Buffalo nickel

Easy Shipping

US Only

Newly Listed

Top Rated House

678 Lots

Sort by:

Most Relevant

1927-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, TWO FEATHERS VARIETY FS-401, GOOD G: 1927-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, TWO FEATHERS VARIETY FS-401, GOOD G 1927-S Buffalo Nickel 5C, Two Feathers Variety FS-401, Good G THE ITEM(S) IN THE PHOTO(S) IS THE EXACT ITEM(S) YOU WILL RECEIVE!

Sep 16, 2026

1927-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, TWO FEATHERS VARIETY FS-401, GOOD G

$86

(60) Random Date Buffalo Nickels: Items are as shown in the image and described in the title - Please note tht we have more than one of these items and the exact item in the image may not be the item you recieve. Winning bidder will r

3 days Left

(60) Random Date Buffalo Nickels

Shipping Department

$38

(50) Random Date/Grade Buffalo Nickels: Items are as shown in image and described in title- Random date and large bulk lots may be stock images, since we have more than one of the items in the lot.

3 days Left

(50) Random Date/Grade Buffalo Nickels

Shipping Department

$32

(40) Random Date/Grade Buffalo Nickels: Items are as shown in the image and described in the title - Please note tht we have more than one of these items and the exact item in the image may not be the item you recieve. Winning bidder will r

3 days Left

(40) Random Date/Grade Buffalo Nickels

Shipping Department

$26

(40) Buffalo Nickels - Random Date and Grade: All bids are a contract and an agreement to pay. Items are as shown in image.

3 days Left

(40) Buffalo Nickels - Random Date and Grade

Shipping Department

$28

Lot of (40) Buffalo Nickels- Mixed Date and Grade: All bids are a contract and an agreement to pay. Items are as shown in image.

3 days Left

Lot of (40) Buffalo Nickels- Mixed Date and Grade

Shipping Department

$29

Lot of (40) Buffalo Nickels- Mixed Date and Grade: All bids are a contract and an agreement to pay. Items are as shown in image.

3 days Left

Lot of (40) Buffalo Nickels- Mixed Date and Grade

Shipping Department

$29

Buffalo Nickel .999 Fine Copper 1oz Round: See photos for condition

4 days Left

Buffalo Nickel .999 Fine Copper 1oz Round

Old World Treasure Company

$5

1927 US Buffalo Nickel

Sep 3, 2026

1927 US Buffalo Nickel

Weatherham Estate Treasures

$25

1937-D Buffalo Nickel 5C MS66 NGC James Earle Fraser: 1937-D Buffalo Nickel 5C MS66 NGC James Earle Fraser This 1937-D Buffalo Nickel features a unique three-legged design, certified by NGC with a grade of MS66. Struck in Denver, this coin is made of 75%

Buy Now

1937-D Buffalo Nickel 5C MS66 NGC James Earle Fraser

$49,700

PCGS MS65+ 1925-D Buffalo 5C Nickel: PCGS MS65+ 1925-D Buffalo 5C Nickel This 1925-D Buffalo Nickel is graded MS65+ by PCGS, indicating a high-quality, uncirculated coin. Struck at the Denver Mint, it features the classic Buffalo design

Buy Now

PCGS MS65+ 1925-D Buffalo 5C Nickel

$6,020

1923-S Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS Uncirculated Coin: 1923-S Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS Uncirculated Coin This 1923-S Buffalo Nickel is a remarkable piece for any numismatic collection. Graded MS64 by PCGS, this uncirculated coin showcases the exquisite cr

Buy Now

1923-S Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS Uncirculated Coin

$2,250

1915 United States Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65 With CAC Endorsement: 1915 United States Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65 With CAC Endorsement This 1915 Buffalo Nickel is certified by PCGS with a grade of MS65 and features CAC approval. The coin is composed of nickel and is unc

Buy Now

1915 United States Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65 With CAC Endorsement

$940

Buffalo Nickel 1928 D 5C MS66 CACG: Buffalo Nickel 1928 D 5C MS66 CACG 1928-D Buffalo Nickel certified by CACG and graded MS66. This uncirculated Denver-mint coin is described as a tougher gem example from the later 1920s issues, displa

