Reviews
Bidder Reviews for Tony Putty Artifacts (426)
TOP RATED4.7 out of 5.0 Stars
Accurate Descriptions
Quick Responses
Easy Payments
Seamless Shipping
1-50 of 426 Reviews
CurtisGurdon, AR
Aug 9, 2026
Good first time experience.
After having these artifacts certified and appraised, I am satisfied with my first time experienced with this auction house.
ScottDefiance, OH
Aug 8, 2026
Very nice item.
Very nice item. it was packaged so good that the USPS could have thrown it at porch and I would be safe to say it would not have been damaged.
ScottDanville, KY
Aug 8, 2026
SimpsonWilmington, DE
Aug 8, 2026
Bid with Confidence
My experience has been; good descriptions, good photos and a professional payment and shipping process
GregShelbyville, IN
Aug 8, 2026
EddieWindsor, CA
Aug 8, 2026
JAMESBurlington, IA
Jun 23, 2026
SteveBrunswick, GA
Jun 12, 2026
KennethEarl Park, IN
May 23, 2026
Everything was packed very well and shipped within a reasonable amount of time.
Very well ran auction. Items are packed very well and shipped on time.
EricLeesburg, VA
May 23, 2026
FrankHuerth, DE
May 23, 2026
DaveDefiance, MO
Jan 3, 2026
No communications, no item delivered, no refund, nothing.
No communications, no item received, no refund no nothing. I think this auction is as trusted as the COAs. Worthless! Buyer beware. Contacted Liveauctioneers to report and still no reply from Putty Auctions.
DennisGrand Ledge, MI
Dec 31, 2025
It's been 2 weeks since the auction house cashed my check, and still no items sent.
2 weeks after the auction house cashed my check, still nothing sent. Terrible and I will never give them my money again, ever.
JimShelbyville, IN
Dec 28, 2025
ThomasGouldsboro, PA
Oct 11, 2025
cameronOld Saybrook, CT
Jul 6, 2025
DougHuntington, IN
Jul 5, 2025
They are one of the best in the business.
Friendly, thoughtful, trustworthy and AAA + + + in every aspect.
MichaelSaint Clairsville, OH
Jun 23, 2025
GeorgeBell City, MO
May 4, 2025
Sells fake non authentic artifacts
Put as is on all artifacts with no return policy knowing they are no good. This is fraud and will be reported to th BBB. Almost every artifact I purchased unless it had a COA was bad. Be Leary of anything they sell!
JeffKnob Noster, MO
Apr 2, 2025
Nice rocks
Always enjoy catalog and sales. Just need to figure out what level your at and go for it. Most states are covered and I like that.
TimMt Sterling, KY
Mar 30, 2025
R. GarlandBloomington, IL
Mar 29, 2025
MichaelEvansville, IN
Jan 5, 2025
LaneLincoln, NE
Jan 5, 2025
Jan 4, 2025
DougHuntington, IN
Jan 4, 2025
CliffLake Forest, IL
Jan 4, 2025
For me, always a smooth process!
Another prime artifact from a prime auctioneer! always a great auction.
R. GarlandBloomington, IL
Jan 4, 2025
SamWaynesville, NC
Oct 7, 2024
ScottDanville, KY
Oct 7, 2024
TimMedina, OH
Oct 6, 2024
LaneLincoln, NE
Oct 6, 2024
ThomasLiberty Hill, TX
Oct 5, 2024
KeithBen Lomond, CA
Oct 5, 2024
StevenIndianapolis, IN
Oct 5, 2024
Honesty and professionalism
I’ve been dealing with the Putty’s for twenty five years and haven’t had any issues a lot of auction houses out there, what I can say is this is one you can trust
JAMESBurlington, IA
Jun 29, 2024
Honesty
Tony has honesty, I’ve been buying from “them” for years and will continue to do so. Jimmy
LaneLincoln, NE
Jun 29, 2024
GaryOoltewah, TN
Jun 29, 2024
FrankSan Francisco, CA
May 26, 2024
Tony Putty Artifacts is a great auction house to work with.
Without question, Tony Putty Artifacts is one of the best auction houses I've worked with. The pieces I've purchased were accurately described, and the opening bid amounts were quite reasonable. Additional information was promptly provided when requested, and, most important, it was easy to reach someone who could answer my questions. Payment processes are very convenient for the customer, and shipments of my purchases were done in a timely manner, with excellent packaging.
ChrisSlatington, PA
May 26, 2024
ronaldLa Mesa, CA
May 25, 2024
John P.Eagle River, AK
May 25, 2024
JohnLong Beach, CA
May 25, 2024
StephenSpringfield, IL
May 25, 2024
HenryEast Falmouth, MA
Apr 9, 2024
was reliable
Seems reliable on the basis of my first transaction. Look forward to their next auction.
FrankSan Francisco, CA
Mar 31, 2024
RobinColdwater, OH
Mar 30, 2024
DougHuntington, IN
Mar 30, 2024
TOP