Heartland Artifact Auctions, IL - Read over 888 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Heartland Artifact Auctions (888)

badge TOP RATED
4.7 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 888 Reviews

AB1 MANAGMENT LLC
Cooper City, FL

Apr 28, 2026
Incredible 6 3/4" Historic Engraved Pipe Tomahawk found in Northern Illinois. Motley COA.

Curtis
Gurdon, AR

Apr 27, 2026
Best auction house 👌
Best auction house ever for authentic artifacts, customer service, and excellent self ranged shipping.
Report
2 1/16" Cache River. E-Notch. Portland County, Tennessee.

Curtis
Gurdon, AR

Apr 27, 2026

Curtis
Gurdon, AR

Apr 27, 2026

Curtis
Gurdon, AR

Apr 27, 2026
Group of 3 Colorful Archaic Pts.

Curtis
Gurdon, AR

Apr 27, 2026
Pre Columbian Chancay Doll, Textile, Peru

Curtis
Gurdon, AR

Apr 27, 2026
Lot of Nodena Blade and Rice Shallow Notch Pts., found by Adam Sisler & Family in Keokuk Co., Iowa

Larry
New York, NY

Apr 27, 2026
MACHU PICCHU, HARDBACK, 172 PAGES, LOTS OF GREAT PHOTOS OF THE RELICS, LANDSCAPE, ARCHITECTURE,

Steve
Brunswick, GA

Apr 26, 2026
BONE, SHELL, COPPER, AND WOODEN RELICS OF THE AMERICAN INDIAN, 1977, FIRST EDITION, PRICE GUIDE

Larry
New York, NY

Apr 05, 2026

Socially
Paris, FR

Apr 05, 2026
DANGER-SELL FAKE GOLD! RUN!
I purchased 2 figurine supposedly precolumbian and made of tumbaga (gold copper mixture usually 50/80 % gold). At the reception of the items, I had them tested and both were 100 % fakes with no gold at all in them! 1 item can be a mistake but 2 is a more a pattern. I told the owner of the auction house and he refused to refund them (in opposition with its store policy) because a minuscule mark had been made on them to analyse them and prove they were fakes! I asked him to delete its many other fake Tumbaga gold item from inventory to protect its customers but he didn’t seem to care! I want a refund but it frightens me because after I send them Back I am Convinced that he will try to resell them and scam other people with them. If you check its full inventory you will see mostly stone artifacts (meaning that thermoluminescence or carbon 14 test can’t be used to prove Authenticity) = impossible to prove their true origin! If he choose to scam People or at the minimum refuse to repair its mistakes (but what do You call doing twice the same mistake and not repairing them …..) with fake Tumbaga gold, what is he doing with the rest of its inventory which can’t be truly analyse like all any other items made of terracotta/wood/…? BE CAREFUL! Better play it safe when you buy antiques.
Report

Jeffrey
Mc Daniels, KY

Mar 29, 2026
Understanding and Patience
These people seem to be understanding and patient when customers have issues. They are cognizant of potential obstacles inherent in the process and will go out of their way to explain and attempt to rectify your concerns. I have issues from time to time, but unlike other auction sites I could name, they've been fully engaged in helping me work through them. I will undoubtedly be using their service again... and again.
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsApr 01, 2026
Hi Jeffrey, thank you for the thoughtful review. We appreciate you recognizing our approach to communication and problem solving. Shipping and checkout can involve a few moving parts, especially when third party tools are involved, so we work hard to stay responsive and clear when questions come up. We truly value your continued trust and look forward to working with you again.

Thomas
Chama, NM

Mar 22, 2026
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsMar 23, 2026
Thanks for the great review, Thomas!
5 3/8" Hohokam Axe, New Mexico

Cynthia
Lakewood, CO

Mar 22, 2026
Be sure to verify authenticity of item before bidding
I was the successful bidder on an item that was described differently on the auction website than the stamp on the item actually suggests. I emailed the auction house yesterday, so am waiting to hear back. But I cannot give more than 1 star at this point. I wouldn’t have even bid on the item if it is in fact not as described on the auction site. I hope I’m wrong.
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsApr 01, 2026
Hi Cynthia, thank you for sharing your concerns. We want to clarify that we did respond to your email, and we have replied again after your follow up as well. At this time, we are still waiting on your response so we can move forward and resolve this with you. Please reply to our most recent message with the details we requested, or confirm the best time to reach you, and we will be glad to continue the conversation and work toward a solution.
3 1/16" Incredible Hardin, found by Jim Irish in Knox Co., Illinois in the 1970's

