Buffalo Nickel

Easy Shipping

US Only

Newly Listed

Top Rated House

849 Lots

Sort by:

Most Relevant

1917-D Buffalo Nickel MS62 NGC: 1917-D Buffalo Nickel MS62 NGC The 1917-D Buffalo Nickel MS62 NGC boasts a rich history, bearing the distinctive signature of its renowned designer, James Earle Fraser. This circulated coin is certifi

18 hrs Left

1917-D Buffalo Nickel MS62 NGC

$240

1937-D 3 LEGS THREE LEGGED BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS64 CAC - VERY PQ: 1937-D 3 LEGS THREE LEGGED BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS64 CAC - VERY PQ The 1937-D Buffalo Nickel boasts an impressive MS64 grade, showcasing exceptional detail and luster. This NGC-certified coin features t

Jul 20, 2026

1937-D 3 LEGS THREE LEGGED BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS64 CAC - VERY PQ

$3,400

Buffalo nickel 1916 D PQ gorgeous color: Buffalo nickel 1916 D PQ gorgeous color The 1916 D PQ Buffalo nickel boasts a gorgeous color, making it a standout among its peers. Certified MS 66 by PCGS, this coin's high grade ensures its exceptio

6 days Left

Buffalo nickel 1916 D PQ gorgeous color

$1,850

1914-S 5C NGC MS64 - Buffalo Nickel: 1914-S 5C NGC MS64 - Buffalo Nickel The 1914-S Buffalo Nickel, graded MS64 by the NGC, showcases exceptional minting quality with its San Francisco Mint mark. This uncirculated coin features a strikin

3 days Left

1914-S 5C NGC MS64 - Buffalo Nickel

$290

Vintage Buffalo Hobo Nickel: and another

Vintage Buffalo Hobo Nickel

Thomas Hirchak Company

$10

(1 bid)

PCGS MS67 Buffalo Nickel 5C 1925: PCGS MS67 Buffalo Nickel 5C 1925 PCGS MS67 Buffalo Nickel 5C 1925, certified by the prestigious Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) with a high grade of 67, showcases exceptional condition and mi

6 days Left

PCGS MS67 Buffalo Nickel 5C 1925

$1,400

1937-S Buffalo Nickel MS67 PCGS: 1937-S Buffalo Nickel MS67 PCGS The 1937-S Buffalo Nickel MS67 PCGS is a highly graded, uncirculated example of the iconic coin series. With its distinctive buffalo design and high-grade certification

3 days Left

1937-S Buffalo Nickel MS67 PCGS

$305

Buffalo Nickel 1920 D 5C PCGS AU55: Buffalo Nickel 1920 D 5C PCGS AU55 The Buffalo Nickel 1920 D 5C PCGS AU55 features a striking design from the Denver Mint, showcasing the iconic bison on its reverse. This circulated coin has been cer

2 days Left

Buffalo Nickel 1920 D 5C PCGS AU55

$205

1919 5C PCGS MS65 - Buffalo Nickel: 1919 5C PCGS MS65 - Buffalo Nickel The 1919 Buffalo Nickel, graded MS65 by PCGS, showcases exceptional detail and luster. This uncirculated coin features the iconic Buffalo nickel design, with its dis

2 days Left

1919 5C PCGS MS65 - Buffalo Nickel

$175

** KEY DATE ** PCGS 1914-D Buffalo Nickel in Mint State 64: KEY DATE! Great Luster! Purt near GEM!

** KEY DATE ** PCGS 1914-D Buffalo Nickel in Mint State 64

$550

(1 bid)

1913-S TYPE 2 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, PCGS XF DETAILS, ENV. DAMAGE. EXTREMELY FINE: 1913-S TYPE 2 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, PCGS XF DETAILS, ENV. DAMAGE. EXTREMELY FINE 1913-S Type 2 Buffalo Nickel 5C, PCGS XF Details, Env Damage Extremely Fine THE ITEM(S) IN THE PHOTO(S) IS THE EXACT ITEM(

22 hrs Left

1913-S TYPE 2 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, PCGS XF DETAILS, ENV. DAMAGE. EXTREMELY FINE

$620

1921-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, PCGS XF DETAILS, SCRATCH. EXTREMELY FINE: 1921-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, PCGS XF DETAILS, SCRATCH. EXTREMELY FINE 1921-S Buffalo Nickel 5C, PCGS XF Details, Scratch Extremely Fine THE ITEM(S) IN THE PHOTO(S) IS THE EXACT ITEM(S) YOU WILL RECEIVE!

