Rail & Road Auctions, IN - Read over 174 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Rail & Road Auctions (174)

badge TOP RATED
4.6 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 174 Reviews

Mark
Tannersville, VA

Jan 30, 2026
Pennsylvania Railroad Cast Iron Keystone Whistle Sign

Eric
New York, NY

Jan 28, 2026
At long last! Very happy with item
I had been looking for this particular item for a number of years, and of course this particular firm came through, as they seemingly find all the good stuff. As usual, they'll be getting my business in the future, too.
Report
New York Central Railroad International Silver Cocktail Shaker - 16 oz. Dial-A-Drink

Guy
Chicago, IL

Jan 20, 2026
It's GREAT
Great item. Fast and reasonable shipping. A + + + + + I'll be back!
Report
The Fulton Co. Four Chime Aermore Exhaust Horn / Whistle

John
Bell Buckle, TN

Jan 14, 2026
Minichamps 1:35 Panzerkampfwagen VI Tiger II "Battle of the Bulge" Diecast WWII German Military Tank

Tim
Siloam Springs, AR

Dec 06, 2025
Great Experience
Very helpful and organized. Very pleased with outcome.
Report
Hobby Master 1:72 Douglas A-1H Skyraider Die Cast USS Intrepid Navy Military Plane - NIB

Gary
Chili, WI

Dec 05, 2025
Very Supportive and Accommodating to the Buyers
Extremely helpful and flexible regarding pickup and delivery.
Report
Hobby Master 1:48 WWII F4U Corsair Die Cast Military Plane - NIB

James
Pittsburgh, PA

Nov 08, 2025
Honest Fast Shipping All Good A +
Fast Honest Shipping All good A +
Report
1923 Pennsylvania Railroad Broad Street Station Fire Photo Album by Edward H. Reuss, Jr.

Eric
New York, NY

Oct 26, 2025
First Class Operation
I have long experience with this auction house. It's hard to beat their combination of interesting items and efficient, effective, no-drama service.
Report
Collection of Atlantic City & Shore Railroad Tickets - Shore Fast Line

Ramon
New York, NY

Oct 02, 2025
The Encyclopedia of Motorcycles

Larry E.
Lima, OH

Dec 05, 2024
Very fast and good service.
Very fast and good service. Very nice people to deal with. Packing of items is very nice.
Report
Coleman 242B Lantern - Nickel with Sunburst Logo

Dan
Swartz Creek, MI

Nov 10, 2024
I was hesitant at first.
I never did this kind of auction before, but I won two of the 4 that I bid on and the process was seamless. Fast secure shipping as well. I'll be back.
Report
Adams & Westlake "The Adams" Pere Marquette Railroad Tall Globe Lantern w/ Clear Cast Logo

chris
Buzzards Bay, MA

Nov 09, 2024
Drove 1000 miles from Cape Cod, Ma to pick up sign.
Road & Rail is AWESOME!! Owner Derik is TOO!! Was well worth the trip. I pray it happens again soon. Happy Day. God Bless
Report
8' Pennsylvania Railroad "Look Out for the Locomotive" Cast Iron Crossing Sign

Stuart
Framingham, MA

Nov 08, 2024
Maine Central Railroad China Kennebec Rimmed Soup Bowl 8 3/4"

Mauricio
Arkansas City, KS

Nov 07, 2024
Great experience like always. Highly recommended!
Amazing auction house
Report
International Silver Milwaukee Road Double Handled Sugar Bowl w/ Lid 6 Oz

Ralph
Fredonia, WI

Nov 07, 2024
Chicago and North Western Railroad Silver Coffee Pot and Bowl

Eric
New York, NY

Oct 31, 2024
Delighted with items
I was very happy with both the items themselves, and the auction house's service. Will be bidding again.
Report
New York, New Haven & Hartford Railroad Silver Pedestal Ice Cream Cup and Tabasco Holder

Robert
Hubbard, OH

Oct 20, 2024
Large Group of Bus, Trolley, & Transit Timetables, Postcards, and Editorials - Greyhound, Hudson

Kim
Wembley Downs, AU

Sep 30, 2024
Amazing quick delivery, Very well packaged
Very well packaged, Items as discribed
Report
Three Matchbox / Lesney No. 31 Lincoln Continental in Original Boxes

chris
Buzzards Bay, MA

Sep 16, 2024
Happy Happy
Happy Happy
Report
Cast Iron Railway Express Agency Sign

