1923 1924 1925 Full Date Buffalo Nickels.

Total Sales1 Sold

Median Sale Price

Sale Price Range

Similar Upcoming Sales

1926-S Buffalo Nickel VF Uncertified 5C Coin

Mynt Auctions

$300

3 days Left

1930-S/S Buffalo Nickel Choice BU+ Uncertified Rare Coin

Mynt Auctions

$270

Apr 30, 2026

1921-S Nickel Buffalo Five Cents CLOSELY UNCIRCULATED

Gold Standard Auctions

$350

7 days Left

1924-D Buffalo Nickel SUPERB GEM BU

Gold Standard Auctions

$325

7 days Left

Three Semi-Key Buffalo Nickels

Coinhunters

$1(1 bid)

Four Semi-Key Buffalo Nickels

Coinhunters

1920-D Buffalo Nickel EF Uncertified

SEUYCO

$190

May 08, 2026

Buffalo Nickel 1921-S F Uncertified

SEUYCO

$145

May 05, 2026

Lot of 2 Buffalo Head Nickels- Both 1937

Leonard Trading LLC

$1(1 bid)

LOT OF 42 MIXED DATE BUFFALO NICKEL COINS

Affiliated Auctions

$10

6 days Left

Lot of 2 Buffalo Head Nickels - 1921, 1924

Leonard Trading LLC

Group of 20 Buffalo Nickels

Matthew Bullock Auctioneers

$15

2 days Left

Seventeen Buffalo Nickels - Dates Include 1929, 1930, (7) 1935, (3) 1936, (5) 1937 - Includes Some

CATAMOUNT AUCTION CO LLC

$15

Apr 30, 2026