Gilbert Mysto Magic

Similar Upcoming Sales

Great Early Ephemera Lot Inc. 1904 Memory Card, 1920's to 50's Cards, Clippings and More

Atlee Raber Auctions4.6

(525)

$20(2 bids)

7 days Left

LOT OF GAMES AND TOYS 19th/20th Century Box length 11".

Eldred's4.8

(480)

$70

2 days Left

Lot of 29 miscellaneous decks or sets of playing cards. 20t...

Potter & Potter Auctions4.6

(604)

$40

Feb 19, 2026

Vintage Toys, Games, Accessories, and Ephemera, Circa 1960s

Burns Auction & Appraisal LLC4.5

(232)

$5(1 bid)

1 day Left

Group of Childrens Items

Cedarburg Auction & Appraisals LLC4.4

(297)

$30(1 bid)

2 days Left

The New Bicycle Game. Salem: Parker Brothers, ca. 1894. Chr...

Potter & Potter Auctions4.6

(604)

$150(1 bid)

Feb 19, 2026

The Game of Playing Department Store. New York: McLoughlin ...

Potter & Potter Auctions4.6

(604)

$150

Feb 19, 2026

A.C. Gilbert Erector Set

Cedarburg Auction & Appraisals LLC4.4

(297)

$30

2 days Left

Gilbert Steel Toolbox with Tools

SJ Auctioneers4.5

(194)

$45

Feb 08, 2026

Boxed Gilbert Erector No. 9-1/2 "Automotive Set

Weiss Auctions4.7

(586)

$50

1 day Left

[TAROT & FORTUNE TELLING]. Group of 10 decks and sets. Incl...

Potter & Potter Auctions4.6

(604)

$150

Feb 19, 2026

Collection of A.C. Gilbert / Mysto Puzzles. New Haven: Myst...

Potter & Potter Auctions4.6

(604)

$125

Feb 19, 2026

Early Gilbert Erector No. 10 Set in Wooden Case

Weiss Auctions4.7

(586)

$300(4 bids)

1 day Left

Violin Vibrophone Quack Medicine Instrument and Ephemera

Dixon's Auction at Crumpton4.5

(66)

$100(2 bids)

Feb 11, 2026

Vintage Gilbert Erector Set in metal box with motors

South Jersey Auction by Babington Auction Inc4.6

(144)

$25

5 days Left

Group of 30 miscellaneous card and tabletop games. American...

Potter & Potter Auctions4.6

(604)

$100

Feb 19, 2026

Similar Sale History

Unlock All Prices

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic AssortmentAC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment Nineteen sets housed in red metal boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Col

See Sold Price

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2005 AssortmentAC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2005 Assortment Thirty-one sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Co

See Sold Price

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic AssortmentAC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment Twenty-eight sets including boxes; sets include No. 2 1/2, No. 3 and No. 3a; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; c

See Sold Price

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic AssortmentAC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment Twenty-three sets housed in wooden boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Co

See Sold Price

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 5 AssortmentAC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 5 Assortment Thirty sets including boxes together with a No. 5A set with box; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; complet

See Sold Price

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic AssortmentAC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment Eighteen sets housed in wooden boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Collec

See Sold Price

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2001 AssortmentAC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2001 Assortment Thirty-one sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Co

See Sold Price

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 5A AssortmentAC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 5A Assortment Thirty sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Collecti

See Sold Price

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 5A and No. 6 AssortmentAC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 5A and No. 6 Assortment Twenty-three sets including seventeen No. 5A and six No. 6; all are including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate

See Sold Price

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 AssortmentAC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 Assortment Thirty sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Collectib

See Sold Price

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2 AssortmentAC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2 Assortment Thirty sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Collectib

See Sold Price

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2 1/2 AssortmentAC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2 1/2 Assortment Thirty-three sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category:

See Sold Price

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 AssortmentAC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 Assortment Thirty sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Collectib

See Sold Price

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 1/2 AssortmentAC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 1/2 Assortment Thirty sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Colle

See Sold Price

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 1/2 AssortmentAC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 1/2 Assortment Thirty-one sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: C

See Sold Price

Sold

(2) Boxed A.C. Gilbert Mysto Magic Exhibition SetsIncludes (2) Gilbert "Mysto Magic" Exhibition Sets. Each appears to be complete, however neither has been collated. Instructions booklets are included, one appears to have reproduction covers. Origina

See Sold Price

Sold

Boxed Gilbert Mysto Magic Exhibition Set #20Boxed Gilbert Mysto Magic Exhibition Set #20, one of the scarcer magic sets, appears to be complete and includes fifteen boxed tricks, 6'' h., 20'' w., 13'' d.

See Sold Price

Sold

Lot Of 5: Gilbert Mysto Magic Sets.Three Mysto Magic Set No. 2 and two Mysto Magic Set No. 5A. All in original boxes, boxes have wear, tearing and tape repairs. All kits appear to be complete but are not guaranteed. Condition (Good - V

See Sold Price

Sold

Boxed Gilbert Mysto Magic Exhibition Set #25Boxed Gilbert Mysto Magic Exhibition Set #25, appears to be complete, including the original poster, instruction booklet, twenty-four boxed tricks, and four legs, 5'' h., 25'' w., 18'' d.

See Sold Price

Sold

(3) Boxed A.C. Gilbert Mysto Magic Sets No. 1-1/2Group of (3) vintage Gilbert Mysto Magic boxed sets No. 1-1/2. Each includes a range of magic trick components with original instruction books. One set appears complete, while the other two show some

See Sold Price

Sold

A.C. Gilbert Mysto Magic Sets. Group of Three.A.C. Gilbert Mysto Magic Sets. Group of Three. New Haven, Conn., ca. 1930s. Comprising Nos. 1½, 2001, and 2005. Boxed sets with original cardboard frames retained. Original instructional booklets inc

See Sold Price

Sold

(2) Boxed Gilbert Mysto Magic Sets No.2-1/2 & No.5Pair of vintage Gilbert Mysto Magic boxed sets, including No. 2-1/2 and No. 5. Both sets feature original illustrated trays and an assortment of classic magic props, including linking rings, wand, bal

See Sold Price

Sold

Lot of 4 Gilbert Mysto Magic SetsLot of 4 Magic sets including a 1922 Mysto Magic set in wood box with instruction book, a collection of Gilbert Mysto magic disappearing bottle tricks in metal box, 1933 A C Gilbert Mysto magic set in

See Sold Price

Sold

Gilbert Mysto Magic Set in Box.Set appears to have not been played with. Complete with all parts and poster. Box has light to moderate wear. Condition (Very Good Plus). Size 20 - 1/2" T. x 13" L.

See Sold Price