Churchill Galleries, NY - Read over 217 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Churchill Galleries (217)

3.9 out of 5.0 Stars

1-50 of 217 Reviews

Wayne
Ogden, UT

Mar 09, 2025
Professional Auction House-
You wonder about things, when bidding on an item from an Auction House you are not familiar with. Will they help with shipping, will they ship it soon, will they answer my emails. Am I going to regret winning the bid. I do this every time myself. With Churchill Galleries Auction you do not need to worry. The item I won was shipped quickly and was packaged with extreme care, so no damage occurred during shipment. They helped with shipping and answered my emails questions immediately. I was very pleased with the transaction and will not hesitate doing business with them again in the future. Thanks-
Report

Eric
New York, NY

Feb 15, 2025
Another good experience
Living within a decent LIRR train ride as I do, I'm able to pick things up from this auction house; in this particular case, the director of the house went out of his way to be helpful. I've had a number of transactions with this firm, and will again in the future.
Report

Alfred
Agawam, MA

Feb 15, 2025
Never sent item I won and never provided a refund after follow up
I did not receive the item I won. I paid for the item and the shipping. After follow up with Churchill Galleries due to not receiving the item and receiving no shipping notice, I was initially told the book I won was lost and he would send a replacement. Despite several follow ups and delays, I never received the book, never received a refund of the book I won and never received a refund of the shipping I have paid. Churchill Galleries has not responded to additional inquiries. Have followed up with LiveAuctionners for assistance. Would never bid or purchase from Churchill Galleries.
Report
1988 Supercars Ferrari Testarossa; Hardcover; ISBN 0831732113 English Mint Condition

Miche
West Des Moines, IA

Jan 31, 2025
Buyer Beware!
Never Received Won Items!!! 11/24/24: won two canvas pictures 11/27: spoke to Churchill, they quickly sent a shipping invoice, which $85 was paid immediately via paypal 1/6/25: verbally spoke to Churchill, not in office, text me so when i'm in office I can send you the tracking information, it shipped 1/13: called, no answer; text requesting tracking, no reply 1/14: called, no answer; text requesting refund, no response 1/31: Writing this review, have never been contact by Churchill, no items ever received and no refund.-I live in Iowa so it must certainly has had sufficient time to arrive even taking into account the holidays or delays. On 1/14 I also opened a ticket with liveauctioneers, bidder support. 1/21: I followed up with liveauctioneers regarding my ticket. 1/25: LiveAuctioneers responded apologizing for the late response due to the high number of email cases. Perhaps this should be my first and last purchase with any auctioneer on liveauctioneers.
Report
Churchill Galleries logo
Churchill GalleriesJan 31, 2025
We are sorry to learn that your items have not arrived. We checked our warehouse, but unfortunately, we could not find them. We will process a full refund for you. In the event that the items are found, we will send them to you.

Tom
Reno, NV

Jan 19, 2025
I think they lost my stuff?
Initially they sent 7 of the paintings I bought. He seemed confused and unsure when I asked about the other 6 paintings. Said he had them and would ship asap. I have not received them or tracking info. I'll keep bugging them while I file a complaint against them. I dont recommend this auctioneer
Report

Kent
Palm Harbor, FL

Jan 13, 2025
ONE OF 4 LOTS WON NOT DELIVERED.. IGNORED BY CHURCHILL AUCTIONS
One 500 $+ lot from 4 won never delivered.. Ovee20 calls and messages with the auction house. They admit the non delivery but only after excuse. Still not delivered and they have refused to respond NOW DISPUTE IS OVER 3 MONTHS OLD AND THEY STILL HAVE NOT RESPONDED EVEN AFTER LIVE AUCTIONEERS CONTACTED THEM … dishonest!!!!
Report
WWII Era Golden German NSDAP Party Badge

Michael
Houston, TX

Jan 11, 2025
Art is beautiful
I purchased 4 different pieces by the same artist and the photo doesn't do them justice. 2 of them are superb. I had purchased them almost 2.5 months ago and was going to gift 2 of them as Christmas presents. Well too late now, but I'll keep them. Good deal, just be aware of the loooong shipping time.
Report

Eric
New York, NY

Jan 11, 2025
An honest auction house with integrity and diligence
One of the books I won couldn't be located. The auction house took it upon itself to make things right by actually going out and hunting for a replacement copy. It took a while, but they succeeded. Full marks for integrity, honesty and diligence, and they'll continue to get my business.
Report
War and the Royal Houses of Europe, Anthony Devere-Summers

