Matthews Auctions, LLC, IL - Read over 159 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Matthews Auctions, LLC (159)

badge TOP RATED
4.6 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 159 Reviews

Jim
Georgetown, TX

Feb 26, 2026

Robbie
Monmouth, IL

Feb 26, 2026
Great to work with.
Great to work with.
Report

Richard
New York, NY

Feb 24, 2026
Smith Miller GMC Semi & West Coast Fast Freight Trailer

Dunja
Peoria, AZ

Feb 03, 2026
At the end everything worked out fine.
I will be back again for some more stuff πŸ‘
Report
Lot of Buick Items Moto Meter, Mascot and Mini Trash Can

Nick
Shrewsbury, MA

Jan 20, 2026
Great company to buy from!
Great staff and great quality items make for a very pleasant experience!
Report
(Gulf) Sanitary Rest Rooms Porcelain Sign (TAC)

Alex
Tolleson, AZ

Jan 20, 2026
item discription
Very good and knowledgable people
Report
Rare Super Chevrolet Service w/Black Wings (30) Porcelain Sign (TAC)

Rick
Brighton, IL

Jan 19, 2026
Have a Pepsi w/Bottle Cap Logo Metal Menu Sign (TAC)

Joe
Dearborn Heights, MI

Jan 19, 2026
.
.
Report
(Oldsmobile) Logo Molded Plastic Lighted Sign

Jeff
Carson City, NV

Jan 16, 2026
The Best!
I always look forward to their auctions. Five Stars in every respect.
Report
Nevada U.S. Route 40 Metal Shield Sign

Major
Flora, IL

Jan 14, 2026
4-Motor Oil Quarts, One Lb Grease & Five Lb Mica Metal Cans

Anthony
Galt, CA

Dec 20, 2025
Porcelain Stop Sign w/Plastic Reflectors (TAC)

Mark
Delray Beach, FL

Dec 14, 2025
Nice job
It was what it was
Report
Goodyear Porcelain Letters

Steven
Sheffield, PA

Dec 13, 2025
They will damage your item moving it improperly and not tell you about it.
I bought a $15, 000 antique oilfield engine that this auctioneer flopped over on its side. Bending the crank shaft. I was never told about it until I discovered all the dirt on the end of the crank shaft and rocker arm. I demanded an explanation. I was called and told not to pickup my items until Friday, then I was called on Wednesday morning and expected to come that day ahead of all the pickup times. Flywheel of engine was running 1” out of round. The attitude was it just fell over gently, no big deal. Movers walked all over engine once it was on its side. Boot prints were all over it when I picked it up. I was able to get $3000 refunded after having to speak with the owner. Movers need to learn how to handle antique engines before taking on anymore auctions that include them. This engine was the prize piece of this collection and it was treated like the runt!
Report
Matthews Auctions, LLC logo
Matthews Auctions, LLCDec 21, 2025
Steve, you were offered a full refund, but you chose to keep the engine and we agreed on a 3000 refund, because if it would have been such a big problem you would have turned the engine away, but even you knew that the flywheels were likely already bent prior to purchase because that is the reason they got some of these great engines is because they were not useful in the oilfields anymore due to damage or something of the sort. As for the engine tipping over, it was mounted on some wooden blocks for display in the museum and after many years the blocks had rotted and when we went to move it the engine tipped off. The engine tipped off slowly and it would have not caused the flywheels or the crank to have been bent with how it fell. As for pickup, we got ready for loadout a day earlier than expected, so we called some of the bigger buyers and asked them if they wanted to come get the items out of the way, you were not demanded to come and pick your stuff up. As you said yourself you are so busy, you didn't even have time to check your phone, so kind of surprising you were able to make time to come and pick up some of your stuff so short notice. Also, not sure of anybody walking all over the engine and the foot marks that you speak of, this is the first time I have heard of that and did not see them when we looked over the engine with you. Also kind of strange that you waited over 3 months to write a bad review for something that was handled, but it just shows that you like stirring the pot or upsetting the apple cart once again.
Gas Pricer Metal Sign

Kenneth
Leechburg, PA

Sep 26, 2025
top notch
very nice people helpful and organized
Report
Shell One Piece Gas Pump Globe

James
Mesa, AZ

Aug 24, 2025
Drink Dr. Pepper Lighted Clock

Lumber & Millwork Andrew J. Youngman
Lake Wales, FL

Aug 23, 2025
enjoyed the auction. I was able to win 5 lots of things I like to collect. Shipping took longer than expected but when asking Dan responded within a few hours. Everything was wrapped professionally and received with no damage. I will be looking forward to the next auction.
Report
Rack of Standard Oil Bottles

Joseph
Mechanicsville, VA

Aug 18, 2025
Smooth professional transaction.
Everything went fine.
Report
Sauer's Flavoring Extracts Counter-Top Display Point of Display (TAC)

Michael
Somers, NY

Aug 17, 2025
Drink Coca-Cola in Bottles Round Thermometer

Robert
Maple Heights, OH

Aug 17, 2025
Great vintage clock
Very professional auction, fair pricing, beautiful packaging. Clock was better than expected.
Report
Raytheon Expert TV & Radio Service Lighted Clock

Eddie
Barrington, IL

Aug 17, 2025
Champion Spark Plugs Store Cabinet

Jim
Olathe, KS

Aug 16, 2025
We Clean & Check Spark Plugs Champions w/Image Metal Sign (TAC)

