Bidder Reviews for ATTIC TO AUCTION, LLC (119)
4.6 out of 5.0 Stars
1-50 of 119 Reviews
JacquelineReading, PA
Feb 01, 2026
Great to Deal with
From how the site is set up, the auction run, the notification and to picking up the item I won, everything was Great.

Dee AnneCave Junction, OR
Jan 05, 2026
Very quick to ship and very reasonable shipping cost!
I have dealt with many different auction houses on live auctioneers, this auction house the best. Shipped out very quickly and one of the most reasonable shipping cost!

JacquelineReading, PA
Jan 04, 2026
Great to work with
Very easy transactions and pick up. Staff was friendly and helpful with pick up times and they have a convenient store location.

KristenReading, PA
Dec 07, 2025
Reliable Auction House
This was my first purchase from Attic to Auction. They were friendly, helpful & professional-I have bookmarked them and will return for future auctions.
MaryReading, PA
Oct 30, 2025
FABULOUS SELECTION OF ITEMS
I love bidding on items in Attic To Auctions sales. They have a wonderful selection of items every auction. The process is fun. And, the team there is amazing! They're very friendly, kind, and knowledgeable. It's a joy to see them when I pick up my items.

MaryReading, PA
Oct 30, 2025
Wonderful company to work with
Mary and her staff are absolutely delightful to work with. They were very accommodating with my pick up needs. They are so friendly and kind.

JoBabbitt, MN
Oct 30, 2025
Excellent Customer Service
Mary was fantastic to work with. I am out of state and needed much more cost effective shipping than what was being displayed on the LA website estimate. Mary helped me get the items packaged and shipped off very cost effectively. I will visit their auctions again!

AndreReinholds, PA
Oct 28, 2025

SCOTTReading, PA
Oct 26, 2025
Accurately described items
Accurate description, good photos and easy pick up are important to me. Well done!

JacquelineReading, PA
Oct 26, 2025
Easy transaction.
So easy and friendly staff to work with. Easy place to pick up items. Smooth transaction.

TimFort Collins, CO
Oct 23, 2025
Intriguing miniatures, a great find
The auction House gave me a great product and it was shipped so as to arrive-not the greatest packaging-but the lot got here-so.

MatthewEscalon, CA
Oct 23, 2025

LisaDeforest, WI
Aug 31, 2025

StanRensselaer, NY
Aug 17, 2025

ChrisRoanoke, TX
Aug 17, 2025

SCOTTReading, PA
Aug 17, 2025

TimFort Collins, CO
Aug 14, 2025
An interesting mantel clock. functioning might be an issue. display only.
this item has safely arrived. It was well packaged. Now the truth-will it run???????? that will have to wait to determine.

AaronNazareth, PA
Aug 11, 2025
Very professional service
Mary was absolutely wonderful to work with; very prompt in her responses, and very helpful with setting up local shipping. The item was received exactly as it was pictured. Could not have asked for a better experience!

MaxDurham, NH
Jul 21, 2025

WalterOaks, PA
Jul 21, 2025

LindsayPottstown, PA
Jul 21, 2025
Great Auction house
I've bought several times, lovely people running this auction house. Very happy with all purchases.

SuzanneNew Castle, PA
Jul 20, 2025
Shipping a Hassle and Expensive
I buy a lot of things at auction and I know shipping costs are high, but Live Auctioneers shipping wanted $53 to ship 10 small pairs of earrings! So, I went with the UPS Store recommended by the auction house. It took several emails and phone calls to even get a quote and then it was about $35 to ship them. Seriously? 10 small pairs of pierced earrings that fit in a 2 x 3 inch box? I'll be bidding elsewhere, where the auction house provides shipping in house and doesn't over charge.

NancyStrasburg, VA
Jul 14, 2025

CarolynOlathe, KS
Jul 14, 2025

MarcGranada Hills, CA
Jun 09, 2025

LorraineHollywood, FL
Jun 08, 2025
Frustrating experience
Customer service was extremely frustrating. I waited for call-backs several times and they were promised but didn't come. It took way too long to get in touch to get my invoice finally paid over the phone, and then the headache of shipping began. Due to poor customer service and hassles with finding a company to finally ship, I don't recommend and won't do business again. My boxes arrived finally yesterday with two broken items, so the nightmare isn't over.