Martin
New York, NY

Mar 08, 2026
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsMar 23, 2026
Thank you for the great review, Martin!
Pre Columbian Portrait Anxiety/Depression Jaina, Ca. 800 A.D.

ed
Centennial, CO

Mar 08, 2026
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsMar 23, 2026
Thank you for the great review, Ed!
2 3/8" Little Bear Creek, Found By Jeff Thompson in Either Florida or Georgia

Daniel
Hendersonville, NC

Feb 22, 2026
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsMar 02, 2026
Thanks for the great review, Daniel!
2 15/16" X 3/4" X 1/2" Paleolithic Double Burin, Found in Western France

Scott
Klamath Falls, OR

Feb 15, 2026
Easy all around transactions.
Easy bidding. Easy payment process, accurate, reasonable shipping cost. Shipped out quickly. Quality operation.
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsFeb 19, 2026
Scott, thank you for the thoughtful review. We are glad to hear the bidding, payment, and shipping process were all smooth for you. We appreciate the feedback and look forward to having you back in future auctions.

Shelly
Llano, TX

Feb 08, 2026
Excellent Auction house
Very quick shipping, excellent service. I would highly recommend buying from Heartland Auction House.
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsFeb 19, 2026
Shelly, thank you for the kind review. We are glad to hear shipping and service were both positive experiences for you. We appreciate the recommendation and look forward to having you join us again.
4 3/8" Fossil Megalodon Shark Tooth

Terry
Fairhope, AL

Feb 08, 2026
Historic American Indian artifacts
Excellent condition historical artifacts presented safely and affordably
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsFeb 19, 2026
Terry, thank you for the great review. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience and are glad to know the material and presentation met your expectations. We look forward to having you back in future auctions.
Stempoint - 2 1/8" L x 1" W

ed
Centennial, CO

Feb 06, 2026
REALLY CHECK OUT WHAT YOU ARE BUYING AND JUST DON'T TRUST THERE DISCRIPTIO
CHECK IT OUT BEFORE YOU BUY
Report

Brad
Gillespie, IL

Jan 28, 2026
Multi Time Buyer
I have been buying artifacts from Heartland for a while now and every time has been smooth, fast invoices, fast-safe shipping, They got it dialed in. Heartland is the best online artifact seller in the USA, in my opinion. They always have the rare, wild stuff everybody lusts for. Every auction. Of course I’ll be back ….
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsFeb 19, 2026
Brad, thank you for the generous words and for being a loyal buyer. We appreciate your continued trust in us and are glad to hear that your experiences with invoicing, shipping, and the overall process have been consistently positive. It means a lot to know you enjoy the material we bring to auction. We look forward to working with you again.
1 5/8" X 1" Cahokia, Partain COA, Found in St. Clair County IL., Ex. James Hinson Collection

Matthew
Hubert, NC

Jan 25, 2026
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsJan 25, 2026
Thank you for the great review, Matthew!
1 3/8" x 15/16" Pre-Columbian Aztec Lip Plug Labret Material Soft Translucent Stone From South

Rodney
Houston, TX

Jan 08, 2026
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsJan 22, 2026
Thank you for the review, Rodney!
3 1/2" Stabilized Insect Specimen, Golden Silk Orb Weaver, Nephila Sp, Warmer Regions of Australia,

Adam
Corydon, IN

Dec 30, 2025
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsJan 22, 2026
Thank you for the review, Adam!
Fossil Shark Tooth, SC

Scott
Wisconsin Dells, WI

Dec 21, 2025
Outstanding transaction.
Outstanding transaction.
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsDec 29, 2025
Thank you, Scott!
Ceremonial Native American Dance Bells

Anthony
Jackson Heights, NY

Dec 18, 2025
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsJan 22, 2026
Thank you for the review, Anthony!
Lot of 3 Neolithic African Pottery Beads, Engraved

