Reviews
Bidder Reviews for Cottone Auctions (346)
TOP RATED4.7 out of 5.0 Stars
Accurate Descriptions
Quick Responses
Easy Payments
Seamless Shipping
1-50 of 346 Reviews
Jerry ABig Horn, WY
Jun 11, 2026
Outstanding service. Expert packing and shipping. I was very impressed with Cottone.
Excellent service, expert packing and shipping of item purchased. I was definitely buy through Cottone Auctions again.
GregNokomis, FL
Jun 11, 2026
Great items, Great Price, Fast Shipping... AAA + + +
Great items, Great Price, Fast Shipping... AAA + + + I had an AAA + + + experience buying from Cottone Auctions. Everything was professional and I felt like a valued customer. (rare in today's world) I will buy from again.
andrewKingston, NY
May 29, 2026
Great auctions, very beautifule items. Super professional. I am very happy. Thanks
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + +
PhilipBurr Ridge, IL
Feb 12, 2026
CherylMoseley, VA
Jan 31, 2026
Fantastic experience
I'm absolutely thrilled with my new Steuben pieces. Cottone Auctions was great from start to finish!
DanielPrinceton, NJ
Dec 11, 2025
WilliamDothan, AL
Dec 11, 2025
GeoffAbington, PA
Nov 30, 2025
Friendly and Professional Auctioneers
A fine experience all around with Cottone Auctions. The folks there are very friendly and helpful, and they are true professionals. I look forward to bidding with them again.
Jul 9, 2025
AudraNantucket, MA
Jun 12, 2025
AmyShreveport, LA
Apr 25, 2025
JohnEdwardsville, IL
Apr 21, 2025
ChristopherBrooklyn, NY
Apr 21, 2025
Great Experience
I love dealing with the people at Cottone Auctions. Always courteous, knowledgeable, and helpful. The items are just as described. The payment and shipping are easy and fast. Looking forward to my purchase.
JosephCandor, NC
Apr 4, 2025
Clifton Bedford Hills, NY
Feb 20, 2025
Anne MarieCoboconk, CA
Feb 20, 2025
Better than described!
Very happy with my purchases that turned out to be far better in person. I would absolutely recommend.
James Monroe, CT
Feb 20, 2025
ScottOgdensburg, NY
Dec 17, 2024
G C SolutionsLouisville, CO
Dec 13, 2024
LeonardCincinnati, OH
Dec 13, 2024
paulWhittier, CA
Dec 13, 2024
Well run operation
Every part of the process ran well. The in-house shipping was outstanding; a delicate clock movement was expertly packaged with no damage in transit.
JimMount Bethel, PA
Dec 11, 2024
fine auction all as described
Super-fast shipping. The best packing I have ever seen. Everything came in excellent condition. I highly recommend Cottone Auction House.
Alfred's-gravenhage, NL
Oct 12, 2024
AllenAlameda, CA
Oct 12, 2024
A terrific auction house!
I have bought many great treasures from Cottone Auctions over the years and cannot recommend them highly enough!
MatthewNew York, NY
Oct 11, 2024
GreggChagrin Falls, OH
Jul 30, 2024
KathleenNew York, NY
Jul 11, 2024
RobLombard, IL
Jul 11, 2024
Shipping overpriced
They wanted 50.00 to mail something that weighs less then 12 oz. Will never use their auction house again
Cottone Auctions
Jul 11, 2024
They were 3 fragile glass bulbs. The UPS charge alone was $35.
PavelStaten Island, NY
Jul 4, 2024
DerkTomball, TX
Jun 29, 2024
James Mussallem Treasures LLCJacksonville, FL
Jun 27, 2024
PatrickBrick, NJ
Jun 22, 2024
Great overall experience
Professional, helpful, friendly! Reasonable shipping! How I wish all auction houses were run.
MaxCachan, FR
Jun 21, 2024
GingerColumbia, SC
Jun 21, 2024
MichaelNew York, NY
Jun 21, 2024
Shipping Process
They did a great job properly and safely packed and protected the item for shipping. It arrived perfect!
SusanKennett Square, PA
Jun 20, 2024
ChristianMünchen, DE
Jun 20, 2024
DominicColeraine, AU
Apr 14, 2024
Excellent Auction House.
Excellent Auction House. Followed up with packing the items how I asked & I am very pleased. AAA + + +
James Mussallem Treasures LLCJacksonville, FL
Apr 9, 2024
HughEau Claire, WI
Feb 19, 2024
AndrewPlacitas, NM
Feb 17, 2024
IrisHamburg, DE
Feb 14, 2024
TOP