Bidder Reviews for Alexander Historical Auctions LLC (295)
4.5 out of 5.0 Stars
1-50 of 295 Reviews
PeterHarrow, CA
Dec 17, 2025
Item as described
Payment should be through one website. Payment should be one time payment not multiple payments that would make it easier. Most items were shipped instantaneously. Items were packaged very professionally.

Murray Mannsville, OK
Dec 08, 2025
Item was well packaged and taken care of. Good folks to work with. Would definitely use again.
Item was well packaged and taken care of. Good folks to work with.

WilliamManahawkin, NJ
Dec 04, 2025

JoeKIT, CA
Nov 20, 2025

RyanDallas, TX
Oct 29, 2025

YuNew York, NY
Sep 24, 2025
Never responds to emails
Paid the invoice immediately but the auction house couldn't locate it and filed a dispute with Liveauctioneers. Reached out to the auction house multiple times but never got any responses after 2 months. Eventually Mary T. of Liveauctioneers intervened and the issue was solved immediately and they shipped my items. Thanks much, Mary!

RogerWilton Manors, FL
Aug 30, 2025

BlaineMason City, IL
Aug 12, 2025
Added fees, SLOW SHIPPING, and does not respond to messages... My item was damaged, no response!
After waiting what seemed like forever for my items to show up, they finally arrived. I was already sour for the added "online fee" which made their buyers premium percentage a lie. Regardless of this, I had sent a few messages wondering where my items were and they NEVER RESPONDED. Finally the other day they arrived and one of the flags was damaged, I messaged this auction house yet again asking what we can do here and again NO RESPONSE. I have never just been blown off before like this, and mind you I spent a great deal of money for this damaged flag that I am apparently stuck with now, rather upsetting.

GregoryLand O Lakes, FL
Aug 04, 2025

TrentKannapolis, NC
Jul 23, 2025
Fees
The item description was accurate and the shipping time was about as expected, however the additional $2k in fees added at the end of invoice were a bit of a shock. Overall satisfied. Thank you.

AndrewFredericksburg, VA
Jul 17, 2025

JoeElkton, MD
Jul 17, 2025
Great people and merchandise
If u want real authentic military items I highly recommend them.. the auction house has great people working there.

JerryNantucket, MA
Jul 12, 2025
Alexander Historical Auctions rocks.
It was a pleasure dealing with Alexander Historical Auctions LLC These folks are the best in every category. Every step of the proses was easy, when I call had a great chat with them. They were very relaxed and answer every question. It as like talking to an old friend. Look forward to doing business with these folks again. Their packaging was excellent and shipped very fast. The item was just as described.

BobBunker Hill, WV
May 05, 2025
Excellent Auction Service
Alexander Historical Auctions is an excellent auction service from start to finish. Item descriptions are 100 % accurate, and ease of imvoicing, payment processing and shipping are first rate.

NicholasOpelika, AL
Apr 28, 2025
Who are we communicating with?
Weve reached out via phone and several emails to only get what seems to be an automative response. We've tried to settle up with our invoice. We won this lot over a month ago. Buyers don't expect a swift transaction.

WilliamJamesville, NY
Apr 28, 2025
Everything was handled perfectly
xcellent experience-everything was perfect-will deal with this auctioneer in the future

WesleyTemple, TX
Apr 27, 2025
Obvious fake fantasy piece by an auction house named Historical Auctions.
Obvious fake. They stated as unknown due to scratches on back so guess they covered theirselves. In hand the “scratches ’ are obvious grinding marks by an electric tool, one side of old belt has all stitches cut so could insert that half of the buckle, other side an obvious recently turned brass screw to open and put the other half of the buckle in the belt. Fake fake fake and I’m not that knowledgeable. $1300 for a fantasy piece. Would never participate in their Auctions again. You would think with a name with historical auctions in their name they would know this was fake in two seconds, I did. And yes I have had a very knowledgeable collector look at it and he knew they second he saw it.

RoySavannah, GA
Apr 22, 2025

MOverland Park, KS
Apr 22, 2025
Accurate description of the item.
The item's description was accurate. The process was business like.

