FISHING TACKLE & SPORTSMEN AUCTION 2024-04-26 Auction - 730 Price Results - Blanchards Auction Service in NY
LiveAuctioneers Logo

The Haskell MinnowArthur Burdett Frost (1851-1928) Fly Fishing PaintingImmell Floating Chippewa Minnow & Box
Done
Potsdam, NY, United States
Auction Details

FISHING TACKLE & SPORTSMEN AUCTION

One of the most important angling auctions in decades, the spring sale will include historic lures and their exceptionally rare "picture" boxes. These highly sought boxes, the majority dating from the late 1800's into the early 1900's, are especially desirable as they feature a graphic illustration of the lure. The collections offered in this auction are also unusual as many of the picture boxes are in excellent condition, a rare designation for lure boxes of this age.
Included in the first day of the auction, which will be held online and attended by a live audience, will be an extremely rare c1859 Haskell Minnow, made by Riley Haskell of Painesville, Ohio. The Haskell Minnow is believed to be the most coveted American lure ever made.
Also featured in this auction are comprehensive collections of early Miller's Reversible Minnows, several in their very rare boxes, and introductory black Shakespeare boxes housing the correct baits, as well as many other obscure short-production lures. Interspersed throughout the first 730 lots will be the lure collection of Sheridan Jones. Referred to as "America's pioneering outdoor writer", Sheridan Jones (1881-1958) was certainly one of the most respected and prolific angling writers of his era. Jones, where noted, owned a number of the lures offered in this auction - many were given to the esteemed author for his professional opinion, others as gifts by lure makers vying for his favor. Stated best by author Joseph Hilko in his 2010 book The Life and Legend of Sheridan R. Jones: "Jones' legacy as an educator, naturalist, professional writer & world-class angler is worthy of remembrance today" There will also be desirable reels & exceptional bamboo rods, such as an 8' Lyle Dickerson Model 8014, 7' Walt Carpenter "Special Project" Payne Fly Rod, Darrell Whitehead Custom Fly Rod Set, 8' 3" Sweetgrass 5-Sided Fly Rod, 7' 5" Mario Wojnicki Penta Fly Rod, 7 1/2' Leonard Pre-Fire Fairy Catskill, most in unused condition
Lot Number: Lowest
72
Sold
Lane's Automatic Minnow: Extraordinary Charles W. Lane Automatic Minnow. Patented July 29, 1913 in Madrid, NY, one of the rarest of all miscellaneous baits. This hollow metal minnow, with patent marked rotating tail, tiny
0001: Lane's Automatic MinnowEst. $400-$500
See Sold Price
Sold
Jamison Winged Mascot: Finished in red and white, with 3 double removable hooks and adjustable "wings", shiny Ex-, with light wear, chip in the line tie hole and age lines.
0002: Jamison Winged MascotEst. $30-$40
See Sold Price
Sold
Heddon 1705 Near Surface Wiggler: Bright yellow strawberry spot model, pigtail line tie, L-rig, marked plane, shiny Ex-/Ex with light wear and fine age lines. With the correct down bass box, Ex- condition, stamped 1705 on both ends,
0003: Heddon 1705 Near Surface WigglerEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
H.S. Welles Musky Patent Bait: Rare large musky-size, measuring just over 4" in length, with "Welles Patent" clearly stamped on the face. Finished in gold (red face), with heavy duty screw eye hook hangers, definitely unfished,
0004: H.S. Welles Musky Patent BaitEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
Zane Grey Owned South Bend King-Oreno: Slick green scale finish, rigged with a huge single Mustad hook, unfished Ex-/Ex, with a few small factory imperfections and faint age lines, bright and shiny. Coming in the correct crisp King-Oreno
0005: Zane Grey Owned South Bend King-OrenoEst. $200-$300
See Sold Price
Sold
Creek Chub Introductory Pikie Box: Coming with its very early 700 in pikie scale finish with bold, long hand painted gill marks, first version cup hardware, red in the eye sockets, unmarked lip and double line ties, shiny Ex-. The
0006: Creek Chub Introductory Pikie BoxEst. $200-$300
See Sold Price
Sold
Moonlight's "The Paw Paw Fish Spear": Early short production wood lure, 4 1/4" in length, c1914, finished in white with red head, rigged with Moonlight brass washer hardware. The condition is exceptional, shiny Ex, definitely unfished.