Michael
New York, NY

Dec 17, 2025
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsJan 22, 2026
Thank you for the review, Michael!
2 11/16" Lizard Effigy Shell Pendant

Ryan
Warsaw, MO

Dec 15, 2025
Smooth transaction
Looking forward to doing more business.
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsDec 15, 2025
Hi Ryan, Thank you for the 5-star review. We’re glad the transaction went smoothly and appreciate your support. We look forward to working with you again.
6" 3/4-Groove Heartbreaker Nebo Axe, broken but great shape and form, found in Central Missouri

Ryan
Warsaw, MO

Dec 15, 2025
Good communication
Tucker is great to deal with. Transaction was smooth and flawless. Thank you, will buy from again.
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsDec 15, 2025
Hi Ryan, Thank you for the kind review and for taking the time to share your experience. We’re glad to hear everything went smoothly, and we’ll be sure to pass your compliments along to Tucker. We appreciate your continued support and look forward to working with you again.
3 5/8" Dalton, Made of Cedar Hill Chert, Found in Northeast Missouri, Ex Bruce Filbrandt

Brad
Gillespie, IL

Dec 13, 2025
Great auction as usual.
Fast safe shipping.
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsDec 15, 2025
Hi Brad, Thank you for the 5-star review and the continued support. We’re glad to hear you had another great experience and that shipping arrived quickly and safely. We appreciate your business and look forward to the next one.
2 1/2" Dovetail, found in Wabash Co., Illinois by Russell Flener

Curtis
Gurdon, AR

Dec 04, 2025
Unbelievable deal
Awesome authentic artifacts at an unbelievably low price.
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsDec 15, 2025
Hi Curtis, Thank you for the 5-star review. We’re glad you were happy with the value and selection in the auction. We appreciate your support and are happy to have you bidding with us.
3" North Blade, found by Bud Goodwin in Pike Co., Illinois

Curtis
Gurdon, AR

Dec 04, 2025
Nice artifacts
Great artifacts for an absolutely unbelievable price.
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsDec 15, 2025
Hi Curtis, Thank you for the 5-star review. We’re glad you were pleased with the selection and value, and we appreciate you taking the time to share your experience.
Lot of 3 Common Field Grade Pts, Ex John Howze Collection

Curtis
Gurdon, AR

Dec 04, 2025
High quality artifacts
Exceptional artifacts for an unbeatable price.
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsDec 15, 2025
Hi Curtis, Thank you for your 5-star review. We’re glad to hear you were pleased with the quality and value of the pieces. We truly appreciate your continued support.
4 3/16'' Etley,Keele COA,Found In Sullivan Co., Missouri,Ex Steve McCabe Collection

Curtis
Gurdon, AR

Dec 04, 2025
Awesome artifacts
One of the kind artifacts for an unbeatable price.
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsDec 15, 2025
Hi Curtis, Thank you for the 5-star review. We’re glad you enjoyed the selection and found something special. We appreciate your continued support and participation in our auctions.
5 1/4" Etley, Pike County Illinois. Nice Large Example with Heavy Patina. Ex Warren Suleski

John
Pea Ridge, AR

Nov 16, 2025
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsDec 15, 2025
Hi John, Thank you for the 5-star review. We truly appreciate your support and are glad you had a positive experience with Heartland.
Bag of marbles

Rodney
Houston, TX

Nov 16, 2025
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsDec 15, 2025
Hi Rodney, Thank you for the 5-star review. We appreciate your support and are glad you had a positive experience with Heartland.
Lot of 2 Fossilized Megalodon Shark Tooth Halves, Florida

Rick
Davenport, IA

Nov 16, 2025
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsDec 15, 2025
Hi Rick, Thank you for the 5-star review. We truly appreciate your support and are glad you had a positive experience with Heartland.
2 1/2" Stunning Color Adena Blade, Ex James Kerr Collection