22 hrs Left

1921-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, PCGS XF DETAILS, SCRATCH. EXTREMELY FINE

$590

1913-D TYPE 1 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, ABOUT UNCIRCULATED AU+, MINOR LAMINATION ERROR: 1913-D TYPE 1 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, ABOUT UNCIRCULATED AU+, MINOR LAMINATION ERROR 1913-D Type 1 Buffalo Nickel 5C, About Uncirculated AU+, Minor Lamination Error Minor planchet lamination error at rever

22 hrs Left

1913-D TYPE 1 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, ABOUT UNCIRCULATED AU+, MINOR LAMINATION ERROR

$135

Buffalo Nickel 1928-5c NGC MS66: Buffalo Nickel 1928-5c NGC MS66 The Buffalo Nickel 1928-5c NGC MS66 is a highly detailed and well-preserved coin, certified by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) for its Mint State 66 grade. Th

6 days Left

Buffalo Nickel 1928-5c NGC MS66

$1,000

Mint error! Nice 1913 Type II Buffalo Nickel in About Uncirculated plus: The planchet has a lot of striations in it. Kind of like a lot of little laminations, almost!

Mint error! Nice 1913 Type II Buffalo Nickel in About Uncirculated plus

$1

1915-S Buffalo Nickel EF40 PCGS: 1915-S Buffalo Nickel EF40 PCGS The 1915-S Buffalo Nickel EF40 PCGS is a circulated example from the San Francisco mint, bearing the signature of James Earle Fraser. With a mintage of over 1.5 million

2 hrs Left

1915-S Buffalo Nickel EF40 PCGS

$165

Semi-Key 1919-S Buffalo Nickel in About Uncirculated plus: Natural surfaces

Semi-Key 1919-S Buffalo Nickel in About Uncirculated plus

$210

(17 bids)

KEY DATE 1913-S Buffalo Nickel: Type 2

KEY DATE 1913-S Buffalo Nickel

$1

Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS67: Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS67 The Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS67 is an uncirculated coin with a high grade of 67, certified by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC). This 1930-dated nickel features the i

6 days Left

Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS67

$670

MS65+ PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1924-5c: MS65+ PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1924-5c MS65+ PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1924-5c features a high-grade certification from the prestigious Professional Coin Grading Service, with a grade of MS65+, indicating except

Jul 25, 2026

MS65+ PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1924-5c

$1,725

Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC 1935: Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC 1935 MS66 Buffalo Nickel from 1935, certified by the NGC as Uncirculated, boasts exceptional detail and luster. This coin features a rich composition of nickel, with a distinct

4 days Left

Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC 1935

$175

THREE HUNDRED Buffalo Nickels: All in Very Good to Very Fine plus

THREE HUNDRED Buffalo Nickels

$120

(12 bids)

1913-S TYPE 1 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, NGC AU58, ABOUT UNCIRCULATED, TONED: 1913-S TYPE 1 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, NGC AU58, ABOUT UNCIRCULATED, TONED 1913-S Type 1 Buffalo Nickel 5C, NGC AU58, About Uncirculated, Toned

22 hrs Left

1913-S TYPE 1 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, NGC AU58, ABOUT UNCIRCULATED, TONED

$305

1914-D Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC: 1914-D Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC The 1914-D Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC boasts exceptional condition, with its circulated state and high grade of MS66. Certified by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC)

Jul 22, 2026

1914-D Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC

$1,050

View:

