American Flyer Toys & Hobbies

Beautiful American Flyer Pony Express Set(20535) First Image

#image-loader-main { display: none; }

Beautiful American Flyer Pony Express Set(20535) First Image

Beautiful American Flyer Pony Express Set(20535)

Total Sales1 Sold

Median Sale Price

Sale Price Range

Similar Upcoming Sales

Lot of 6 Rolling Stock Trains (1 of 12)

Lot of 6 Rolling Stock Trains

Bodnar's Auction Sales

Feb 11, 2026

Lot of O Gauge Rolling Stock (1 of 11)

Lot of O Gauge Rolling Stock

Bodnar's Auction Sales

Feb 11, 2026

AHM HO Gauge Passenger Car Lot (1 of 12)

AHM HO Gauge Passenger Car Lot

Bodnar's Auction Sales

Feb 11, 2026

Lot of Lionel Engines and Tenders (1 of 10)

Lot of Lionel Engines and Tenders

Bodnar's Auction Sales

Feb 11, 2026

Lot of 10 O27 Gauge Rolling Stock (1 of 12)

Lot of 10 O27 Gauge Rolling Stock

Bodnar's Auction Sales

Feb 11, 2026

Lot of 5 HO Gauge Engines (1 of 11)

Lot of 5 HO Gauge Engines

Bodnar's Auction Sales

Feb 11, 2026

Lot of 2 O27 Lionel Engines (1 of 13)

Lot of 2 O27 Lionel Engines

Bodnar's Auction Sales

Feb 11, 2026

Lot of Lionel Postwar 027 gauge trains (1 of 12)

Lot of Lionel Postwar 027 gauge trains

Bodnar's Auction Sales

Feb 11, 2026

Lot of 2 HO Gauge Engines (1 of 13)

Lot of 2 HO Gauge Engines

Bodnar's Auction Sales

Feb 11, 2026

Lot of 10 O27 Gauge Rolling Stock (1 of 13)

Lot of 10 O27 Gauge Rolling Stock

Bodnar's Auction Sales

Feb 11, 2026

Lot of 10 O27 Gauge Rolling Stock (1 of 12)

Lot of 10 O27 Gauge Rolling Stock

Bodnar's Auction Sales

Feb 11, 2026

Lot of 8 HO Gauge AHM Rolling Stock (1 of 12)

Lot of 8 HO Gauge AHM Rolling Stock

Bodnar's Auction Sales

Feb 11, 2026

Lot of 3 Erie Lackawanna HO Gauge Engines (1 of 7)

Lot of 3 Erie Lackawanna HO Gauge Engines

Bodnar's Auction Sales

Feb 11, 2026

6 BRASS H.O. TRAINS INCL. O & W, DENVER & RIO GRANDE + (1 of 6)

6 BRASS H.O. TRAINS INCL. O & W, DENVER & RIO GRANDE +

EstateOfMind Auctions

Feb 21, 2026

6 BRASS H.O TRAINS INCL LONG ISLAND DIESEL ENGINE #464+ (1 of 7)

6 BRASS H.O TRAINS INCL LONG ISLAND DIESEL ENGINE #464+

EstateOfMind Auctions

Feb 21, 2026

8 BRASS H.O. TRAINS INCL O & W #278 LOCOMOTIVE, TENDER+ (1 of 9)

8 BRASS H.O. TRAINS INCL O & W #278 LOCOMOTIVE, TENDER+

EstateOfMind Auctions

Feb 21, 2026

Similar Sale History

Unlock All Prices

Sold

Beautiful American Flyer Pony Express Set(20535) (1 of 6)

Beautiful American Flyer Pony Express Set(20535)S gauge. 1959. Clean matched set! Includes a 21925 & -1 UP PA Alco AA Diesels. Graphics match nicely with lettering on 1 side is a bit lighter on both units; 24837 Star Dust combine; 24838 Dream Cloud

Sold

AMERICAN FLYER PONY EXPRESS TRAIN SET (1 of 2)

AMERICAN FLYER PONY EXPRESS TRAIN SET S ga, 21925-1 dummy PA Alco w/bell, 24837 Stardust combine, 24838 Dream Cloud, 24839 Columbia River vista dome, 24840 Moon Glow obsv, orig boxes, 3 are complete, 2 are missing ends, C8.

