Bidder Reviews for Casco Bay Auctions (427)
4.7 out of 5.0 Stars
1-50 of 427 Reviews
RobertNewburyport, MA
Jan 23, 2026

DerekSan Francisco, CA
Dec 27, 2025

TimEdinboro, PA
Dec 25, 2025

PascalBronx, NY
Dec 23, 2025
Definitely THE smoothest transaction I have had those past years. AmAzingly well packed! THANK YOU
Definitely one of the smoothest transactions I have had those past years. Amazingly well packed! Great in communication and very accommodating. A bit disappointed by a painting thought to be older but its description was accurate. THANK YOU!!!!

NickOverland Park, KS
Dec 20, 2025
item as described. charged twice.
made arrangements to pay auction house privately after auction. did so and awaited item. they did not mark it as paid on the website, so then LiveAuctioneers charged me again! had to get it reversed. not great. item is lovely though.

VictorAntioch, CA
Dec 17, 2025

josephDennis, MA
Dec 13, 2025

TrishaHolton, KS
Dec 13, 2025

CliffordMattituck, NY
Dec 05, 2025

KevinNorwich, CT
Dec 03, 2025
Great item.... Great auction house
Very pleased with item. Shipping very reasonable and item arrived in perfect condition. Thank you

JayManlius, NY
Nov 08, 2025

Oct 30, 2025
This LiveAuctioners website is unsuitable for auctions and purchases.
This LiveAuctioners website is unsuitable for auctions and purchases. It's run by completely incompetent idiots. Change your auction platform.

JeanEddington, ME
Oct 17, 2025
The items described perfecty
No surprises as the item pictures and descriptions were spot on. I have purchased a few things through Casco Bay and they are always easy to work with.

VictoriaRidgeland, MS
Oct 11, 2025

DavidTuscaloosa, AL
Oct 11, 2025

ReneChester, MD
Oct 11, 2025

AnnHikurangi, NZ
Oct 11, 2025
great transaction
the Casco Bay shipping dept really helped me out with a tight shipping deadline. They were very responsive and accurate in communicating.

ElizabethDania Beach, FL
Sep 28, 2025
A lovely grouping of wonderful items... thanks so much!!!
I look forward to your next auction...

MichaelWestwood, MA
Sep 08, 2025

GEORGE K ARNOLD FINE ART & ANTIQUESOrmond Beach, FL
Sep 06, 2025

DonaTenants Harbor, ME
Sep 06, 2025

SharonOlathe, KS
Sep 06, 2025
Accurate description and awesome packing!
My item was exactly as described, and from the picture, what I was expecting and then some. Great quality. The shipping was quick and Casco had contracted UPS to pack and ship, which was done extremely well and protectively-more than I expected. Very happy and satisfied!

JeffreyBaraboo, WI
Aug 09, 2025

LisaPlymouth, MA
Aug 09, 2025

NadineWoodstock, GA
Aug 09, 2025
Met all expectations
An easy auction company to do business with from bidding, shipping and communication!

PaulTrenton, NJ
Aug 09, 2025

GuyChicago, IL
Aug 01, 2025
It's GREAT
A great surprise!! The pieces were really good. Very fast and reasonable shipping cost. I'll be back!! Thank you.

MitchellKnoxville, TN
Jul 20, 2025
Very satisfied!
Casco Bay has been great with communication as well as shipping! Prices of shipping are great compared to the other shipping firms. I always try to see what Casco Bay offers in their auctions.

CoulsonBountiful, UT
Jul 14, 2025
Good Photos, Fast Service, Great Shipping.
Relatively short period from auction's end to shipping the item. Professional in-house packing and shipping and a much better deal than the typical UPS Store fees.

RobertFredericksburg, VA
Jul 12, 2025

CharlieFlushing, NY
Jul 08, 2025
Disappointed – Inaccurate Condition Reports and No Response
Two of the items I won had significantly inaccurate condition descriptions. At Apr 12, 2025 Lot 0159 LARGE CHINESE ROSE MEDALLION BOWL. was described as being in very good condition, but it was actually damaged and had been repaired — something that should have been clearly disclosed. I reached out to the auction house for clarification, but received no reply. I ended up wasting several hundred dollars on misrepresented pieces. Overall, a very unsatisfactory experience.

DanielBoston, MA
May 26, 2025

GregHobe Sound, FL
May 19, 2025

JohnCharlotte, NC
May 03, 2025

SarahPortsmouth, NH
May 01, 2025
A + experience
Very satisfied with CBA. They are easy to reach and respond to calls/emails promptly. I have found them to be very accommodating. Packaging was done with great care. Item as described.

EdMilton, WI
Apr 04, 2025
Good price and quick shipping
Item was as described. Fair price. Quick shipping. Thanks for a good experience.

KevinPerkasie, PA
Mar 29, 2025
Great Experience with Casco Bay Auctions
This was our first experience with Casco Bay Auctions. Communications, bidding and invoicing was so easy. They handled everything superbly! Shipping was fantastic. Thank you so much. We will see you again.

JayAustin, TX
Mar 29, 2025
Hook’em Horns
Great plate guys! Thanks for making the transaction so easy! Keep up the good work-and hook’em

TimothyStevenson, MD
Mar 29, 2025

HeatherGrand Forks, ND
Mar 29, 2025

BradfordPotomac, MD
Mar 26, 2025

MarianneKenneth City, FL
Mar 15, 2025

RachelCambridge, MA
Feb 15, 2025
Great Transaction
Items were as or better than described, were packed securely, and arrived in a timely manner. I particularly appreciated receiving a post-purchase email detailing pick-up or delivery options-with some auction houses, I have to go looking for details in their auction agreements, or mistakenly believe that the item will be automatically sent. You definitely have a future repeat customer!

ElizabethDania Beach, FL
Feb 11, 2025

StephenMenlo Park, CA
Feb 08, 2025
Great communication and timely delivery.
Casco Bay Auctions very friendly and responsive to inquiries.

MarcieSimsboro, LA
Jan 28, 2025
Casco Bay Auctions easy to use
I've since had a few negative experiences with other Auction houses so I appreciate Casco. Quick easy and as described. Will attend more of Casco Bay Auctions!

ReneChester, MD
Jan 25, 2025
Absolutely smooth process! From nice to payment to packaging to receiving, it was seamless.
Smooth process

TOP


