CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC, MA - Read over 64 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC (64)

4.4 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Easy Payments

1-50 of 64 Reviews

Robert
Dixon, IL

Jan 28, 2026
Old Colorful Lucky 7 Pinball Game - Approx 19"x11"

Sarai
Fountain Valley, CA

Jan 23, 2026
AAA + seller, fast shipping
Great experience.
Report

American Pawn Company
North Fort Myers, FL

Jan 20, 2026
Item as described
Item as described, will purchase from in the future
Report

Victor
Antioch, CA

Jan 15, 2026
Lot of Pink Depression Glass - Candlesticks, Jar, Pitcher, Etc

Harry
Oldtown, ID

Jan 08, 2026
I haven't received myIve called them and got no response and I've texted them and got no response.
Very very poor customer service. I will not do business with them again. I guess I will have to go to my credit card and do a dispute. A big hassle for a couple comic books.
Report
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCJan 21, 2026
Unfortunately, this customer never paid for their items. So there is not much we can do. Never contacted us directly-only left a negative review.
Nine Vintage Marvel Comic Books - Western Gun Fighters No.11, Two-Gun Kid No.81, 86-88, and Rawhide

Violet
Huntingdon Valley, PA

Dec 28, 2025
Reasonable shipping. Nice to deal with
Nice to deal with. Shipping cost was cc reasonable.
Report
Three Goebel Hummels - 'Meditation/Girl with Basket and Letter', 'Sister', 'Village Boy'

Tricia
Spencer, IA

Dec 25, 2025
Accuracy of description
Very disappointed in purchase-says unsearched and clearly searched and picked thru jewlery! Should label it as scrap junk but live and learn.
Report
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCJan 21, 2026
We are sorry to hear of your disappointment. The two jewelry lots you purchased were both listed as 'unresearched' not unsearched. However, we did not search them-we consigned them just as the consigner wanted. If there are any questions prior to the auction we are more than happy to assist.
Assorted Smalls Including Coin Silver Nights of Pythias Pin/Medal - Military, Political, Ribbons,

Greg
North Myrtle Beach, SC

Dec 25, 2025
Great Auction House Will use again
Great Auction House Will use again
Report
Seven Vintage DC Aquaman Comic Books - No.30, 41, 44, 46, 47, 49, 50

Jack
Spring Grove, PA

Dec 22, 2025
Two U.S. Mint Silver Proof Sets - 2002 & 2003

Anthony
Monkton, MD

Dec 22, 2025
Not reliable description
Stated it was Josie and pussycat production cel. Misleading, Josie and Valorie where print copies. Melody's head was the only production cel. This wasn't a complete production cel as stated. Would not recommend this auction house. Have bought hundreds of auctions onliveauctioneers.com. This is the worst
Report
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCDec 22, 2025
Very sorry you were disappointed. If you had contacted us we would have been more than happy to work with you on a solution. However, picture # 4 clearly shows exactly what you described... we never said it was a 'complete' production cel. Again, we are sorry that you were disappointed.
Josie & The Pussycats Production Cel Vintage Hanna Barbara Animated Series

Nick
Falls Village, CT

Dec 16, 2025
Helpful
Great auctioneer! Every item I have won from them is hassle free, well described, and everything is handled well!
Report
Lot of Bottle Openers, Pocketknives, Tie Tacks, Casings, Etc.

Miriam
Studio City, CA

Dec 04, 2025
Easy to work with. Honest description. My favorite spongeware piece. Mint condition!
Easy to work with. Honest description. My favorite spongeware piece. Mint condition! Perfect packing.
Report

Michael
Plainwell, MI

Dec 04, 2025

Gregory
Santa Fe, NM

Nov 14, 2025
Great seller
Great seller
Report
Railroad Related Hat/Lapel Pins, Uniform Pins, Buttons, Etc. from Six Santa Fe Railroad

Michael
Rockfall, CT

Nov 13, 2025
Four Antique Hand-Painted Clay Marbles

Michael
Bangor, PA

Nov 13, 2025
1834 Capped Bust Silver Half Dollar

Douglas
Mesquite, TX

Nov 13, 2025
Forty-Four Vintage Playbills

Matthew
Escalon, CA

Nov 07, 2025
Framed Autographed 'The American Triple Crown 1937-1946' Horse Racing Winning Jockey Print by Fred

