Reviews
Bidder Reviews for McCreary Auctions LLC (93)
TOP RATED4.5 out of 5.0 Stars
Accurate Descriptions
Quick Responses
Easy Payments
Seamless Shipping
1-50 of 93 Reviews
DanielEl Prado, NM
Jul 19, 2026
JohnMemphis, TN
Jul 19, 2026
RalphNewport Beach, CA
Jul 19, 2026
LarrySan Diego, CA
Jul 19, 2026
MichaelCape Girardeau, MO
Feb 21, 2026
TscharnerBoca Grande, FL
Feb 21, 2026
StephenLancaster, PA
Feb 11, 2026
TheodoraWheeling, WV
Oct 17, 2025
ChrisRoseville, OH
Sep 28, 2025
Great Auction House
Items arrived in great condition! Just as described! Packaged extremely well! Shipped extremely quick! Excellent experience! Definitely would like to attend another auction, very fair Auction House! Great Transaction! THANK YOU SO MUCH! CHRIS
MichaelCape Girardeau, MO
Sep 20, 2025
CharlesSaint Augustine, FL
Jun 18, 2025
Poorest communication of any Seller I've bought from.
1. Poorest communication of any Auction I've bought from (and I buy $100, 000's from every major Auction House with Accounts at Bonhams, Sothebys, Heritage, Freeman-Hindman, etc). As of yesterday, 4 months post auction McCreary refuses to tell me which UPS Store my item is at. Instead I received a rude reply. 2. McCreary only offers 1 shipping option with UPS Store (the most expensive, bar none). 3. McCreary immediately (next day) transfers items to the UPS Store not allowing customer pick-up. 4. In many years of buying on Live Auctioneers I will never buy from McCreary again. 5. If you are going to buy, get your UPS Store shipping quote before you bid. 6. I 'm filing a formal Complaint with Live Auctioneers and VISA.
DawnellSaratoga, CA
Mar 12, 2025
Weller Pots
Exactly as described. One of the pieces was actually better than I thought it would be.
DoraTwin Lakes, WI
Mar 8, 2025
NanetteSomerset, NJ
Mar 2, 2025
A + Seller
Easy transactions, quick delivery, well packed with tracking. Yes, I would buy from McCreary Auctions LLC again!
GloriaCharleston, SC
Mar 1, 2025
RachelGreat Barrington, MA
Jan 13, 2025
Don't Bother
Descriptions and condition not accurate. Owner thought it was funny that my items arrived broken and never followed up. Shipping company was the worst I have ever dealt with. Expensive and sloppy. Packed like they don't give a hoot about the contents.
StanSan Francisco, CA
Dec 11, 2024
Very responsible auction house
McCreary House has demonstrated ability to overcome obstacles and resolve external shipping issues, promptly responded to my inquiries.
SusanKennett Square, PA
Nov 23, 2024
MichaelCape Girardeau, MO
Nov 23, 2024
AliciaEnid, OK
Nov 23, 2024
NancySavannah, TN
Nov 23, 2024
MichaelDowagiac, MI
Nov 19, 2024
Splendid Example of Fulper in Mint Condition
Splendid example of Fulper in mint condition, packed very well and shipped instantly by polite, accommodating, communicative sellers! I simply could not be happier with the transaction, and I am SO pleased to add this rare Effigy Bowl to my small but carefully assembled collection of Fulper Pottery. I highly recommend McCreary's Auction, without any hesitation at all. They are honest and kind, and they offer beautiful American Art Pottery! THANK YOU SO MUCH! Michael
KeithBen Lomond, CA
Aug 5, 2024
DeniseSaint Louis, MO
Jul 22, 2024
Excellent customer service
McCreary Auctions were very accommodating for pickup. Extremely helpful with securing items and helping pack my items.
kerryTroy, MI
Jul 21, 2024
Accurate Description and Fast, Easy Service
Seems to know quite a bit about art pottery and other collectibles. Acurately described pieces and uses same terminology collectors use.