Mike
Glauchau, DE

Sep 15, 2024
Fast and smooth transaction!
I am completely satisfied with this auction house. Fast shipment, well packed. A fast and smooth transaction! Thanks!
Report
Pair of 1905 GRS Original Stock Certificates

Don
Ferguson, MO

Sep 13, 2024
Cast Iron Notary Seal Stamp for Archie Monroe Quarrier of Louisville & Nashville Railroad

Kirk
Bloomington, IL

Sep 13, 2024
Five Chicago Burlington and Quincy Railroad Employee Large Format Timetables - 1911, 1924, 1926,

David
Pittsford, NY

Sep 12, 2024
Pair of Brass Railroad Keys - Columbus & Newark and Jersey Shore, Pine Creek & Buffalo Railway

Robert
Greenwood, IN

Sep 12, 2024
Three Chicago Area Railroad Locks - Chicago South Shore & South Bend, Chicago Aurora & Elgin, and

Josh
Santa Monica, CA

Sep 08, 2024
Great Auctions!
Wow. A smooth, easy process with fast, careful shipping. Great items. I will definitely be bidding again!
Report
Union Pacific Railroad Guard #6 Badge and Detective Badge

Barr
Sandy, UT

Aug 26, 2024
Northern Pacific Railway Advertisement - Thomas Moran Color Grand Canyon Yellowstone Park

Gene
Valdese, NC

Jul 19, 2024
Buyers premium is high
The auction house is good but they charge high buyers premiums on their lots. It's 5 % cheaper to bid on their site but 17 % is still too much. They could do better with shipping costs as well.
Report
Norfolk and Western Railway Wooden Safety Bulletin Sheet

Gary
Hoover, AL

Jul 18, 2024
Three Baltimore and Ohio Railroad Locks and Keys - Adlake, Fraim, Slaymaker, and FS Hardware

Mauricio
Arkansas City, KS

Jul 18, 2024
Great auctioneer
Amazing items and professional auction house
Report
Atchison, Topeka, And Santa Fe Railroad China Ancient Mimbreno Plate 7 3/4"

Eric
New York, NY

Jul 18, 2024
As usual, Rail & Road solid
Have bought through this auction house a number of times, and will continue to do so. A combination of good stuff and careful handling of items.
Report
New York Central Railroad Mercury China Oval Celery Tray, Coffee Cups, and Saucer

chris
Buzzards Bay, MA

Jun 01, 2024
Great folks to deal with. Happy and will bid again.
All Good Here!!
Report
Nathan P5 Locomotive Horn Manifold

Alberto
Hialeah, FL

May 31, 2024
Good CR
Good transaction
Report
11 Pieces of Ford Passenger Car Sales and Promotional Literature 1957-1959

David
El Dorado Springs, MO

May 31, 2024
Pair of Chevrolet Rocket Style Hood Ornaments - 1955 Full Size and 1957 Bel Air & Nomad Rocket

Donald
Lubbock, TX

May 31, 2024
1957 Ford Supercharger Shop Manual

Joe
Natick, MA

May 30, 2024
Adams & Westlake Reliable Kansas City Southern Bell Bottom Lantern w/ Clear Cast Globe

Robin
Hudson's Hope, CA

May 30, 2024
Most Excellent!!
I highly recommend Rail & Road Auction House. I was treated with respect, had any questions I had answered politely and promptly. An overall wonderful experience! I look forward to future auctions!
Report
Three Walter L. Green New York Central Framed Advertising Prints - "In The Hudson River Valley" ,

Annie
Columbus, IN

Mar 29, 2024
Great experience!
Fantastic experience with this auction house. Items were packed well and shipped quickly. Much appreciated!
Report
Three Baltimore & Ohio Railroad China Centenary Harper's Ferry Plates 10 1/2"

Eric
New York, NY

Mar 15, 2024
Plain and Simple: Solid Auction House
I've bought, now, a number of times from Rail & Road, and find their selection of items on offer excellent, and their service also excellent. I would recommend them. (Just don't bid against me.)
Report
Pair of New York, New Haven & Hartford Railroad Cap Badges - Trainman and Baggageman

Jerry
La Junta, CO

Jan 28, 2024
Great auction to deal with
Always enjoy dealing with Rail & Road Auction, excellent packing and quick shipping. Always look forward to the next auction.
Report
1880 Eureka Springs Railway Unissued Stock Certificate

