Buffalo nickel

Easy Shipping

US Only

Newly Listed

Top Rated House

674 Lots

Sort by:

Most Relevant

Eighteen Circulated Buffalo Nickels: Two 1914-S, 1915-S, 1917-D and 1918-D. Thirteen mixed dates and grades

Eighteen Circulated Buffalo Nickels

$1

1921-S Buffalo Nickel EF45 NGC: 1921-S Buffalo Nickel EF45 NGC The 1921-S Buffalo Nickel EF45 NGC is a highly detailed and well-preserved circulated coin, certified by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation. With its striking design an

Sep 10, 2026

1921-S Buffalo Nickel EF45 NGC

$275

Uncertified Choice BU Nickel Buffalo 1923: Uncertified Choice BU Nickel Buffalo 1923 Choice BU Nickel Buffalo 1923, featuring the iconic design of James Earle Fraser's Buffalo nickel, with its copper composition and classic design elements. Th

2 days Left

Uncertified Choice BU Nickel Buffalo 1923

$74

1938-D/ S 5C Buffalo NGC MS67 - Buffalo Nickel - Popular Variety: 1938-D/ S 5C Buffalo NGC MS67 - Buffalo Nickel - Popular Variety The 1938-D/ S Buffalo Nickel, certified NGC MS67, boasts a striking appearance with its distinct design elements. This popular variety

Sep 13, 2026

1938-D/ S 5C Buffalo NGC MS67 - Buffalo Nickel - Popular Variety

$200

1913 Buffalo Nickel Type 1 DDR FS-1802 MS64 PCGS: 1913 Buffalo Nickel Type 1 DDR FS-1802 MS64 PCGS The 1913 Buffalo Nickel Type 1 DDR FS-1802 MS64 PCGS is a highly graded example of the iconic coin, boasting a stunning MS64 condition that showcases i

Sep 8, 2026

1913 Buffalo Nickel Type 1 DDR FS-1802 MS64 PCGS

$420

Buffalo Nickel MS65 NGC: Buffalo Nickel MS65 NGC The 1924 Buffalo Nickel MS65 NGC is a highly graded, uncirculated example of the iconic nickel coin. With its rich history and stunning condition, this coin showcases exception

Sep 14, 2026

Buffalo Nickel MS65 NGC

$325

Nickel Buffalo 1919-D F12 PCGS: Nickel Buffalo 1919-D F12 PCGS The 1919-D Buffalo nickel is a highly detailed and intricately designed coin, featuring the work of renowned artist James Earle Fraser. With a rich history and a mintage

9 hrs Left

Nickel Buffalo 1919-D F12 PCGS

$30

Twenty-four Mixed Buffalo Nickels: Assorted Dates and Grades

Twenty-four Mixed Buffalo Nickels

$1

1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 Choice BU Uncertified: 1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 Choice BU Uncertified Choice BU Uncertified 1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 boasts its high-grade condition, showcasing the coin's natural beauty. This uncirculated specimen

Sep 7, 2026

1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 Choice BU Uncertified

$405

MS67 PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1937-S: MS67 PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1937-S MS67 PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1937-S is a highly graded, uncirculated buffalo nickel with a strong certification from PCGS. Certified to be in excellent condition, this coin

Sep 10, 2026

MS67 PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1937-S

$220

1914-S 5C NGC MS64 - Buffalo Nickel: 1914-S 5C NGC MS64 - Buffalo Nickel The 1914-S Buffalo Nickel is an uncirculated coin with a high level of detail and luster, showcasing its MS64 grade. Certified by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporatio

Sep 5, 2026

1914-S 5C NGC MS64 - Buffalo Nickel

$290

1935-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-801 AU55 PCGS: 1935-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-801 AU55 PCGS The 1935-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-801 AU55 PCGS is a circulated example from the San Francisco Mint, featuring James Earle Fraser's iconic design. With its di

Sep 8, 2026

1935-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-801 AU55 PCGS

$305

MS65 Buffalo Nickel 1929-D: MS65 Buffalo Nickel 1929-D MS65 Buffalo Nickel 1929-D is a highly detailed and accurate representation of the 1929-D Buffalo Nickel, certified by PCGS as circulated. This coin features a striking desi

