Winfield Auction Gallery, NY - Read over 103 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Winfield Auction Gallery (103)

badge TOP RATED
4.5 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 103 Reviews

Tim
Fort Collins, CO

Dec 08, 2025
these items have safely arrived. Thanks.
The walnut mirror is fantastic. The miniature tea pot is great. the quality of the SW American rug is lower than anticipated. Not sure of its authenticity-closer to Mexican rugs/wall hangings.
Report
Chinese Porcelain Miniature 5.5" Teapot with Silver Overlay 20thC

David
Rochester, NY

Dec 01, 2025
Questionable item descriptions
I bid on two items described as vintage 20th century lamps somewhat impulsively and without doing my due diligence. Researching the items a bit more several days later (but still prior to the auction), a google lens search turned up the same style lamps listed on 1stdibs for very high prices. The casual observer might then conclude that this item is in fact quite valuable and worth bidding a lot on, but looking more closely, I saw that the items were in fact the very same lamps that I was bidding on (listed by the same auction house), cross-listed on a different platform. You might assume they were simply taking a stab at getting a better price on1stdibs.com prior to the auction, or it could be perceived as manipulating bidders into thinking the items are more valuable than they actually are. They were also described as "vintage 20th century lamps," but further searching on google revealed that they had been sold at Lowe's and Walmart in the presumably not-too-distant past. To be fair, the lamps were nice enough and probably worth what I paid, but I just felt that their tactics were a little deceptive. I will not be bidding with them again.
Report
Vintage Dirk van Erp Style Arts & Crafts Copper & Mica Table Lamp 20thC

Joan E
Gaines, PA

Nov 29, 2025
Very easy to pay and work with staff. Easy pickup.
This organization is amazing and have wonderful listings at good prices.
Report
Roseville Art Pottery Blue Window Planter With Magnolia Pattern Mid 20thC

James
Macomb, IL

Oct 02, 2025
12" French Art Nouveau Cut Back Flower Art Glass Vase Signed Galle C1920

Joan E
Gaines, PA

Sep 30, 2025
Very pleased with my auction wins. They are beautiful and life enhancing.
Just as described. So beautiful and impressive. Great auction find.
Report
Two New York/Rudolstadt Pottery Figural Porcelain Vases 19thC

Rochelle
Palm Beach Gardens, FL

Sep 27, 2025
French Art Nouveau Cameo Cutback Art Glass Perfume Atomizer C1920

Tim
Fort Collins, CO

Sep 14, 2025
an interesting auction item.
as described in write up. very different, I wish the lid chain was present-but it was not pictured so I guess it never was available.
Report
Chinese Porcelain Miniature Teapot with Silver Overlay 20thC

Josh
Wichita, KS

Jun 01, 2025
Excellent service
Perfect transaction. Shipping is top notch.
Report
Antique Roseville Art Pottery Vase with Mostique Pattern C1930

Joan E
Gaines, PA

Jun 01, 2025
Fun and Exciting
Great time bidding on items as a pastime and the pick up of wins is close and easy.
Report
Antique Chinese Figural Carved Giltwood Sculpture Stand Circa 1910

Daniel
Prairie Du Chien, WI

Apr 12, 2025
TOTALLY UNRESPONSIVE!
No one has communicated with me. I sent a dozen emails to Winfield Auction stating that I would pick the item up within the 60 day time frame permitted in its auction. I have cancelled the transaction with my credit card (AMEX) because Winfield tacked on an extra $350 for shipping I don't need. A month later I received a call from a Winfield Auction truck driver that the action item is being dropped off at my residence. No one will be at the residence for a week. I don't mind paying for the item I won, but I am not paying for a delivery fee I don't need when my nephew who lives 40 minutes away could have picked the item up. DMK
Report
Antique Stickley School Arts & Crafts Oak Single Door & Drawer Cellarette c1910

Joan E
Gaines, PA

Apr 06, 2025
Fast and easy to pay and retrieve the two pieces.
Great Auction House to work with.
Report
Chinese Brass Strapped Rosewood Tall Twelve Drawer Lingerie & Jewelry Chest