24

Easy Shipping

US Only

Newly Listed

Top Rated House

849 Lots

Sort by:

Most Relevant

1917-D Buffalo Nickel MS62 NGC: 1917-D Buffalo Nickel MS62 NGC The 1917-D Buffalo Nickel MS62 NGC boasts a rich history, bearing the distinctive signature of its renowned designer, James Earle Fraser. This circulated coin is certifi

18 hrs Left

1917-D Buffalo Nickel MS62 NGC

$240

1937-D 3 LEGS THREE LEGGED BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS64 CAC - VERY PQ: 1937-D 3 LEGS THREE LEGGED BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS64 CAC - VERY PQ The 1937-D Buffalo Nickel boasts an impressive MS64 grade, showcasing exceptional detail and luster. This NGC-certified coin features t

Jul 20, 2026

1937-D 3 LEGS THREE LEGGED BUFFALO NICKEL NGC MS64 CAC - VERY PQ

$3,400

Buffalo nickel 1916 D PQ gorgeous color: Buffalo nickel 1916 D PQ gorgeous color The 1916 D PQ Buffalo nickel boasts a gorgeous color, making it a standout among its peers. Certified MS 66 by PCGS, this coin's high grade ensures its exceptio

6 days Left

Buffalo nickel 1916 D PQ gorgeous color

$1,850

1914-S 5C NGC MS64 - Buffalo Nickel: 1914-S 5C NGC MS64 - Buffalo Nickel The 1914-S Buffalo Nickel, graded MS64 by the NGC, showcases exceptional minting quality with its San Francisco Mint mark. This uncirculated coin features a strikin

3 days Left

1914-S 5C NGC MS64 - Buffalo Nickel

$290

Vintage Buffalo Hobo Nickel: and another

Vintage Buffalo Hobo Nickel

Thomas Hirchak Company

$10

(1 bid)

PCGS MS67 Buffalo Nickel 5C 1925: PCGS MS67 Buffalo Nickel 5C 1925 PCGS MS67 Buffalo Nickel 5C 1925, certified by the prestigious Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) with a high grade of 67, showcases exceptional condition and mi

6 days Left

PCGS MS67 Buffalo Nickel 5C 1925

$1,400

1937-S Buffalo Nickel MS67 PCGS: 1937-S Buffalo Nickel MS67 PCGS The 1937-S Buffalo Nickel MS67 PCGS is a highly graded, uncirculated example of the iconic coin series. With its distinctive buffalo design and high-grade certification

3 days Left

1937-S Buffalo Nickel MS67 PCGS

$305

Buffalo Nickel 1920 D 5C PCGS AU55: Buffalo Nickel 1920 D 5C PCGS AU55 The Buffalo Nickel 1920 D 5C PCGS AU55 features a striking design from the Denver Mint, showcasing the iconic bison on its reverse. This circulated coin has been cer

2 days Left

Buffalo Nickel 1920 D 5C PCGS AU55

$205

1919 5C PCGS MS65 - Buffalo Nickel: 1919 5C PCGS MS65 - Buffalo Nickel The 1919 Buffalo Nickel, graded MS65 by PCGS, showcases exceptional detail and luster. This uncirculated coin features the iconic Buffalo nickel design, with its dis

2 days Left

1919 5C PCGS MS65 - Buffalo Nickel

$175

** KEY DATE ** PCGS 1914-D Buffalo Nickel in Mint State 64: KEY DATE! Great Luster! Purt near GEM!

** KEY DATE ** PCGS 1914-D Buffalo Nickel in Mint State 64

$550

(1 bid)

1913-S TYPE 2 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, PCGS XF DETAILS, ENV. DAMAGE. EXTREMELY FINE: 1913-S TYPE 2 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, PCGS XF DETAILS, ENV. DAMAGE. EXTREMELY FINE 1913-S Type 2 Buffalo Nickel 5C, PCGS XF Details, Env Damage Extremely Fine THE ITEM(S) IN THE PHOTO(S) IS THE EXACT ITEM(

22 hrs Left

1913-S TYPE 2 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, PCGS XF DETAILS, ENV. DAMAGE. EXTREMELY FINE

$620

1921-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, PCGS XF DETAILS, SCRATCH. EXTREMELY FINE: 1921-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, PCGS XF DETAILS, SCRATCH. EXTREMELY FINE 1921-S Buffalo Nickel 5C, PCGS XF Details, Scratch Extremely Fine THE ITEM(S) IN THE PHOTO(S) IS THE EXACT ITEM(S) YOU WILL RECEIVE!