GIAN LUCA
Cento Fe, IT

Jan 27, 2024
very fine seller!
A very fine seller, fine forwarding. I am very satisfied.
Report
T.R. McElroy's Mac Key Morse Code Telegraph Key - Serial Number 5650

Gary
Hoover, AL

Jan 26, 2024
Dietz NYCS Red Globe Railroad Lantern, NYCS Dressel Lantern Body, And Unmarked Dietz Vesta CNX Red

Keith
Evansville, IN

Jan 26, 2024
3" Lunkenheimer Three Chime Baldy Steam Whistle

Tracy
Durango, CO

Jan 25, 2024
Group of Three New York Central Railroad Lanterns - Dietz Vesta and Adlake 250 Kero

David
Pittsford, NY

Jan 25, 2024
Five Erie and Lackawanna Railroad Dining Car Items - St. Albans China Plate, Silver Flatware, and

Eric
New York, NY

Jan 16, 2024
(2 of 2) Plus Many More
Repeating what I just left, earlier: I've now had numerous dealings with Rail & Road auctions, and I find them to be pleasingly competent, plus lots of fun in terms of what they have on offer. I will be keeping a sharp eye on what they have to offer.
Report
Erie Railroad China Starucca Reversal Demitasse with Saucer and Centennial Dinner Plate

Eric
New York, NY

Jan 16, 2024
1 of 2 (Plus Many More!)
I've now had numerous dealings with Rail & Road auctions, and I find them to be pleasingly competent, plus lots of fun in terms of what they have on offer. I will be keeping a sharp eye on what they have to offer.
Report
Four Pieces of Milwaukee Road Dining Car China Traveler Hot Food Cover, Lunch Plate, Bouillon Lid,

Adam
Hollis, NH

Dec 24, 2023
Do not expect your items to arrive undamged
I had purchased a number of items from this seller during a single auction. Several of the items were framed artwork, covered with glass, as typical for these kinds of items. The items were large and heavy. Suffice to say that the items were insufficiently packed in picture boxes, with a just + single layer of bubble wrap +. Just how the seller could expect these items, one of which was original artwork on canvas, to arrive unscathed, still confounds me to this day. The packages were shipped by insured UPS and arrived promptly. As any five year-old would understand, drop a heavy piece of glass or hit it with other potentially heavy boxes, and it’s gonna break. And shatter they did. As you will can imagine, shards of loose broken glass did no justice to the original artwork-it was destroyed in transit. Another picture arrived with broken glass and the corner of the frame damaged on account of insufficient packaging. Upon arrival, I immedialy called the issues to Derek Thomas, the owner of the auction house. While he was very congenial and offered to assist in processing a claim, he totally and thoroughly deflected any responsibility for the damage caused by his company’s failure to properly and safely package my purchases, placing the blame on solely upon UPS. The items were insured and the insurance company was swift in processing the claims and reimbursing me for the purchases and shipping fees. All said, if you are purchasing a fragile item from this seller, especially if it’s glass you should have zero expectation that it will arrive in anything but throw-away condition. Just be sure that your purchase is insured for full value and that you have empty space in your dumpster.
Report
Cadillac V-16 Photographic Print by Jorge Garcia - The Car and the Castle

Andy
Glendale, CA

Dec 12, 2023
Rail & Road Auctions logo
Rail & Road AuctionsDec 12, 2023
This package was damaged by UPS after being packed to the specifications of our consignor who shipped a number of these items previously. We offered to help file the appropriate claim with UPS and our shipping insurance carrier, and never received a reply or any images showing the damage.
1937 Pontiac Chrome Plated Ternstedt Cast Hood Ornament

T.J.
Port Huron, MI

Nov 22, 2023
GREAT AUCTIONEER. HIGHLY RECOMMEND.
I have dealt with Rail and Road Auctions on numerous occasions, and have always been pleased with quality of the service received. Derek and his crew have been great to deal with, and I will most definitely continue to be both a buyer and a seller with them.
Report
Six Golden State, Chicago, Rock Island, Southern Pacific and Pacific Railroad Roly Poly Glasses

Arthur
Verona, VA

Nov 17, 2023
Terrific auction house
Variety of RR stock offered is usually wide and of high quality. Effective on-line software w/nice real-time auctioneer pic-in-pic. Great people. Only 1 minor concern: I don't like packaging 'peanuts' (which I know help defray costs, lol). I'll deal w/it because they're worth it. AF
Report
Chesapeake & Ohio Railroad George Washington Service Plate 10 3/4"