Vintage Auctions, OH - Read over 998 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Vintage Auctions (998)

badge TOP RATED
4.7 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 999 Reviews

Charles
San Francisco, CA

Mar 24, 2026
Happy to bid with them again
Happy to bid with them again
Report
Lapis Lazuli Sterling Pendant & Mesh Chain

Cathy
Riverview, FL

Mar 19, 2026
Variety of (10) Brooches

Katherine
Flint, MI

Mar 18, 2026
(6) Gold & Silver-Tone Chain Necklaces

Dwain
Ocala, FL

Mar 12, 2026
Hubley Smokin Texan Cap Gun With Holster

Lindsay
Waterville, OH

Mar 05, 2026
Gold Tone Sterling Gemstone Necklaces

Amy
Naples, FL

Feb 28, 2026
Remington Bird Dog Hunting Pocket Watch

Edward
Wilmington, DE

Feb 26, 2026
(50) MIXED DATE MERCURY SILVER DIMES

Edward
Wilmington, DE

Feb 25, 2026
1986 Mo 1 onza Silver

Victoria
Westerville, OH

Feb 24, 2026
Sterling Listings Containing Silver-Plated Items
Be very careful with this auction house. We have been working with them since 2024 and have found that items not as described are quite common, especially in multi-item lots. Whether intentional or not, they mix fine jewelry with costume jewelry. The listing may state “sterling,” but silver-plated items are included in the lot. We have made multiple returns, yet they continue mixing up the lots. In the end, you may bid too much on a lot that isn’t worth it. Do your due diligence — use a magnet or test with acid.
Report
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsFeb 24, 2026
Thanks for your feedback. We have been going through a major internal transition that involved changing processes on how we deal with Sterling and other fine jewelry. Things we thought were being done were not. That has changed. The new policies and procedures make sure we are digging deeper into the items we sell. We are sorry you have not been satisfied with all your past purchases, but we assure you, things are changing and getting better. Also, understand, we are human, so some mistakes may still be made, but we are doing our best to make sure more double checks are in place to prevent them. We hope to continue doing business with you.
Citrine Sterling Rings & Necklaces

Bruce
Mounds View, MN

Feb 19, 2026
Amazing comics and shipping
Always great working with this auction house!!
Report
(10) Marvel Comics Mixed Lot F-VG

MICHAEL
Cincinnati, OH

Feb 19, 2026
timely shipping!
packaged remarkably well, but over done I think. shipping is expensive.
Report
Fantastic Four 1967 Marvel #64 (G/VG)

Gloria
Eatonton, GA

Feb 18, 2026
2013 1oz 999 Silver China Panda, PCGS MS-70

todd
Waterville, OH

Feb 17, 2026
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsFeb 18, 2026
Thank you for your rating!!
Star Wars Master Visions Jeremy Bulloch

Clinton
San Antonio, TX

Feb 11, 2026
Great auction
Very good auction and great shipping
Report
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsFeb 18, 2026
Thank you so much for your review and rating! We hope you continue bidding with us!
2000-S Silver Kennedy Half, PCGS PR-69 DCAM

Mobile Exchange Gt Inc
Doral, FL

Feb 10, 2026
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsFeb 18, 2026
Thank you so much for your rating!
Stauer James Madison Watch

Richard
Birdsboro, PA

Feb 09, 2026
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsFeb 18, 2026
Thank you for the rating and thank you for bidding with us!
4 Sterling Mens Fashion Rings

Suzanne
Minneapolis, MN

Feb 04, 2026
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsFeb 18, 2026
Thank you for your rating!!
Whitney Kelly Red Tigers Eye 925 Necklace

Rupert
Mcknight, PA

Feb 04, 2026
Simple auction process
First time bidding on Vintage Auctions. The process was transparent and it was easy to understand when the lot was coming up and how to bid.
Report
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsFeb 18, 2026
Thank you so much for bidding with us and leaving us a review!
Harley Davidson Signed Sterling Ring

marcos
Rialto, CA

Feb 01, 2026
(15) Cards Pokemon

Sarai
Fountain Valley, CA

Jan 31, 2026
AAA + Seller
Items as described. In-house shipping provided. Very happy with my purchase-overall an excellent experience. Thank you!
Report
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsFeb 18, 2026
Thank you so much! We are Happy that you had a good experience with us!
Two Sterling Moonstone Bracelets

Donna J
North Vernon, IN

Jan 30, 2026
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsFeb 24, 2026
While we appreciate your feedback, we could use more details so we can make this 5 stars in the future.
Zippo 500 Million June 5,2012 In Case

Dave
Dallas, TX

Jan 29, 2026
Honest seller that puts a premium on customer service-5 stars all the way *****
Great seller, fast shipping, honest and puts a premium on customer service and satisfaction! 5 stars all the way! I look forward to dealing with them again soon! Thanks!!!!!
Report
India 6" Machete

Travis
Dayton, OH

Jan 29, 2026
Two G.I. Joe: A Real American Hero!