0007: Moonlight's "The Paw Paw Fish Spear"Est. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
Moonlight Zig Zag: Rare early maroon box, 1913 patent date appears on the top label with the end marked "No. 6 White", grading strong Ex-, with only light wear/soiling, and including the Sheridan R. Jones collection
0008: Moonlight Zig ZagEst. $150-$200
See Sold Price
Sold
Nifty Minne: From Joseph M. Ness of Minneapolis, Minnesota, this scarce minnow tube is complete with the original central celluloid tube, fancy script marked spinners, and "Pat. Pend'g" stamped brace. Dating from
0009: Nifty MinneEst. $100-$150
See Sold Price
Sold
"Miller's Original Wood Minnow" Picture Box: Finished in rarely seen white with red and green spots and black back stripe, rigged with Pflueger Neverfail hardware and Miller's twin spinners, the brass spinner stamped "Pat. Applied For". A very
0010: "Miller's Original Wood Minnow" Picture BoxEst. $1,000-$1,500
See Sold Price
Sold
Miller's Reversible Spinner: Marked PAT. APPLIED FOR on W.H. Miller's early unique spinner. Condition on the silver and gold wash spinners is Ex with only minor aged tarnish. From the Union Springs Specialty Co.
0011: Miller's Reversible SpinnerEst. $50-$75
See Sold Price
Sold
Keeling Surface Tom: Rarely seen complete combination, the crisp 2pc box clearly stamped "Surface Tom" and housing the correct striking bait, not only finished in Keeling's beautiful yellow/gold sides with black back,
0012: Keeling Surface TomEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
The Turner Casting Bait: Featuring the original removable belly weight, enabling the lure to fish as either a surface or underwater bait, pre-1920, in an orange "scaled" finish over white, this scarce lure is uniquely
0013: The Turner Casting BaitEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
Bite-Em Bait & Coldwater Wiggler: 4" Coldwater Wiggler in white with red on the nose and into the chin vent, shiny VG+/Ex- with nose and tail chipping, light wear and age lines, and a Bite-Em Bait, white/red/gold, complete harness,
0014: Bite-Em Bait & Coldwater WigglerEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
Heddon Tadpolly: Green scale, L-rig, good glass eyes and a marked tail plate, Ex-/Ex, with only a few flakes and tight age lines, appearing unfished. The Tad-Polly introductory box is unmarked, grading about VG+. The
0015: Heddon TadpollyEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
Moonlight 2009 Jointed Pikaroon: Finished in bright yellow perch with red side stripes, good glass eyes, about Ex-, with light wear, minuscule nose rub, factory imperfections and faint age lines, much better than most. Coming in a
0016: Moonlight 2009 Jointed PikaroonEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
Creek Chub 3852 Beetle: White with red wings, gold belly stamp, Ex- with light wear, factory imperfections and age lines. Coming in the correct No. 3852 end label box that's VG+/Ex- with a color fold out catalog.
