Elliott Auctions, IN - Read over 135 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Elliott Auctions (135)

badge TOP RATED
4.6 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 135 Reviews

Scott
Lawndale, CA

Apr 08, 2025
Shipping was reasonable. Got my items safely. Very Happy!!!
Shipping was reasonable. Got my items safely. Very Happy!!!
Report
Lot Of Hasbro Star Wars Galactic Heroes

Jim
Arcadia, OH

Mar 15, 2025
Postwar American Flyer S Gauge 660 663 aluminum

William
Ballwin, MO

Mar 15, 2025
Modern American Flyer S Gauge 48407 Gilbert Chemicals

Grant
New Philadelphia, OH

Mar 15, 2025
Modern MTH Rail King MT-1106 SF 4-8-4 Blue Goose

Nathan
Quil Ceda Village, WA

Mar 15, 2025
Modern American Flyer S Gauge 9711 Southern Pacific box car in box

Nathan
Quil Ceda Village, WA

Mar 15, 2025
Modern American Flyer S Gauge 49048 NYC

Nathan
Quil Ceda Village, WA

Mar 15, 2025
Modern American Flyer S Gauge 48231 2003 TTOS Linde Gas in box

Bryan
Doylestown, PA

Feb 15, 2025
Great auction house
Have bought many items from them and every time I receive my item quickly and no issues
Report
Postwar American Flyer S Gauge 466 Comet PA diesel loco Chrome

Bob
Lebanon, CT

Nov 02, 2024
The shipping amount is ALWAYS ridiculously high.
I have no complaints regarding Elliott Auctions except there needs to be some way of letting the prospective bidder know how much the shipping charge will be prior to placing a bid. The shipping company they use (Shipping Saints) is ridiculously expensive, and even after getting a good deal on the auction, the shipping charge ruins whatever gains you might have gotten. And they don't do a very good packing job to boot! There is certainly ways to alert the bidder in advance of the possible shipping fees. approximate weight and size can five a good generality of the cost if someone can take the time to do it.
Report
Marx O Gauge steam locos tenders diesel locos handcars

Robert
Colesville, MD

Oct 31, 2024
Great people and VERY willing to help!
Great people and VERY willing to help!
Report
Eleven O Gauge Maxi Atlas box cars and reefers 2-Rail

Chris
Kissimmee, FL

Oct 05, 2024
Let’s do it again
It was great deal: auction. My 4th and great as always
Report
O27 track crossover bumpers RCS controller Marx Lionel

Bob
Mancelona, MI

Oct 05, 2024
Fifteen Unboxed Matchbox Road Champs Kinsmart Maisto and More Die Cast Cars

Gabriel
Miamisburg, OH

Oct 03, 2024
Hibben Knives Single Shadow Dagger United Cutlery with Sheath

Norman
Mc Cormick, SC

Sep 21, 2024
GEM? 0-6-0 brass 2-Rail O scale switcher parts

Chris
Kissimmee, FL

Aug 18, 2024
Sixteen Prewar/Postwar UCS Remote Control Track  Sets w/controllers

Stephen
Pasadena, CA

Aug 07, 2024
Great experience
Overall, this was a great experience with Elliott Auction house. I like the fact that their commission is only 15 % compared to other auction houses which are as high as double that very efficient in the entire process.
Report
Prewar Lionel Standard Gauge 309 Pullman State brown

Guy
Chicago, IL

Aug 03, 2024
It's GREAT
Thank you for a great train. Your service has been great. Reasonable and quick in-house shipping. I'll be back!!!
Report
Prewar Lionel Std Ga 332 Baggage car in original box

Hank
Lemont, IL

Jun 23, 2024
.
The shipping and handling is considerably higher other auction houses
Report
Bachmann Plasticville O/S kits new unbuilt in box two 500 four 0550

Bill
Yalaha, FL

Jun 15, 2024
Modern Era Lionel O Gauge 18583 AEC 57 switcher in shipper

Kelly
Davisburg, MI

May 18, 2024
Postwar Lionel O Gauge 350 6446-11 6446-12 356 parts

David
Tucson, AZ

May 07, 2024
Hot wheels
Easy and fast transaction, great descriptions, packed well. No worries 👍
Report
Lot Of Fourteen Johnny Lightning Matchbox Hot Wheels And More

Teddy
Pontiac, IL

May 01, 2024
Hallmark Keepsake Ornaments Lot of 3 Arctic Friends Jolly Glass Snowman and More

Apr 20, 2024
They are reliable and willing to work with you
They are reliable and willing to work with you
Report
Modern Lionel O Gauge 18513 New York Central GP-7 in box

Arthur
Oklahoma City, OK

Apr 11, 2024
Monarch Devore Scale-Craft O Scale couplers Model Die Casting marker lamps

