ACME Auctions LLC , NY - Read over 60 Reviews from Customers
LiveAuctioneers Logo
Reviews

Bidder Reviews for ACME Auctions LLC (60)

badge TOP RATED
4.6 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy

Accurate Descriptions

trophy

Quick Responses

trophy

Easy Payments

trophy

Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 60 Reviews

CliffordMattituck, NY

Jul 8, 2026
George Washington Holding American Flag with Cherries, 1908 Patriotic Illustrated Postcard.

AdrianaSan Antonio, TX

Jun 21, 2026
Color Lithograph postcard depicting the 1906 San Francisco Earthquake's Church of the Advent Ruins.

TERESANixon, NV

Jun 21, 2026
Historic Pyramid Lake, Nevada, landscape postcard featuring unique volcanic formations

RobertDixon, IL

Jun 13, 2026
Early chromolithograph postcard of a tabby kitten in a wicker basket with holly, Brewsters, N.Y.,

CliffordMattituck, NY

Jun 9, 2026
Vintage Pierce Arrow Tour Bus, Los Angeles Auditorium Hotel, 1930s era postcard.

ZachareniaNea Smyrni, GR

Feb 19, 2026
Antique Postcard: Allegorical Woman as Greece with National Flag & Coat of Arms, circa 1900s

MarkArnprior, CA

Nov 23, 2025
The Amazing Spider-Man #312 Marvel Comics 1988 comic book featuring the Green Goblin vs Hobgoblin

ShelleyYorktown Heights, NY

Nov 14, 2025
Great cards! Great prices! Fast & pleassant service!
What wonderful cards! Described accurately + packaged carefully + shipped quickly = terrific experience with a great seller. I'll bid again.
Report
Postcard of the Egyptian Art, Music & Literature float from the 1909 Hudson-Fulton Celebration.

RobertDixon, IL

Nov 14, 2025
German postcard with Santa Claus and toys wishing 'Fröhliche Weihnachten', embossed border c. 1916

CliffordMattituck, NY

Oct 7, 2025
Linen Postcard showing the beautiful home of child movie star Shirley Temple in Los Angeles,

FredricStow, OH

Sep 29, 2025
Best Online Auction House
This is my fourth auction with Acme, and I love this house. Dave runs a great auction, has reasonably priced items, and logical/fair/fast shipping fees. I've been doing online auctions for 15 years. This is the best online auction house out there.
Report
Alaska Native Village Real Photo Postcard, Fur-Clad Figure and Tents, Schallerer’s Seward Shop

RobertDixon, IL

Sep 27, 2025
Greetings from California large letter linen postcard showing iconic state scenes, circa 1940s.

RobertDixon, IL

Sep 19, 2025
Raphael Tuck & Sons postcard New Year Greetings, woman in green fur-lined cape holding a lantern.

ShelleyYorktown Heights, NY

Sep 15, 2025
1906 Woonsocket Rubber Co. Advertising Postcard: Footwear of Nations Series, No. 8 Turkey

ShelleyYorktown Heights, NY

Sep 15, 2025
RPPC Real Photo Postcard showing street scene with storefronts in Manchester Depot, VT, circa 1910s.

ShelleyYorktown Heights, NY

Sep 15, 2025
1908 Advertising Postcard for Chi-Namel Varnish from J F Howe Hdw & Supply, Freedom, Pennsylvania.

CliffordMattituck, NY

Sep 14, 2025
Postcard showing the historic Jenny Wade House and Monument in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, circa 1930s

JohnLisle, IL

Sep 9, 2025
Excellent item, fast response to pirchase and delivery.
Historic item for a Presidential campaign.
Report
1908 W.J. Bryan & John W. Kern Presidential Campaign Postcard, Gilt Embossed Patriotic Design.

JeffBurlingame, CA

Aug 28, 2025
Great Auction Company
Super fast shipping and everything was well packaged. They offer in house shipping at a very reasonable cost. They are a great auction house to do business with and I highly recommend them! I will definitely buy from them in the future!
Report
Captain America Comics #25 Timely Comics 4/43 Human Torch story - Captain America drinks liquid

LeifWesthampton Beach, NY

Aug 27, 2025
Great seller!
Ver accommodating and great value!
Report
Sports Illustrated #v65 #24 CGC 7.5 Mike Tyson cover Time Inc. December 1, 1986 Subscription Edition

FredricStow, OH

Aug 25, 2025
WWI Armistice Day Ceremony RPPC Postcard, Large Crowd & Soldiers, Palmer, Massachusetts c. 1919

Shawn White Bear Lake, MN

Aug 25, 2025
1979 Milton Bradley Electronic Star Bird Space Transport Toy with Box, Parts & Instructions

DouglasNew Palestine, IN

Aug 23, 2025
Smooth transaction Thank Youp
No problems here
Report
c. 1903 Decoration Day Series Postcard Honoring Civil War Veterans with Union Soldier Equipment.

MikeSchwielowsee, DE

Aug 23, 2025
Topp!
Tolles Auktionshaus! Alles reibungslos geklappt und schneller Versand nach Deutschland
Report
1910 Eisendrath Postcard of Lincoln & Assassination Reward Poster, Postmarked Brooklyn, NY

RobertDixon, IL

Aug 15, 2025
Raphael Tuck "Independence Day" Series patriotic postcard of a boy in a sailor suit in a

RobertDixon, IL

Aug 5, 2025
U.S. America Patriotic Postcard: Woman, Flag, Goldenrod, Great Seal. Platinachrome Co. N.Y.

