A.C. Gilbert Co. Toys & Hobbies

Gilbert Mysto Magic Set in Box. First Image

#image-loader-main { display: none; }

Gilbert Mysto Magic Set in Box. First Image

Gilbert Mysto Magic Set in Box.

Total Sales2 Sold

Median Sale Price

Sale Price Range

Similar Upcoming Sales

Vintage Magic Encyclopediae and Player Guides (1 of 1)

Vintage Magic Encyclopediae and Player Guides

Stanley Gibbons Baldwin’s

Feb 20, 2026

Red Ryder #13 (1 of 1)

Chairish Auctions

Vincent Price Hang Man Game, Monster Insult Postcards (12), and 'Sounds To Make You Shiver' Vinyl (1 of 1)

Vincent Price Hang Man Game, Monster Insult Postcards (12), and 'Sounds To Make You Shiver' Vinyl

Lee Fox Auctioneers

1 day Left

Mac No. 80 Jungle Race Marble Toy Game (1 of 9)

Mac No. 80 Jungle Race Marble Toy Game

A New Day Auctions LLC

Magic Paper Tricks And In The News Paper Trick (1 of 6)

Magic Paper Tricks And In The News Paper Trick

Rapid Estate Liquidators and Auction Gallery

11 hrs Left

AL G. BARNES AND SELLS-FLOTO CIRCUS POSTER (1 of 1)

AL G. BARNES AND SELLS-FLOTO CIRCUS POSTER

Freedom Auction Company

Feb 12, 2026

AL G. BARNES AND SELLS-FLOTO CIRCUS POSTER (1 of 1)

AL G. BARNES AND SELLS-FLOTO CIRCUS POSTER

Freedom Auction Company

Feb 12, 2026

AL G. BARNES AND SELLS-FLOTO CIRCUS POSTER (1 of 1)

AL G. BARNES AND SELLS-FLOTO CIRCUS POSTER

Freedom Auction Company

Feb 12, 2026

Vintage Jinx Jigsaw Puzzle "It's Hexed" (1 of 8)

Vintage Jinx Jigsaw Puzzle "It's Hexed"

Rapid Estate Liquidators and Auction Gallery

5 hrs Left

Collection of A.C. Gilbert / Mysto Puzzles. New Haven: Myst... (1 of 2)

Collection of A.C. Gilbert / Mysto Puzzles. New Haven: Myst...

Potter & Potter Auctions

Feb 19, 2026

The Mysterious Planchette. British, early 20th century. Blo... (1 of 2)

The Mysterious Planchette. British, early 20th century. Blo...

Potter & Potter Auctions

Feb 19, 2026

STRAUSS TIN WINDUP TOM TWIST w/ BOX (1 of 10)

STRAUSS TIN WINDUP TOM TWIST w/ BOX

Milestone Auctions

Feb 07, 2026

Two Petrie & Lewis Magic / Puzzle Sets. New Haven : Petrie ... (1 of 2)

Two Petrie & Lewis Magic / Puzzle Sets. New Haven : Petrie ...

Potter & Potter Auctions

Feb 19, 2026

MYSTIC SKULL & GREEN GHOST GAMES w/ BOX (1 of 9)

MYSTIC SKULL & GREEN GHOST GAMES w/ BOX

Milestone Auctions

Feb 07, 2026

MAC 1920'S TIN MYSTERY GUN SHOOTING TOY w/ BOX (1 of 4)

MAC 1920'S TIN MYSTERY GUN SHOOTING TOY w/ BOX

Milestone Auctions

Feb 07, 2026

Boxed A.C. Gilbert #10094 & 10084 Erector Sets (1 of 12)

Boxed A.C. Gilbert #10094 & 10084 Erector Sets

1 day Left

Similar Sale History

Unlock All Prices

Sold

Gilbert Mysto Magic Set in Box. (1 of 3)

Gilbert Mysto Magic Set in Box.Set appears to have not been played with. Complete with all parts and poster. Box has light to moderate wear. Condition (Very Good Plus). Size 20 - 1/2" T. x 13" L.