Michael
Goliad, TX

Apr 06, 2025
Shipping/packing was not careful.
While I can find the items I ourchased at other places, I still expect packing/shipping to be done with care. This was Not done be Winfield and their shipper. I chose in house shipping for convenience, and most of my past auction houses offering it take extra care packing antiques. Winfield acted like “ok, we have a good box, thats enough”!! He items I purchased were already old, and he throwing of packages by shipper personnel then caused additional damage in transit, that would have been avoided, if Winfield had thoroughly protected the items with bubble wrap/padding materials Inside the boxes And cases. Im going to have to really consider whether I want to chance bidding with them again, because picking up in person is Not an option at Long distance.
Report
LT Box Of Antique Violin Repair Parts And Tools C1900

Dale
East Amherst, NY

Apr 05, 2025
Miscellaneous Brass Hardware C1900

David
New York, NY

Apr 05, 2025
Linda Craige Henri (Mrs Robert Henri) by Robert Henri, 43" O/C Portrait, Signed, 1897

Henry
Los Angeles, CA

Apr 05, 2025
easy and convenient
auction house was responsive and worked with my shipper. super easy.
Report
Antique Arts & Crafts Mission Mahogany Magazine Stand Signed Stickley 20th C

Kent
Tulsa, OK

Apr 05, 2025
Accurate description, excellent service
The items were accurately described, including description, shipping cost was reasonable and fast.
Report
Pair of Alberto Giacometti Cubism Bronze Sculptural Musicians 20thC

Steven
Rochester, MI

Apr 02, 2025
Pr English Royal Crown Derby Old Imari Bone China Gilt Candlesticks with Seal

Andrew
Grove City, PA

Mar 30, 2025
Linda Craige Henri (Mrs. Robert Henri), Large Still Life O/C Painting, Signed, Framed, C1905

Ed
Ambler, PA

Mar 18, 2025
Great Experience
Very easy to work with and very helpful
Report
Antique Arts & Crafts JM Young Mission Oak Slat Back Rocking Chair  c1910

JOHN
Warren, PA

Jan 23, 2025
Expensive shipping
Ask for shipping quote before the auction. There are no other options for shipping in the vicinity. UPS stores will not pick up and they don't deliver to them. Tried to orchestrate pick up a number of times. No response to emails or phone messages.
Report
Antique Musical Wax Automaton Doll Figure With Glass Eyes C1900

Richard
Ithaca, NY

Nov 30, 2024
Great group of people. Pleasure to do business with.
Great group of people. Pleasure to do busibness with.
Report
Antique Frank Lloyd Style Arts & Crafts Prairie Style Stained Glass Window C1920

Revson
New Milford, CT

Sep 16, 2024
Winfield Auction Gallery is the best!
The shipping charges are extremely reasonable. I asked prior to my purchase for a shipping quote and I was more than happy with the estimate and even better both delivery men were very professional. I would gladly buy from them again.
Report
Egyptian Revival Figural Triptych Three-Section Gold Giltwood Wall Mirror 19th C

David
New York, NY

Sep 14, 2024
Frankart School Art Deco Bronze & Crystal Sculptural Lamp, Woman & Ball, C1930

David
Ho Ho Kus, NJ

Jun 08, 2024
Large Maxfield Parrish Landscape Print “Homestead By River”, Framed, C1930

Mike
Marshall, NC

Jun 08, 2024
WAG was great with shipping help
Will buy again from WAG-excellent transaction. Description was accurate-just as I expected.
Report
Antique Ansonia Bronzed Metal Figural Mantel Clock with Classical Woman C1890

Philip
Swedesboro, NJ

Mar 29, 2024
Pair Italian Floral Etched Venetian Glass Mirrored Commodes 20th C

Diana
Troy, PA

Mar 23, 2024
Antique Bronze Cupid & Dolphin Statue on Marble Plinth 19th C

Philip
Swedesboro, NJ

Nov 14, 2023
Antique Louis XIV Kingwood And Satinwood Ormolu Marble Top Commode C1920