ATTIC TO AUCTION, LLCJun 08, 2025
We accommodated this buyer when she was restricted from paying on the platform by Live Auctioneers. The delay was due to payment issues not our service. Additionally, we sent her items immediately to a local shipper for packaging. I believe this behavior by her may have been why she was restricted in the first place? Lesson learned by us to avoid risky bidders like this. For this reason she will likely be restricted on the platform.

StewartSaco, ME
Jun 08, 2025

MaryReading, PA
Apr 15, 2025
So happy with my experience
The items were all as described. I couldn't be happier. The staff was so helpful and friendly at pick up. The items are beautiful. I will be participating in all of their auctions! I'm recommending Attic to Auction to all of my family and friends.

JoanDelray Beach, FL
Mar 23, 2025

PatriciaMarblehead, MA
Mar 18, 2025

MiriamReading, PA
Mar 17, 2025

ClaudiaCambria, CA
Mar 17, 2025
Lovely merchandise handled with care.
I purchased four fragile items, all in their original boxes from the manufacturer. The items arrived to me in excellent condition, just as shown in the photos. The packing process was very well done. I couldn’t have asked for a better result.

MaryReading, PA
Mar 16, 2025
GREAT Auction Company! Friendly & Professional!
I just love buying from Attic to Auction's online Auctions. They have a great selection, descriptions are accurate and most importantly: the owner, Mary, and her staff are just delightful. They're helpful, friendly and very professional. It's always a pleasure to pick up my items and chat with the ladies:)

MelindaCarson, CA
Mar 10, 2025
Beautiful Lladro
These are beautiful Lladro figures, accurately described. Packed very safely and shipped quickly.

catherineWest Fork, AR
Mar 10, 2025
great experience
Their shipping and wrapping employees damaged1 item, hard to fill a report out to them.

MaryReading, PA
Mar 04, 2025
Great Coin Auction
I was thrilled to find such an amazing collection of coins. They were described well, excellent detailed photos. Most of all, the customer service was amazing. Very prompt, professional and friendly dealings with the owner and her staff. Everyone was so helpful.

catherinePittsford, NY
Feb 17, 2025

AlbertManhasset, NY
Feb 16, 2025
Trouble free transaction.
Personnel were professional, friendly and helpful in making it a pleasant transaction.

MaryReading, PA
Jan 22, 2025
Great auctions!
Their auctions offer a wonderful variety of items, often themed so you can find a lot of items in one auctions. The auctions are fun and the Christmas items I won are perfect and even nicer in person!

CatherinePottstown, PA
Jan 12, 2025
GREAT Auction House!
I have purchased from Attic to Auction several times and are never disappointed! The owner, Mary, is professional, courteous, kind and always available to answer any questions. She is extremely knowledgeable with any and all items on the bid whether they are antiques or collectables. The auctions are diverse, and you never know what you will find. Her photos are spot on, and the descriptions are very informative and well researched. Never just a one liner description which sets this auction house apart from others. She goes above and beyond to let you know exactly what you are getting. I highly recommend Attic to Auction and will continue to bid!

LisaBrookhaven, GA
Dec 29, 2024
The BEST!
Per usual, these items were even better in person! From the inventory to the bidding to the seamless, to the professional shipping service-Attic to Auctions is by far one of my all time favorite auction houses!

SheilaBlue Island, IL
Dec 28, 2024
Shipping Cost Prohibitive
I won a small piece of jewelry in this auction. Attic to, Auction was great to work with. However, the shipping company they use charged $45.00 to send me my small piece of jewelry. I have had many items shipped to me from other auctions and have never paid that much. I will not be returning.

FrederickSaint Joseph, MI
Dec 24, 2024
Recommended
Auction house operation and instructions are clear and concise. Bidding experience is perfect. Communications and coordination with shipper were so-so. Understandable due to Christmas rush. Packaging a little risky, though everything arrived intact.

MaryReading, PA
Dec 04, 2024
So many unique finds
I love participating in their auctions. Great items. Always accurately described. I can’t wait until the next auction!

MaryReading, PA
Dec 04, 2024
Beautiful items
They always have a great selection and amazing descriptions with photos making bidding a breeze. Very honest auction company.

MaryReading, PA
Dec 04, 2024

TimFort Collins, CO
Dec 04, 2024

TOP