0017: Creek Chub 3852 BeetleEst. $50-$75
See Sold Price
Sold
Early South Bend 5hk Underwater Minnow: Very early bait, having the slender body style with tapered tail, shallow cups and unmarked pointed props. Finished in sienna crackleback yellow belly with 2 fine hand painted gill marks and good
0018: Early South Bend 5hk Underwater MinnowEst. $150-$200
See Sold Price
Sold
Creek Chub Husky Musky: Finished in perch scale with red blush gills and fins, dated flat lip, double line ties and heavy duty screw eye hardware, at least Ex-, possibly unfished. It's not easy to find this late 1920's bait
0019: Creek Chub Husky MuskyEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
2 Buckeye Bug-N-Bass: Bass size Bug-N-Bass including an unfished (shiny Ex) white coach dog with a BNB-7 printed insert card and crisp Patent Pending box, unmarked. Also a crappie finish, other than missing the rear hook
0020: 2 Buckeye Bug-N-BassEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
Heddon 1909H Crab Wiggler: Finished in rare red scale, with 3 screw marked collar, L-rigged double hooks and good glass eyes, shiny Ex-/Ex, possibly unfished with the pork rind still attached to the hook pin. Includes the
0021: Heddon 1909H Crab WigglerEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
2 Early Moonlight Zig Zags: Both early models dating from the teens, with washer tail and nose, shallow cups, blended face, and appearing unfished, Ex-/Ex and shiny Ex, each with only light wear and clean hardware. Rarely seen
0022: 2 Early Moonlight Zig ZagsEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
Early Harkauf "Plug Bait" Box: Rarely seen 2pc cardboard box measures 3 5/8" x 2 3/8", end label only, marked "One Plug Bait" and stamped "Yellow Gold Spots", dirty and worn but solid. The early 2 3/4" Pflueger Globe is unmarked,
0023: Early Harkauf "Plug Bait" BoxEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
South Bend Flyrod Lures: Includes an empty target box marked for a "Feath-Oreno Minnow No.1 Red Ibis", an empty window box, unmarked, with a Callmac Bug "No. 3 Clark's Fancy" card, 3 unfished baits on cards: Wizard-Oreno,
0024: South Bend Flyrod LuresEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
2 Boxed Novelty Lures: Includes a scarce Shmoo in red/white with black accents, appearing unfished, shiny Ex, its correct window box with original insert is end stamped 59RH, solid but VG/VG+ due to top wear. And a
0025: 2 Boxed Novelty LuresEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
Heddon Baby Torpedos: Both L-rig with marked props, white with red eye and tail, VG+ due mostly to a thin over-varnish, in a VG+/Ex- condition box stamped 122, and shiner scale, VG with a nose chip and heavy old
0026: Heddon Baby TorpedosEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
Early A&I St. Lawrence Gang: Very rare 6 1/4" x 2" two-piece box, complete with a full top label and housing a pristine gang, including its wire wrapped gimp, still sewn to the original card, stamped 2/0. Also included are two
0027: Early A&I St. Lawrence GangEst. $150-$200
See Sold Price
Sold
Early Wm. Reed & Sons Bait Rig: Rarely seen bait mount with "Patent" marked on both wings, 3 1/4" not including the original swivel, hooks and gimp trace, unused and in Ex condition. "The Dream Spinner" card measures 6" in length,
0028: Early Wm. Reed & Sons Bait RigEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
Early Miller's Musky Minnow: Made by W.H. Miller of the Union Springs Specialty Co., this extremely rare lure dates from the teens, prior to the production of the Miller's Reversible Minnow. Musky-size (5 1/2"), constructed with
0029: Early Miller's Musky MinnowEst. $500-$700
See Sold Price
Sold
Earliest Miller's Reversible Minnow: Extraordinary first version, 4 1/4", with a slender wood body finished in super rare red head with hand painted gold spots and white mid/rear sections. Constructed with through-body fine wire,
0030: Earliest Miller's Reversible MinnowEst. $1,000-$1,500
See Sold Price
Sold
Shakespeare Weedless Rubber Casting Frog: Very rare early frog, c1908, 3 1/4" in length, rigged with a through body fixed treble hook, front B-notch spinner, and retaining the original rubber weed guard. The hand painted green finish with