Sold

American Flyer Pony Express Diesel Train Set (1 of 6)

American Flyer Pony Express Diesel Train Set American Flyer S Gauge Pony Express diesel train set. The set is new in the box. Set No. 6-49600.

Sold

American Flyer S Guage Set 6-49600 in box (1 of 4)

American Flyer S Guage Set 6-49600 in box American Flyer Pony Express Set 6-49600, in Box. Powered and Dummy Unit and 4 passenger cars. S Gauge

Sold

AMERICAN FLYER 20535 PONY EXPRESS TRAIN SET (1 of 1)

AMERICAN FLYER 20535 PONY EXPRESS TRAIN SET S ga, 21925 & 21925-1 AA diesels, 24837 combine, 24838 coach, 24839 vista dome, 24840 obsv, C6-7.

Sold

AMERICAN FLYER 20535 PONY EXPRESS TRAIN SET (1 of 1)

AMERICAN FLYER 20535 PONY EXPRESS TRAIN SET S ga, 21025 loco, 21025-1 loco, both missing nose decals, 24837 Stardust, 24838 Dream Cloud, 24839 Columbia River, 24840 Moon Glow, drumhead cracked, w/track & transformer, C6-7.

Sold

AMERICAN FLYER 6-49600 PONY EXPRESS TRAIN SET (1 of 1)

AMERICAN FLYER 6-49600 PONY EXPRESS TRAIN SET S ga, UP Alco AB units w/4 coaches, w/an extra 6-48119 B unit, 6-48908 coach & 6-48909 vista dome, 6-48941 diner, orig boxes & set box & inserts, C9.

Sold

American Flyer Lionel Pony Express Set 49600, Plus (1 of 2)

American Flyer Lionel Pony Express Set 49600, Plus S Gauge. Nice reissue of this great set. Includes a PA Alco AA diesels with 4 matching passenger cars, boxed with setbox, plus the 48119 matching PB B-unit with RailSounds; 48908 & 48909 coach & vista

Sold

American Flyer Lionel Pony Express Set 49600, Plus (1 of 2)

American Flyer Lionel Pony Express Set 49600, Plus S Gauge. Nice reissue of this great set. Includes a PA Alco AA diesels with 4 matching passenger cars, boxed with setbox, plus the 48908 & 48909 coach & vista-dome; 48941 diner. They appear unrun with

Sold

AMERICAN FLYER 49600 PONY EXPRESS SET (1 of 2)

AMERICAN FLYER 49600 PONY EXPRESS SET S ga, electric set w/extra Union Pacific cars 48908 & 48909, orig boxes & inserts, C8-9.

Sold

AMERICAN FLYER 49600 PONY EXPRESS SET (1 of 2)

AMERICAN FLYER 49600 PONY EXPRESS SET S ga, contains 48106 AA w/horn, 48904 combine, 48905 Pullman, 48906 vista dome, 48907 obsv, orig set box top worn, orig boxes, C8-9.

Sold

American Flyer Train Set 20535 S Pony Express Passenger Set 1959 (1 of 6)

American Flyer Train Set 20535 S Pony Express Passenger Set 1959 WORKS GREAT AND TESTED! American Flyer S Pony Express Passenger Set: 21925-I This set includes a diesel, and 2 passenger cars ending number 37 and 38. These items feature metal trucks, metal wheels, a

Sold

American Flyer Train Set 20535 S Pony Express Passenger Set 1959 (1 of 7)

American Flyer Train Set 20535 S Pony Express Passenger Set 1959 WORKS GREAT AND TESTED! American Flyer S Pony Express Passenger Set: 21925-I This set includes a diesel, and 2 passenger cars ending number 37 and 38. These items feature metal trucks, metal wheels, a