Stephen
Lewisburg, OH

Jan 01, 2025
CURRIER AND IVES / CHILDHOODS HAPPY DAY / LITHOGRAPH

Daniel
Saint Charles, MO

Dec 18, 2024
Seller not recommended
After a long an unknown long delay in shipping my item, I requested a refund. After that request, they shipped my item without notification and caused the item to be held at the UPS Store while I was away on a two week out of state business trip. The vendor recalled my item and has not re-shipped. I asked for a refund and eventually they gave my money back, but a few days later they charged my card again, without authorization, and has since ghosted me. I have been working with Live Auctioneers for support and the process goes on. Vendor received $230.00 for my item on 8/20/2024 and today's date is 12/18/2024 with no end with this problem in sight. Bidders beware!!!
Report
Churchill Galleries logo
Churchill GalleriesDec 19, 2024
It seems there was a lapse in your recollection. Initially, you declined to pay for the item post-auction due to the shipping fees cited by Live Auctioneers. Subsequently, you completed your payment through PayPal a month after the auction concluded. Your item was shipped to the address you provided. Question: If you knew you were going to be away and you have received tracking information from us, why did you not reach out to UPS to either collect your item or redirect it to your new address? You have access to your tracking details — please contact UPS to arrange delivery to your location. We advise you to do this promptly to avoid the risk of the item being sent back to us.
Vintage German Stein

Mark
Bridgeport, CT

Dec 09, 2024
WARNING! They take your money and wont ship
Paid for item on Sept 29, received item December 7. Worst shipping in the country; I'm 75 miles away! Called 4 times, tried to have it picked up but they weren't available. You have been warned!
Report
Lionel Mickey Hand Car

Sami
Pleasant Hill, CA

Dec 05, 2024
Over 60 Days and no product.
After several calls and messages (in the last 60 days), Churchill Galleries came through with delivery and everything was in great condition and packed well. If they could step up communication, it would be a plus. They did reach out after receiving the items to make sure everything was ok and that they were looking into a new shipper. I appreciated the communication.
Report
Lionel Peter Rabbit and Cat

Barry
Hewlett, NY

Nov 17, 2024
Hagstrom's Atlas of Queens and Nassau Counties Long Island New York

Douglas
Sound Beach, NY

Nov 04, 2024
Avoid this auction house at any cost
I live 20 min away from this auction, I won several lots with the intent of picking them up. I contacted them to arrange pickup and owner said he would give me a pickup appointment date by the end of the week, Waited till end of week and called and was told in a stern voice that he would contact me when I could pickup my items and not to call him, waited till the following week and went there directly to find out where my items were and he suggested that I use the link and have them shipped to me at a cost of $285. I refused and told him to get me my items, he whined and told me I had disrespected him and to leave. Waited another week and my items were still not there. Total of 4 weeks before I could pickup my items and when I did get them they were all stacked on top of each other in a box getting all scratched up, Owner can’t handle the business and is full of excuses. Stay away
Report
Churchill Galleries logo
Churchill GalleriesNov 04, 2024
You have been dishonest. You arrived at the gallery a day after the auction without an appointment to retrieve your winning bids. We had informed you that you needed to schedule a visit, as the items from that auction were not yet prepared. Your behavior was quite aggressive, and you identified yourself as a police officer. You also referenced other unfavorable comments on our live auctioneer's platform and threatened to leave similar feedback. Consequently, we found it necessary to prohibit your participation in future auctions. It seems there is a lapse in your recollection, as you neglected to mention in your review that we had offered you an earlier appointment, which you canceled due to being out of town. You inspected, signed for, and collected your purchase over three weeks later without any problems, yet now you assert that the items are damaged. This situation reflects poorly on you.
Ives 3245 Electric

Oct 20, 2024
Never buy
Told shipper pack securely they threw it in a box and shipped it and low and behold they were broken 60 dollars and to top it off they only sent one of my lots contacted them and of course if you read there reviews they blame it on everyone but themselves WILL NOT BUY FROM THEM AGAIN can't wait to see there response to why only one lot was shipped and that they allow there shippers to pack that way shows there real character
Report
Churchill Galleries logo
Churchill GalleriesNov 04, 2024
You alleged that the items you received were damaged. We promptly informed you that we would look into this issue with our shipping partners and get back to you. It appears that our initial response did not meet your expectations, leading you to follow through on your intention to leave a negative review for Churchill Galleries. This seems to be a common approach among bidders who express concerns about what they perceive as excessive fees charged by Live Auctioneers for shipping the same items. Additionally, in your personal email to us, you warned Churchill Galleries about potentially disseminating negative reviews among your veteran acquaintances. Your specific remark was, “I have many veterans who collect soldiers like me; I will ensure they are informed about your auctions so they can spread the word and refrain from bidding. You brought this on yourself.” Such a spiteful statement.
WWI/WWII Cast Metal Toy Soldiers with Two Tents