LindaLouisville, KY

Aug 4, 2025
Trustworthy and Responsible
Very pleased with this auction house!
Report
Main Street, Carson City, Nevada, with view of the Mint, early 20th century photo postcard.

DianeSouth Bend, IN

Jul 21, 2025
Entrance to Moanalua, Hawaiian Islands. Scenic Landscape Postcard. Honolulu Photo Supply Co.

MaryannePhiladelphia, PA

Jul 20, 2025
One of the Best
Items are always as described and shipped with care. I enjoy the number and variety of items for sale. It feels like a company that cares. Looking forward to the next auction.
Report
Early 20th C. Woman with Pink Pennant, "At The Game" by Reinthal & Newman, N.Y. postcard

Jul 20, 2025
Kit Carson, Pathfinder, Santa Fe Fiesta Postcard. Fred Harvey Series. Painting by G. Cassidy.

KenWilliston Park, NY

Jul 20, 2025
U.S. Battleship Connecticut, 1908 Enrique Muller Copyright, Colorized Naval Postcard

JoshShelbyville, TN

Jul 20, 2025
1908 Kansas Postcard: Comic Caricature of Man & Cigar Store Indian Woman, Tobacco Ad, "Love at first

JudithGainesville, FL

Jul 20, 2025
Japanese Illustration Postcard: Woman & Child, French Verse, "Mihon" Seal, Undivided Back Design

FredricStow, OH

Jul 20, 2025
Great Auction House!
This was my second auction with Acme. It is the best auction house I have dealt with online in 10 years. The item descriptions are thorough and accurate. The prices are very reasonable. And the shipping is swift and more than reasonably priced. It's light years better than the incredibly high prices that Liveauctioneers wants for shipping. I can't wait for the next auction.
Report
Paul's Golf Driving Range, Hot Springs National Park, Arkansas, "Play at Night" Postcard

RickyHagerstown, MD

Jul 20, 2025
Hagerstown, MD: Cumberland Valley and Norfolk and Western R.R. Station, tracks, c.1907-15 postcard.

DanMedford, NJ

Jul 8, 2025
All lots were very well described
I just wanted to say that the lots in the auction I attended were probably the best described of any internet auction I have ever participated in. Each single postcard was described to the smallest detail, even the one that were low value. I look forward to bidding in their next auction. Also, great communication from the auctioneer. And great postage (free over $50).
Report
West Side Main Street, Randolph, Iowa, ca. 1912 Looking Almost like Ghost Town, RPPC Postcard

CliffordMattituck, NY

Jul 6, 2025
Postcard: Black and White Photographic Portrait of Actor Gary Cooper, Smiling in Suit and Tie

BruceMounds View, MN

Jul 5, 2025
Great product and came quickly, securely.
Super great comics and an awesome auction house to buy from!!
Report
Lot of Assorted Comic Books as Shown, featuring Ultimate Spider-Man and Marvel Universe X Spidey

DonLeland, MS

Jun 16, 2025
ACME Auctions Did A Great Job!
ACME did a great job with the description of the item, processing of my payment, and prompt shipping.
Report
Antique Christmas Postcard: Santa Claus with Reindeer, Holly, and Toys; Addressed to Maine

JoshShelbyville, TN

Jun 15, 2025
German New Year Greeting Postcard: Three Cartoon Boys in Uniforms Smoking Cigars, Early 20th C.

HenryPalmetto Bay, FL

Jun 15, 2025
U.S.S. Macon Airship Moored at Mast, Akron, Ohio, Early 20th Century, Colorized Lithograph

KevinCollege Park, MD

Jun 15, 2025
Graf Zeppelin airship flying over Friedrichshafen, lakeside town view, early 20th century.

FredricStow, OH

Jun 15, 2025
Nice items, quick bidding, quick shipping
This was first time bidding with Acme. Enjoyed it. Bidding was smooth, prices were good, and shipping was quick and inexpensive. I'll be back.
Report
Omaha, Nebraska Tornado Aftermath: 22nd & Ohio Street, March 23, 1913. Olson Photo Co.

PaulPortland, OR

Jun 15, 2025
Hartford, Connecticut Flood Scene, 1936: Submerged Commercial Buildings and Rescue Boat

DianeSouth Bend, IN

Jun 12, 2025
Jessie Willcox Smith "Among The Poppies" Illustration, Three Children in Field, c. 1909-1910

RobertDixon, IL

Jun 9, 2025
Antique Greeting Postcard: Waving Teddy Bear Seated on Pedestal, "As Teddy B." Poem, 1907

CliffordMattituck, NY

Jun 3, 2025
Die eiserne Jungfrau, Nürnberg Royal Castle Pentagonal Tower, German Torture Device Exhibit

SueNorthridge, CA

Jun 2, 2025
Fabulous auction company with great service!
Was so happy to find this auction company! Enjoyed the experience. Learned a lot from the descriptions. Excellent quality of the items, (postcards) received. In-house shipping was quickly done. Deserves the 5 stars!
Report
Chevron Gas Station Scene: Woman with Late 1950s Car, Attendant, Service Ad Card Back

NicholasTroy, PA

May 18, 2025
Lot of Five 19th Century Tintypes Featuring Photos of Men and Women with One Outdoor Photo

RichardBurbank, CA

May 18, 2025
Marvel Masterworks Vol 17: Hardcover – Daredevil Nos. 1-11 (Stan Lee, Wally Wood)