Sold

Lionel American Flyer Extended UP Pony Express (1 of 3)

Lionel American Flyer Extended UP Pony Express S Gauge. Includes the 49600 AA PA diesels with 4 matching passenger cars; plus 48119 PA B-unit with RailSounds; 48908 coach & 48909 vista-dome; 489431 diner. All are unrun with boxes & setbox, C9-10

Sold

Lot of 3: American Flyer No. 49600 Pony Express (1 of 1)

Lot of 3: American Flyer No. 49600 Pony Express Set Includes: Two Union Pacific Alcos, one powered and one not powered, a Combo Car, a Pullman, an Observation Car and a Vista Dome Car. All are mint in the sealed box. Set box shows some yellowing ar

Sold

American Flyer Lionel Extended UP Pony Express (1 of 3)

American Flyer Lionel Extended UP Pony Express S Gauge. Includes the 49600 AA Diesels with 4 cars, all obs and set box; Plus 48908, ob; 2 -48909 obs; 48941 NO box; 48119 UP B-Unit with RailSounds, NO box. All would benefit from a cleaning and show

Sold

American Flyer S Gauge 20535 Union Pacific Pony Express Passenger Set with Original Boxes and Set (1 of 8)

American Flyer S Gauge 20535 Union Pacific Pony Express Passenger Set with Original Boxes and Set American Flyer S Gauge 20535 Union Pacific Pony Express Passenger Set with Original Boxes and Set Box that includes - 21925 UP Powered Alco PA nd 2125-1 UP Non-Powered Alco PA Diesel Locomotives, 2483

Sold

Beautiful American Flyer 20445 Northern Pacific Passenger Set w/ Original Boxes and Set Box (1 of 12)

Beautiful American Flyer 20445 Northern Pacific Passenger Set w/ Original Boxes and Set Box Beautiful American Flyer 20445 Northern Pacific Passenger Set w/ Original Boxes and Set Box. The set contains - 21551 Alco PA Northern Pacific Diesel, 24843 Baggage and Club Car, 24846 Coach, 24849 Vi

Sold

Beautiful American Flyer S Gauge 21573 GE New Haven Electric w/ OB (1 of 8)

Beautiful American Flyer S Gauge 21573 GE New Haven Electric w/ OB Beautiful American Flyer S Gauge 21573 New Haven GE Electric w/ OB, C8. This Pieces is Gorgeous! The Paint is Near Perfect. The Box is Very Square with Great Color.

Sold

American Flyer Express 550 Plane (1 of 5)

American Flyer Express 550 Plane American Flyer tin litho plane circa 1920's, pushing plane turns propeller, 19.5" L, 18" W

Sold

American Pony Express Model (1 of 3)

American Pony Express Model Painted wood. Westward Expansion. 10"Sq. X 9"H. (From the Newark Museum, NJ.)

Sold

Beautiful American Flyer S Gauge 639 Painted Yellow Boxcar (1 of 4)

Beautiful American Flyer S Gauge 639 Painted Yellow Boxcar Beautiful American Flyer S Gauge 639 Painted Yellow Boxcar, C8+.

Sold

c1930 Restored American Flyer Locomotive No. 4694 (1 of 10)

c1930 Restored American Flyer Locomotive No. 4694 The beautiful American Flyer locomotive No. 4694 was fully restored by the Toy Train Operating Society with the sticker as shown. Lots of patent numbers listed on bottom with the last number from 1932

Sold

Harry Jackson (American, 1924-2011) Pony Express II, number 13 , 1980 (1 of 5)

Harry Jackson (American, 1924-2011) Pony Express II, number 13 , 1980 Harry Jackson (American, 1924-2011) Pony Express II, number 13 , 1980 bronze signed Harry Jackson, numbered and dated (base) height 12 1/2 x width 17 x depth 10 inches Property from a Private Collecti

TOP