22 hrs Left

1921-S BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, PCGS XF DETAILS, SCRATCH. EXTREMELY FINE

$590

1913-D TYPE 1 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, ABOUT UNCIRCULATED AU+, MINOR LAMINATION ERROR: 1913-D TYPE 1 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, ABOUT UNCIRCULATED AU+, MINOR LAMINATION ERROR 1913-D Type 1 Buffalo Nickel 5C, About Uncirculated AU+, Minor Lamination Error Minor planchet lamination error at rever

22 hrs Left

1913-D TYPE 1 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, ABOUT UNCIRCULATED AU+, MINOR LAMINATION ERROR

$135

Buffalo Nickel 1928-5c NGC MS66: Buffalo Nickel 1928-5c NGC MS66 The Buffalo Nickel 1928-5c NGC MS66 is a highly detailed and well-preserved coin, certified by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) for its Mint State 66 grade. Th

6 days Left

Buffalo Nickel 1928-5c NGC MS66

$1,000

Mint error! Nice 1913 Type II Buffalo Nickel in About Uncirculated plus: The planchet has a lot of striations in it. Kind of like a lot of little laminations, almost!

Mint error! Nice 1913 Type II Buffalo Nickel in About Uncirculated plus

$1

1915-S Buffalo Nickel EF40 PCGS: 1915-S Buffalo Nickel EF40 PCGS The 1915-S Buffalo Nickel EF40 PCGS is a circulated example from the San Francisco mint, bearing the signature of James Earle Fraser. With a mintage of over 1.5 million

2 hrs Left

1915-S Buffalo Nickel EF40 PCGS

$165

Semi-Key 1919-S Buffalo Nickel in About Uncirculated plus: Natural surfaces

Semi-Key 1919-S Buffalo Nickel in About Uncirculated plus

$210

(17 bids)

KEY DATE 1913-S Buffalo Nickel: Type 2

KEY DATE 1913-S Buffalo Nickel

$1

Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS67: Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS67 The Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS67 is an uncirculated coin with a high grade of 67, certified by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC). This 1930-dated nickel features the i

6 days Left

Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS67

$670

MS65+ PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1924-5c: MS65+ PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1924-5c MS65+ PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1924-5c features a high-grade certification from the prestigious Professional Coin Grading Service, with a grade of MS65+, indicating except

Jul 25, 2026

MS65+ PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1924-5c

$1,725

Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC 1935: Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC 1935 MS66 Buffalo Nickel from 1935, certified by the NGC as Uncirculated, boasts exceptional detail and luster. This coin features a rich composition of nickel, with a distinct

4 days Left

Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC 1935

$175

THREE HUNDRED Buffalo Nickels: All in Very Good to Very Fine plus

THREE HUNDRED Buffalo Nickels

$120

(12 bids)

1913-S TYPE 1 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, NGC AU58, ABOUT UNCIRCULATED, TONED: 1913-S TYPE 1 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, NGC AU58, ABOUT UNCIRCULATED, TONED 1913-S Type 1 Buffalo Nickel 5C, NGC AU58, About Uncirculated, Toned

22 hrs Left

1913-S TYPE 1 BUFFALO NICKEL 5C, NGC AU58, ABOUT UNCIRCULATED, TONED

$305

1914-D Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC: 1914-D Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC The 1914-D Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC boasts exceptional condition, with its circulated state and high grade of MS66. Certified by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC)

Jul 22, 2026

1914-D Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC

$1,050

View:

24

TOP