JamesNashville, TN
Jul 21, 2024
JoanTigard, OR
Jul 21, 2024
SallyExeter, NH
Jul 21, 2024
Great Customer Service
They contacted me immediately about shipping the item and it arrived quickly.
SharonTerre Haute, IN
Jul 21, 2024
Very nice experience
People were very nice. Auction experience was smooth. Was personally contacted about shipping. Packing was excellent.
WalterChicago, IL
Jul 20, 2024
MichaelNew Albany, OH
May 13, 2024
BillMeadville, PA
May 12, 2024
DavidHo Ho Kus, NJ
May 11, 2024
DIANNAGreendale, IN
May 11, 2024
It may take a couple weeks to get your merchandise.
It may take a week or so to get your merchandise. Hang in there.
SusanKennett Square, PA
May 11, 2024
SALOFF ENTERPRISESEdinboro, PA
May 11, 2024
Prompted communication, item as described, recommended Live Auctioneer partner & much appreciated
Prompted communication, item as described, recommended Live Auctioneer partner & much appreciated, smooth transaction
ChristopherChurch Hill, TN
May 11, 2024
Fast shipment, well packaged, exactly as pictured
Fast shipment, well packaged. Exactly as pictured and no funny light tricks to make them look better than they are. Pleased with my winnings and the after-auction service provided. Top notch group to work with.
KristySan Diego, CA
Apr 5, 2024
GeraldLincoln, IL
Feb 7, 2024
your shipping is a disaster
bad shipping
McCreary Auctions LLC
Apr 4, 2024
so please let me know what happened so I can attempt to resolve. Greg McCreary
JohnKansas City, MO
Feb 5, 2024
JeffreyCoshocton, OH
Feb 4, 2024
Shipping Instructions difficult to find
Invoice was immediate but it did not include Shipping instructions. We contacted them by email, and they did not respond. In the middle of all the legal information we found a phone number for the UPS store in the small town. They are the only shipping facility in the area, and it will take 3 to 5 days for your items to be shipped. It would have been helpful to have known that the Auction House was going to take our items to the UPS store and that the UPS store would contact us when our items were ready to ship. Instead, the UPS store had hundreds of people contacting them and as they were friendly, we could tell they were a bit frustrated. We just needed to be told; if you are not contacted by the 3rd business day, please contact the UPS store. The items were packaged wonderfully and arrived safely.
ChrisPittsburgh, PA
Jan 23, 2024
UPS 5134 did a great job packing and shipping my item
UPS 5134 did a great job packing and shipping my item. Would definitely use them again.
KristySan Diego, CA
Oct 23, 2023
RichardLakewood, OH
Sep 30, 2023
Great transaction
First-time buyer from this auction house, and everything was very smooth. Good response to questions, smooth processing/shipping through their required shipper.
DanielManheim, PA
Sep 30, 2023
I LOVE MCCREARY THE MOST ITS THE BEST!!!!
This is the very best Auction House, I don’t know why anyone buys retail from overpriced sites, or Bidding wars sites that are like a carnival, McCreary has a Heart of Gold and gets the best pieces, this isn’t the stuffy auction house that You may be used to, the fees are fair and fear not for shipping, He is the best of the best of the best at Connecting you with their preferred shipping company, also, The communication Here is second to none, I absolutely Love this place and would prefer to exclusively buy Here than any other site or seller, I am so thrilled it asked me to leave a feedback rating because they deserve the very same Best From their customers that they give them with their unbiased review, I seriously can’t even begin to tell You how honestly the pieces are listed, how Helpful they are, how spectacular the owner is, and I’ve even bought a six thousand dollar piece Here once and That was my first purchase with them and have to tell You I was nervous spending that kind of money, And it was every big as good as this experience, so, weather you’re spending $225 on a plate or $6k on a vase, they treat you the same, and they treat their customers like Gold, I really hope they stay in business for a very long time!!!!-Dan in Pennsylvania
TOP