Nick
Shrewsbury, MA

Aug 16, 2025
Drink Coca-Cola w/Motor Boat Dispenser Porcelain Sign (TAC)

James
Winthrop Harbor, IL

Aug 09, 2025
GREAT assistance!
I was concerned about automatic payment and items being shipped before being able to establish the fact that I would be driving to auction site, paying cash and retrieving items. Not getting any response from "LiveAuctions" I DID receive a response from an incredible employee of Matthews LLC. She (i misplaced her name) was absolutely fantastic to work with and able to set my mind at ease making sure it would all work out.
Report
Coca-Cola w/ Bottle & Art-Deco Metal Flange Sign (TAC)

Francesco
Polanco Ii SecciΓ³n, MX

Jun 24, 2025
Happy customer!
Good communication, fair shipping price, good quality product. Highly recommended auction house.
Report
3-Still Coin Banks

Robert
Willoughby, OH

Apr 15, 2025
Bing Ford Sedan

dan
Macungie, PA

Feb 27, 2025
Another smooth purchase.
Simple, easy and very smooth. Product was well packaged and taken care of. Great people to deal with.
Report
Rare Favor Cycles & Motos w/Tiger Logo Metal Sign (TAC)

steve
St-amable, CA

Feb 15, 2025
5 star
5 star
Report
Kentucky Club Pipe Tobacco Metal Thermometer (TAC)

Clifford
Mattituck, NY

Feb 07, 2025
1927 Arcadians & 1931 Fred & Jane Booklets

Mike
Renton, WA

Jan 22, 2025
Scratch Built Packard Style Car Model

Chris
Baden, PA

Jan 22, 2025
Exceptional shipping
I was very pleased with my auction experience with Mathew’s Auctions. Bidding, notifications, payment were super simple! My items were shipped in a timely fashion and pack with extreme care! Very impressed with the whole experience. I will definitely buy again! Thank you!
Report
Hot Wheels Sizzlers '70 Plymouth Cuda T/A

steve
St-amable, CA

Jan 22, 2025
5 star seller
always perfect
Report
Metal Sign w/Stag

steve
St-amable, CA

Jan 20, 2025
5 star
5 star auction all perfect many thanks
Report
Pepsi:Cola Bottle Cap Shaped Metal Sign (TAC)

Barry
Waterford, MI

Jan 19, 2025
very helpfull
great service fast shipping
Report
Pair of Pepsi-Cola Bar Stools

raymond
Orange, CA

Jan 19, 2025
Personal contact
Very helpful and responsive to all my questions and concerns Great people to work with Descriptions were accurate
Report
Bank Note Cigars & El Bubble Bubble Gum Cigars Boxes

Scott
Waukesha, WI

Jan 19, 2025
Drink Royal Crown "Best By Taste-Test" Metal Thermometer (TAC)

Mike
Harris, MN

Jan 18, 2025
Veedol Skating Girl Metal Sign (long hair )(TAC)

Standish
Saint Augustine, FL

Jan 17, 2025
Ingersoll Watches w/Image Porcelain Sign (TAC)

Adlane
Houston, TX

Aug 19, 2024
Peugeot Automobiles Porcelain Sign (TAC)

Scott
Villa Rica, GA

Aug 18, 2024
Great overall experience!! No issues!!
Good Communication! Sent in a reasonable time! Packaged extremely well! Great overall experience!! All good!
Report
Coca-Cola "The Pause That Refreshes" w/Lady (TAC)

Ronald
Hoofddorp, NL

Aug 17, 2024
Early Phillips (Auto Lamps) w/Image Porcelain Sign (TAC)

Tracy
Stacy, MN

Aug 17, 2024
Awesome packaging and shipping
Great company
Report
Greyhound (bus) w/Logo Metal Sign (TAC)

Walter
Chicago, IL

Jul 20, 2024
Lot of 4 Oldsmobile Brochures - 1 (1965) 1 (1967) 1 (1968) 1 (1970) 1 (1971)

Mike
Bridge City, TX

May 16, 2024
πŸ‘
πŸ‘ πŸ‘
Report
Foremost Ice Cream Metal Sign

Mike
Bridge City, TX

May 14, 2024
πŸ‘ πŸ‘
πŸ‘ πŸ‘ πŸ₯°
Report
Dixie Milk Neon Clock

Ron
Redlands, CA

Apr 26, 2024
Chevrolet Sales & Service Economical Transportation Porcelain Sign (TAC)

Dennis
Lowpoint, IL

Apr 26, 2024
Drink Coca-Cola Refresh! Porcelain Curb Sign (restored)

Dave
Hingham, MA

Apr 26, 2024
Know how you will be paying.
I’ve been trying to change my account from auto pay (credit card with a exhorbant fee) to a pay by check. No response. I can’t tell the difference between Live Auctions and Matthews. Way too confusing to me. I’ll buy elsewhere.
Report
1950's Chevorlet w/Bowtie Logo Plastic Lighted Clock

Adam
Burr Ridge, IL

Apr 26, 2024
Accuracy of the description
Outstanding service from one of the top auction houses in the country
Report
Sealed Power Piston Rings Molded Plastic Lighted Clock (TAC)

Mike
Renton, WA

Mar 28, 2024
1937 Packard Six & 120 Dealer Sales Brochure Large Original Sedan Coupe Rare

Christopher
Burt, NY

Mar 24, 2024
1936 Buick Eight Series 40 60 80 90 Color Sales Brochure Catalog XL Original