Barton & Co., NY - Read over 44 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Barton & Co. (44)

4.3 out of 5.0 Stars

1-44 of 44 Reviews

Barbara
Knoxville, TN

Jan 07, 2026
Very helpful with all stages of auction and shipping
Absolutely beautiful items. Very helpful with all stages of purchase and shipping. Extremely pleased.
Report
Victorian Cameo Shell Lights, Pair

Carl
Manakin Sabot, VA

Jan 06, 2026
Ilya Bolotowsky, Modernist Silk Screen Print - E, Signed And Numbered

Christopher
Rocky Hill, CT

Jan 06, 2026
Barton & Co. logo
Barton & Co.Jan 06, 2026
Thank you!!!!
Mid Century Black Glass Stacked Ball Lamps

braddock
Buxton, ME

Nov 21, 2025
not sterling beware
not sterling as listed. This would be obvious even to novice when held in hand. never returned due to was not worth hassle
Report
Barton & Co. logo
Barton & Co.Jan 06, 2026
This is not a correct comment. Please delete this.
Pr Antique Hand Painted Green Glass and Sterling Wine Glasses

Dane
Sacramento, CA

Apr 20, 2025
Great shipping rates
This auction house is on a very short list of houses where I didn't feel gouged by the shipping.
Report
Plaster Cast Winston Churchill and Eisenhower Busts By Nemon

Catherine
Rockville, MD

Mar 19, 2025
Italian, Garofano Faenza for Sigma Ceramic Tableware

Patricia
Southampton, NY

Mar 18, 2025
Antique Sterling Silver and Mother of Pearl Baby Rattle and Teething Ring

Suzanne
Williamston, MI

Mar 18, 2025
Some items from lot arrived broken
Items were as advertised. I had to contact the auction house at least a week after to inquire about shipping. Items were then shipped quickly but some arrived broken. Contacted auction house several times to get a response. Communication is slow and issue not yet resolved.
Report
Barton & Co. logo
Barton & Co.Mar 24, 2025
Thank you for your feedback Suzanne. 2 of your 6 plates from one of your two lots were broken when you opened your box. We are so sorry for this. we offered to accomodate you We offered to refund you $8 oif the $25 for the lot and you are now asking for $20.
c. 1850 Flow Mulberry Ironstone Plates, Podmore Walker

Roxanne
Alpine, CA

Mar 18, 2025
Great packaging
Packaged items well
Report
Ironstone Pitcher

Kathleen
Brooklyn, NY

Mar 18, 2025
Barton is the best!
Thanks for all your help Cori! All our items came just in time to look fabulous in our set.
Report
Antique hand Painted Tea Canister Table Lamps

Patti
Bridgehampton, NY

Mar 18, 2025
Unique Pair of Vintage Gilt Metal Candlesticks

Tony
Brightwood, VA

Dec 15, 2024
A Wonderful First-Time Experience with Barton & Company
This was my first time participating in an auction held by Barton & Company, and it was a positive experience from start to finish. The LiveAuctioneers shipping quote was quite high, so I was delighted when Cori offered to pack and ship this chess set for a very reasonable rate. The detail of the chess pieces is extraordinary, and the storage case with its perfectly sized spaces for each piece serves as the playing board when turned over. Cori packed everything carefully, and the set arrived in fine condition. I look forward to participating in future auctions by Barton & Company!
Report
Japanese Carved Bone Chess Set With Wooden Board

Jenny
East Hampton, NY

Dec 10, 2024
Barton & Co. has the best items and follow up is professional and lovely in every way.
Barton & Co. has the best items and follow up is professional and lovely in every way.
Report
Aerin Lauder Gilt and Celadon Vases

Gerald
Buffalo, NY

Oct 30, 2024
Grace Knowlton, "Socialite Ceramists" Raku Fired Ceramic Sphere c.1982,

Steven
Madison, WI

Aug 19, 2024
They should have shipped this after numerous attempts
They never shipped the item, after many emails. At least they should consider a refund. I'm sure they will have their excuse, but there is no excuse, either ship the item paid for, or refund. Neither happened.
Report
Atomic Age Ice Bucket

Alejandro
North Haledon, NJ

May 09, 2024
Excellent.
Very happy all around.
Report
Louis XVI Style, Gilt Bronze Ormilou and Granite Body and Base Candlesticks