0031: Shakespeare Weedless Rubber Casting FrogEst. $200-$300
See Sold Price
Sold
Jamison Musky Coaxer: Large 2 1/4" body on this very rarely seen lure, with white finish, red felt wings, original red feather tail and oversized hooks. Condition is Ex-, with light general wear and soiling. It would be
0033: Jamison Musky CoaxerEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
Jamison Winged Mascot: Early 4" lure finished in rare solid yellow, about VG+ with wear, lip chips, touchup to line tie holes, a few pointers and age lines. A bold color on the Winged Mascot, certainly a stand-out bait for
0034: Jamison Winged MascotEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
The Immell Bait Co. "Chippewa" Skipper: Early combination in exceptional condition and extremely rare. Distributed by C.J. Frost of Stevens Point, Wisconsin, this large box with bold red "CHIPPEWA" on the top of the wrap-around label and
0035: The Immell Bait Co. "Chippewa" SkipperEst. $700-$1,000
See Sold Price
Sold
The Rhodes Wooden Minnow: From the William Shakespeare Co. of Kalamazoo, Michigan, measuring just under 4", blended blue back with rare hand painted side stripes, blemish free yellow glass eyes, see through gem clip hardware
0036: The Rhodes Wooden MinnowEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
South Bend 953 Musky Casting Minnow: One of South Bend's rarest underwater minnows, only produced in 1914, rigged with marked pointed props, finished in white with a blended slate back and hand painted gill marks. Outfitted with 3 heavy
0037: South Bend 953 Musky Casting MinnowEst. $300-$400
See Sold Price
Sold
Early Heddon 176 Wood Slide-Lid Box: Rare Heavy Casting Minnow box, printed on all four sides, most likely dating to 1907, marked very clearly on both ends "Heddon's "Dowagiac" Minnow, Rainbow No. 176". All but the lid would grade
0038: Early Heddon 176 Wood Slide-Lid BoxEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
Dewey's Feather-Getum Intro Picture Box: Extremely rare, this extraordinary box dates from the 1920's and houses a large-size red Feather-Getum (unfished Ex) on the original card-stock insert. Retaining its bright color, measuring 5 3/4" in
0039: Dewey's Feather-Getum Intro Picture BoxEst. $300-$400
See Sold Price
Sold
2 Boxed Shakespeare Lures: Pressed eye baits including a seldom seen Jack Smith, red/white with glitter, about VG+ with wear, a few touchups in flakes, couple of small bubbles and age lines. And a Jointed Egyptian Wobbler,
0040: 2 Boxed Shakespeare LuresEst. $20-$30
See Sold Price
Sold
Boxed Pflueger Globes: Includes a 3750 Musky Globe, 3770 and 3750 Globes, all appearing unfished, each in the correctly stamped box. The canoe boxes are crisp with fold out paper.
0041: Boxed Pflueger GlobesEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
Montague Automatic Casting Float: With original "Sunbeam" decal, 2 piece picture box with full wrap-around label, weight, and fold out instruction paper. The float is VG/VG+ due mostly to a few touchups/chips, wear and soiling, the
0042: Montague Automatic Casting FloatEst. $30-$40
See Sold Price
Sold
1932 Heddon Catalog: 32 page catalog with cover stamp regarding a 10% government tax and a "Want Our 1934 Catalog?" Heddon stamp. With vivid color illustrations, a page showing the Heddon "Lone Eagle" Kit and Fly
0043: 1932 Heddon CatalogEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
Heddon Artistic Minnow Intro Box: Beautiful sienna crackleback finish and having the correct bucktail treble and gold washed hardware, shiny Ex-, with only one tiny chip at the belly weight, slight wear and tight age lines, most
0044: Heddon Artistic Minnow Intro BoxEst. $150-$200
See Sold Price
Sold
Chapman No. 1 Electric Bait: A "Pat. Ap'd For" marked spinner with "Chapman, Son & Co. Rochester, N.Y." stamp. With a large feathered treble hook (no bead), the exterior sides of the 2 5/8" blades appear to have been fisherman
0045: Chapman No. 1 Electric BaitEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
Early L.S. Hill Spinner: No. 3 with a 3" fish shaped blade that has patent date stamps of "May. 23. 76" and "Feb. 4. 79." With fishing wear, the front nickel plate polished, and remnants of the red back paint, VG/VG+.
