Rare Treasures, PA - Read over 1,284 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Rare Treasures (1,284)

badge TOP RATED
4.5 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 1,284 Reviews

roman

Feb 19, 2026

Tomas
Bajorai, LT

Feb 17, 2026
Item won, but not shipped for already a months. It looks scam auction place
Item won, but not shipped for already a month. It looks as scam auction place
Report

Thaddeus
Philadelphia, PA

Feb 16, 2026

Scott
Waterford, MI

Feb 16, 2026
To do your research!
In the description, it didn't say the items were replicas. If I knew that was the case, I would have never bid on them.
Report

Patrick
Fairfax Station, VA

Feb 16, 2026

Elizabeth
Fairfax Sta, VA

Feb 16, 2026
Seamless and easy transaction
This item was delivered extremely quickly and in perfect order. A very smooth transaction.
Report

Marek
Praha 1, CZ

Feb 16, 2026

Christophe
Crissier, CH

Feb 10, 2026
Not professional
Months before receiving the parcel. It was lost with no valuable explanation. Very bad experience! Not any more. I will buy only with professionals in the future.
Report

Luis
Sacramento, CA

Feb 09, 2026
Outstanding
Outstanding in every way possible.
Report

Mark
Raton, UM

Feb 07, 2026
I will do more business with them again.
When I finally got ahold of someone at the Auction House. Everything went smoothly and quick!
Report

Ashley
Karana Downs, AU

Feb 03, 2026
Service and Shipping
Always excellent service, always extremely understanding, paitent and helpful. Always a pleasure to deal with.
Report

Gary
Macclenny, FL

Feb 02, 2026
Great job
Great auction house!!
Report

Michael J
Parker, CO

Feb 02, 2026

charles
Atlanta, GA

Feb 02, 2026

Tim
Bay Village, OH

Feb 02, 2026
Excellent Artefacts
The artefacts are exactly as described
Report

Steven
Dana Point, CA

Feb 02, 2026
Honest and friendly people
One of the most honest and helpful plus sellers I’ve dealt with!
Report

Michael
Los Angeles, CA

Feb 02, 2026

Tim
Berea, OH

Jan 29, 2026
Fraudulent auction
Everything they sell and has sold is fake.
Report

Shel
Harrisburg, PA

Jan 29, 2026
Nice items.
Thanks for the great items in my collection.
Report

Shel
Harrisburg, PA

Jan 29, 2026
Great auction company.
Received all items on time! Very interesting items.
Report

Michael
Kent, WA

Jan 26, 2026
Fake Item
Was excited to receive this item from the late 1800's until I found it being sold at an online store for native American items. With a little digging it seems almost all of the native American items they sell can be bought hare at a fraction of the price, https://www.crazycrow.com/site/I would not buy anything from this house without physical proof of authenticity.
Report

Gary
Macclenny, FL

Jan 24, 2026

Gary
Macclenny, FL

Jan 24, 2026

johnny
APO, AP

Jan 24, 2026
Great items and service.
As described and fast shipping!
Report

johnny
APO, AP

Jan 24, 2026
Great items and service.
As described and fast shipping!
Report

johnny
APO, AP

Jan 24, 2026
Great items and service.
All items as described and fast shipping!
Report

johnny
APO, AP

Jan 24, 2026
Great items and service.
All items as described and fast shipping!
Report

johnny
APO, AP

Jan 24, 2026
Great item and service.
All items as described and fast shipping!
Report

johnny
APO, AP

Jan 24, 2026
Great item and service.
As described!
Report

David
Tel Aviv, IL

Jan 23, 2026
Overall positive experience but communications could be better
Overall positive experience but when I had a problem with the shipment (it took ages to arrive) and wrote to them asking for assistance, I did not receive a response. The item eventually arrived so all's well that ends well, but their communications could and should be better.
Report

Noreen
Port Charlotte, FL

Jan 22, 2026
Correction to Previous Review
The auction house contacted us and corrected the situation to our complete satisfaction. Very few auctioneers will do that. We are now satisfied with our experience.
Report