BRENNA
New York, NY

May 08, 2024
Vintage Tin Litho, Book Themed Banks

William
Waverly, OH

May 07, 2024
Large Cast Iron Pig Piggy Bank

Jenny
East Hampton, NY

May 07, 2024
They have great items and great customer service too!
So impressed with Barton & Co they have access to great items and present them well and accurately and customer service is excellent.
Report
Five Japanese Stoneware Plates with White Glaze

Jenny
East Hampton, NY

Mar 17, 2024
I am so impressed with both the quality of descriptions and responsiveness in general.
Barton & Co has never let me down. I have bid and won countless items over the years at auction with Barton & Co and find them to be professional and responsive and have the best most swoon worthy items to bid on. They seem to have access to the best collections and treat their customers/shoppers with respect. Highly recommend.
Report
Van Briggle Pottery Mulberry Lotus Leaf

Judy
New York, NY

Mar 17, 2024
Excellent selection and excellent service
Barton & Co. is one of my favorite sellers and I always follow their sales. Cori has an excellent eye for antiques and art, and has a good enough reputation that she also is entrusted to sell a lot of high-end furniture and other items from known retailers. There always is a combination of fun, eclectic pieces and coveted brand names. What Good descriptions, and quick response if you need more information. Service is dependable; the one and only time there was an issue with a sale she took care of it right away. I've never gone wrong buying from them or selling with them.
Report
Antiqe Cranberry Etched Glass Tumblers, Deer and Dot

Clinton
East Hampton, NY

Mar 14, 2024
Great experience
Was an overall great experience Definitely would buy from them again
Report
Barton & Co. logo
Barton & Co.Mar 14, 2024
Thank you Clinton! You're the best!
Nancy Davis, Original Watercolor Landscape Painting on Paper

Lauri
Norway, MI

Mar 12, 2024
A wonderful experience
I was so excited to have the opportunity to bid on some highly sought after ironstone cake stands. Everything went smoothly after winning the auction, and my items were shipped and arrived very well packaged. Barton & Co. did an amazing job!
Report
Barton & Co. logo
Barton & Co.Mar 12, 2024
Thank you so much for participating and for taking your valued time to write this review. Your feedback is much appreciated!!
Antique Ironstone and Unmarked Cake Stands and Fruit Platter

Francesco
Polanco Ii Sección, MX

Mar 05, 2024
happy customer
Package received, everything packed perfectly, the products are better than in the photo
Report
Linda Levinson & Callan Gilt Picture Frames

Zhang
Beijing, CN

Oct 29, 2023
miserable experience
This is a private workshop, very unprofessional and irresponsible. Before the auction, I asked about the packaging and freight, and Barton & co. told me it was US $500. After purchasing the goods, he would be charged US $1, 000 for only transporting 2/3 of the goods. I had no choice but to accept his price increase. However, even though the shipping cost more than doubled, he still used cheap second-hand materials, coupled with very irresponsible packaging techniques, resulting in both items being broken. Communicated with him about compensation and did not reply at all. I also suspected that he deliberately concealed the condition of the lot. In his description, it was very good, but the goods received were glued together. For antiques, this is the difference between heaven and earth. So this is an auction company that is completely untrustworthy. I have asked Liveauctioneers to step in and resolve the issue. If there is still no result, I will definitely take it to court.
Report
Barton & Co. logo
Barton & Co.Mar 12, 2024
Please never try to challenge the necessary costs for shipping to china. If you do not want to pay for proper crating, you will most likely, and unfortunately, receive items broken because the materials your budget allowed for is not suitable for international shipping. We gave our best with what your parameters would allow. We were very expendable to you during all 11 phone calls your daughter made to us asking many questions and trying to barter the fees.
Monumental Chinese Han Terracotta Figure of a Demon

zhengjianmei
Gresham, OR

Oct 17, 2023
24K Gold Chinese Zodiak Figurines

alison
Bellport, NY

Sep 16, 2023
You do not always get your won items
Upon arrival to pick up my 4 items, 2 were not there and no one knew I was coming. One item apparently got shipped out of state with the original owner’s other things. The other item was with the auctioneer. She said she would mail it to me. She apologized and said she had not seen my email that I was coming to pick up my items. Then she apologized for the other item not being there and said she ‘ … lost sleep over it.. ’ after searching the house all night for the item and blamed the owners. Which I was confused about because she said she didn’t know I was coming … I received the 2nd missing item about 6 weeks after purchase because it apparently got thrown away. Again blamed on the original owner. Then it suddenly it appeared and was mailed to me. Lots of discrepancies in the stories. And I was very disappointed on not receiving the first item I won that while I was refunded for it, was the one item I was there for initially.
Report
Barton & Co. logo
Barton & Co.Oct 30, 2023
Wow sorry you are so upset! YEESH.
Gorgeous Gorham "Jolie" Etched Pattern Crystal Champagne Flutes