Sep 10, 2026

MS65 Buffalo Nickel 1929-D

$255

Buffalo Nickel 1914-S 5C MS64: Buffalo Nickel 1914-S 5C MS64 The Buffalo Nickel 1914-S 5C MS64 is an uncirculated coin with a rich history, featuring the iconic design of James Earle Fraser's buffalo on its reverse. Certified by PC

Sep 11, 2026

Buffalo Nickel 1914-S 5C MS64

$310

MS66 Buffalo Nickel 1934: MS66 Buffalo Nickel 1934 MS66 Buffalo Nickel 1934 is a highly graded uncirculated example of this iconic coin, certified by the NGC. Featuring a rich history and distinctive design, this 1934 Buffalo

Sep 3, 2026

MS66 Buffalo Nickel 1934

$160

1926 5C CACG MS66+ - Buffalo Nickel: 1926 5C CACG MS66+ - Buffalo Nickel The 1926 Buffalo Nickel, graded MS66+, boasts exceptional condition with minimal wear. Certified by CACG, its high grade reflects the coin's impressive state of pre

Sep 12, 2026

1926 5C CACG MS66+ - Buffalo Nickel

$310

1925 Buffalo Nickel MS65+ PCGS (CAC): 1925 Buffalo Nickel MS65+ PCGS (CAC) MS65+ PCGS certified 1925 Buffalo Nickel, bearing the distinctive buffalo design and made from nickel coin composition. This circulated/uncirculated coin features

Sep 15, 2026

1925 Buffalo Nickel MS65+ PCGS (CAC)

$275

MS65 PCGS CAC Buffalo Nickel 1915: MS65 PCGS CAC Buffalo Nickel 1915 MS65 PCGS CAC Buffalo Nickel 1915 - A highly graded example of the iconic Buffalo nickel, certified by PCGS as MS65 and marked with a CAC (Certification of Authentici

Sep 9, 2026

MS65 PCGS CAC Buffalo Nickel 1915

$240

1913 5C PCGS MS67 (Type 1) - Buffalo Nickel - Popular One Year Type Coin: 1913 5C PCGS MS67 (Type 1) - Buffalo Nickel - Popular One Year Type Coin 1913 Buffalo Nickel, graded MS67 by PCGS, showcases the Type 1 design featuring a buffalo on the obverse and a shield on the re

Sep 10, 2026

1913 5C PCGS MS67 (Type 1) - Buffalo Nickel - Popular One Year Type Coin

$425

1931-S Buffalo Nickel DDR 1-R-VI MS66 PCGS: 1931-S Buffalo Nickel DDR 1-R-VI MS66 PCGS The 1931-S Buffalo Nickel DDR 1-R-VI MS66 PCGS is a highly graded circulated coin, certified by the prestigious Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) as M

Sep 13, 2026

1931-S Buffalo Nickel DDR 1-R-VI MS66 PCGS

$305

1936 Buffalo Nickel DDO FS-101 MS64 PCGS: 1936 Buffalo Nickel DDO FS-101 MS64 PCGS The 1936 Buffalo Nickel DDO FS-101 MS64 PCGS is a highly detailed and well-graded coin, certified by the PCGS as MS64, indicating a high level of mint state co

Sep 3, 2026

1936 Buffalo Nickel DDO FS-101 MS64 PCGS

$145

1926-S 5C PCGS Fine 12 - Buffalo Nickel - Popular Key Date: 1926-S 5C PCGS Fine 12 - Buffalo Nickel - Popular Key Date The 1926-S Buffalo Nickel, graded PCGS Fine 12, showcases the iconic design of the San Francisco Mint. This circulated coin features a well-w

5 days Left

1926-S 5C PCGS Fine 12 - Buffalo Nickel - Popular Key Date

$52

1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF35 NGC: 1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF35 NGC The 1924-S Buffalo Nickel is a highly sought-after coin, featuring the iconic design of James Earle Fraser's buffalo. Certified by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (N

Sep 7, 2026

1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF35 NGC

$240

1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF35 NGC: 1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF35 NGC The 1926-S Buffalo Nickel, graded VF35 by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC), showcases its circulated condition with subtle wear and a rich history. This coin be

Sep 7, 2026

1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF35 NGC

$225

View:

24

Easy Shipping

US Only

Newly Listed

Top Rated House

674 Lots

Sort by:

Most Relevant

Eighteen Circulated Buffalo Nickels: Two 1914-S, 1915-S, 1917-D and 1918-D. Thirteen mixed dates and grades

Eighteen Circulated Buffalo Nickels

$1

1921-S Buffalo Nickel EF45 NGC: 1921-S Buffalo Nickel EF45 NGC The 1921-S Buffalo Nickel EF45 NGC is a highly detailed and well-preserved circulated coin, certified by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation. With its striking design an

Sep 10, 2026

1921-S Buffalo Nickel EF45 NGC

$275

Uncertified Choice BU Nickel Buffalo 1923: Uncertified Choice BU Nickel Buffalo 1923 Choice BU Nickel Buffalo 1923, featuring the iconic design of James Earle Fraser's Buffalo nickel, with its copper composition and classic design elements. Th

2 days Left

Uncertified Choice BU Nickel Buffalo 1923

$74

1938-D/ S 5C Buffalo NGC MS67 - Buffalo Nickel - Popular Variety: 1938-D/ S 5C Buffalo NGC MS67 - Buffalo Nickel - Popular Variety The 1938-D/ S Buffalo Nickel, certified NGC MS67, boasts a striking appearance with its distinct design elements. This popular variety

Sep 13, 2026

1938-D/ S 5C Buffalo NGC MS67 - Buffalo Nickel - Popular Variety

$200

1913 Buffalo Nickel Type 1 DDR FS-1802 MS64 PCGS: 1913 Buffalo Nickel Type 1 DDR FS-1802 MS64 PCGS The 1913 Buffalo Nickel Type 1 DDR FS-1802 MS64 PCGS is a highly graded example of the iconic coin, boasting a stunning MS64 condition that showcases i

Sep 8, 2026

1913 Buffalo Nickel Type 1 DDR FS-1802 MS64 PCGS

$420

Buffalo Nickel MS65 NGC: Buffalo Nickel MS65 NGC The 1924 Buffalo Nickel MS65 NGC is a highly graded, uncirculated example of the iconic nickel coin. With its rich history and stunning condition, this coin showcases exception

Sep 14, 2026

Buffalo Nickel MS65 NGC

$325

Nickel Buffalo 1919-D F12 PCGS: Nickel Buffalo 1919-D F12 PCGS The 1919-D Buffalo nickel is a highly detailed and intricately designed coin, featuring the work of renowned artist James Earle Fraser. With a rich history and a mintage

9 hrs Left

Nickel Buffalo 1919-D F12 PCGS

$30

Twenty-four Mixed Buffalo Nickels: Assorted Dates and Grades

Twenty-four Mixed Buffalo Nickels

$1

1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 Choice BU Uncertified: 1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 Choice BU Uncertified Choice BU Uncertified 1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 boasts its high-grade condition, showcasing the coin's natural beauty. This uncirculated specimen

Sep 7, 2026

1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 Choice BU Uncertified

$405

MS67 PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1937-S: MS67 PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1937-S MS67 PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1937-S is a highly graded, uncirculated buffalo nickel with a strong certification from PCGS. Certified to be in excellent condition, this coin

Sep 10, 2026

MS67 PCGS Buffalo Nickel 1937-S

$220

1914-S 5C NGC MS64 - Buffalo Nickel: 1914-S 5C NGC MS64 - Buffalo Nickel The 1914-S Buffalo Nickel is an uncirculated coin with a high level of detail and luster, showcasing its MS64 grade. Certified by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporatio

Sep 5, 2026

1914-S 5C NGC MS64 - Buffalo Nickel

$290

1935-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-801 AU55 PCGS: 1935-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-801 AU55 PCGS The 1935-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-801 AU55 PCGS is a circulated example from the San Francisco Mint, featuring James Earle Fraser's iconic design. With its di

Sep 8, 2026

1935-S Buffalo Nickel DDR FS-801 AU55 PCGS

$305

MS65 Buffalo Nickel 1929-D: MS65 Buffalo Nickel 1929-D MS65 Buffalo Nickel 1929-D is a highly detailed and accurate representation of the 1929-D Buffalo Nickel, certified by PCGS as circulated. This coin features a striking desi