Jen
Albany, NY

Oct 11, 2024
Never got my item despite weekly attempts and conversations
They strung me along for a month, reporting that they had the item and would call the day before scheduled time to pick up to be told we will call you back to make sure someone is there. In actuality they had conflict with the sonseignor and never obtained the item. I held on for so long because this is an item I was researching and waiting for the right price for over a year. Initially thought it was a scam but poor communication, follow through and organization.
Report
Six Midcentury Modern Chairs

Raja
Dubai, AE

Oct 09, 2024
did not receive my won items
i won two paintings in May and still did not receive them, i contacted Churchill Galleries and Live Auctioneer and no feedback yet
Report
Churchill Galleries logo
Churchill GalleriesOct 09, 2024
Your purchase shipped via USPS TRACKING INFORMATION: CH ********** 52US. We regret the delay.
Rare Peter Keil (B. 1942) Oil Painting - Mother and Child

Blaine
East Peoria, IL

Sep 25, 2024
VERY EXPENSIVE/SLOW SHIPPING, Damaged Item, No Response,
What can I say other than this experience was awful. I made my payment immediately, after 3 weeks of being told my items shipped, then more excuses as to why my items had not shipped, I basically had to threaten to contact my credit card company... So after nearly a month from my payment being made, my items arrived barely protected and crammed into the box for $52 I was expecting quicker and better packing. The sword I purchased had the very uncommon sword knot that was in mint condition, this arrived ripped, torn and destroyed (very disappointing). So I gave this company the benefit of a doubt and tried to contact them, over a week ago they were sent photos and contacted, I was told I would be contacted. After no contact I have now messaged them on Live Auctioneers (still have not been contacted.) If you must have an item they are auctioning then be my guest, but personally from my experience and overall dissatisfaction I would say just wait and do business elsewhere, because I purchased an item that showed up damaged and have been taken advantage of and ignored regarding the situation.
Report
Churchill Galleries logo
Churchill GalleriesSep 25, 2024
We are taken aback by your comment. We received your message and assured you that we will investigate the matter with your shipper, UPS – Tel: **********. We did and they assured us they will reach out to you after their investigation. Your purchase is insured, and you can address any concerns regarding this with them directly. It is regrettable that you responded negatively to other reviews that may not hold substantial value, contributing to a collective criticism. Additionally, it’s worth noting that we have numerous satisfied customers who appreciate the service we provide, which was overlooked in your feedback. Thank you.
Gherman Rhird Reich NSDAP Small Flag

Jeffrey
Spokane Valley, WA

Sep 10, 2024
Not good
I purchased these katanas. They looked good in the photos. Proper era saya, tsuba, fittings and handles. However only on handle is actual wood with rayskin the other is plastic and the most important part is that they have been dulled and chromed. That is the worst thing to do to a katana. People want naturaul steel and a proper edge or the remnants of one. None of these issue were disclosed in the listing. Not good. Not what I thought I was getting at all. Now repair costs will be more to restore to original. (Thanks whatever idiot ********** these up) also they really need to state these things in there listing. Went from excited to sever disappointment.
Report
Churchill Galleries logo
Churchill GalleriesSep 25, 2024
Sorry to hear. We will look in to it. Thank you.
WWII Japanese Fixer / Handyman KATANA Swords

Steve
West Newton, MA

Sep 06, 2024
Worst experience ever
Won item July 21st, still do not have it and no response to queries. This place should be avoided.
Report
Churchill Galleries logo
Churchill GalleriesSep 06, 2024
Greetings, We thought your book was already shipped and delivered. We instructed UPS to dispatch your book and they had it all this time until we spoke to them today. They sent it out today-tracking information 1Z CIX 379 03 0 **********. We apologize for the mix up. Thank you.
1991 Klemantaski and Ferrari English, Italian, French Hardcover

Christian
Matawan, NJ

Sep 04, 2024
WWII German Arm Band

Eric
New York, NY

Aug 17, 2024
Satisfied Once Again
This was a group of two books I won at auction. One book took a bit to get in inventory, but in due course, the book was located and sent on to my satisfaction; in the case of the other book, a very acceptable set of substitutes was found. Combined with the convenience of getting stuff from this auction house (a train ride away), they'll be getting more business.
Report
The Tongs & The Bones, Lord Harewood