Robert
Cathedral City, CA

Jan 27, 2026
(2) Pens & (2) Pencils

Paul
Lincoln, VT

Jan 23, 2026
Came fast and well packaged
Felt fine bidding with them and would happily bid again. The package came within a reasonable time and my item was well protected. It went smoothly and professionally.
Report
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
We greatly appreciate your 5 star review! See you next auction.
Taxco 925 Glass Art Bracelet

Mark
East Northport, NY

Jan 20, 2026
Review for Sterling Necklace set
I received the necklace set on-time and in great condition. It was well packed and protected. Thank you for the sale.
Report
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
Your feedback means so much! Thanks for your business!
Larimar Sterling Necklaces & Earrings

Julie
Mundelein, IL

Jan 08, 2026
Great items, excellent service, tremendous packaging.
Great items, excellent service, tremendous packaging.
Report
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
Thanks again for the 5 stars!
2001 Graffiti Peace Design Iron Stone Zippo Sealed

Julie
Mundelein, IL

Jan 08, 2026
Great items, excellent service, tremendous packaging.
Great items, excellent service, tremendous packaging.
Report
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
Your feedback means a lot! Thanks for your business!
(5)  Camel Lighters

Clarence
Wilmington, NC

Jan 06, 2026
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
Thank you for the 5 stars!
4 Vintage Character Watches

Keith
San Angelo, TX

Dec 31, 2025
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
We appreciate your 5 star review!
Vintage Sterling Marcasite Necklace & Ring

Danielle
Ooltewah, TN

Dec 30, 2025
Be weary
I won a couple comics on an auction, they were sneaky in their photos about laying one comic over the other. So when I got them at home multiple books were torn in half and incomplete. This could not be seen in the photos posted nor was it stated in the description for the lot. Once I reached out to address the issue, they would not respond.
Report
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 30, 2026
We apologize that you are not satisified with the items you won. This is the first we have heard of an issue with your items. Please contact our office and let's work something out. We value your business and would have worked something out with you had we known. Our office number is ********** or email **********
The Amazing Spider-Man Lot Of 4

Richard
Chelan, WA

Dec 30, 2025
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
Thanks so much for the 5 stars.
Scientific Buckeye Jr. Cabin Cruiser Model Kit

Steve
Manteca, CA

Dec 30, 2025
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
Thanks for your review! Let us know what we can do to get all 5 stars in the future.
Litho Tin Fire Engine Friction Powered

Greg
Ravenna, OH

Dec 25, 2025
Easy
Simple to deal with
Report
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
Thanks for taking time to leave us a great review! Hope to see you bid again!
Assorted Pocket Knives Lot

John
Gardendale, TX

Dec 25, 2025
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
We appreciate the 5 stars!
Beautify Texas Zippo Lighter 2012 Sealed

Russ
East Stroudsburg, PA

Dec 25, 2025
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
Thanks for leaving a 5 star review!
Fired- 2004 Harley Davidson Zippo

Russ
East Stroudsburg, PA

Dec 25, 2025
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
Thanks for the 5 stars!
Harley-Davidson Genuine Zippo Lighter Tin

James
Austin, TX

Dec 20, 2025
Excellent item … better than the pictures
Great service and handling.
Report
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
Your feedback means a lot to us! We appreciate you and your business!
Buck 110 Lockback With Sheath & Box

Charles
Orlando, FL

Dec 15, 2025
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
Thanks for your 5 star review!
Late 1800s Pocket Watch

Nirun
Portland, OR

Dec 14, 2025
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
We appreciate your 5 stars!
ULTRA BLADE RICHARTZ LOCK BACK KNIFE

William
Dothan, AL

Dec 11, 2025
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
Thanks for the 5 stars!
Martin 5-18

Chris
Cincinnati, OH

Dec 11, 2025
Easy to communicate with
Bought a lovely vintage amplifier from Vintage Auctions, they were quick to respond to any questions I had. Only complaint I can really think of is the shipping was a little slower than I expected, however, I used to work for a large auction house so I can understand the post auction craziness that may have contributed to slowing that process down. Overall, I would definitely recommend bidding on an item from Vintage Auctions and asking as many questions as needed. They were professional and punctual with their communication.
Report
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsJan 26, 2026
We appreciate your business and your feedback. Bid with us again!
1966 Fender BF Vibro Champ Amp

Bruce
West Haven, CT

Dec 07, 2025
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsDec 11, 2025
thank you for rating!
WWI German Samson Werk Bayonet

Richard
Indianapolis, IN

Dec 05, 2025
Easy
Quick shipping. Accurate description. 100 % satisfied.
Report
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsDec 11, 2025
Thank you for your review and rating!
Trollbead Sterling Necklace

Matthew
Escalon, CA

Nov 21, 2025
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsDec 11, 2025
Thank you for your rating!
Kenny Easley Signed Mini Helmet COA

Richard
Oxnard, CA

Nov 19, 2025
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsDec 11, 2025
Thank you for your rating!
Sterling Cross Necklace

Joe
Athens, TN

Nov 19, 2025
Item was as described
Reasonable shipping price and received fairly quick. Item was as described
Report
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsDec 11, 2025
Thank you for bidding with us and leaving us a review!
January 4th 1863 Three Dollars

Edmundas
Westmont, IL

Nov 19, 2025
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsDec 11, 2025
Thank you for your rating and bidding with us!
Three 23kt Gold Cards

Richard
Birdsboro, PA

Nov 13, 2025
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsDec 11, 2025
Thank you for bidding with us!
Batman Gateway To Death!

Moises
Porter Ranch, CA

Nov 11, 2025
Five Star Auction House
I’ve used them for at least Three Years. They’re the Absolute Beat from A-Z
Report
Vintage Auctions logo
Vintage AuctionsDec 11, 2025
Thank you so much for your review and rating!
15 Vintage Women's Stretch Band Watches