Sep 10, 2026

MS65 Buffalo Nickel 1929-D

$255

Buffalo Nickel 1914-S 5C MS64: Buffalo Nickel 1914-S 5C MS64 The Buffalo Nickel 1914-S 5C MS64 is an uncirculated coin with a rich history, featuring the iconic design of James Earle Fraser's buffalo on its reverse. Certified by PC

Sep 11, 2026

Buffalo Nickel 1914-S 5C MS64

$310

MS66 Buffalo Nickel 1934: MS66 Buffalo Nickel 1934 MS66 Buffalo Nickel 1934 is a highly graded uncirculated example of this iconic coin, certified by the NGC. Featuring a rich history and distinctive design, this 1934 Buffalo

Sep 3, 2026

MS66 Buffalo Nickel 1934

$160

1926 5C CACG MS66+ - Buffalo Nickel: 1926 5C CACG MS66+ - Buffalo Nickel The 1926 Buffalo Nickel, graded MS66+, boasts exceptional condition with minimal wear. Certified by CACG, its high grade reflects the coin's impressive state of pre

Sep 12, 2026

1926 5C CACG MS66+ - Buffalo Nickel

$310

1925 Buffalo Nickel MS65+ PCGS (CAC): 1925 Buffalo Nickel MS65+ PCGS (CAC) MS65+ PCGS certified 1925 Buffalo Nickel, bearing the distinctive buffalo design and made from nickel coin composition. This circulated/uncirculated coin features

Sep 15, 2026

1925 Buffalo Nickel MS65+ PCGS (CAC)

$275

MS65 PCGS CAC Buffalo Nickel 1915: MS65 PCGS CAC Buffalo Nickel 1915 MS65 PCGS CAC Buffalo Nickel 1915 - A highly graded example of the iconic Buffalo nickel, certified by PCGS as MS65 and marked with a CAC (Certification of Authentici

Sep 9, 2026

MS65 PCGS CAC Buffalo Nickel 1915

$240

1913 5C PCGS MS67 (Type 1) - Buffalo Nickel - Popular One Year Type Coin: 1913 5C PCGS MS67 (Type 1) - Buffalo Nickel - Popular One Year Type Coin 1913 Buffalo Nickel, graded MS67 by PCGS, showcases the Type 1 design featuring a buffalo on the obverse and a shield on the re

Sep 10, 2026

1913 5C PCGS MS67 (Type 1) - Buffalo Nickel - Popular One Year Type Coin

$425

1931-S Buffalo Nickel DDR 1-R-VI MS66 PCGS: 1931-S Buffalo Nickel DDR 1-R-VI MS66 PCGS The 1931-S Buffalo Nickel DDR 1-R-VI MS66 PCGS is a highly graded circulated coin, certified by the prestigious Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) as M

Sep 13, 2026

1931-S Buffalo Nickel DDR 1-R-VI MS66 PCGS

$305

1936 Buffalo Nickel DDO FS-101 MS64 PCGS: 1936 Buffalo Nickel DDO FS-101 MS64 PCGS The 1936 Buffalo Nickel DDO FS-101 MS64 PCGS is a highly detailed and well-graded coin, certified by the PCGS as MS64, indicating a high level of mint state co

Sep 3, 2026

1936 Buffalo Nickel DDO FS-101 MS64 PCGS

$145

1926-S 5C PCGS Fine 12 - Buffalo Nickel - Popular Key Date: 1926-S 5C PCGS Fine 12 - Buffalo Nickel - Popular Key Date The 1926-S Buffalo Nickel, graded PCGS Fine 12, showcases the iconic design of the San Francisco Mint. This circulated coin features a well-w

5 days Left

1926-S 5C PCGS Fine 12 - Buffalo Nickel - Popular Key Date

$52

1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF35 NGC: 1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF35 NGC The 1924-S Buffalo Nickel is a highly sought-after coin, featuring the iconic design of James Earle Fraser's buffalo. Certified by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (N

Sep 7, 2026

1924-S Buffalo Nickel VF35 NGC

$240

1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF35 NGC: 1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF35 NGC The 1926-S Buffalo Nickel, graded VF35 by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC), showcases its circulated condition with subtle wear and a rich history. This coin be

Sep 7, 2026

1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF35 NGC

$225

View:

24

TOP