0046: Early L.S. Hill SpinnerEst. $30-$40
See Sold Price
Sold
G.M. Skinner Turkey Foot: No. 5, marked "G.M. Skinner Clayton, N.Y." and "Patented May 18, 1886". The copper blade is uncleaned, nickel plated on the reverse, Ex condition with only light wear, most likely unfished. One of
0047: G.M. Skinner Turkey FootEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
2 Early Spinners: 1 3/4" squid bait stamped "Wm H. James Brooklyn, N.Y." (near Ex), and a No. 3 "F.S. Graves Albany, N.Y." stamped kidney tandem (VG+/Ex-).
0048: 2 Early SpinnersEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
Early Chapman's Pike Oval: Also known as the Thousand Island Bait, the 2 1/8" blade is marked "W.D. Chapman Theresa, N.Y." with the early IXL in a scalloped rectangle stamped below and No.1 in a scalloped rectangle above. With
0049: Early Chapman's Pike OvalEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
Pflueger May Bug: This rare bait was first offered in the late 1880's from the Enterprise Mfg Co. of Akron, Ohio. With fine detailing and featuring a two piece body and leg assembly, front mounted barrel swivel and
0050: Pflueger May BugEst. $100-$150
See Sold Price
Sold
Shakespeare Revolution Wood Box: Coming in an exceedingly rare wood slide top box, rigged with Rhodes front and rear props and "acorn" style capped body sections. Condition of the Revolution is shiny Ex-/Ex, most likely unfished.
0051: Shakespeare Revolution Wood BoxEst. $700-$1,000
See Sold Price
Sold
Hayes Flyrod Bugs & Catalog: Includes a rare fold out flyer, 13" x 6" when open, in near Ex condition, most likely dating from the 20's, with a Hayes Feather Minnow and a slant-face Bass Bug, both about Ex-.
0052: Hayes Flyrod Bugs & CatalogEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
Calkins Glass "Chum Mino" Tube: Measuring 10" in length, this very rare glass tube was made by Lowell B. Calkin of Millville, New Jersey. Calkin, born in 1919, was a maker of custom glass for scientific purposes and novelties,
0053: Calkins Glass "Chum Mino" TubeEst. $200-$300
See Sold Price
Sold
Rush Tango Midget: 2 1/2" Midget Tango (unfished Ex), victory finish, in an early white 2pc box, with the color stamping lightly crossed out and "#25 Victory Finish" handwritten in script, appearing to be factory, with
0054: Rush Tango MidgetEst. $30-$40
See Sold Price
Sold
Moonlight Pollywog: Beautiful lure in red and white with black eye shadow and blue nose and chin, shiny Ex-, with wear, pointers, tiny nose rub and age lines. The blue "Patents Pending" box grades about VG+ with an
0055: Moonlight PollywogEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
Payne's Humane Woggle-Bug: A rarely seen lure dating from 1915, this exact Woggle-Bug appears on page 65 of "The Life and Legend of Sheridan R. Jones". Finished in white with red hand painted chin, complete with all three
0056: Payne's Humane Woggle-BugEst. $50-$75
See Sold Price
Sold
South Bend Whirl-Oreno: Finished in frog spot with black and yellow hair tail, about VG+, with wear/rubs, a few small chips, hook marks and age lines, all common to this 30's bait. The hardest of the cataloged colors to
0058: South Bend Whirl-OrenoEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
3 South Bend Bass-Orenos: Two Standard Bass-Orenos: frog finish with good glass eyes (shiny Ex-), and a no-eye in red/gold (VG+/Ex-), and a no-eye Babe-Oreno, rainbow (about Ex-). The three boxes grade VG+ to Ex-/Ex, marked:
0059: 3 South Bend Bass-OrenosEst. $30-$40
See Sold Price
Sold
1927 Creek Chub Catalog: Scarce 44 page catalog, color and black & white, "New" in this issue: the Wiggle Fish, Polly Wiggle and Creek Darter, with illustrations of the Select Six Assortment and Deluxe Six Assortment boxed