Kenny
Saint Petersburg, FL

Jan 15, 2026
Solid
I am impressed with the way the auction is run and with how the seller handled the sale of their products.
Report

Robert
Port Jervis, NY

Jan 15, 2026

Timothy
Salina, KS

Jan 12, 2026
Very Nice!
Super nice item! The cross has been hard for me to find. I will use this auction house again in the future.
Report

John
Parma, OH

Jan 12, 2026

Michael
Kent, WA

Jan 12, 2026
Item Not Authentic!
Upon receiving the item, it was clear it was not an authentic item. I contacted the seller, and he said he would give me a refund. It took several weeks to get a refund and in the end it was not for the full amount. I would highly recommend doing a lot of research on the items you are looking to buy including looking at past auctions from this seller. I was able to find the exact item sold 5 different times as authentic. Every item is from a different era and tribe and everyone made the exact same design, pretty had to believe. I have bought another item which was supposed to be authentic native American items, which I believe is also not authentic. I saw this because I found a website that sells both the items and they can be bought at a fraction of the price I paid. When I brought this up to the seller he said that is a reproduction site. Which would mean I had two of the originals of the 30 items offered, to hard to believe.
Report

Charles
Elizabethport, NJ

Jan 11, 2026
Great prices and fast shipping
I kinda messed up and they worked with me and I got my products. Thank you so much and I truly appreciate everything.
Report

Michel
Blainville, CA

Jan 10, 2026
Great auctionneer
excellent transaction
Report

Steven
Dana Point, CA

Dec 29, 2025
Unresponsive
Purchased a number of items and paid over $2, 000 the same day I received the invoice. Since then they don’t respond to my emails regarding the shipping or delivery!
Report

Thaddeus
Philadelphia, PA

Dec 29, 2025

Tim
Bay Village, OH

Dec 29, 2025
Excellent
I always enjoy purchasing from Rare Treasures. Artifacts are always great and the fact that they do in house shipping is fantastic! No extra hassle!
Report

Chris
Edgewood, NM

Dec 29, 2025
Items as described
Items as described, packaged well and shipping was quick
Report

James
Mesquite, TX

Dec 29, 2025
Great auction house
N/A
Report

Ricky
Dublin, TX

Dec 26, 2025
Issues not mentioned
Seller listed this item as an original. He had no documentation but promised to send me some with the item. He sent nothing with the item and as soon as I opened the item it was clear the seller had not fully disclosed the items condition. The item had been broken in half and glued back together which you can make out in the photos after you have it in hand. I knew the documentation was sketchy and bid anyway so that is my bad. To have not stated in the auction that the item had been broken in half and glued back together is the sellers bad. The seller did send me a guy's name that supposedly brought it back after I complained but totally blew off the fact that it was broken in half. Again, my main issue is it was broken and glued back together. Any collector knows something broken and glued affects the items value. The seller offered a refund after I complained to Live Auctioneers but getting a refund when paying with a credit card was never a concern. This guy passing off an item with undisclosed warts was my issue. I'd buy my "rare treasures" from someone else that is honest and cares about his or her reputation. Thanks, and happy collecting.
Report

Adolph
Arlington, VA

Dec 16, 2025
Professional
Very reliable, courteous, and expeditious.
Report

Robert
Grovetown, GA

Dec 15, 2025
Outstanding service
All items are properly represented and services are outstanding.
Report

Tim
Bay Village, OH

Dec 15, 2025
Excellent service
Quick and easy shipping and their artifacts are always satisfactory
Report

RUSSELL
San Angelo, TX

Dec 15, 2025

Richard
Avon Lake, OH

Dec 13, 2025
Nice Item
Great item and it came as described. A bit of confusion about payment and shipping but the auction house cleared it up. I have bought items before and they always helpful. I recommend this auction house!
Report

Em
Hicksville, OH

Dec 09, 2025