Grahame
Astoria, NY

Nov 06, 2025
Thank you
very pleasant experience
Report
Invicta Ceramics Men's Watch Model No. 0318 - Solid Ceramics and Tungsten with Swiss Parts

Martin
Summerville, SC

Oct 30, 2025
Antique American Waltham Coin Silver Fahys Pocket Watch with Fancy Floral Face - Approx 189 Grams -

Barbara
Long Beach, CA

Oct 28, 2025
Great item, packaged with care, shipped fast
Great item, packaged with care, shipped fast
Report
Vintage Beaded Shawl

Devin
Dillon, MT

Oct 21, 2025
Older Illinois Wadsworth Autocrat Pocket Watch Model #6197550 - Untested

David
Midlothian, TX

Oct 20, 2025
Beautiful Coins!!!
The coins I received are just beautiful! The coins arrived quickly, packed well with protective measures and care.-I'm very happy with this transaction!
Report
Graded 2003-Mo One Ounce .999 Fine Silver Mexico Libertad - First Strike - MS67 by NGC

Julie
Midland, TX

Sep 19, 2025
First time buyer
This was my first purchase from this auction house and I am extremely satisfied. Products are described thoroughly and had excellent photos. Shipping cost was excellent!
Report
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCSep 23, 2025
Thank you for the review... Hope to do business in the future!
Graded 1986 China Silver 5 Yuan - USA's 1st Trip to China - Empress of China - MS69 by NGC

Kyleen
Lincoln, RI

Sep 19, 2025
These lots should have been labeled as junk/craft
I won several jewelry lots from Catamount Auctioneers on LiveAuctioneers and was very disappointed with my purchase. Most of the jewelry was broken, missing stones, or mismatched, and many pieces were not even jewelry at all — just random junk items like buttons and toothpicks. These lots should have been clearly labeled as “craft” or “junk” jewelry. After reaching out, they refunded me $50, which was about what I had paid for shipping. While I appreciate the partial refund, it did not come close to making up for the misleading descriptions and poor quality of the items received. Overall, this was a frustrating experience, and I would not bid with this auction house again.
Report
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCSep 23, 2025
As we said before... we are sorry to hear of your dissatisfaction. The lots this customer purchased were large amounts of jewelry. Pictures were provided. The customer could have asked for more pictures or asked any questions about the items. On one of the lots they purchased they doubled our estimated value. We tried to work with them... even offered to have them return the items (at their expense) for a full refund but chose not to. The purchase date of these items were 5/22/25.
Assorted Costume Jewelry - Various Types, Materials, Conditions

STEPHEN
Panama City Beach, FL

Sep 18, 2025
Very professional!
Very professional. Highly recommended. I'm a return client.
Report
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCSep 23, 2025
Thanks! We appreciate your return business.
New Old Stock Ertl Ford New Holland Die Cast Tractors

bob
Palmer, MA

Sep 18, 2025
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCSep 23, 2025
Thank You!
Signed Adam Vinatieri NFL Super Bowl XXXVI Framed Poster - Approx 26"x23"

Marvin
Maple, CA

Sep 18, 2025
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCSep 23, 2025
Thank You!
1998 Toy Biz Marvel Comics 8" Captain America Action Figure - Famous Cover Series

Stephen
Hampton Bays, NY

Sep 18, 2025
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCSep 23, 2025
Thank You!
Automobile Books and Catalogues - Blue Book, Triumph, Jaguar, Etc

Tom
Geneseo, IL

Sep 04, 2025
Great Customer service.
Had a slight problem with shipping and they promptly took care of it.
Report
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCSep 23, 2025
Thank you for the review... Hope to do business in the future!
Like New Two Piece Cortland 7' Long Fishing Pole with Sleeve & Tube

Bruce
Mounds View, MN

Sep 04, 2025
Amazing comics, safe, secure, fast shipping
Everything was amazing with this transaction with my comics, and how quickly and secure they arrived. However, I wasn't notified when they shipped them nor got a tracking number. Nonetheless AWESOME over all and will most certainly will bid with them again!! Thank you!!
Report
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCSep 23, 2025
Thanks for the review. Sorry that we missed getting you the tracking number. We appreciate your business!
Twenty-Eight Total Chastity and Tomb Raider Comic Books

Kelli
Auburndale, FL

Aug 19, 2025
Excellent Items, Excellent Service
Excellent items, great prices, excellent customer service thank you
Report
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCSep 23, 2025
Thank you for the review... Hope to do business in the future!
Mattel Wonder Woman Collectible Barbie Doll in Original Box