Arthur
Oklahoma City, OK

Apr 11, 2024
Prewar O scale 2 and 3 rail freight cars kit built brass wood

Lynne
Woodland Park, CO

Mar 09, 2024
Perfect 5 Star Seller
Perfect 5 Star Seller
Report
Postwar Lionel Electronics-Lab Mark IV No. 3203 w/parts

J
Hampstead, MD

Mar 08, 2024
100 % there
All Items very nice
Report
O/S Gauge Plasticville BY-4 DH-2 BN-1 1908-198 in boxes

J
Hampstead, MD

Mar 08, 2024
Rail King NKP Madison 30-6244-1 -2 -3 -4

Wayne
Ogden, UT

Mar 05, 2024
As shown in Listing-
Received these relief valve steam engine weights. They were shipped quickly and were received in good condition. Packaged well. Please with this transaction.
Report
Wilesco steam engine safety valve weights D16 and others

Stephen
Pasadena, CA

Feb 27, 2024
Various railroad Signals
This was described as O Gauge and standard gauge railroad signs. After receiving the package, it looked like they’re primarily O Gauge signs. Very reasonable price for the auction and dachshund went very smooth from start to finish.
Report
Prewar Lionel Ives Standard/O Gauge accessories

Bob
Jacksonville, FL

Feb 19, 2024
Great items
Good all around auction.
Report
Lionel O Gauge containers cable reels logs loads

Eric
New York, NY

Feb 18, 2024
No muss, no fuss, good item
Nothing really to report, because the auction house did their job smoothly and with no problems. Quite simply, I'm pleased and happy.
Report
Postwar Lionel O Gauge 2423 Hillside Obs in box

john
Fargo, ND

Feb 17, 2024
Great customer relations.
Very easy to work with
Report
Postwar Lionel O Gauge 56 MStL Mine Transport

Mike
North Tonawanda, NY

Feb 17, 2024
Hassle free
Have won multiple lots with Elliott Auctions and have never been disappointed. Buyers premium, shipping costs, and packing have all been reasonable and top notch.
Report
Ten Pittman motors two Mabuchi motors

Peter
Dundas, AU

Dec 30, 2023
MTH Rail King 30-1130 Union Pacific aux tender

Mike
Winnetka, IL

Dec 30, 2023
Easy to deal with
Fast shipping and very good communication
Report
Modern Era Lionel O Gauge 16706 17603 17231 in box

Louis
Starrucca, PA

Dec 30, 2023
A fine auction house
I would happily bid with them again.
Report
Prewar American Flyer O Gauge switch 4180 controller uncoupler

Bob
Munster, IN

Dec 30, 2023
Three Bachmann HO Gauge M*A*S*H cardstock diorama buildings NOS

Bradley
Topeka, KS

Dec 03, 2023
Carefully packed, as described
I have purchased from this auction house a couple of times and both times things have been exactly as described and arrived in great shape. Good packing.
Report
HO/O/S/N Gauge huge lot of rivets sorted numbered

Kenneth
Bruce, MI

Dec 02, 2023
Two Postwar Lionel O Gauge 1666T-4 clear tender shells curiosity

Tom
Roanoke, VA

Dec 02, 2023
Easy auction purchase
Items were safely and properly packed. Prompt shipping
Report
HUGE lot Bennett Kramer Lionel decals dry rubs Rail Chief 700E

LC
Apple Valley, CA

Nov 25, 2023
They were able to resolve my problem.
Helpful
Report
Postwar Lionel O 027 Super O Gauge insulating pins adapters

Edgar
Wellsburg, WV

Nov 25, 2023
Three HO Gauge Mantua General  2-4-0 steam locos

Nov 16, 2023
Florence Giuseppe Armani Hawk Statue

John
Milwaukee, WI

Nov 09, 2023
Took 10 days to get a shipping quote.
They took 10 days to get me a shipping quote and then hounded me for payment of shipping. My items were paid for the same day.
Report
Elliott AuctionsNov 09, 2023
We apologize it took so long to get you into shipping and generate you an invoice, we have a full time staff of 1 and a part time staff of 1. Our email payment reminders are automated, we don't hound our customers. Thank you and we apologize for the inconveniences. Elliott Auctions
Walthers Pacific Fast Mail Kemtron Model Power others constant lighting

frank
Bayonne, NJ

Nov 05, 2023
Most important was to get my first transaction between me an Elliott completed.
Thank you Elliott.
Report
HO Scale Hobbyline Erie diesel train 4 A units 3 passenger

Matthew
Myrtle Beach, SC

Nov 04, 2023
One hundred eleven M.V. Products Headlight & Marker Lenses NEW

Ken
Williston Park, NY

Nov 04, 2023
Four HO Gauge American Model Toy aluminum passenger cars unfinished

David
Hastings, FL

Nov 04, 2023
Great Auction House
These are great people that I have done business with before and will again.
Report
HO Scale Atlas 8240 Louisville and Nashville GP-7 diesel locomotive unit road number 401, unrun in

John
North Ridgeville, OH

Oct 08, 2023
ACCURATE
Good people
Report