Sold

A.C. GILBERT MYSTO MAGIC SET IN THE ORIGINAL BOX (1 of 6)

A.C. GILBERT MYSTO MAGIC SET IN THE ORIGINAL BOX A nice colorful top lid, showing a magician rabbit and a depiction of the devil. Marked "Copyright 1938." The box is mostly complete, but has some missing parts to the side apron and some tape on anot

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment (1 of 11)

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment AC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment Twenty-eight sets including boxes; sets include No. 2 1/2, No. 3 and No. 3a; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; c

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 5 Assortment (1 of 17)

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 5 Assortment AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 5 Assortment Thirty sets including boxes together with a No. 5A set with box; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; complet

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment (1 of 19)

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment AC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment Eighteen sets housed in wooden boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Collec

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 5A Assortment (1 of 16)

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 5A Assortment AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 5A Assortment Thirty sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Collecti

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 Assortment (1 of 1)

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 Assortment AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 Assortment Thirty sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Collectib

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2 Assortment (1 of 1)

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2 Assortment AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2 Assortment Thirty sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Collectib

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 Assortment (1 of 1)

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 Assortment AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 Assortment Thirty sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Collectib

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment (1 of 20)

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment AC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment Nineteen sets housed in red metal boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Col

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2005 Assortment (1 of 12)

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2005 Assortment AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2005 Assortment Thirty-one sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Co

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment (1 of 20)

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment AC Gilbert Mysto Magic Assortment Twenty-three sets housed in wooden boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Co

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2001 Assortment (1 of 9)

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2001 Assortment AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2001 Assortment Thirty-one sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Co

Sold

Lot of 4 Gilbert Mysto Magic Sets (1 of 4)

Lot of 4 Gilbert Mysto Magic Sets Lot of 4 Magic sets including a 1922 Mysto Magic set in wood box with instruction book, a collection of Gilbert Mysto magic disappearing bottle tricks in metal box, 1933 A C Gilbert Mysto magic set in

Sold

VINTAGE 1963 Gilbert Mysto Magic Set #2 1/2 Complete (1 of 9)

VINTAGE 1963 Gilbert Mysto Magic Set #2 1/2 Complete 1963 Vintage Gilbert Mysto Magic Exhibition Set. It was copyrighted 1938 by the A. C. Gilbert Co. New Haven, Conn. U.S.A. Original props. The box measures about 20 1/2" x 13 1/4". The graphics on the

Sold

Lot Of 5: Gilbert Mysto Magic Sets. (1 of 5)

Lot Of 5: Gilbert Mysto Magic Sets.Three Mysto Magic Set No. 2 and two Mysto Magic Set No. 5A. All in original boxes, boxes have wear, tearing and tape repairs. All kits appear to be complete but are not guaranteed. Condition (Good - V

Sold

2 GILBERT MYSTO MAGIC SETS (1 of 4)

2 GILBERT MYSTO MAGIC SETS #2 1/2, appears complete, #5A, incomplete, orig boxes & inserts minor wear, C6-8.

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 1/2 Assortment (1 of 1)

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 1/2 Assortment AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 1/2 Assortment Thirty sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: Colle

Sold

Gilbert Mysto Magic (Exhibition Set) No. 1 (1 of 6)

Gilbert Mysto Magic (Exhibition Set) No. 1 Gilbert Mysto Magic (Exhibition Set) No. 1, not complete but does contain a good amount of the set, ca. 1940s, box measures 10 1/8" x 18" x 1 1/4"

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2 1/2 Assortment (1 of 1)

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2 1/2 Assortment AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 2 1/2 Assortment Thirty-three sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category:

Sold

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 1/2 Assortment (1 of 1)

AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 1/2 Assortment AC Gilbert Mysto Magic No. 1 1/2 Assortment Thirty-one sets including boxes; from the Estate of Peter Quinn Condition: Good to Fair, moderate to heavy wear overall; completeness is unknown Category: C

Sold

Antique 1910 PRE-GILBERT "MYSTO MAGIC" Boxed Magic Set. Excellent. (1 of 8)

Antique 1910 PRE-GILBERT "MYSTO MAGIC" Boxed Magic Set. Excellent.Antique 1910 PRE-GILBERT "MYSTO MAGIC" Boxed Magic Set. Excellent. This Mysto Magic Set come in its original box which measures 6.75x15.5x2.5" deep. It has an illustrated lid label contains a 6 compon

Sold

Lot Of 6: Gilbert Magic Sets. (1 of 6)

Lot Of 6: Gilbert Magic Sets.No. 2001 Mysto Magic, includes instruction booklet, box lid has some torn corners. No. 2001 Mysto Magic, obviously missing some parts, has a nice clean original box. No. 1 Mysto Magic Exhibition Set,

Sold

Mysto Magic Set No. 2006. New Haven, A.C. Gilbert Co., (1 of 3)

Mysto Magic Set No. 2006. New Haven, A.C. Gilbert Co.,Mysto Magic Set No. 2006. New Haven, A.C. Gilbert Co., ca. 1939. Attractive and apparently complete magic set from the Mysto line. Two trays of apparatus inside, including metal coin box, Mysto slates

TOP