Peter Peter Pumpkin Eater McCoy Cookie Jar 10.5" tall First Image

#image-loader-main { display: none; }

Peter Peter Pumpkin Eater McCoy Cookie Jar 10.5" tall First Image

Peter Peter Pumpkin Eater McCoy Cookie Jar 10.5" tall

Total Sales1 Sold

Median Sale Price

Sale Price Range

Similar Upcoming Sales

MCCOY BLACK MAMMY COOKIE JAR 11" (1 of 5)

MCCOY BLACK MAMMY COOKIE JAR 11"

DejaVu Estate Sales & Auctions, LLC

$60

15 hrs Left

1960 McCoy El Rancho Western Ceramic Drink Dispenser Cookie Jar Style Crock (1 of 8)

1960 McCoy El Rancho Western Ceramic Drink Dispenser Cookie Jar Style Crock

$50

15 hrs Left

McCoy Ceramic Barrel Cookie Jar, Nabisco (1 of 4)

McCoy Ceramic Barrel Cookie Jar, Nabisco

Lion and Unicorn

$10

5 days Left

McCoy Ceramic Cookie Jar (1 of 6)

McCoy Ceramic Cookie Jar

Lion and Unicorn

$10

5 days Left

McCoy Ceramic Cookie Safe Jar (1 of 4)

McCoy Ceramic Cookie Safe Jar

Lion and Unicorn

$20

3 days Left

Coca-Cola 11 1/4" Cookie Jar Coke & a Song Cookie Jar Jukebox (1 of 9)

Coca-Cola 11 1/4" Cookie Jar Coke & a Song Cookie Jar Jukebox

ABBEY ROSE ANTIQUES II INC

$30

Jul 31, 2026

McCoy Ceramic Grandma Cookie Jar (1 of 4)

McCoy Ceramic Grandma Cookie Jar

Lion and Unicorn

$10

5 days Left

McCoy Pottery Jug Cookie Jar (1 of 4)

McCoy Pottery Jug Cookie Jar

Lion and Unicorn

$10

5 days Left

McCoy Ceramic Moonshine Jug Cookie Jar (1 of 4)

McCoy Ceramic Moonshine Jug Cookie Jar

Lion and Unicorn

$10

5 days Left

Hull Pottery Little Red Riding Hood Cookie Jar (1 of 11)

Hull Pottery Little Red Riding Hood Cookie Jar

Keystone Auction LLC

$25

3 days Left

2005 Coca-Cola New With Tags Polar Bear Igloo Cookie Jar ‘Serve Ice Cold’ (1 of 8)

2005 Coca-Cola New With Tags Polar Bear Igloo Cookie Jar ‘Serve Ice Cold’

ABBEY ROSE ANTIQUES II INC

$40

Jul 31, 2026

McCoy Bicentennial Milk Can Cookie Jar (1 of 4)

McCoy Bicentennial Milk Can Cookie Jar

Lion and Unicorn

$10

5 days Left

Three Cookie Jars (1 of 15)

Three Cookie Jars

$50

Jul 25, 2026

Coca-Cola Polar Bear Downhill Cookie Jar - 9.5" Ceramic Holiday Sledding Figurine with Box (1 of 8)

Coca-Cola Polar Bear Downhill Cookie Jar - 9.5" Ceramic Holiday Sledding Figurine with Box

ABBEY ROSE ANTIQUES II INC

$20

Jul 31, 2026

McCoy Pottery Ceramic Whiskey Barrel Cookie Jar (1 of 4)

McCoy Pottery Ceramic Whiskey Barrel Cookie Jar

Lion and Unicorn

$10

5 days Left

McCoy Pottery Coffee Grinder Ceramic Cookie Jar (1 of 4)

McCoy Pottery Coffee Grinder Ceramic Cookie Jar

Lion and Unicorn

$10

5 days Left

TOP