Old Kinderhook Auction Company, NY - Read over 220 Reviews from Customers

Bidder Reviews for Old Kinderhook Auction Company (220)

badge TOP RATED
4.6 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 220 Reviews

MM
Kailua, HI

Jul 16, 2025
Adorable painting and wonderful service
This painting is adorable and arrived in perfect shape. We would be thrilled to use this auction house again!
Report
American School, "Kilauea, Hawaii"

Brian
Wayne, PA

Jun 12, 2025
Old Kinderhook was great/Live Auctioneers shipping service atrocious
Old Kinderhook seems to be a great auction house. I appreciate their responsiveness to any questions I had. Unfortunately, I used Live Auctioneers shipping services. Not only did it take a month for it to ship, and not only was it very poorly packed, but the 17th/18th c. painting on wood arrived cracked in two pieces down the middle with significant paint loss, all due to the shoddy shipping. I reported it to LiveAuctioneers immediately upon receiving the item and now after 10 days I still have no word about my claim and am still left with an irreparably damaged painting. Satisfied with Kinderhook, but deeply disappointed with LiveAuctioneers shipping and disappointed this 300-year-old painting has been so severely damaged.
Report
Antique Painted Icon with Gilt Metal Riza

Judith
Brooklyn, NY

May 20, 2025
No
No
Report
2 Loro Piana and 1 Polo by RL Cashmere Beanies

Kelly
Shawnee, OK

Sep 28, 2024
Item is excellent
Item was in excellent condition but it was completely full of trash which made it much heavier & made the shipping a lot more. Not happy about that at all.
Report
Antique Merryweather & Sons English Fire Bucket

Keith
Homer Glen, IL

Sep 18, 2024
Ask for additional hi def photos
I purchased what appeared to be a pristine portrait painting c. 1840. The one image showing a defect was notable but insignificant. However there were no images of a repaired hole or another image that should have shown the six inch repaired tear. Similarly the description noted that the canvas had been relined but said nothing about being glued to an unknown semisolid backing. Frankly, I would never consider buying a painting from this auction house ever again.
Report
American School, Portrait of a Young Woman

Montgomery House Antiques & Gifts
Middletown, NY

Sep 18, 2024
Superb Auction House
Old Kinderhook is simply one of the best! I have dealt with many over the years and I am in fact retired from the auction industry, so I know what I am talking about. Bid with confidence!
Report
Antique Seals & Printing Blocks

Jerry A
Big Horn, WY

Sep 17, 2024
Excellent auction experience.
Personnel at auction company were very friendly and helpful. It made for a very pleasant and satisfying experience. I would definitely bid in future auctions if desired items are offered.
Report
"High Plains Warrior" by Gerald Shippen

Peter
West Hollywood, CA

Sep 17, 2024
Early Antique Wedgewood Caneware Game Pie Dish

Beer
New Paltz, NY

Sep 17, 2024
Set of 4 Early Spanish Rush Seat Chairs

Judith
Brooklyn, NY

Sep 17, 2024
Huge Group Vintage Copper Cookware

Jennifer
Chicago, IL

Sep 17, 2024
Two Ikebana Stone Vases

Jeffrey S.
Harrisonburg, VA

Aug 29, 2024
Excellent service
And they have a lovable canine greeter!!!
Report
Antique Shenandoah Valley Pottery Bowl

Mark
Albany, NY

Jul 30, 2024
As always, thanks.
Been buying from the auction house for some time. Always a friendly and good experience.
Report
American Whistler Gilt Frame 14 1/2" x 18"

Elizabeth
Atlantic Beach, NY

Jul 26, 2024
Wedgwood for Ralph Lauren Clearwater Porcelain

Charles
Rensselaer, NY

Jul 25, 2024
Great place and people
Wonderful staff
Report
Vintage Tabriz Rug 38" X 67"

Mark
Slingerlands, NY

Jul 24, 2024
Vintage Tribal Rug 48" X 69"

Sharon
Leicester, MA

Jul 24, 2024
Large Group Chinese Blue & White Porcelain

Christine
Chevy Chase, MD

Jul 24, 2024
2 Fornasetti Porcelain Face Plates

Xenia
North Bergen, NJ

Jul 24, 2024
Perfect
Repeat purchaser. I enjoy the quirky selection available as well as the canine staff, who should get a raise.
Report
American School, Victorian Building

Lee
Marlborough, MA

Jul 23, 2024
Great folks — Very accommodating — And the best food!
Really great folks who were very accommodating, and as a plus, they had the best food, all home made, I've seen at any auction.
Report
Group of Five Frames

Nestor Diego
Newark, NJ

Jul 23, 2024
Great service
Fast contact and excellent attention, before and after the auction. Very helpful with the payment process and to coordinate the shipping! Thanks!
Report
Antique Ebonized Jizai-Kagi Pot Holder

Zach
Ghent, NY

Jul 23, 2024
Great
I am very happy with my winning lots for them, They are very nice and helpful. I have been dropping stuff off to them as well as buying from them for a few years now, I am always recommending them to people. definitely will continue our relationship with buying and selling.
Report
Columbia County NY Related Articles