Buy Now

Buffalo Nickel 1928 D 5C MS66 CACG

$6,360

PCGS MS66+ 1926 Buffalo 5C Nickel: PCGS MS66+ 1926 Buffalo 5C Nickel This 1926 Buffalo Nickel is graded MS66+ by PCGS, indicating a high-quality, uncirculated coin. Struck in nickel, it features the classic Buffalo design and does not

Buy Now

PCGS MS66+ 1926 Buffalo 5C Nickel

$1,060

EF45 San Francisco 1921 Buffalo Nickel Graded by PCGS: EF45 San Francisco 1921 Buffalo Nickel Graded by PCGS This 1921-S Buffalo Nickel has been certified by PCGS with a grade of EF45, indicating it is a circulated coin in extra fine condition. Minted in

Buy Now

EF45 San Francisco 1921 Buffalo Nickel Graded by PCGS

$1,470

PCGS VF35 1924-S Buffalo Nickel 5C: PCGS VF35 1924-S Buffalo Nickel 5C This is a 1924-S Buffalo Nickel graded VF35 by PCGS. The coin is circulated and features the classic Buffalo design. It is composed of nickel and originates from the

Buy Now

PCGS VF35 1924-S Buffalo Nickel 5C

$940

PCGS MS66 1929-S Buffalo 5C Nickel: PCGS MS66 1929-S Buffalo 5C Nickel This is a 1929-S Buffalo Nickel graded MS66 by PCGS. The coin is uncirculated and features the classic Buffalo design. It is composed of nickel and was minted in the

Buy Now

PCGS MS66 1929-S Buffalo 5C Nickel

$1,180

1926 Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS66+ Uncirculated Philadelphia Mint: 1926 Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS66+ Uncirculated Philadelphia Mint This 1926 5C Buffalo Nickel is certified by PCGS with a grade of MS66+, indicating its excellent uncirculated condition. Minted in Philade

Buy Now

1926 Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS66+ Uncirculated Philadelphia Mint

$1,020

CACG PR66 1937 Buffalo Nickel 5C Philadelphia Proof: CACG PR66 1937 Buffalo Nickel 5C Philadelphia Proof 1937 5C Buffalo Nickel certified by CACG with a PR66 grade. Struck in Philadelphia and listed as uncirculated, this proof issue is described as the

Buy Now

CACG PR66 1937 Buffalo Nickel 5C Philadelphia Proof

$2,550

PCGS AU58 1935-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-801: PCGS AU58 1935-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-801 This 1935-S Buffalo Nickel is graded AU58 by PCGS and features the DDR FS-801 designation. Composed of nickel, this circulated coin originates from the Unite

Buy Now

PCGS AU58 1935-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-801

$1,540

PCGS MS63 1923-S Buffalo Nickel CAC: PCGS MS63 1923-S Buffalo Nickel CAC This 1923 Buffalo Nickel was minted in San Francisco and is graded MS63 by PCGS. It features the CAC designation, indicating additional verification of its quality.

Buy Now

PCGS MS63 1923-S Buffalo Nickel CAC

$1,870

NGC MS67 Plus CAC 1938-D Buffalo 5C Nickel: NGC MS67 Plus CAC 1938-D Buffalo 5C Nickel This 1938-D Buffalo Nickel is graded MS67+ by NGC and features attractive toning. Struck in Denver, this uncirculated coin is composed of copper with a finen

Buy Now

NGC MS67 Plus CAC 1938-D Buffalo 5C Nickel

$1,220

1927 Philadelphia Buffalo Nickel Graded MS65 by ANACS: 1927 Philadelphia Buffalo Nickel Graded MS65 by ANACS This 1927 Buffalo Nickel from the Philadelphia Mint is graded MS65 by ANACS. Designed by James Earle Fraser, the coin is uncirculated and composed

Buy Now

1927 Philadelphia Buffalo Nickel Graded MS65 by ANACS

$560

View:

24

Easy Shipping

US Only

Newly Listed

Top Rated House

678 Lots

Sort by:

Most Relevant

1927-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, TWO FEATHERS VARIETY FS-401, GOOD G: 1927-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, TWO FEATHERS VARIETY FS-401, GOOD G 1927-S Buffalo Nickel 5C, Two Feathers Variety FS-401, Good G THE ITEM(S) IN THE PHOTO(S) IS THE EXACT ITEM(S) YOU WILL RECEIVE!