Charles
Manville, RI

Aug 14, 2024
Middle Eastern Burly Dancer Drum w/ Case

Sivam
Sabak Bernam, MY

Aug 06, 2024
great wed side.
great wed side, yes selling genuine bank note and coin
Report
WWII Era Japanese 10 Yen Bank Note

Phyllis
Monroe Twp, NJ

Aug 04, 2024
Hummel Large Boy with Umbrella Figurine

Gul
Inwood, NY

Aug 01, 2024
Large Lladro 14 1/4" Sea Breeze, Brisa Marina, Porcelain, Made In Spain Retired

Trent
Kannapolis, NC

Jul 26, 2024
Nice Visor
Item was accurately described and photographed. No problems with the folks. 👍
Report
Original German NSDAP (NAZI PARTY) POLITICAL LEADERS VISOR CAP

Eric
New York, NY

Jul 25, 2024
Another successful dealing
This auction house is moderately convenient for in-person pickup, and I was able to get this book-a good one-easily. The head of the house is a very pleasant man and loves to chat!
Report
Book "The Old Lie, The Great War and the Public School Ethos" by Peter Parker

Bill
Elyria, OH

Jul 17, 2024
Slow to deliver
I won an item and it took a month to get to me from New York to Ohio. There was much communication involved on my part. It was like "pulling teeth" to get a tracking number and an ETA of the item I won. Don't worry, Churchill, I won't be doing business with you again.
Report
1990 Leyton House CG911 Formula 1, Spark, China, 1/43 Scale, Mint Condition

Meg
Peachtree City, GA

Jul 06, 2024
I have not received this painting
I have not received this painting. I have tried messaging the auction house through The app. I have called the gallery directly and cannot get through. I did get a call back finally and they said the item would be shipping that week, which was theee weeks ago. Last week they said they would contact me with a shipping tracking number. They did not. I cannot get anyone to follow up with this and actually walk this painting through the shipping process. I literally got a painting from Ukraine in two weeks. I have received every other item within two weeks. It has been six weeks. There is no reason for shipping to take this long. I am beginning to think they have no idea where the painting is.
Report
Churchill Galleries logo
Churchill GalleriesJul 08, 2024
You recently spoke to the gallery and you were informed the item is with our shippers and we will revert back to you with tracking information when dispatched. They are back today. Expect your tracking information within 24hrs. Support team-Churchill Galleries
Peter Keil Oil on Acrylic Painting

John
Cape Coral, FL

Jun 30, 2024
Not recommended
Not recommended will not return messages
Report
Churchill Galleries logo
Churchill GalleriesJul 08, 2024
Your statement is incorrect. As of recent, the gallery was communicating with you on shipment of your purchase. You were notified to expect tracking information shortly and that has not changed. Thank you.

Phyllis
Monroe Twp, NJ

Jun 30, 2024

Rodor
Sacramento, CA

Jun 13, 2024
1962 Ferrari 250 GTO 24 Hours of Le Mans, Bburago, Italy, 1/18 Scale, Mint Condition

Christopher
Norwell, MA

May 30, 2024
This was my first time purchasing from Churchill Galleries and it was Great!
This was my first time purchasing from Churchill Galleries.... As I always do-I first read the reviews before bidding-frankly I was concerned about some of the reviews that described issues with shipping... But the 2 Chelsea Clock items were way to nice to pass on... so I rolled the dice. After the auction, I spoke with Charles... whom I found to be a great guy! Very personable and very responsive... I requested that the auction house ship my items... after i received an estimate from Live Auctioneers that almost knocked me out of my chair! When I spoke to Charles about shipping he provided me with a cost that was incredibly reasonable. I just received the clocks today and the packing was OUTSTANDING!!! They arrived in tact, as described and packed to withstand the trip. For those of you with any concerns about bidding with Churchill Galleries... forget them! I found the auction house to be very responsive, fair and auctioning GREAT Items!-Looking forward to bidding again!!! Thanks Charles and thanks for the great customer service!
Report
ANTIQUE CHELSEA SHIP'S BELL CLOCK / YATCH HANDLE

David
Killeen, TX

May 27, 2024
Leroy W. Kingman: Our County & its PeopleTioga County NY.