Frank
Orlando, FL

Aug 14, 2025
Shipping
I think the cost of shipping is out of hand!! Everything else was great!!
Report
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCSep 23, 2025
Thanks for your business!
Five U.S. Commemorative Silver Dollars - 1986-S Statue of Liberty, 1987-S U.S. Constitution, 2004-P

Robert
Dixon, IL

Aug 05, 2025
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCSep 23, 2025
Thanks for your business!
Two Rare Christmas Santa Postcards - Santa in Brown Suit - Believe to be German

Nick
Falls Village, CT

Jul 27, 2025
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCAug 11, 2025
Thanks for your business!
Collectible Beer Related Bottle Openers and Corkscrews - Brewmania - Piels, Molson, Miller,

Paul
Hartsville, TN

Jul 18, 2025
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCAug 11, 2025
Thank you for the review... Hope to do business in the future!
Bianchi #X15 Holster - Size Large

david
Auburn, NY

Jul 17, 2025
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCAug 11, 2025
Thank you for the review... Hope to do business in the future!
Vintage Ghostbuster - Who You Gonna Call XL Jacket

Marcelo
Linden, NJ

Jul 04, 2025
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCAug 11, 2025
Thank you for the review... Hope to do business in the future!
WWII Silver Coin Set

Judy
Merced, CA

Jun 12, 2025
I enjoyed this auction
Items were well packed and shipped fairly quickly The quality of the Christmas postcards was good
Report
Antique Christmas Postcards - Children Themed

Robert
Dixon, IL

Jun 09, 2025
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCAug 11, 2025
Thanks Again Robert. Appreciate your business!
Early Sports Related Pins - Various Subject Sports

Richard
Birmingham, AL

Jun 06, 2025
Excellent auction house
First time working with Catamount, I'll be back. Excellent service!
Report
Antique and Older Door, Etc. Hardware - Knobs, Plates, Locks, Etc.

Robert
Dixon, IL

May 16, 2025
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCAug 11, 2025
Thanks Robert! You've been a great customer from the start.
Many Assorted 45 Vinyl Record Sleeves - Some with Records

Clifford
Mattituck, NY

May 11, 2025
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCAug 11, 2025
Thank you for the review... Hope to do business in the future!
Older Gypsy Witch Fortune Telling Playing Cards - Great Condition/Complete - U.S. Playing Card Co.

Jim
Prescott, AZ

Apr 12, 2025
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCMay 03, 2025
Thanks! Hope we can do business in the future!
Twelve Vintage Walt Disney Comic Books - 'Mickey Mouse' No. 219-222, 224, 225 & 'Donald Duck' No.

Abby
Ithaca, NY

Apr 10, 2025
Excellent experience with Catamount Auctions. I would bid again.
Excellent experience with Catamount Auctions. I would bid again. For some reason liveauctioneers will not allow customers to complete this survey unless they use 2K characters. So: xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Report
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCMay 03, 2025
Thanks Abby. We appreciate your positive review and your business!
Red and Butterscotch Bakelite Drink Stirrers

todd
Waterville, OH

Mar 31, 2025
A + + +
I bought comics from 5 different auction houses over a two week period and only one other auction house shipped the comics almost as good as this house. The other 3 damaged them by packing them wrong. You can trust catamount auctions to ship your comics properly. I look forward to future auctions from them.
Report
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - Reprinting the First Issue Comic Book

Gary
Princeton, CA

Mar 19, 2025
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCMay 03, 2025
Thanks!
Eagle Binder of U.S. Mint Uncirculated Coin Sets - 2007 (P & D), 2008 (P & D), and 2009 (P & D) - In

Michelle
Fairmont, WV

Mar 12, 2025
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCMay 03, 2025
We appreciate your business... hope we can do more in the future.
Costume Jewelry - Various Makers

todd
Waterville, OH

Mar 07, 2025
Amazing
Great auction house. Packaged perfectly and arrived fast.
Report
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCMay 03, 2025
Thanks Todd! Hope to do business with you in the future!
Fifteen Magazine Sized Vintage Comic Books - Various Types

Sharon
Pennsville, NJ

Mar 07, 2025
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC logo
CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLCMay 03, 2025
We appreciate your business... hope we can do more in the future.
Vintage Steiff Teddy Bear - Approx 10"Tx12"L