Sep 16, 2026

1927-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, TWO FEATHERS VARIETY FS-401, GOOD G

$86

(60) Random Date Buffalo Nickels: Items are as shown in the image and described in the title - Please note tht we have more than one of these items and the exact item in the image may not be the item you recieve. Winning bidder will r

3 days Left

(60) Random Date Buffalo Nickels

Shipping Department

$38

(50) Random Date/Grade Buffalo Nickels: Items are as shown in image and described in title- Random date and large bulk lots may be stock images, since we have more than one of the items in the lot.

3 days Left

(50) Random Date/Grade Buffalo Nickels

Shipping Department

$32

(40) Random Date/Grade Buffalo Nickels: Items are as shown in the image and described in the title - Please note tht we have more than one of these items and the exact item in the image may not be the item you recieve. Winning bidder will r

3 days Left

(40) Random Date/Grade Buffalo Nickels

Shipping Department

$26

(40) Buffalo Nickels - Random Date and Grade: All bids are a contract and an agreement to pay. Items are as shown in image.

3 days Left

(40) Buffalo Nickels - Random Date and Grade

Shipping Department

$28

Lot of (40) Buffalo Nickels- Mixed Date and Grade: All bids are a contract and an agreement to pay. Items are as shown in image.

3 days Left

Lot of (40) Buffalo Nickels- Mixed Date and Grade

Shipping Department

$29

Lot of (40) Buffalo Nickels- Mixed Date and Grade: All bids are a contract and an agreement to pay. Items are as shown in image.

3 days Left

Lot of (40) Buffalo Nickels- Mixed Date and Grade

Shipping Department

$29

Buffalo Nickel .999 Fine Copper 1oz Round: See photos for condition

4 days Left

Buffalo Nickel .999 Fine Copper 1oz Round

Old World Treasure Company

$5

1927 US Buffalo Nickel

Sep 3, 2026

1927 US Buffalo Nickel

Weatherham Estate Treasures

$25

1937-D Buffalo Nickel 5C MS66 NGC James Earle Fraser: 1937-D Buffalo Nickel 5C MS66 NGC James Earle Fraser This 1937-D Buffalo Nickel features a unique three-legged design, certified by NGC with a grade of MS66. Struck in Denver, this coin is made of 75%

Buy Now

1937-D Buffalo Nickel 5C MS66 NGC James Earle Fraser

$49,700

PCGS MS65+ 1925-D Buffalo 5C Nickel: PCGS MS65+ 1925-D Buffalo 5C Nickel This 1925-D Buffalo Nickel is graded MS65+ by PCGS, indicating a high-quality, uncirculated coin. Struck at the Denver Mint, it features the classic Buffalo design

Buy Now

PCGS MS65+ 1925-D Buffalo 5C Nickel

$6,020

1923-S Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS Uncirculated Coin: 1923-S Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS Uncirculated Coin This 1923-S Buffalo Nickel is a remarkable piece for any numismatic collection. Graded MS64 by PCGS, this uncirculated coin showcases the exquisite cr

Buy Now

1923-S Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCGS Uncirculated Coin

$2,250

1915 United States Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65 With CAC Endorsement: 1915 United States Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65 With CAC Endorsement This 1915 Buffalo Nickel is certified by PCGS with a grade of MS65 and features CAC approval. The coin is composed of nickel and is unc

Buy Now

1915 United States Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65 With CAC Endorsement

$940

Buffalo Nickel 1928 D 5C MS66 CACG: Buffalo Nickel 1928 D 5C MS66 CACG 1928-D Buffalo Nickel certified by CACG and graded MS66. This uncirculated Denver-mint coin is described as a tougher gem example from the later 1920s issues, displa