Anatoly
Brooklyn, NY

May 12, 2024
Very Happy with this Auction House Thank you.
Very Happy with this Auction House Thank you.
Report
Large Collection of Soviet Union Space Pins (1200)

Bradley
APO, AP

May 05, 2024
Will not respond to emails
I can’t get Charles to respond via email on my shipping arrangements, though we have spoken on the phone and he said he would. I understand it takes some time after the auction, but it’s been 28 days and I can’t even get an update on if it’s going to get shipped anytime soon. I guess I keep waiting.
Report
Churchill Galleries logo
Churchill GalleriesMay 05, 2024
Your comments are false. We responded to your April 9th email twice as well as spoke to you on the phone on the 10th of April after your email enquiring about shipping out your item to your location-US Military base in Japan. We informed you that your tracking information will be forwarded to you when sent. You called a few days later and you were further informed a tracking will be provided when item is dispatched. Your purchase was on consignment and the consignor was away and now back and the item will be dispatched. We acknowledge and regret the delay. Thank you.
Japanese Flag WWII w/ Signatures

Zecheng
Ann Arbor, MI

Apr 29, 2024
Please avoid this auction at all costs
I purchased this watch from them last year, and the item was never sent despite hundreds of phone calls. They made various excuses to delay shipping and eventually after 4 months or so I decided to ask for a refund. Until today there has been no refund whatsoever and they have refused to answer any call. I would consider this auction house a big red flag to purchase from.
Report
J.L Caldwell and Co. Pocket watch. Late 19th century. 18 Karat Gold. 21 Jewels. Swiss Make.

Jerry
Federal Way, WA

Apr 27, 2024
I have never received the Art.
I have paid in full plus extra for shipping, I have never received the Art. Ive called numerous times and even spoken to them and they promise to ship but dont. i bought this item October of 2023
Report
Pencil signed Guy Buffet Limited Edition Lithograph 57/ 595 (No Frame)

Eric
New York, NY

Apr 14, 2024
(See second review, same date)
I actually reviewed the items here in my (positive) review that I've posted separately. Bottom line: solid auction house, friendly service.
Report
Newspaper: Journal American /August 13th 1945/ HIROSHITO CONFERS WITH TOGO

Eric
New York, NY

Apr 14, 2024
Quite happy!
This was actually two separate auctions, but I picked up the items all at once. Having had experience with this auction house before, I now knew what to do, and with a few phone calls, all but one of my items were neatly arranged for me to pick up. One minor item, a newspaper, couldn't be located, but I was offered a book to replace it, which was entirely reasonable and satisfactory to me. So I'll be watching out for more auctions from this house. Good selection of books.
Report
Royal Book "The Reign of King Boris III of Bulgaria"

Eric
New York, NY

Mar 30, 2024
Turned out well!
An initial effort to pick up the items glitched, but a second attempt proved to be rather pleasant, as the gentleman at the auction house proved to be quite chatty and helpful. One small item didn't turn up, but a suitable substitute was found. AND there were a few books and other items I picked up at the shop while I was there. Now that I know what the drill is, I will be bidding again with this firm.
Report
WWI US Army Ammo Pouch w/ Insignia

Carey
Palm Harbor, FL

Mar 18, 2024
Debrett's Peerage & Baronetage, Knightage, & Companionage 1973 - 1974 Edition

Jaime
New York, NY

Mar 10, 2024
Fantastic!
Great customer service. I will bid with them again
Report

Mathieu
Laval, CA

Feb 26, 2024
Shipping is bad with live auctionners
Do not ship with live auctionner it is very bad. They charged 127 $for shipping on a 135 $item and it took a whole month to receive. It was well package tho.
Report
German SS Waffen Battlefield M40 Stahlhelm

Mourad
Saint-jean-sur-richelieu, CA

Feb 02, 2024
Original picture post WWII BERLIN NATIONAL GALLERY / COPYRIGHT ATELIER BADEKOW

Richard
Crestview, FL

Feb 02, 2024
Takes your money, doesn't deliver items.
Seems to be a rip off. Taking your money and not delivering items paid for.
Report
US ARMY WWII M1 NET HELMET WITH BAND / INNER LINING

Dennis
Lomita, CA

Jan 24, 2024
Collection WWII US Military and others patches

Bryan
Egg Harbor Township, NJ

Jan 16, 2024
finest auction house
This auction house may have the finest military items for sale, I was thrilled when my posters arrived, were packed so carefully – very happy with my finds
Report
Original WWII Military framed advertising poster/ 3 rd  LIBERTY LOAN. Measures approximately:

Arlene
West Bloomfield, MI

Dec 09, 2023
Ghambaro Oil Painting on Canvas /WINTER IN GREENWICH