Butterscotch Auction
Founded in 1987 by fine art appraiser Paul D. Marinucci, Butterscotch Auction Gallery has established itself as one of the preeminent estate auction houses in the greater New York City area. It is the oldest and foremost auction of Westchester County, NY, and has developed a reputation for great serviceability and high-quality merchandise among consignors and buyers alike.
Situated in the historic town of Bedford Village, NY, the gallery holds three large-scale estate auctions each year in the village's 200-year-old 'Historical Hall' a unique setting for the presentation of antiques, fine art, and jewelry. Each auction draws large audiences of collectors, dealers, museum curators, and private individuals from around the globe, and offers myriad items across the spectrum of decorative and fine arts, with particular emphasis in American Art, Asian Art, and jewelry.
Upcoming Auctions from Butterscotch Auction
Reflections of the Season
A Live, In-Person and Online auction with over 570 lots sourced from local estates & collections, featuring: A wide selection of American, Continental, and English Silver, various owners; Buccellati, Bulgari, Cartier, Tiffany, and other Designer Jewelry, various owners; Items sold on behalf of the Field Hall Foundation, Cortlandt Manor, NY; American, Old Master, and Continental Paintings, Prints, and Sculpture; various owners; American Classical Furniture and Decorative arts from a South Salem, NY estate; Asian Art, Art Glass, Scientific instruments, and moreBidder Reviews for Butterscotch Auction (212)
4.4 out of 5.0 Stars
8 Latest Top ReviewsSee All
MichaelSaint Clairsville, OH
Sep 23, 2025
Thank you, great piece!
Received this wonderful candle stand and it's better than expected. Butterscotch was great through the entire process. See you again!
RichardBirmingham, AL
Sep 04, 2025
Excellent auction house
Excellent auction house. Items well packed and shipped timely. Items were just as described. Look forward doing business in the future
RobertDamascus, OR
Aug 17, 2025
Great people. Went out of their way to expedite shipment of a complex set of framed photos.
Great people. Went out of their way to expedite shipment of a complex set of framed photos.
SETHHewlett, NY
Apr 13, 2025
Good auction.
I'd bid on any lot I was interested in@ Butterscotch Auctions. Though communication could be a little better; they responded quickly to my inquiries. Please let me know when works by Henry Stull Richard Stone Reeves come up for sale.
JayAustin, TX
Apr 02, 2025
Wow Wow Wow
What a great experience! I had a question about payment and they responded within 20 minutes! Description was spot on including additional Extra high resolution pictures On their website! So happy with My purchase! Keep up the good work-Thanks for making the transaction so easy! You guys are the best!-I have lots of dealings with buying pottery on live auctioneers and you guys are tops.
SusanNew Milford, CT
Mar 07, 2025
You can always count on your item being exactly how described. That's so important!
I have been going to Butterscotch auctions for about 30 years. I have never been disappointed once! Paul Marinucci has always been fair and honest. Not necessarily nice all the time, but a good man.
Past Auctions from Butterscotch Auction
Record Auction Results for Butterscotch Auction
TOP