Dianne
Wake, VA

Nov 11, 2025
All good! Smooth as can be, excellent photos & description, economical in-house shipping.
Great experience. Heartland mentioned an illegible signature on this pottery, but provided excellent photos so one could actually see that it was signed by Felix Ortiz, a highly regarded first generation potter of Mata Ortiz. Kudos for Heartland! And the in-house packing and shipping was perfect. Superb packing of pottery, economical and quick shipping. It doesn't get better than that!
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsNov 11, 2025
Hi Dianne, Thank you so much for the kind words and thoughtful feedback. We’re thrilled to hear the experience was smooth and that the detailed photos helped clarify the signature — we’re always happy when a piece like that finds someone who appreciates its significance. We’ll pass your compliments along to our packing and shipping team as well — they take great care, especially with pottery. We truly appreciate your support and look forward to working with you again in the future. – The Heartland Artifact Auctions Team
Stunning Casa Grande Pottery Vessel, Signed but not legible.  Approx 8" Diameter.

robert
Saint Louis, MO

Oct 31, 2025
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsNov 11, 2025
Hi Robert, Thank you for the 5-star review! We truly appreciate your support and are glad to have you as part of the Heartland community. – The Heartland Artifact Auctions Team
3 1/8" Copper Precolumbian Alligator from South America

Dennis
Wausau, WI

Oct 19, 2025
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsNov 11, 2025
Hi Dennis, Thank you for the 5-star review! We appreciate your continued support and are always glad to work with collectors like you. – The Heartland Artifact Auctions Team
Lot of 3 Vintage Single Blade Pocket Knives, Knife. Nice Solid Built Knives

Todd
Moorpark, CA

Oct 19, 2025
Excellent experience
This was a very easy auction experience. Bidding, payment and shipping were seamless. Would definitely consider bidding with Heartland again.
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsNov 11, 2025
Hi Todd, We really appreciate you taking the time to leave a review. It’s great to hear that everything from bidding to shipping went smoothly. We’re glad you had a positive experience and look forward to having you join us again in a future auction. – The Heartland Artifact Auctions Team
BUCK SINGLE BLADE POCKET KNIFE, HUNTING KNIFE, GREAT DESIGN

Steve
Odessa, WA

Oct 14, 2025
Terrific service
I was pleased with the prompt service and support. Sometimes the on line service is challenging. They were helpful and prompt. Packing was detailed. Thank you
Report
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsNov 11, 2025
Hi Steve, Thank you for the kind review. We’re glad we could provide helpful and timely support throughout the process. We understand that online services can be challenging at times, and we appreciate your trust in us. Our packing team will be glad to hear their attention to detail was noticed. – The Heartland Artifact Auctions Team
Antique Chinese Hongshan Culture Jade Locust Effigy Pendant, Hand Carved in High Detail

Michael
Saint Clairsville, OH

Oct 09, 2025
Olmec Drug Spoon. Veracruz, Mexico. Highly polished, mottled Jadeite. 3 3/4". Drilled for

Kirsten
Sweet Home, OR

Sep 30, 2025
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsNov 11, 2025
Hi Kristen, Thank you for the 5-star rating. We truly appreciate your support and are glad you had a positive experience with Heartland. – The Heartland Artifact Auctions Team
1997 Central States Archaeological Journal

James
Orrington, ME

Sep 29, 2025
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsNov 11, 2025
Hi James, Thank you for the 5-star review. We appreciate your support and look forward to having you join us again in a future auction. – The Heartland Artifact Auctions Team
Working Canvasback Duck Decoy, Hand Carved, Glass Eyes, 14" Approx.

Thomas
Chama, NM

Sep 28, 2025
good, honest auction house that will go above and beyond to help their clients
no
Report
16" Native American Basket

John
Long Beach, CA

Sep 28, 2025
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsNov 11, 2025
Hi John, Thank you for the 5-star review. We appreciate your support and are glad to have you as part of the Heartland community. – The Heartland Artifact Auctions Team
Frame of 9 Cuyahoga Co., Ohio Drills,

Kirsten
Sweet Home, OR

Sep 12, 2025
Matched Set Polished Agate Geode Bookends

James
Canandaigua, NY

Sep 07, 2025
Heartland Artifact Auctions logo
Heartland Artifact AuctionsNov 11, 2025
Hi James, Thank you for the 5-star review. We truly appreciate your support and are glad to have you in the Heartland community. – The Heartland Artifact Auctions Team
3 1/4" Alaskan Bone Carving