into Australia. US posta thinks it knows all foreign to them import laws. Cordier Auctions were excellent, extremely supportive. The shipping company used a box over twice the required size to ship my items, costing excess in shipping. That and the US postal service were the issues I had. These issues were out of Cordier Auctions control.
MorrisFife, WA
Mar 14, 2026
One of the best companies I done business with
Love to do more business with this company everything was on time
HeidiWashington, DC
Feb 27, 2026
Mobile Exchange Gt IncDoral, FL
Feb 23, 2026
AmandaMillers Falls, MA
Feb 20, 2026
Feb 14, 2026
picture vs actual stone
customer service was good, unfortunately the color of the stone in the picture (quite lovely) vs that of the actual stone-meh, very light
RinaRidgewood, NY
Feb 10, 2026
Terrible Packaging
Condescending and terrible, irresponsible packaging practices. Packing peanuts were actively falling out of the box, and all the corners were damaged. Not to mention the tape was barely holding the box together. The auction house is condescending and unhelpful; you'll have to deal with all your shipping issues yourself.
Samuel Coopersburg, PA
Jan 30, 2026
GerardAdel, IA
Jan 30, 2026
PennieFairlawn, OH
Jan 30, 2026
Great items. Long drive in a blizzard
I loved my pieces, however I didn't realize where in PA they were. PA is an hour away, but the eastern part was 4.5 hours. I called to find out shipping rates, and the amount (over $200) was greater than my bid prices! So I figured out the estimated gas cost to drive there at $60. As long as I could make the drive in a single day so I didn't have to drive at night, and not pay for a hotel room, it was do-able. I learned that I had to arrange a date and time in advance. We were in the midst of snowstorms all over NE Ohio in January. I picked the next day when it was not supposed to snow (January 21), which was 5 days in the future. So the trip there was good. I made it to my pickup early, and my items were waiting for me. I bid farewell to the nice people and headed home. When I reached the PA mountains, the snow started. It was very slow driving on the twisty roads for about 2 hours. There was very low visibility, and driving behind plows as well. By the Ohio border, the snow had stopped, but it was dark. I made it home by 8 pm. I hadn't figured the cost of the OH and PA Turnpike tolls, which was over $60 for the PA part alone. Total pickup cost was about $140, about half the cost of the shipping. Other auction houses that I deal with tell me to come pick up items within x amount of days. If Cordier did that, I would have picked a better day to go. The lack of pickup flexibility and the high cost of shipping are my only 2 complaints. Everything else about Cordier is fine.
RobertDixon, IL
Jan 28, 2026
TobiasKarlsruhe, DE
Jan 27, 2026
RobertHudson, NY
Jan 2, 2026
Great Auction-Great Variety of Items Offered
Great auction house to add to my list. Accurate descriptions and photos. Thanks.
That Was Then IncDeerfield Beach, FL
Dec 30, 2025
Some good, some not good. Be wary.
The auction house did properly reveal condition even after asked prior to auction. They also did know much about the items they were auctioning. They would have to have something very compelling for me to consider bidding with them again. The UPS store I used, while expensive, expertly packed the fragile items I purchased.
DavidVirginia Beach, VA
Dec 25, 2025
TOP