WilliamJamesville, NY
Apr 22, 2025

DouglasNew Florence, PA
Jan 08, 2025
Did not complete sale
Won this item over a month ago repeated emails and phone calls no response. Very unprofessional beware maybe you'll get a good deal from them and they'll just ghost you

AdamMinesing, CA
Jan 07, 2025

MouradSaint-jean-sur-richelieu, CA
Jan 04, 2025

RonaldEmeryville, CA
Dec 27, 2024
Straight Ahead Company with in house shipping and realistic shipping fees
Straight Ahead Company with in house shipping and realistic shipping fees

GEORGEStone Mtn, GA
Dec 27, 2024

TraceyOwasso, OK
Dec 25, 2024

ProkopiosLas Vegas, NV
Dec 19, 2024
OVERALL EXPERIENCE
EXCELLENT AUCTION HOUSE. STRAIGHT FORWARD, FAST SHIPPING AND EXCELLENT PACKING. I WILL DEFINITELY BUY AGAIN.

AndreasLuedinghausen, DE
Sep 18, 2024

EricNew York, NY
Sep 13, 2024

JohnLisle, IL
Sep 12, 2024
Great historic photographs and letters
I received a young ********** Cheney autographed photo. Hard to obtain. Other national historic photos too many to mention. A great purchase.

EricNew York, NY
Sep 08, 2024
Part 1 of 2 items handled very well
This was a moderately fragile item, so I was very pleased to see it shipped carefully and well. Quite happy.

D. ClarkeSan Antonio, TX
Sep 06, 2024

Andrew000000, JM
Sep 06, 2024

KeithNew York, NY
Sep 06, 2024
I PAID FOR AN ITEM TWO WEEKS AGO AND IT STILL HAS NOT SHIPPED
Unsatisfactory customer service. Poor response!

JeffAltoona, PA
Jul 06, 2024
WW2 Poster
Never seen a dancing Hitler I love it. Great auction great price great delivery very satisfied.

KathleenElma, WA
May 29, 2024
Good experience with the Auction House
Very nice items, professionally packed, arrived in great condition, thanks!

SergeiBrooklyn, NY
May 17, 2024

TimothyBurlington, CT
May 17, 2024
Zoom in closely before you bid.
Great experience bidding with Alexander Historical with the exception of the description of HJ knife grip. They mentioned all the defects of the knife to include the loose inset diamond, but not the crack on the grip itself. Imagine my surprise when I opened the bubble wrapped knife and saw an obvious crack. This is how they described the knife in the auction, “with a black checkered grip and an inset H. J. emblem, a bit loose.” No mention of why the emblem was loose. Hence the title of the review, “zoom in closely before you bid” because had I done so, I would have caught the omission and the crack in the photo. You can learn from my mistake. My bad as well as theirs. On the upside, the helmet I bought from them was very accurately described and fairly priced.

BruceWest Haven, CT
May 16, 2024

JamesBrownsboro, TX
May 15, 2024

RachelJamaica, VT
Feb 18, 2024
Excellent, trustworthy, swift and shipping costs very reasonable.
They went above and beyond, quite impressive. Shipping was thoughtful and very reasonable. Trustworthy is a big deal and they are trustworthy. I will be back for more.

WilliamUvalde, TX
Feb 09, 2024
Great Experience
The item I received was exactly as advertised. The payment process was easy and quick. I've won items from Alexander Historical Auctions before and every time has been an outstanding experience.

GongyuNew York, NY
Feb 09, 2024

MichaelSaint Petersburg, FL
Dec 30, 2023

michalToronto, CA
Dec 30, 2023
TOP CLASS AUCTION HOUSE
EASY PAYMENT-FAST SHIPPING-VERY GOOD PACKING-PLEASURE DEALING WITH YOU HAPPY NEW YEAR ALL THE BEST

GuyRhoadesville, VA
Dec 21, 2023
Their packaging of the items was perfect to make the shipping process.
The items they show and auction are represented with great detail. You get what is on the auction. Great Job

TOP