0060: 1927 Creek Chub CatalogEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
Creek Chub Injured Minnow: Appearing unfished, bright fireplug finish, good glass eyes, gold side stamp, Ex condition with only one pointer. The box grades near Ex- with a fold out catalog, end stamped 6505. From the
0061: Creek Chub Injured MinnowEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
Heddon Spindiver: Early green scale finish with marked front spinner and diving lip. Condition on this L-rigged bait is VG/VG+ with wear/flakes, a cracked eye and age lines. The VG+ down leaping bass box has an
0062: Heddon SpindiverEst. $100-$150
See Sold Price
Sold
Heddon No-Eye Crab Wiggler: Uncataloged model, manufactured using the later style 1600 Deep Diving Wiggler body, small cup and screw eye hardware and early, marked U-collar. Finished in green scale, most likely a depression era
0063: Heddon No-Eye Crab WigglerEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
Heddon Wiggle King: Coming in a rarely seen introductory box, stamped 2002, this early bait is finished in red head blended to white, appearing unfished but light box wear, small varnish chipping at the tail and fine
0064: Heddon Wiggle KingEst. $75-$100
See Sold Price
Sold
Arbogast Musky Jitterbug Picture Box: Extremely rare large yellow box, 2pc, measuring 6" x 3" x 1 3/4" with an oversized Jitterbug illustration and printing on all four flaps, solid and about VG+ with wear/rubs and light soiling. The
0065: Arbogast Musky Jitterbug Picture BoxEst. $150-$200
See Sold Price
Sold
Arbogast Tin Liz Sunfish: 3 fin model, hairlines in the underside eye, otherwise shiny Ex-. The box is stamped 3242, about Ex- overall.
0066: Arbogast Tin Liz SunfishEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
2 South Bend Lures: Fish-Oreno in copper, about Ex-, in a EX-/Ex condition introductory Fish-Oreno box marked 953 SF, with printed bottom and hang tag, and a Wiz-Oreno in yellow perch scale, in a rough (marker writing)
0067: 2 South Bend LuresEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
Decker Surface Water Casting Bass Bait: Early rotaryhead from Lake Hopatcong, N.J., finished in solid white, marked Ans B Decker, about Ex- with wear, small rubs, pointers and age lines.
0068: Decker Surface Water Casting Bass BaitEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
Early Folk Art Wood Lure: Great folky appearance, 4 5/8", unrigged, large metal cups for eyes, the front half carved out to allow for an interior spring attached to the wire leader, as well as large openings at the gills.
0069: Early Folk Art Wood LureEst. $30-$40
See Sold Price
Sold
Early Heddon Crab Wiggler: In shiny white with red eye and tail, rigged with large cup and screw eye hardware, marked U-collar and good glass eyes. About Ex-, with light wear, a couple of pointers, tail chip and age lines,
0070: Early Heddon Crab WigglerEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
Heddon 1809B Crab Wiggler: Bright frog spot finish on this L-rigged Crab Wiggler with good glass eyes, inch worm line tie and marked collar, only light wear and age lines, shiny Ex-. The semi-tall box (with Baby Crab Wiggler
0071: Heddon 1809B Crab WigglerEst. $40-$50
See Sold Price
Sold
South Bend 904R Underwater Minnow: 3hk minnow in red hex finish with black hand painted gill marks, good glass eyes, blunt marked props, shiny Ex-. Housed in a tough target box that's also about Ex-, stamped 968 MS (for a Midge-Oreno
0072: South Bend 904R Underwater MinnowEst. $50-$75
See Sold Price
View:
72
TOP