Bidder Reviews for Icon Fine Arts (53)
4.5 out of 5.0 Stars
1-50 of 53 Reviews
RobertaWynnewood, PA
Jan 23, 2026

TodWashington, DC
Dec 11, 2025

JasonDurham, CT
Aug 10, 2025

JasonDurham, CT
Aug 10, 2025

TodWashington, DC
Aug 06, 2025

TonyJersey City, NJ
Apr 16, 2025

TomReno, NV
Mar 16, 2025

RachelCambridge, MA
Feb 05, 2025

RachelCambridge, MA
Feb 05, 2025
Excellent Transaction
Item was well packed, and arrived in a timely manner. The flag is even more impressive in person. Thanks!

TodWashington, DC
Feb 04, 2025

DennisAllegan, MI
Jan 30, 2025
Authentication and Shipping Cost
It's to be determined if the signature is authentic and shipping cost was outrageous being it was Media male.

Icon Fine ArtsJan 30, 2025
We do not ship "media mail" because we have to insure for the value. You were charged a whopping 30 dollars for boxing, shipping, insurance. You are not going to believe this but all of those things and labor cost money. Probably best if you skip our auctions going forward. Your total was one tenth the price of the value of the object.

RickTacoma, WA
Dec 31, 2024

WilliamStaten Island, NY
Nov 04, 2024
Failed to send a Paid Item
I won an auction item from Icon Fine Arts ("the auction house") way back in September of 2024 (almost 7 months ago). I was quickly sent an invoice which included extra costs-PLUS shipping. I paid the invoice in FULL. I was then informed by the auction house that they do NOT have the item. They did not know what happened to it ???). I expressed my disapproval to the auction house. However, seeing I had no choice, I requested a refund of $193.87. TO DATE, I have received NOTHING AT ALL from the auction house-neither the item nor the refund. The auction house was not happy with my review. Too bad. I am not happy with its service. I was told to try PayPal or Zelle for a refund. I do not use them. I have been hacked using both for several thousand dollars. All the auction house has to do is send me a check. My name, address, etc., has been supplied multiple times. Since September of 2024, I have won multiple auction items from all over the world (Spain, Italy, Scotland, England, and even war-torn Ukraine), including the USA. Not one of them had a problem mailing me my won item. Their service was great! I will not go away. I will now write a review update every month until I receive my refund.

Icon Fine ArtsNov 04, 2024
I immediately offered to refund your money as soon we determined that we made a mistake. You refused. I offered you discounts on any other item and full credit. You refused. You immediately began to call us liars and adopt a threatening tone. I hope this is a lesson for you. Threats and bullying accomplish nothing. In the end you will get you exactly what was offered in the first place. We love our buyers but that being said we hope to never ever hear from you again. Please note that you are our only bad review in four years of business with hundreds of transactions. Goodluck and goodbye.

TaraCambridge, MA
Oct 23, 2024

Josh Santa Monica, CA
Sep 08, 2024
Excellent Auction House!
Wow. A really smooth, easy process with fast, careful shipping. Very satisfied and I hope to bid with them again!

Joe-live-auctionsLongmont, CO
Mar 06, 2024
Fantastic Experience
Icon is meticulous in their identification, description, packaging, shipping, and communication. I can not imagine a better LiveAuctioneers experience. I can bid with this house with 100 % confidence, and that's a good feeling. Thanks, Icon Fine Arts!

LindseyPalm Springs, CA
Dec 12, 2023

DarrenWoodbridge, VA
Aug 20, 2023

CatalinaLondon, GB
Aug 13, 2023
they were so helpful!
So very helpful which made the shipping super easy for me.

Icon Fine ArtsAug 13, 2023
Thanks! You are very easy to work with. Enjoy your art!

MatthewStudio City, CA
Jul 04, 2023
Knowledgable and Responsive
What initially drew me to Icon fine Arts was they were auctioning items I had not seen elsewhere. Each inquiry I made was answered quickly and helped make me a more knowledgable bidder. When I made a mistake, Chad and the people at Icon made seamless adjustments to help me. Icon appreciates their bidders, even if they're newbies like me. I now look ahead to their next auctions to find more unique items which will brighten my home.

Icon Fine ArtsJul 04, 2023
Thanks for the kind words! We do our best. You have purchased some great items. Thanks!

CurtisFayetteville, NC
May 10, 2023

MarkCherry Hill, NJ
Apr 10, 2023

larrySan Diego, CA
Aug 23, 2022

IsaiahOmaha, NE
Jul 22, 2022

DanielBoston, MA
Jul 20, 2022

DavidHamilton, VA
May 11, 2022

IvicaNew York, NY
May 08, 2022

KrisMountain Top, PA
May 08, 2022
Item not signed by Bob Dylan
Seller said "Signed Bob Dylan Planet Waves LPis an album cover with LP signed by the named artist. This piece came from a private collector with unknown origination and authentication. This piece comes with the original certificate of authenticity from a closed established music and memorabilia dealer in Las Vegas." I purchased the item and after taking this item to JSA they said this signature was not signed by Bob Dylan. So after paying for the shipping, buyers premium and the signed album I am out $107.00 plus the 35.00 I paid to JSA for authentication service. If this seller has other items from the same collector I would highly recommend passing on the items. As far as the seller goes they were responsive to any questions I had about shipping.

Icon Fine ArtsMay 08, 2022
I have never heard of JSA? I have heard of PSA. The item in question was exactly what we said it was which is a signed Album cover from a memrobilia dealer that retired in Las Vegas. I think you should get a second opinion from a reputable authenticator. I reccomend PSA or Becket it is who does all the Pawn Stars authentication. As far as giving us a two star rating for selling an item exactly as described in an auction that was very clear about what it is that is on your karma. You might be interested to know I have received multiple thank you's from people who went to other authenticators with out a problem. We are not a retail store we sell estates and describe the items exactly as they are. Did they tell you how they knew? Did they see it in person? I bet not. Goodluck

PeterTucson, AZ
Feb 09, 2022

SoniaPhoenixville, PA
Jan 26, 2022

RyanPlano, TX
Dec 10, 2021

Dec 02, 2021

DanaNew York, NY
Nov 20, 2021
Great experience!
I loved what I bought and the whole experience was extremely positive. They shipped immediately, everything was packed well and answered all my questions. They responded immediately. I am 100 % ready to buy from Icon Fine Arts again. Thank you!!!!!

CIndian River Shores, FL
Nov 02, 2021

MarilynSanta Fe, NM
Oct 26, 2021

allanNashville, TN
Oct 08, 2021

PaulArlington Heights, IL
Oct 08, 2021

PetrPraha 6, CZ
Jun 30, 2021
Great seller
Everything was exactly as described, well packed with care, and expeditiously delivered. Simply, excellent and professional service.

DwainOntario, CA
Jun 12, 2021

MatthewAshland, OH
Jun 01, 2021

MatthewAshland, OH
Apr 28, 2021

JoeFort Lauderdale, FL
Apr 28, 2021
Beautiful Item
Very nice experience all the way through. Shipped fast and well packaged. Thank you

TOP