Miriam
Newtown, PA

Jul 16, 2024
Perfect transactions!
Would do business again. Easy transaction. Fast shipping. A + + +!
Report
Itzchak Tarkay, "Lady in Red III"

Adin
Tucson, AZ

Jul 14, 2024
Quality, fair auction & shipper.
As a new comer these folks were accurate in description, very fair in pricing with an honest ending. I used Country Postman for shipping, could not have been happier. Fast and perfect deal! Thanks to all!
Report
Vintage Hooked Rug of Dogs 19" X 36"

Carolyn
Glebe, AU

Jun 24, 2024
Great auction (challenging shipping situation)
There are always great things turning up at auctions in the Hudson Valley from old estates in the region. I won this painting at a good price and have already restored it. But getting it home was a challenge. The local UPS store gave me an estimate, then tripled it after I won the auction. I turned to Purple Comet as recommended by the auctioneer. Thanks to the Old Kinderhook for their patience in the process.
Report

Mark
Slingerlands, NY

May 29, 2024

Cleveland
Staunton, VA

May 28, 2024
Flawless!
This was a flawless transaction. Great images, reasonable starting price, good updates for further bidding, convenient shipping services, and prompt and easy conclusion. More auction houses ought to be as good as Old Kinderhook!
Report

James
West Park, NY

May 28, 2024

Cody
Boxford, MA

May 28, 2024

Alvaro
Hilton Head Island, SC

May 25, 2024
Good auction-favorable, with reasonable reserve pricing
Seamless process. UPS store 5539 did a nice job shipping item.
Report

Michael
West Hartford, CT

May 16, 2024
Good experience
Nice item, as described. Recommended shipper was very reasonable.
Report

Royce
Rehoboth Beach, DE

Apr 25, 2024
Exactly as described and excellent service. A + + + + +
High quality business and team of employees. A + + + + +
Report
Sterling Silver Link Necklace

Robert
Hudson, NY

Mar 27, 2024
As always, a Great Auction
Great descriptions and photos, knowledgeable and helpful staff. Looking forward to the next auction.
Report
Liberty & Co. Tudric Pewter Dish

Deborah
Amenia, NY

Mar 26, 2024
Fair & Fun
The pricing is fair and the people (and dogs) are great. I've gotten some wonderful things there!
Report
Modern Armchair

Steven
Boulder, CO

Mar 26, 2024
Lot of Mixed Textiles

Mark
Slingerlands, NY

Mar 26, 2024
Chinese Wall Hanging of Buddha

Timothy
Kinderhook, NY

Mar 26, 2024
Great experience for first time bidding on an auction.
OK Auction Company was friendly, helpful and very easy to work with. I picked up my items and they packed up the items in my car quickly and carefully. Overall, I would easily recommend the Old Kinderhook Auction Company.
Report
Rene Gruau, "Le Balcon A Nice"

Mark
Albany, NY

Feb 23, 2024
American Barbizon Frame 16" x 20"

James
Provincetown, MA

Feb 22, 2024
Agnes Weinrich, Woodblock with Exhibition Booklet

Nell
Westmoreland, NH

Feb 20, 2024
Group Quality Costume Jewelry Faux Pearls

Lowell
Weehawken, NJ

Jan 14, 2024
Antique Roman Engravings of Bacchanalian Scenes

Lowell
Weehawken, NJ

Jan 14, 2024
Early Antique Meissen Porcelain Basket

Robert
Cold Spring, NY

Jan 07, 2024
A professional company
Every thing went smoothly:)
Report
Hudson River School Gilt Frame 14" x 20 1/4"

Vicki
Putnam Valley, NY

Dec 30, 2023
Super easy to deal with!
All went smoothly, the item was as described and in excellent condition when I picked it up. Everyone was friendly and helpful and they were very organized. I would definitely feel comfortable buying through them again.
Report
Pair Fulper Pottery Candlesticks & A Stangl Bird

Mark
Slingerlands, NY

Dec 28, 2023
Antique Nichols Chinese Deco Rug 108" x 145"

brad
Marmora, NJ

Dec 28, 2023
thank you
very pleased and thank you
Report
Group of Antique Colored Glass

Bruce
Basking Ridge, NJ

Dec 28, 2023
Old Kinderhook sells FAKE Chinese porcelean. They describe Chinese porcelean as antique when NOT.
Old Kinderhook sells Chinese porcelain which they claim are antiques. An antique is something that is 100 years old or older. I believe the "antiques" they are selling were made in this century. I believe they know this and sell them anyhow.
Report
Four Antique Chinese Imari Porcelain Plates

Joseph
East Nassau, NY

Dec 27, 2023
Baldwin Brass Bouillotte Lamp

John
Hebron, CT

Dec 27, 2023
Boston Federal Mahogany Card Table

Tim
Mechanicville, NY

Dec 27, 2023
Great auction
Good auction to buy from. A true pleasure!
Report
Antique Metalware Lot