Virginia
Okemos, MI

Jun 28, 2023
Whiting Davis Snake Hinged Bangle Bracelet

Vicki
Niskayuna, NY

Jun 28, 2023
Sterling and Amber Oval Pendant or Brooch

Victor
Palm Beach, FL

Feb 07, 2023
Barton & Co. logo
Barton & Co.Jun 28, 2023
Thank you for your business!!
Antique Bamboo 3 Tier Etagere

Missy
Studio City, CA

Feb 03, 2023
Framed Folk Art Style Painting

Erika
Haddon Heights, NJ

Jan 28, 2023
Best auction experience ever
This was an amazing auction experience start to finish. Such interesting items, beautifully photographed. I had questions about some lots which Cori answered very promptly. Packing of my item was outstanding, which meant a lot as it was a gift. Both Cori and Katie were a complete pleasure to deal with. Happy to follow and purchase again. Thank you Barton & Co!
Report
Barton & Co. logo
Barton & Co.Mar 01, 2023
Thank you so much Erika for your kind words!! We absolutely loved working with you and hearing about how special your item was as a sentimental gift for your sister! We look forward to working with you again soon!
Antique D.M. Ferry & Co., Choice Flower Seeds Oak Box

Jeffrey
San Francisco, CA

Jan 28, 2023
Meissen White Porcelain Bisque (Biscuit) Ware Figures, Late 18th-Early 19th Century

Joshua
Knoxville, TN

Nov 09, 2022
Arts And Crafts Oak Rocking Chair

Rachel
Water Mill, NY

Oct 12, 2022
Excellent items and service
This auction house went above and beyond to answer my questions and ensure that the bidding and buying process was a positive experience. I love my items and will definitely be purchasing from them again in the future. Highly recommend! Can’t wait to keep following their sales.
Report
Royal Cauldon "Bittersweet" Tea Set

Mindy
New York, NY

Aug 30, 2022
Original, Oil on Canvas, Floral Arrangement, Donald Purdy

Gary Ross
Madison, CT

Aug 28, 2022
This is a great system!
The Barton/LiveAuctioneers system worked really well for us, after many months of watching the regular emails on items matching our search pattern, a collection of important works by that artist/maker came up, so I placed a bid corresponding to what I could reasonably afford to spend for it but fully expected to be outbid, and on auction day I won which came as a complete surprise. The shipping went very well, and now we are thrilled to be enjoying theses pieces we would not have known of or had any chance to own, but for this system.
Report
Set of 12 Moser Bohemian Glass and Decanter

Howard
Brick, NJ

Jun 26, 2022
Monotype Print "In Theater" Wilder, 1962

Joe
Fort Lauderdale, FL

Apr 26, 2022
Perfect Experience!
All good all the way around. Good auctioneer and recommended. Thank you
Report
Tiffany & Co Makers, Knife Rests

Dong
Beijing, CN

Apr 11, 2022
It's too bad.
I bought thirteen pieces of jewelry from this auction company, and when I received the goods, I found that two were missing, and another one was crushed. I was very angry and got in touch with the auction company. The auction company told me that one item is still in their company, and they don't know where the other one is? And the crushed one doesn't say anything. First of all, I asked the other party to send me the remaining one, but I haven't replied yet. How can such an auction company do business in the future? It's too bad.
Report
Barton & Co. logo
Barton & Co.Apr 14, 2022
Apologies for your experience. We replied telling you you would receive the piece that was missing, and a refund for 1/4 of your sale! Do not know how one bracelet did not make its way to CHINA... we do our best and sometimes strange oversights happen.
Chinese Sterling Filagree and Enamel Jewelry

John
Roslyn, NY

Mar 27, 2022
Joan Miro Abstract Print

David
New York, NY

Dec 25, 2021
Cleo Brass Tripod Wishbone Lamp

Ariane
Bay Head, NJ

Aug 18, 2021
Mid Century Rattan Wall Mirror

Christine
Fairhope, AL

Jul 24, 2021
Excellent Customer Service and products were shipped quickly!
I will definitely use Barton & Co. again. I appreciated their quick response to my questions and they packed and delivered all items very quickly. I was very happy with them!
Report
Limoges Blue Gold Round Box