Buy Now

Buffalo Nickel 1928 D 5C MS66 CACG

$6,360

PCGS MS66+ 1926 Buffalo 5C Nickel: PCGS MS66+ 1926 Buffalo 5C Nickel This 1926 Buffalo Nickel is graded MS66+ by PCGS, indicating a high-quality, uncirculated coin. Struck in nickel, it features the classic Buffalo design and does not

Buy Now

PCGS MS66+ 1926 Buffalo 5C Nickel

$1,060

EF45 San Francisco 1921 Buffalo Nickel Graded by PCGS: EF45 San Francisco 1921 Buffalo Nickel Graded by PCGS This 1921-S Buffalo Nickel has been certified by PCGS with a grade of EF45, indicating it is a circulated coin in extra fine condition. Minted in

Buy Now

EF45 San Francisco 1921 Buffalo Nickel Graded by PCGS

$1,470

PCGS VF35 1924-S Buffalo Nickel 5C: PCGS VF35 1924-S Buffalo Nickel 5C This is a 1924-S Buffalo Nickel graded VF35 by PCGS. The coin is circulated and features the classic Buffalo design. It is composed of nickel and originates from the

Buy Now

PCGS VF35 1924-S Buffalo Nickel 5C

$940

PCGS MS66 1929-S Buffalo 5C Nickel: PCGS MS66 1929-S Buffalo 5C Nickel This is a 1929-S Buffalo Nickel graded MS66 by PCGS. The coin is uncirculated and features the classic Buffalo design. It is composed of nickel and was minted in the

Buy Now

PCGS MS66 1929-S Buffalo 5C Nickel

$1,180

1926 Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS66+ Uncirculated Philadelphia Mint: 1926 Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS66+ Uncirculated Philadelphia Mint This 1926 5C Buffalo Nickel is certified by PCGS with a grade of MS66+, indicating its excellent uncirculated condition. Minted in Philade

Buy Now

1926 Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS66+ Uncirculated Philadelphia Mint

$1,020

CACG PR66 1937 Buffalo Nickel 5C Philadelphia Proof: CACG PR66 1937 Buffalo Nickel 5C Philadelphia Proof 1937 5C Buffalo Nickel certified by CACG with a PR66 grade. Struck in Philadelphia and listed as uncirculated, this proof issue is described as the

Buy Now

CACG PR66 1937 Buffalo Nickel 5C Philadelphia Proof

$2,550

PCGS AU58 1935-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-801: PCGS AU58 1935-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-801 This 1935-S Buffalo Nickel is graded AU58 by PCGS and features the DDR FS-801 designation. Composed of nickel, this circulated coin originates from the Unite

Buy Now

PCGS AU58 1935-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-801

$1,540

PCGS MS63 1923-S Buffalo Nickel CAC: PCGS MS63 1923-S Buffalo Nickel CAC This 1923 Buffalo Nickel was minted in San Francisco and is graded MS63 by PCGS. It features the CAC designation, indicating additional verification of its quality.

Buy Now

PCGS MS63 1923-S Buffalo Nickel CAC

$1,870

NGC MS67 Plus CAC 1938-D Buffalo 5C Nickel: NGC MS67 Plus CAC 1938-D Buffalo 5C Nickel This 1938-D Buffalo Nickel is graded MS67+ by NGC and features attractive toning. Struck in Denver, this uncirculated coin is composed of copper with a finen

Buy Now

NGC MS67 Plus CAC 1938-D Buffalo 5C Nickel

$1,220

1927 Philadelphia Buffalo Nickel Graded MS65 by ANACS: 1927 Philadelphia Buffalo Nickel Graded MS65 by ANACS This 1927 Buffalo Nickel from the Philadelphia Mint is graded MS65 by ANACS. Designed by James Earle Fraser, the coin is uncirculated and composed

Buy Now

1927 Philadelphia Buffalo Nickel Graded MS65 by ANACS

$560

View:

24

TOP