Diana
Troy, PA

Oct 29, 2023
Antique Victorian Hand Crafted Patchwork Crazy Quilt Circa 1890

Kevin
Galveston, TX

Sep 16, 2023
Item was as advertised
The shipping costs were a little steep but it arrived intact. Good all-around experience. Trustworthy.
Report
Antique Arts & Crafts Slag Glass Table Lamp, circa 1920

Doug
Smyrna, TN

Sep 04, 2023
Utica White's Pottery, NY Blue Decorated Stoneware Jug, Pub Scene, circa 1880

Philip
Swedesboro, NJ

Mar 22, 2023
Pair Italian Mahogany Inlaid Olive Wood Bombe Commodes 20thC

Olivette
Fredericksburg, VA

Dec 07, 2022
French Louis XIV Style Gilt Bronze Tiered Twelve Light Chandelier, 20th C

Raymond
Sarasota, FL

Dec 04, 2022
Antique Stickley Brothers Oak With Pressed Cane Magazine Rack, c1910

Natalie
Long Island City, NY

Dec 04, 2022
Excellent Auctioneer!
Excellent seller, friendly and helpful!
Report
Antique Mid-Century Modern Lucite & Nylon Light Shade, 20th C

Michelle
Rivesville, WV

Oct 17, 2022
Antique Lancaster, PA Amish Hand Made Quilt Circa 1900

Colleen
Conroe, TX

Sep 18, 2022
Great experience
Received item it was as in excellent condition as described. Packaging was good and shipping was reasonable. I would definitely buy from this auction house again.
Report
Antique Arts & Crafts Weller Hudson Art Pottery Stylized Floral Vase, circa 1920

SCOTT
Cascade, CO

Mar 26, 2022
Good service
Prompt delivery of lot won. Good quality thank you
Report
Antique Southwestern American Indian Navajo Wool Rug

William
Buford, GA

Mar 26, 2022
EXCELLENT Service!
First.. I LOVE my portrait! Second.. the customer service was AWESOME! They shipped to me.. actually delivery to my door from delivery company they use.. VERY nice guys.. I kept updated from start to finish!! I LIKE THEM!
Report
Antique Painting, Portrait of a Woman, Oval Frame c1880

Johannes
Riviera Beach, FL

Mar 26, 2022
Everything was fine
The Auction House did a good job in every respect, and the shipping was promptly. Items was very well and safely packaged. The shipping department obviously knows what they are doing.
Report
Antique Austrian Royal Vienna Porcelain Cobalt Portrait

Daryl
San Jose, CA

Mar 16, 2022
Great item.
Quick response and experience.
Report
Antique Japanese Aesthetic Meiji Porcelain Bottle Vase

David
Pittsburgh, PA

Mar 07, 2022
👍
👍
Report
Antique Oak Postmaster Double Door Hanging Wall Cabinet

PATRICIA V
Brookhaven, GA

Nov 27, 2021
Antique Oil Painting "Lakeside Encampment" by Rymer

Robert
Prairie Grove, IL

Nov 27, 2021
Antique English & French Iron Battle Armour "17thC"

Dan
Howell, MI

Nov 27, 2021
Great experience
Everything was clear, and accurate. Couldn’t be happier.
Report
Eastlake Berkey & Gay Attrb. Walnut & Burl Inlaid Table

Douglas
Atlanta, GA

Nov 27, 2021
Antique Chinese Rose Medallion Hand Enameled Tureen

Eric
Berkeley Springs, WV

Nov 27, 2021
Aesthetic Bach School Wrought Iron Console Table 19th C

Barbara
Madison, WI

Nov 16, 2021
Friendly, Fast and Efficient.
Winfield Auction Gallery is an A + + organization, dedicated to great service and oriented to complete customer satisfaction! I highly recommend their auctions.
Report
New Hope School Impressionistic Winterscape Signed Baum

Chris
Pittsburgh, PA

Nov 16, 2021
In-house shipping
Professionally packed by the in-house shipping team. Well-done.
Report
Lg Maxfield Parrish Golden Hours Edison Mazda Calendar

Robert
Westfield, MA

Nov 14, 2021
Great experience
Extremely reasonable shipping fees. Item better than expected.
Report
Chambers School Painting, Evening On The Delaware, 1880