Reviews
Bidder Reviews for Coins and Auctions Since 1994 (477)
TOP RATED4.7 out of 5.0 Stars
Accurate Descriptions
Quick Responses
Easy Payments
Seamless Shipping
1-50 of 477 Reviews
RichardBirdsboro, PA
Aug 17, 2026
JosetteAllentown, PA
Aug 17, 2026
Coins, coins, and more coins
Reced my coin today. Packaged well. Hoping the grading and toning is as listed. But happy bidding experience.
ThomasEagle, MI
Jul 16, 2026
MichaelPalm Coast, FL
Jul 15, 2026
ScottKokomo, IN
Jul 8, 2026
RichardCanon City, CO
Jun 24, 2026
ScottKokomo, IN
Jun 11, 2026
ScottKokomo, IN
Jun 11, 2026
MichaelPalm Coast, FL
Jun 3, 2026
AnthonyPortland, ME
May 26, 2026
Excellent experience
Great products. Received exactly what I expected and was very happy with the items received. No issues with shipping or payment process. Would buy from them again without a doubt.
SobhanLynnwood, WA
May 21, 2026
Regrets on not finding them sooner
What surprises me most about this auction house is their incredibly low premium — in fact, they are the only ones I’ve seen with almost no premium at all. This is the only auction platform that doesn't completely drain your wallet with extra "online fees," "buyer's premiums," “extremely high shipping fee,” or "credit card purchase fees." I only wish I had discovered them before Washington precious metals extortion tax; otherwise, I easily would have spent tens of thousands of dollars here by now.
KennethMary Esther, FL
Apr 29, 2026
Zelle accounts are bad tried 3 different accounts sent to me from representatives
They charge very high fees to do business and shipping is ridiculous. Also I tried to make three payments for Zelle account Close my account please
EnidSan Martin, CA
Apr 15, 2026
What Was Pictured Wasn’t What I Received
1884-O Morgan Silver Dollar M64 lot 0652 and the 1904-O photos shown was much nicer, no flaws on her face than the coins I actually received. Both coins I received have significant flaws on the smooth part of her face. The rest of the coins I received were exactly what their picture reflected.
StevenRomulus, MI
Apr 9, 2026
JosephEl Segundo, CA
Apr 1, 2026
ChristopherMesa, AZ
Apr 1, 2026
No response from Auction House
This is my second purchase from C & A. I appreciate their low premiums and the first transaction was flawless. But this go round I won three individual Morgan Dollars and a set of 20 PCGS graded MS64 Morgan Dollars. The description contained the following statement: "Disclaimer: when this gets delivered, you will find somewhere between 2 and 5 different dates and mint marks on average. These are picked at random by the consignor and usually the price is fantastic!" which being a coin reseller was agreeable to me. When the lot was delivered the entire lot of 20 coins were ALL 1884-O which PCGS has graded over 92, 000 in that mintage. Not the 2 to 5 different years/mint marks as promised in the description of the lot. I reached out to them immediately after I received the coins (about 10 days ago now) and have not heard back from them. As it is it will take me several years to resell these 20 coins as they are all the same. My only hope is that with the rise in silver prices I can recoup most of my spend on the lot but I fear that half of these will end up as Christmas gifts to family members. Disappointing experience this time especially with the lack of a response.
JohnHaverhill, MA
Apr 1, 2026
JOSEPHPrinceton, WV
Apr 1, 2026
ArziRego Park, NY
Mar 26, 2026
Great seller!
Auctioneer with one of the best buyer's premium around. Items shipped were packed securely, and sent promptly. Would gladly purchase from again.
ChrisChicago, IL
Mar 19, 2026
KennywayneGlendora, CA
Mar 11, 2026
TrishPort St Lucie, FL
Mar 11, 2026
DavidRedondo Beach, CA
Mar 11, 2026
WilliamHot Springs National Park, AR
Feb 24, 2026
KennywayneGlendora, CA
Feb 18, 2026
Make sure the price is correct with shipping packages.
My experience with live auction has been great... Thank you!! Kennywayne
Jonathan Canandaigua, NY
Feb 9, 2026
CharlesPrescott, AZ
Jan 28, 2026
Jonathan Canandaigua, NY
Jan 21, 2026
Jan 1, 2026
MitchDeland, FL
Jan 1, 2026
You get what you buy
The coins I bought were exactly what saw in the picture and explained in definition of the coins they
CharlesElizabethport, NJ
Dec 17, 2025
JeffreyGreentown, PA
Dec 10, 2025
DavidKasilof, AK
Dec 8, 2025
Not as Advertised
The item showed it was 'fine gold'. Upon receipt, the item assayed at 10k. I returned it. The seller has not responded to emails.
MarkJasper, GA
Oct 29, 2025
KennethLaughlin, NV
Oct 18, 2025
Jonathan Canandaigua, NY
Oct 18, 2025
JerryEast Brunswick, NJ
Oct 8, 2025
ChristopherYuma, AZ
Sep 29, 2025
Honest!
Bought my first items to "test" this auction house. Legit item, no hidden fees of any kind. Will use them again!
Jonathan Canandaigua, NY
Sep 24, 2025
DavidEast Haven, CT
Aug 26, 2025
Damaged goods
I'm very disappointed with the auction group. The silver bar was quite damaged. No excuse for that. After charging all the extra fees it questions the groups level of integrity and professionalism
JohnHuntington Beach, CA
Aug 7, 2025
Excellent company from start to finish!!!!!!
Highly recommend that you deal with this company. Everythinf was seamless.
RodSaint George, UT
Aug 6, 2025
TOP